Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Working through the maze of rules to answer if this works. 

Files

Previews only

Pass Without Trace and Surprising the enemy: D&D 5e

If you like what I do and would consider supporting this channel through Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Treantmonkstemple If you would like to know how I calculate damage or how baseline damage is determined, I go through it in this video: https://youtu.be/zg0bAl1WPGQ Timestamps: 0:00 Intro 3:54 The basic rules 5:55 The hiding rules 7:49 The obscurement rules 8:45 Example encounter 10:08 Coming out of hiding 11:45 Interpreting these rules 12:50 Pass without trace and surprise Join my discord: https://discord.gg/6z97aaq Follow me on Twitter: https://twitter.com/ChrisHonkala

Comments

matan oron

I first thank you for the informative video. Love your work. I watched this one a few times. I don’t understand why you came to the conclusion that the players need to roll for surprise at the start of combat. The raw don’t really say make a roll for surprise. Its say the DM compares the Dexterity (Stealth) checks of anyone hiding with the passive Wisdom (Perception) score of each creature on the opposing side. I believe it means the dexterity stealth roll the party made before starting combat. And btw as a DM you can also use the group check rules for a group stealth check, so only half of the group will need to pass the check. Love to hear your thoughts.

Treantmonkstemple

The reason I came to that conclusion is because a stealth roll for moving silently and a stealth roll for hiding are 2 different things. You are correct it doesn't specifically say you make a roll at that time, it just says to compare the results.

Treantmonkstemple

but allow me to make a comparison. If I make an athletics check to break down a door, then attempt to grapple the creature behind the door, should the DM call for a new roll? Grapple doesn't say specifically you make a roll either, just that you compare the results - basically the same wording. Why would I read checking for surprise one way and checking for grapple another way?

matan oron

Ok I’ll go with your comparison. Yes it’s the same check but it’s a totally different task. you trying to grapple and braking a door are two different tasks, but with moving stealthily and hideing are practically the same. You are trying to avoid being seen by someone. And I agree that if you open a door you also might draw some attention and lose your hidden state but if you just come around a corner or behind a some obstruction I’ll think you are still hidden, as long of course that your target not actively looking for you or on guard for someone to come the same way.