Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Final BSG replacement poll!

  • Bridgerton 270
  • Snowfall 378
  • Fringe 319
  • Silo 171
  • Twisted Metal 115
  • 2026-03-10
  • 1253 votes
{'title': 'Final BSG replacement poll! ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Bridgerton', 'votes': 270}, {'text': 'Snowfall', 'votes': 378}, {'text': 'Fringe ', 'votes': 319}, {'text': 'Silo', 'votes': 171}, {'text': 'Twisted Metal ', 'votes': 115}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 3, 10, 19, 58, 42, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1253}

Content

Your recommendations have been noted, and now we are back with final 5! We combed through all of your comments and included the most frequently mentioned or liked shows, and consulted with all of the boys who will be watching one of these to make sure you guys would be getting a great reaction. The options are below. Feel free to vote for one or multiple. This poll will close on Friday. Happy voting!

Comments

Kwame James

Let go snowfall one time

Devlin Draconis

Is this supposed to be multiple choice? Because it currently isn’t

Anansi

Fringe would be great! I wonder if anyone on the couch has seen it?

Unstablebeast

Damn, I have no interest in any of these options, i guess I'll vote twisted metal since its atleast short and kinda funny

Imari

If yall don’t vote silo lol it’s so short

MarcusDiggler

On everything I love they need Snowfall in their life! I get fringe is more similar to what is being replaced but come on

Rosemary

BRIDGERTON WITH A FULL COUCH PLEASEEEEEEEEWE

bob

Why isn't 12 Monkeys on this list?

SnapGrapplePop

Oh damn, I didn’t know Fringe was gonna be on the list. I think it’s such an underrated show! Definitely gets my vote, but I’d also be happy with a Bridgerton watch (as long as we get a fancy boys dress up day for at least one ep)

Rosemary

Right I’d love if chris, suraj, spidey, and pat went full gentleman of the ton

Chris Skalicky

Silo! It's awesome (and short!)...then follow it up with Fringe!

Gambit3838

Dear God I NEED FRINGE or SILO to win. SILO has only had 2 (10) episode seasons. Finish it by JUNE and start a new poll folks. VOTE FOR SILO ☝️✌️

Gambit3838

OMG That would be such a great watch. Same with HELIX. Both amazing sci-fi with awesome conspiracies.

Thee Chronicle

Omg Are we finally getting SILO 🔥🔥🔥🔥 lets gooooo. Hopefully Fringe after that 🙏🏽🤞🏾

Teresa

Bridgerton please 🙏

Manny

Fringe should be the pick! John Noble puts on a master class for this show!

Michael Acuna

Patrons, what could you tell me about these shows and which do you find the most interesting?

Drueisms

Omg I missed when Fringe entered the conversation. It's one of my absolute favorites, definitely neck and neck with BSG.

Jamie Edwards

Snowfall it's the only right choice

WB

Fringe

Hank Scorpio

When was the first one? I completely missed it....

Hank Scorpio

Its like this with a lot of reaction channels tbh. Some of the worst choices imaginable. The Perfect Mix just had a movie poll where Back to the Future FINALLY won (after about 2-3 straight years of losing) and the only reason it won is because Sausage Party was number 2 and anybody who didnt want that voted BTTF just so it would lose.

maya

Guys are you JOKING TWISTED METAL IS RIGHT THERE

mylestheone

Snowfall gets my vote. I loved Silo season 1 but good lord I struggled with Season 2. Felt like nothing was happening until the end

Imari

Silo season 2 was just as good as the first season I personally don’t see how people don’t like that season

Jon Nelson

No twin Peaks is a shame

Chaos T

Fringe please. Not a lot of reactors react to it.

Donkon88

SNOWFALL!!!!!!

James E

SILO!!!!!!!

Tone

Wen Fringe!

Panos

Fringe for sure.

JacobT

Snowfall

Dominic

Snowfall ❄️

SergeTroy

Silo (well, that percentage isn’t terrible and at least it made it to the final poll. GL everybody!

