Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Leave a like and comment your favorite part of the reaction!

Files

Comments

ForWhyTho

My whole family was addicted to this show my 3 uncles and their kids, myself and my grandma even would go to my Dad's every Sunday to watch the show (well we all broke away once he moved after Season 4) but rewatching it always brings back those fun memories and debates wed have watching it and the after show Talking Dead 💕

Warius

Boy, the more I find out about that Shane guy, the less I care for him

* Rose *

When Lori said, “Maybe this isn’t a world for children anymore,” that line always hits deep. I understand what she means, but zombies or not, children have always faced cruelty, hardship, and sadness in life. That doesn’t mean the world isn’t meant for them. As a parent, I hate the idea of my kids facing any kind of hardship, but aside from the obvious zombies and apocalyptic circumstances, a lot of what Lori described already exists in today’s world. The fear, pain, and uncertainty are still there.... just in different forms. You could easily look at the world today and say the exact same thing for some children.

Sherry Bandito

Just invest in Kleenex lol you might need it

Sherry Bandito

I like you watched the opening credits. It’s some cool art and it changes. So many just skip it

Dayton Hansen

Continuing to very much enjoy, can't wait for more!

Angelica Albanese

"Welcome to the show that's become my addiction, and also my depression, at the same time" Welcome to TWD family, Tom! :P

Narth_Vader

I’m glad you can understand and empathize with Lori’s perspective on Carl potentially dying. A lot of reactors can easily vilify her over this episode without considering the grim implications of the world they live in now. For all she knows there could be nothing but death and suffering beyond the hellscape they’ve already witnessed. Their detour at the CDC solidified that there is no hope for a cure. As a parent myself, I think it’s completely valid to consider if your child be spared of whatever horrors may be waiting. But Rick is also right to keep hoping and fighting because Carl still sees goodness in this world. These dilemmas are why season 2 is one of the best!

WillDaBeast Grasslands

The crazy thing is, Shane does the worst things for the best reasons. It doesn't justify what he did, but it explains so much about his inner conflict of emotions because he knows he's crossing a line and he doesn't like it, yet he does it anyway. The look on his face when he came back alone really says it all; he feels himself losing his sanity and he feels helpless about it. He tries to do the best thing possible as quickly and lazily as possible because that's what he thinks will guarantee him the best results. I think deep down there's an admirability about his dedication to make the "hard" choices that harbor the best results, but like you said, the ego makes it dangerous, and wreckless. That being said, although Otis was an innocent victim the whole way through, I can kinda understand Shane's thought process for sacrificing him even though I heavily disagree with it. Shane didn't want to kill Otis. I'm willing to bet that Shane actually started really liking Otis. But in his mind, in that moment, Otis was no longer a human being, but an obstacle between him and saving Carl's life. That "obstacle" was also the one responsible for Carl's current situation as well, even though it was unintentional. So although the arithmetic behind his decision is distorted, I find it hard to call it "evil". He didn't get pleasure from it, he just gave up too quickly and put saving Carl's life before anything, and anyone else. An admirable, yet naive, impulsive, and dangerous thought process.

Daniel Burnham

I really think about this episode in the theme of Rick losing faith in God after the deer but still clinging to the past as his thing of worship. Shane and Lori have lost their faith in people and nature being kind but Rick still remembers the myths of the old world, his stories of Shane and his “reasonableness” that Lori hated so much in the first season. She asks him why it would be better for him to live and he doesn’t have an answer, he just has faith. It’s also him holding out that allows the miracle of Shane coming back just in time. So his faith does sustain their world because the righteous and moral world doesn’t come from reason.

Sherry Bandito

Shane let his true colors out again.rip Otis

Timothy Payne

To answer your question about walkers sneaking up on people: my own personal head canon is that our guys are so exposed to gunfire without ear protection, and that’s why they don’t seem to hear them sometimes. Just my head canon.

Angelica Albanese

oke actual thoughts on the episode and your reactions: (random thought) Love how episode 3 starts off with Shane like, "New haircut, who dis?" I love that Daryl, who is bothered by Carol's crying (not in the sense of it's annoying but in the sense of, she's sad and he empathizes with her situation), and Andrea's noises at trying to load that clip (which probably did annoy him lol), chooses to leave/make himself useful instead of yelling at them (like Merle probably would've). The scene at the high school when Shane and Otis are taking a breather and the walkers sneak up on them on the other side of the fence. I totally get what you're saying about the ambient noise they should've heard. I think the sound design choice there was intentional. Shane and Otis are very winded and focused on gaining that air back so neither weren't really paying attention to noise, even though they should've been. There are other moments in this show, including season one, where we get the ambient walker noises in the background of a scene, so I figured there was intention behind not putting it here. Could've just been a cheap jumpscare and I'm looking more into it than the showrunners ever intended, to be fair. Poor Otis, his murder is so brutal :( And I agree, Shane is an evil man.

