Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

New Show After Squid Game Final Poll

  • True Detective S1 241
  • Bojack Horseman 170
  • 2026-10-20
  • —2026-10-22
  • 411 votes
{'title': 'New Show After Squid Game Final Poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'True Detective S1', 'votes': 241}, {'text': 'Bojack Horseman', 'votes': 170}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 10, 22, 17, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 10, 20, 23, 44, 3, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 411}

Content

We have decided that You does not qualify as a short series show. I (Nick) am completely at fault and I apologize for keeping it in the polls as long as I did. We are happy to explain what a "short series" is in the comments or in the next short series voting cycle. Essentially, the show needs to be no longer than 40 hours (closer to 35 preferably) of reaction time, not runtime and You would push the reaction time over that number. Here is the final poll!

Comments

Ceylen

True detective gang🗣️🙏🏼

ammogreed

Let's goooooo true detectiveeweeee

Stephen L

Not the horse 😭

Alice Bernal

bojack we’ve been waiting so long 🙏🙏

Nick Oleson

Dang now we gonna be stuck with a cartoon talking horse. True detective gotta win!!!

Lyric

True detective

Agustin Mercado

Should’ve added the fourth place option to replace the 3rd place option

PJ H

Bojack!

Jesse James

RT sure knows how to split fandoms haha. I ain't seen either of these shows.

Lucas

Bojack please! Literally the reason I joined the Patreon was to vote for it

Andrew R

I think N/A was mistakenly omitted

ROSE 🌹

I get why YOU is out but im sad!! Come on TD its seriosuly 7 episodes, then we can have another vote!

BugBite23

Why are people against Bojack? Like really? I think we need more animated shows!

ROSE 🌹

No offence to the Bo lovers, but You would have taken this, Im gonna be ticked if the horse wins lol.

Busy Wimp

Doubt it seems like there's some sort of bias towards it by more than half his audience and it sucks its the only reason im paying for patreon

Green

It was winning by a lot last I saw this is a tragedy

ROSE 🌹

It's because it actually didn't fit in with the rules, it's over 40 hours, Nick didn't realize.

Magus

looks like the bojack base pulled some BS. your rule was 40 episodes or 40ish hours. 40hours and 40 minutes isnt over by THAT much. theres many great shows that are barely over the 40 hour mark. i think in the future perhaps having short be between 20-30 then you could have medium be say 40-70 episodes. like the walking dead is 4x longer than You. which is significant. like the walking dead with 177 episodes vs something you would never watch like stargate sg1 with its 214 episodes or supernatural and its 327 episodes.. which im sure most of your viewers would be voting on supernatural if that showed up on a poll. as much as i want to see bojack and have ZERO interest in True Detective im voting true detective just because i think You got ruled out just because bojack people cried about you likely going to win out over it. so the scales need balancing

Squiggles

I would love for a karate kid trilogy reaction and then the cobra Kai show! Would be cool to see tom break down the mentality of the kids in the show as it goes on. And I think the show is around 40 hours total.

ROSE 🌹

I get what you Mean, but with YOU you gotta think, 45 mins an episodes works out to an hour, with the stopping and starting for Toms reactions, it is only 43 hours, but I get it, it doesnt fit the rules specified and there were lots of shows that could have been named if we were being loose on the rules, I personally love Ted Lasso but its 46 hours so I didn't put it in. They can't make everyone happy!

ROSE 🌹

I dont think there is a bias per say, True Detective is a front runner besides being great we can watch it quick! 7 episodes...and have another vote in weeks..Just makes sence. I feel like Bojack has lots of fans here!

CJ

true detective then we can vote for bojack soon after with how short it is

Russ Tan

Both of these shows are masterpieces in their own ways. Whichever one doesn't win is going to keep getting voted for in other polls and you're going to keep having people voting for things out of spite. It's very clear to me that people want both, so just queue them up.

Ana Saldana

i’ve never seen either but i’m voting for the one without the talking horse sorry bojack lovers 😭😭

Busy Wimp

Just reading the comments here seems like there's a distain for it other than the fans

Harley

Is it fair that some people are voting against something rather than voting for something?