SergeTroy

That’s actually funny for me, I loved every episode of season 2 but for some reason I had a hard time getting myself to watch the last 2 episodes. It was like there was some sort of mental block, like a hypnotist had put me under and said, “Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live … or watch the final two episodes of Sill season 2.”

Paradoxhamartia

I'll admit I'm biased, but Fringe is sincerely such a good series. I hope it wins cause I'm 100% sure people would be happy to discover such a memorable story along with the Normies.

Juan Betancur

And Gamorrah (Italian mafia show HBO )

DELUG

🗣️ Brick by Brick

Mthagod

Snowfall 👀

bmp

Joey boi

I BUILT THIS

Tijuan

Snowwwwfaaalllllll

Chris Skalicky

Fringe and Silo are both fantastic series that I think the couch will enjoy.

VenturaInTheBaja

Bridgerton? Maybe on your own but it is terrible for a react channel. Yikes.

VenturaInTheBaja

They’re going to do BRIDGERTON, this is such a downer…

Sailor Mars

There are other react channels that watch bridgerton and pull in good views so that’s just not true

Jon

yellowjackets

Chris K.

FRINGE! I could do with a rewatch.

Kyle Turman

Will Jojos ever be on one of these lists? Like, ever?

SunnydaleClassof99

Dang, was really hoping Doctor Who would find it's way on here after the last poll. I think there's a big audience for it here & on YouTube. I get a bit of a feeling you aren't super keen to watch it though so that probably is the most important factor.

Michael Colorado

I haven't heard of any of these shows except for silo

Zach Hershman

This vote is for a show that ONLY the guys will be watching. The girls don't have the time for another show.

Manny D.

They replace shows with similar shows usually. They’re not going to replace a live action show with an anime

Manny D.

I’ve been loving Reel Rejects and Badd Medicine’s Bridgerton reactions so that’s a you problem 🤷‍♀️

OBrian Vega

I hope they do Dexter after the sopranos

Kamina 1

Y'all are not ready for Saint. ❄️👖👔 😮‍💨

GrayStark

I am vivified, revivified, and rejuvenescent by the tears of the bridgerton fans below.

Scott (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-08 02:00 Where's the "none of the above" selection? Ooof
2026-03-10 23:45

@eric.na.goo.yen

Admittedly I don’t care for any of these titles. But I figure the boys, and especially Pat, would probably like Snowfall the most. Enjoy, gentlemen.

Joey boi

Snowfall is so gud so many memorable characters 🔥

Neumann

fringe! so gd unappreciated despite it being genuinely so well done and interesting with such interesting characters, it flew under the radar the same way the expanse did

Paul Stanley

Fringe! It's like a sibling to Lost and BSG and would be a perfect replacement show. Great characters, fantastic acting, deep lore exploring cool sci-fi concepts, and an amazing score by Michael Giacchino!

G0d_Ginrai

Fringe! It’s like The X-Files meets Lost meets Supernatural meets Gravity Falls meets Where’s Waldo.

Bryce Nielsen

I'll never understand the type of person who willing comes here to leave a comment like "I've never heard of these shows" Like... congrats? Are you expecting a prize? Why does anyone care that you have not watched any of these shows before? These are all incredibly popular shows, you being ignorant of them does not change that.

Thee Chronicle

Who is voting for Bridgerton? 🙄 lol

Kwame James

You misspelled broadwalk empire

Thee Chronicle

If Silo aint winning. I guess im changing my vote to fringe

Michael Colorado

People are forgeting how boring fringe was I stopped watching after season 1

MojoJojoGojo

I actually enjoyed Bridgerton just finished s4 right now with my girlfriend..normies would like it especially Rana....but snowfall needs this Win

Gwyn

Snowfall beats all of these, and I say that as a Silo fan.