Elliot

Thanks for playing the intro Tom. Appreciate it.

Korivex

One thing to keep in mind. At first Shane tried to give the bags to Otis and told him to run a head. Otis wouldn't leave Shane, so in Shane's eyes they would both die and Carl would too. He was willing to be the sacrifice but Otis wouldn't go for it. I think Shane did this to save Carl, not himself. It is still a line, it was still terrible... Rick would have gotten both of them out. This act says a lot about Shane's character and what he is willing to do.

GingerBread

I kinda got that feeling as well watching this. pushed to his literal limit Shane enters that killer fight or flight type mode and acts without worrying about consequences. at least in the moment as I agree I feel like the look on his face when he gets back of shock and horror shows that he really really didn't want to do it but had to act.

MochaMishu

If it was Rick out there with Otis I believe he would have done anything he could to get them both out of there, there was still a chance to get out of there together. Shane knew that there was a chance, but he also knew if he killed Otis his chances to get the stuff and get out of there would be much more likely. I think about just how much time it took for him to fight off Otis and get the bag, if they just kept going together.

griffin(aruto) cofell

lol it's gotta be something like that. The amount of gunshots directly next to their heads over and over

Elliot

Doesnt get a much more scumbag move than what Shane did. And he didn't for a second do that for Carls sake. That was purely to save his own neck. And spot on Tom, he will kill Rick any chance he thinks he can get away with it and Ricks his friend. The rest of the group are completely expendable in Shanes eyes unless it benefits him.

Demceez

I always chalked it up to to the fact the gun fire 100% will have nulled their hearing and adrenaline and fear can significantly disrupt your ability to concentrate n hear. When you are terrified, your brain enters survival mode, causing shifts in your senses and cognitive processing

AJ

I've been thinking about this episode since the start of season one. Shane's choices are so ✨questionable✨ You really want to shake him a little. Or a lot

Brock

i was itching for more TWD, keep it up Tom!

Ethan

It is mental what Shane did, however. After several rewatches of the show... Am I a bad person for not feeling sorry for his decision..? It's all hypothetical of if they both would've made it out or not, but the end line is that if the medicine did not reach Carl in time, he would also be dead.

Zumanji

The beginning of the fall of Shane? He crossed a line that he may not come back from, he’s devolving perhaps? He already had the base personality of an angering disrespectful hothead & you add in an apocalypse to that base personality you may end up with a ticking time bomb 🫣😅

Frank(ie) D

“I’m kinda sick” *sips from the Whataburger cup* LOL. The show only gets crazier uncle Tommy…

Jesse James

I think Shane has some sociopathic traits in him, like he's obviously willing to let someone die for his own short term personal gain. Rick definitely would've been more of a tactician.

Jesse James

I don't have kids, I wouldn't mind kids but as you put I'm one of those guys who does not see current world affairs as good for kids, if your kids are already here that's another thing. :)

Bro

This episode always got me. Shane and Otis working like a team to survive and get out of there. And then Shane leaves him there to die. It surprised when I first witnessed it. Too me Otis was an underrated character. That if he lived longer I think could have been a fun character to watch his progression.

Fender Fox

Oh I forgot... Shane's that guy.... 🤦

Bro

Season 2 is a literal work of art and that cliffhanger with Otis’s death was just the start.

Reaction Therapy

I can totally relate, and I can only imagine life for these children who will NEVER know normal😢

Reaction Therapy

Agreed, and I also struggle with how Shane pouts about not being the leader and always seeming like he has the right answer, which usually means leaving someone behind😩

Erica Smith

Can’t say this enough. Shane forever lost me, from the moment he put that gun up behind Rick’s back in the woods. Didn’t expect much from him since.