MLG

People calling it a cartoon like a slur

MLG

Rose you have SEEN the comments? There is a huge bias

MLG

Yeah but Bojack has been up for so long

ShouldHaveDoneThisEarlier

How is it unfair to use your vote to express : „I don’t like this, please react to the other show.“?

CJ

i know and i also love that show and can’t wait for his reaction to it but i think it justs make sense to go ahead and watch TD season 1

Busy Wimp

Bojack has been in the polls and getting second for over a year now

Gabino Martinez

Bojack Horseman could offer so much more to break down when it comes to a therapist perspective

Janet

I didn't vote at all.

Harley

This channel has a lot of content on offer. There have been many shows on the polls I have no interest in, I never voted against them, I hope the people that enjoy them liked Tom's reactions to it. It would have been selfish of me to vote against them out of spite.

MLG

You are a goat. I did the same for dexter

Daniel Burnham

Voting Bojack explicitly because of the haters

James L

I get your point, but Bojack is within the rules being under 40 hours. I don't get how that's BS.

James L

Another vote for Bojack. Starting to feel like Sisyphus at this point

MamaBinTN

Yesss, let's GO! True Detective!

Anika

Am I wrong to feel cheated with this last minute change? Like in the end of the first Hunger games? I feel You, winning should be honored. Sorry, but I don't feel comfortable voting in this last poll now, out of principle.

Anika

I'm refusing to vote in this poll. The mistake wasn't our fault. I have nothing against BoJack. I originally voted You and Bojack. But it wasn't winning. Fair is fair.

Anika

"It takes approximately 43 hours (or about 37.5 to 43 hours depending on credits) to watch the complete You series on Netflix. Breakdown by Season Total Seasons: 5 seasons Total Episodes: 50 episodes (10 episodes per season) Average Episode Length: About 42 to 60 minutes (roughly 52 minutes per episode)"

Edward

You won last pool btw

Luke H

BOJACK PLEASE

Luke H

BOJACK

Heather

personally, I've got more than enough shows on this channel to watch (came for TWD, now got The Haunting, AND GoT has started? oh, I'm locked tf in) to not really be too disappointed by this change/final poll between two shows I don't have interest in so I've just not voted this time around, but I am really gutted about You being disqualified. hopefully after The Haunting Of Hill House, Tom will choose another show from the recommendations we've sent in and that one could be You, altho I'm unsure on the time constraints for the slot of his own pick.

CampEvolution

Dang I was looking forward to You haha. Still hope you post the rest of Haunting of Hill House!

CampEvolution

I opened the Patreon app to this post lol. As soon as I looked, I see more Haunting! Ty lol!!!

CampEvolution

Also I do remember S1 of True Detective being very good.

Nexus

should Bojack not be moved to the new tier? as its a cartoon?

Elliot

You might be able to dare to hope this time haha.

ukii

cant believe ppl are still this closed minded in 2026 lolll

ukii

literally but people are afraid and too closed minded for "cartoons" which is super sad bc they're missing on a shows geared towards mental health.... tom is a therapist people always forget that 😭

ukii

the rules were clear tho

kalindi

Except they weren't, which is why Nick has had to make this post in the first place, to clarify he meant *reaction* time, not *run* time? If the rules were clear, YOU never would've been in the poll to begin with, and nobody would have gotten their hopes up for no reason.

Dashed

Why not just finish true detective then do bojack after?

Nix

True Detective

Sherry Bandito

Did YOU not make the cut? Was looking forward to that one

ShouldHaveDoneThisEarlier

It is not spiteful to express a preference via a vote, even if none of the things on offer are what you actually wanted. Also, having a preference doesn’t mean that you automatically dislike the other thing. Not talking about myself btw. I love True Detective, but Bojack is a great show aswell.