Gwyn

BODIES BODIES BODIES

Gwyn

THIS MAN SHIT

DELUG

Brick by Brick

SnapGrapplePop

It must be tough for them to put up a series that has such a fall off. Some series of Dexter are really good, but its last series is legendarily bad

SnapGrapplePop

It can be difficult to judge a show if you’ve only watched 1/5th of it. Many shows find their feet after the first season

Saequan

Snowfall 😮‍💨

Stefan

fringe is more up you alls ally and highly underrated but loved

Stefan

yeah and so underated

Stefan

100%

Stefan

dopnt be uncultured

Mark

snowfall will win but Fringe definitely deserves a chance...both spectacular shows!

Sean Carleton

Fringe is the most Lostesque show of the bunch. There are reasons it's still talked about.

PurelyRed

not realizing that you guys put alice in borderland in the poll three days ago cost me so hard because i have been waiting for a reaction to that since forever T-T but...i guess my vote goes to snowfall i suppose..

MEM

Silo

DELUG

Pls Watch Grimm 🔥

Dale D. Ellis

SILO PLZ!!!!!!!!!! 🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿

Cee Jay

Twisted Metal and Silo people need to come over to Fringe.

RAV3RXTZ

Come on FRINGE! It's one of the best sci-fi shows and it is a complete finished series. I don't have apple, so haven't seen any of their shows yet.

Grimbane42

Welp, there goes Twisted Metal lol Can't wait till one of my stream teams decides to watch it. Stephanie Beatriz and Will Arnett are gold in it. Anthony Mackey is perfect as a lead too.

Kyle Turman

It was just a generic question dude

Aj

Brick by brick

Drueisms

Fringe and Bridgerton. Full couch for Fringe, just the boys for Bridgerton.

Solebat

Stargate SG-1

Rosemary

snowfall is the show of pain and despair can we watch something lighthearted and romantic for once

Rosemary

I want a full couch for Bridgerton at least Ketty and Rana with the boys we def need a little feminine energy on that couch so I'm fine if we don't get it rn so you guys can have more time to work out the schedule the dream would be Chris and Ketty ofc, Rana, Suraj, Pat, Spidey, and Navi if possible 🫰

Azalea Skye

The last season and finale were absolutely terrible, but Dexter: Resurrection was amazing. l'm so excited for more Dexter.

Azalea Skye

Yes!!!!! 12 Monkeys is amazing, one of my favorite shows. I wish more people would discover it.

Mike Drop

If the Normies would watch Fringe before Blind Wave, I bet Eric would quit and come over.

Chris Skalicky

Switching my vote from Silo to Fring with Silo slipping in the voting.

Thee Chronicle

Switching my vote from silo to fringe aswell. Lets get fringe over the line. Come on fans of Silo lets switch to Fringe.

Fede GG

Please, FRINGE for the WIN !!!!!!! I can't wait for you all to meet OLIVIA and WALTER, 2 of my favorite characters from any SCI FI show.

Michael Colorado

I love how passionate you are about your screen time. It’s cute that you think this is a personality trait.

Chaos T

Underrated comment.

Chaos T

There will be a large number of people who will vote for Bridgerton in the next poll if people voting for Bridgerton switch their vote to Fringe.

Paradoxhamartia

Imagine living a life where you don't know who Olivia FUCKING Dunham is. We must save the Normies from such a cruel fate!

Kamina 1

I voted for Snowfall. I've never watched Fringe. But seeing how much love that show is getting in the comments, and the comparisons that have been made to other shows that I love, I want it to win just so I have a reason to finally binge it lol. I've seen many of the sci fi legends like X Files, Battlestar Galactica, The Expanse, Gravity Falls, etc. And even Supernatural i love as well. Let's go FRINGE!!! Hopefully someone high up makes an executive decision, and Fringe get pushed through 🙏

Stefan

Snowfall is boring

Stefan

Silo fans help us win fringe and we will help you get silo next

Grimbane42

switched my vote to fringe

Joey boi

I really enjoyed it and the acting is p gud, just dislike the ending?

SnapGrapplePop

I’m not hopeful on Fringe making up that ground, so I restarted watching it again. It’s so good.

Gershwin Alessandro Farao

I remember the days of their The Wire reactions..Snowfall will be really for them