Brittany Lewandowski

I 1000% agree with Shane's decision here; I'd have shot Otis, too. Am I evil? What he did isn't evil at all. The only choice in that moment was to kill 1 for 2 to survive or all 3 of us are dead. He literally had no other choice. Shane isn't evil yea can clearly see in his eyes how fucked up and guilty he feels after doing it. I also really hate the fact that during all the Shane-shooting-Otis debate, no one mentions SHANE TRIED TO SACRIFICE HIMSELF FIRST. If Otis had agreed, Shane would be dead. Most people, when they look at these situations, look at them from a real-world viewpoint instead of asking, "What would you do in that situation?" And I'm sorry if my choices are between killing the guy who got us into this due to his own recklessness in the first place or saving myself and the child I love like my own. You're going to shoot. Most people are shooting the other to ensure you get that kid what they need. Thinking otherwise is naive. Especially when most people say they'd kill for their child, but in this case they wouldn't? It wasn't a matter of wanting to be on top; if it was, he wouldn't have tried to sacrifice him earlier on in the trip. I find a lot of hypocrisy in this fandom, and a lot of my views are hot takes. Shane is in my top 3 favorites in this show, and I will always defend him (except on the Lori assault). Lori is the character I hate the most out of any fictional character ever, and I do understand her reasoning for her thoughts on Carl. All the people who think she's evil for it are once again looking at it from a modern society viewpoint and not a "What if I were in that situation?"

Brittany Lewandowski

Shane was the leader, tough, and no one died; their camp was safe. Then Rick came up and ruined it all and just took over leadership. Shane generally is always right. Sometimes you have to leave people behind. I dont think his actions here need justification, he did the only the could there or they were all going to die.

Stephen L

Are you watching for the first time as well?

Stephen L

By far the most excited I’ve ever been is for this show with you reacting. I love love love breaking bad but for some reason this show has a choke hold on me haha

Reaction Therapy

Great feedback Angelica! Thank you…. This show has me hooked😊

Reaction Therapy

This is true for me….once you make this decision, you can easily make it again, he crossed a line😩

Reaction Therapy

Here’s my issue…Shane is about self preservation, for him and who he cares most about, therefore everyone else matters less than he and his tribe…why didn’t he come back to the group and tell them honestly what happened? Because it would have gotten him killed I’m still in the camp with Lori that Carl not surviving in this horrific world might save him from immense trauma…but it’s all a judgement game Brittany, I love the fact that you’re here and making these comments because they make sense and help me see a new perspective….thank you for saying what you said I LOVE THIS SHOW!!!😊

Jack

I am so glad you're having a good time recording these reactions to TWD. It's one of if not my all time favorite TV shows/movies. I can't wait to see your reactions to later episodes and tense scenes!

Dave Canon

I live 1.5 hrs away from where they filmed 95-98% of this show. Was able to even meet some of the actors. I met Daryl (Norman), glen (Steven), Hershel (Scott), t-dog (iron e),and several others that haven’t been introduced in the show yet. Those were the days.

Jack

Nice to see another tøp fan here😁

Valerie ♡

Every time I've watched this show I'm never not disturbed by what happened to Otis, how unfair and painful his fate was

Brittany Lewandowski

On the other hand, telling them what really happened, Hershel may have decided not to help Carl and kick them off the farm. (He might also fix Carl because he's a kid) and kick them off the farm. I also don't think anyone would have killed him for it either. Rick and Lori will just be happy Carl's alive, and I also think our group would agree with it. Each one for different, varying reasons. But I also think in this world, you need to be about self-preservation; that's how you survive. Caring about strangers? That's not safe or smart. You have to protect your own. (I do have to say I also have the entire series and spinoffs and what not that alter my view on certain situations.)

Brittany Lewandowski

It was fair though, he was reckless and got himself in a situation where the only option wa skill him or 3 people die. He should let Shane Sacrifice himself when he tried to. Which people never remember.

Brittany Lewandowski

But also he isn't about self-preservation, as he offered himself up as a sacrifice to let Otis go with all the supplies first. He had been willing to die to get the supplies to Carl. If Otis had just accepted, he'd be alive, and Shane would be dead.

Brittany Lewandowski

So you don't remember that he had offered to die earlier on and let Otis go with the supplies. No? Because it doesn't fit the narrative. He did it for Carl. Clearly, you don't have anyone you love enough to kill for. It wasn't a scumbag move; it was the ONLY move. It's Otis's own fault he died. He could have let Shane sacrifice himself and taken the supplies first; he could not have been reckless and paid attention before shooting a gun.

Brittany Lewandowski

This choice isnt questionable at all. It was the only choice. All 3 of them would have died if he hadnt. He loves Carl like his own son and was basically his second father at that point. Everyone would kill for their child. and if you wouldnt you dont deserve to be a parent.

Brittany Lewandowski

You're crazy if you think Rick wouldn't have gotten them both out; he'd have killed Otis too. Let's be real. I agree with the rest mostly.

Brittany Lewandowski

Season 2 is my least favorite season, but Otis got himself in the situation. Don't be so reckless when shooting a gun. And when someone offers to sacrifice themselves for you (when you put them in that situation), you should take it.

Brittany Lewandowski

There was no chance, and Shane would have killed him, too, to get out. They were literally being caught up to, they would all be dead otherwise. They fought for a like a minute thats not enough time to get out.