Magus

you is good. not game of thrones good. but still good. i really wanted to see bojack but i stand by my decision to vote for a show i dont want to watch instead on principal that you was taken out of the running because it was 40 minutes over the allotted runtime... thats nonsense. they even said ABOUT 40 hours.... define ABOUT. i get some people feel a certain way about GoT because of some of overly sexual stuff. especially the incest.. but look at human history. common practice for royalty to keep power within the family... or just living in alabama (joking cause stereotypes and all that) but seriously we watched 2 hours of GoT and there was maybe 2 minutes of incest. if you look at the over all run time i dont think the total incest time even = 30 minutes of the show. boiling GoT down to just being about incest is like saying You is all about rebinding old books.

Caleb Thomas Smalling

I'm starting to feel like Bojack will never win one of these polls. People won't give it a chance. I just don't understand.

Edward

Just for 2 episode

Anika

You may think so, either way, they should have caught it before. I run a business. If there is a mistake, especially one I didn't catch or correct, I send them a new item, no cost to the client. I honor what was expected. So changing things, like this, at the last minute, rubs me the wrong way. Especially with how long their voting process is. It could have been caught earlier.

Anika

You was winning by twice as many votes. So, yeah. Doesn't feel right.

Ethan Price

They'll possibly make note of the popularity of the vote and then it'll get some attention for the longer series maybe. I don't think it's that big a deal really but I guess I can understand why someone would feel begrudged with it being a paid membership, but I will say if you're gonna keep paying for the Patreon then may as well still vote for whats gonna appear on your feed day in day out

Ethan Price

I do think reaction time is also harder for us to work out than runtime to be fair, how tf we supposed to know how long he'll react to a scene for hahahahah

Sherry Bandito

Oh that’s too bad it’s such a great show

Sherry Bandito

I might be the odd one Øut for not giving got a chance, just everything I’ve seen and heard I feel I wouldn’t like it. Maybe I will try it again. I loved You though

Mason Miller

You could say the same thing for true detective

Magus

same goes for game of thrones just because some people are too close minded for a bit of family lovin. which is actually something that happens in the real world and used to happen a lot in royal families. and makes up like maybe 3% of GoT. but yea lets over inflate those scenes and say its 100% all about that

ukii

yea a bunch of people in this channel are still stuck w the "animation=bad" mentality.... in 2026 mind u🥲

Anika

The approximate time I found was 37 hours to about 43 hours. They could have let it slide, (it wasn't over by much), since it wasn't removed earlier.

Anika

I've said enough of what may have been unpopular opinions, so I'm not touching this one. But it seems an interesting psychology of people with so much hate in their hearts for something that's animated, despite the content of the actual show, especially for people that have no idea what something may contain.

Anika

Nope, it won't win, and it may never win on it's own, because a lot of people here seem to dislike animated shows with a passion, for no other reason but to hate. They vote against it, just to keep it from winning. But yeah, I'm stepping back a bit. Too much stress and drama.

Anika

The hate is kind of gross in here, for something many people enjoy.

BugBite23

Well it's just weird to me. I've found some animated shows to be so much more interesting than regular shows at times. I follow another reaction group and they always make a space for different categories of shows. There's almost always an anime/cartoon, there's a drama, there's movies of all kinds... It's such a great channel and it feels like everyone has something they love to watch there. It's very accommodating and positive there. Surprising that the therapist's followers are not more positive and supportive of others. I like Tom but I'm worried about the fighting or disrespect in the comments. I think these issues need to be addressed so everyone can enjoy things he reacts to.

Busy Wimp

Facts another comment said it well enough. It's been a runner up so many times it should just be queued for another time in the future.

Pushindazeez

Ugh, why not just put all the cartoons on that tier so those of us who dislike them aren't subjected to it (ie. Cartoon horse)

kalindi

You're not subjected to it though? You can just choose not to watch the animation reactions. Nobody is forcing you to watch anything 🤷🏻‍♀️

doll

Will "You" ever be reacted to or is out of the question completely?

MLG

There used to always be an animated show, dunno what happened. I guess there's the anime tier now but idk.