Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Mostly small stuff, but I think it adds up.

Files

Previews only

Patron early release: Fixing the Monk

If you would like to know how I calculate damage or how baseline damage is determined, I go through it in this video: https://youtu.be/zg0bAl1WPGQ Timestamps: 0:00 Intro 1:52 What to fix 5:10 What to avoid 9:38 Martial Arts fixes 13:31 Hit die fix 13:56 Ki fixes 15:46 Quickened healing fix 16:52 Stunning strike fix 17:42 Stillness of mind fix 19:28 Timeless body fix 20:28 Empty body fix 20:56 Perfect self fix 21:36 Review 24:10 DPR analysis My 11 fixes for the Monk: Hit die d10 Martial arts allows light or medium armor Martial arts die(dice): d6, d8, 2d6, 3d6 Ki DC is based on dexterity Patient defense doesn’t have a resource cost Quickened healing costs 1 ki point Stunning Strike has a limited resource pool, then costs ki Stillness of Mind now works as it should (The intent here is your bonus action is still available) Timeless body recovers a level of exhaustion on a short rest Empty Body is a bonus action Perfect self now adds +4 to Dexterity and Constitution Playing with math - the DPR calculations: (14x0.6) plus critical chance (8x0.05) = Thats 8.8 DPR. Level 2 add 2 flurry of blows per short rest = 9.31 DPR (6.5x0.6) + (3.5x0.05) = 4.08 per attack 2 attacks over 16 rounds = 0.51 Level 3 one more FoB = 9.56 Level 4 +1 damage per hit, one more FoB (16x0.6) + (8x0.05)= 10 (7.5x0.6) + (3.5x0.05)= 4.68/8 = 0.58 Total DPR 10.58 Level 5 - Martial arts die now d8, extra attack added, versatile now adds +1 damage (27.5x0.6) + (13.5x0.05) = 16.88 5 Flurry of Blows = (8.5x0.6) + (4.5x0.05)=5.33 x 5 / 16 = 1.66 Total DPR 18.54 Level 6 - +.33 = 18.87 Level 7 - +.33 = 19.2 Level 8 - Dex 20, damage increases by 1 per attack (30.5x0.6) + (13.5x0.05) = 18.98 FoB (9.5x0.6) + (4.5x0.05) = 5.93 = 0.37 per attack (2.96) Level 9 - 22.31 Level 10 - 22.68 Level 11 - Martial arts die scales (d10) (33.5x0.6)+(16.5x.05)= 20.93 FoB (10.5x0.6) + (5.5x0.05) = 6.68 = 0.41 per attack (4.52) Level 12 + 0.41 Level 16 - FoB damage is now maximum (using every attack) Level 17 - martial arts die scales (36.5x0.6)+(19.5x0.05)=22.88 Level 20 - Damage increases by 2, chance to hit 70% (42.5x0.7)+(19.5x0.05)=30.73 Revised to 2d6 at 11 and 3d6 at 17. Level 11 - Martial arts die scales (2d6) (38x0.6)+(21x.05)= 23.85 FoB (12x0.6) + (7x0.05) = 7.55 = 0.47 per attack (5.17) Level 12-16 + 0.47 Level 16 - FoB damage is now maximum (using every attack) Level 17 - martial arts die scales to 3d6 (48.5x0.6)+(31.5x0.05)=30.68 Level 20 - Damage increases by 2, chance to hit 70% (54.5x0.7)+(31.5x0.05)=39.73 Join my discord: https://discord.gg/6z97aaq Follow me on Twitter: https://twitter.com/ChrisHonkala

Comments

Ken Livingston

Didn't you do a TreantMonk Variant video for Monk?

DOUGLAS REYNOLDS

The changes are great. Having to be "forced" to increase dexterity and wisdom is harsh. So just focusing on dexterity is fair. I like the increase of unarmed damage as well as it represents monks kicking kneeing and not just punching. And while wearing medium armor is a nice option it is definitely not game breaking. I think the DC needs to be a choice between strength or dexterity like the battlemaster but perhaps wisdom also... With the option of medium armor, a player might leave dexterity at a 14 or 16. I love the stunning strike pool. Great fix. AWESOME What might be cool is KI/smite feature. You hit and you can spend a KI point to add one martial art die of extra damage. It's not OP.

Anonymous

Really great changes. Usually, monks are really rare at my table, but if someone wants to play it, I will probably use these changes. Now I want to see how you change the subclasses, because there are some horrible features there. Putting my bet in a dedicated spellcasting with Four Elements monk (kinda like Eldritch Knight and Arcane Trickster).

Krakenbreath

I like the changes, but I think Martial Arts die should scale as 1d4@1, 2d4@5, 3d4@11 and 4d4@17 because players role playing a monk should be mindful rolling their dice. Also, sad to see Standing Still go to the sidines (probably my favourite feature from ALL the variants).

Glenn Wilson

This is a solid fix for the base class but not AL compatible so unless I start my own campaign in my own world (did so in 1974 and with AD&D/1st, what a lot of work,) not changing anything. Waiting to see what you do with subclasses…

Glenn Wilson

Oh, and… have you thought about “fixing” the martial classes or is Rune Knight the “way to go” to balance them against Casters? Honestly I almost think the closest balance was in 1974 era original D&D but the balance really hurt casters until very high levels for a plethora of reasons/rules..

mojosilver82

Just this A$$'s 2 cents. If any class can claim to be as tough as a barbarian, it's the monk. There also the only 2 martial class with unarmored defense. So I'll never understand why the developers gave monks D8 hp and not D12 hp. I also think that not only should monks get simple, martial weapons, and "armor". But that martial arts should give a tavern brawler equivalent. Anyone who has seen a martial arts movie has see something that is not a weapon used as a weapon. And tie it to the monks martial arts die. Other wise great job Treantmonk!

Glenn Wilson

Not necessarily, not at all. Since I will be out of D&D for a while (enrolled in two time intensive programs) it probably will be less effort to start slowly building my own Fantasy game framework looking forward to 2022/2023.