Brittany Lewandowski

It wasn't for his gain, though; it was for Carl. If it was just about him, why did he try to sacrifice himself earlier to let Otis take the supplies? Everyone forgets this because it removes half the argument and ability to call him evil.

Sherry Bandito

Yes it is!! My favorite kinda people ❤️

Triad

Yeah this season is where shit starts to get real

AJ

So sorry this comment was so triggering for you. Have a wonderful day!

Nail Orhan

dude when the intro fades in from a scene to the actual intro its so fricking HYPE

Reaction Therapy

Huge flex Dave! I’m envious😊 that is sooooo cool, not only to meet them but to be around where they filmed and see how it got brought to life🙏

Amy J

I knew when I heard Shane's story he was lying, he's not a very good liar but with what everyone is going through? Understandable that they would want to just believe him

Tzahi Wolkowicz

I would assume it gets to you because you can see yourself in the situation. Not a zombie apocalypse - but an apocalypse. We all can. Serial killers, mobsters - all fun and games, but we can't relate to them. We can relate to a collective disaster striking ordinary people - we are surrounded by wars; some of us live through wars. So in some aspects, it hits closer to home than many other fictional works. It could have been any other type of disaster with the same group dynamics - and it would have worked well.

Korivex

Well, we don't really know for sure and your view is realistic but I see Rick as someone who wants to be the saviour and is always trying to protect everyone, he takes on the responsibility to keep everyone alive. I think he would have seen it as his failure if Otis didn't make it out alive. So, I think he would have come up with some other clever way for them to both make it out alive. I've never seen Rick sacrifice anyone before or after.

Bro

I can understand your take and respect your opinion. However Otis couldn’t have known anyone was there. All he knew was there was a deer and he was hunting so I don’t see why he would need to be more careful. If he didn’t know living people were there. That’s something Otis couldn’t have predicted.

Bro

Nevermind I understand what part you’re talking about. I can completely agree with that. Definitely reckless but you can tell Otis had a good heart. Ultimately in the end he saved Carl just as much as Shane but not in the way he expected of course.

Nicholas J Hoover

I feel like the world only used to be like this. it's so weak to consider giving up better then living in strife. I'm not trying to disrespect that, just consider that having to struggle use to be normal

Nicholas J Hoover

I don't vilify her, but it is incredibly misguided. Rick was right.

Jake

That question of Why should I keep my child alive in this world goes for everyone. Rick and Lori have guns, they can opt out just as easily, yet they dont. Yes they go through terrible things, but they still want to live. If you'd ask Carl, he'd probably want to live too, imo it wouldn't be fair to make that choice for him.

Fatal N Felony

i feel like they shouldn't decide whether carl lives or dies. as bad as the world is you already brought him into it and he deserves to be able to make his own decision now

Zero

The thing about Shane here, he really didn't want to have to do that and it wasn't a decision made callously. You can see how frustrated he is when he tells Otis to leave him behind and he refuses; he knows that one of them isn't going to make it and right in that moment he comes to the conclusion of what he thinks he needs to do, because Carl's life is his priority. And he was the one with the limp that was the most vulnerable, so he knew he was probably the one that was going to die if he didn't sacrifice Otis and he might not have made it back either. Hard choice to have to make all around, honestly.

Dee D

I'm sorry this show depresses you. I watched it Sunday nights when it originally aired and I swear sometimes I felt like I just needed to call in to work on Mondays! 😂😂 I sometimes wanted to tell my boss I had a loss in the family because that's what it would feel like. Just stock up on Kleenex and keep watching. We're crying with you.

Amos Smith

“this is my addiction and my depression” i get it tom. its been years since the show ended and i still cannot get over how phenomenal these early seasons are. i lost one of my twin sons almost a year ago, just a little over a week before his 1st birthday. but even before my own personal trauma; this section with carl, no matter how many times i watch it, just gives me such a desperate feeling and i think that’s part of why i think it is such a phenomenal experience. the way this was all written and shown, it makes you FEEL EVERYTHING the characters are feeling and that, in my opinion, is a mark of MASTERFUL cinema.

Amos Smith

i may be in the minority here, just finished watching with you tom, but i don’t think shane had a choice here. he tried to tell otis to just go and take the bag. shane hits the ground, clearly frustrated, and says okay and they get up. i think shane’s frustration in that moment, whether he knew it or not, was because he knew that he would have to kill Otis. Otis wouldn’t leave him there, which would end with neither of them getting back with the things to save Carl’s life. that being said, i do think this is the final nail in the coffin that makes shane give up that last little shred of humanity he had left.