Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Strive Sequel Poll and comment on changes

  • Great, I like new mechanics 137
  • Good, but I wish it was slightly different 110
  • Not my thing, not gonna to play unless major changes are made 5
  • 2019-10-12
  • 252 votes
{'title': 'Strive Sequel Poll and comment on changes', 'choices': [{'text': 'Great, I like new mechanics', 'votes': 137}, {'text': 'Good, but I wish it was slightly different', 'votes': 110}, {'text': 'Not my thing, not gonna to play unless major changes are made', 'votes': 5}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2019, 10, 12, 15, 50, 58, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 252}

Content

So, how did you like it?

I'm glad people seem to be interested in the sequel and gave plenty of response. I've got some of the issues and have tried to address them in reset patch, but I also gonna do it here.

So, firstly on the changes:

Time flow. Apparently many people actually prefer a turn based time flow, so I added that. I believe the game can be played in both, so hopefully this will make it more comfortable for those who prefer turns to pauses.

Work schedule. Originally I had a pretty extensive system in mind involving energy, fatigue and exhaustion as a way to manage slave's work schedule. You didn't exactly required to make character rest manually, but overall the system was needlessly complex and didn't provide the choice for player I wanted to make it: namely, choosing to make your slave overwork for your benefits. So I failed and decided to replace it with work rule system, which is very self-explanatory, while slaves work constantly now. I might make the system slightly more complex (like making them also not work at certain time of day), but that can be managed later.

Now on some of the concerns.

Firstly, I'll remind that it's a tech demo, which has a goal of representing new mechanics. I know that it times it might look like the game became more like a management/strategy rather than an RPG, but this is mostly due to lack of content, and first Strive game has started as 90% management game as well, based around getting slaves and making them work for you. I'll go into details of future content at some point in future, but I do have plans to make a lot more possible interactions and reactions. 

Some parts are unintuitive (mainly, some players haven't realized that you use skills for obedience/fear now) or feel clunky, but those will naturally be improved once we get the tutorial rolling out. 

So you can vote here on what you feel about the demo and let me know what parts you did or did not like. You can also ask questions or report bugs at our discord channel as it has a subchannel for sequel now.  

https://discord.gg/VXSx9Zk 

Comments

Kevin Love

Took me a while to work out the praise/scold thing.

Silent

Мне кажется, зря отказались от механики усталости. Когда рабы работают сутки напролет, это как то снижает степень вовлечения в игру. Походовый режим... ну в принципе как режим времени, по сути дела. Может, сделать суточный режим? Расписание заданий на сутки, работа отдых, приход ресурсов раз в день по окончании, не знаю. Пока не могу понять. То что игра имеет стратегическую компоненту, менеджмент, мне лично интересно.

Jan Kunowa

I like a lot of changes and hope there will be new ways to improve Wit as an example since most jobs are only for physics.. I haven't had the time to craft some items that further reduce the decay of fear but from what I can say without them it's a lot of daily work to click I order to keep your slaves/servants

Maverik

Yes, I plan to make items more common. As for the decay, try characters with high Tame factor/low Brave factor, they have considerably slower decay and require less attention.

Citillara

Will the game will be scriptable like the previous one ? I enjoyed rescripting stuff I didn't liked / adding / removing with the gd scripts

Stuart Faulds

I like what you've done so far, although the travel back from places seems to be broken currently.

Maverik

Thank you! Can you tell how exactly it's broken? It seems to work with no issues.

Tri3Ax

First impression is good. I like that the systems are all more nuanced. That was my biggest complaint about the original, wanted a bit more meat to everything. The obedience/fear on skills, while it took some getting used to, makes sense. Frankly... "talking" to people once a day became a routine in the original, I just used the exact same sequence every time, so boiling it down to something simpler with skills is just better. And the fact that you can appoint minions to use those skills on the rest of your harem is really nice. only real complaint is that starting gear is slow. Also, I notice that you can't farm cloth by default.. I'm about to unlock silk farming to see if I can farm in then but that appears to be an oversight

Maverik

Thanks, yes I plan to rebalance material/gear availability greatly in future, so right now its a bit slow and somewhat grindy.

Oldcityguy

The characters do not return to mansion. This message appears in the console: SCRIPT ERROR: return_to_mansion: Invalid get index of type 'String' (on base: 'Dictionary'). At: res://src/scenes/SlavePanel.gd:624

Maverik

Hmm... does not seem like I can replicate it. Can you provide a save file?

Tri3Ax

I just checked, you cant gather cloth. If that alone became possible from the start it would just be slow but ok, but having to buy it to get started is a bit too rough

Maverik

Yes, right now you can buy it or get it form combat.

Oldcityguy

Seems to happen only if the zero travel time debug option is on.

Tommi

I may be alone in this, but I don't like how you choose your stats and your starting slaves right away in the beginning. I liked the old system of when you leveled them up, you increased certain ones. I only played the tech demo for a short try, so I may have missed something, like if a similar system is in place. Other than that, I think all of the changes have been improvements, and my previous complaint is opinion based anyways.

Anthony Harland

I definitely like the way you are going with the new game, though I am curious if you will be able to capture slaves in the dungeon fights

Verden

well it takes some time to getting used to these changes, a quality of life improvement would be if, travel time would be shown in the overview instead on clicking on each and everyone. also aint starting areas pretty far away, or is it just me ?

r

Don't mind new features and systems but the UI seems to have taken a big step backward from the original (understandable as it is WIP). Character creation also doesn't really make sense as new players are given 0 context over what each of the stats actual in-game value is given game mechanics were changed. (how much is 1 str worth vs 1 mag vs 10% evasion, how much is obedience worth, etc, etc.)

Maverik

Some of the UI is not really finished (mainly outside screen) but I'm not sure what might be wrong with others like slave tab. As for the character creation, there's hardly any good solution for stat value as RPG style games never really give enough information during character creation. The only solution I see to this is to give a preset character with comfortable stat distribution for beginners. Or maybe a separate tutorial sequence which would allow to take same taste in management, craft and fight.

Smaug

Lot of what he is saying could probably be solved with some mouseover tips.

Maverik

Could you elaborate? I thought I've put mouseover tips over pretty much everything.

Smaug

Just tried the update, I think the by-hour time advance is great. Also noticed race-specific classes, that's an interesting idea, would be cool to eventually have rare classes with really specific/difficult requirements. Also: SCRIPT ERROR: make_quest_for_guild: Division By Zero in operator '%'. At: res://src/world_gen.gd:288

Dartanis

Even with just 5 characters total, managing Obedience and Fear through skills feels like a chore, and it will only get worse when you get more slaves. Most of the "feeling like a chore" comes from the UI requiring way too many cliks for what is essentialy a "maintenance" feature. I can think of 2 ways to fix this, Option 1: Modify the UI so you can, in one screen, see and use every spell and ability on every charcter by just clicking once on the spell or ability from a "common pool" of available spells (doesnt matter who has the spell, if they can cast it, its available in the common pool) and then clicking on slaves to boost fear or confidence, with either the spell running out from the common pool, or pressing ESC canceling you out of using the ability. Option 2: (And this is my prefered option) make obedience and fear abilities passives, allowing a single character to manage X number of other characters either through fear or obedience. These passive abilities would return a set number of obedience or fear back, making for "management" characters that would look after a set number of slaves, that could negate easier or more pliable slaves fear/obedience loss completely, while making characters with low tame and high bravery still lose fear/obedience over time. This would free the player to only manage higher value characters with potentialy better stats or unique abilites, these valuable character traits being offset by low tame and high brave values that make them difficult to manage without the player getting involved

Tri3Ax

I think having 3 to 5 presets, and then "make your own" would probably be a good approach

Dartanis

The same problem currently exists in the "world map" as well, needing way too many clicks and screens to send people somewhere. I would recommend a list of every character that can simply be dragged and dropped, or clicked and asigned to a location with 2 mouseclicks (one to select, one to asign to a location) from the "map/location screen" itself.

Dartanis

I elaborated some of the UI issues in a post further down, but for the character creation stats not making much sense when you make a character, I can give some solutions. You have tooltips for "what each stat does" but the way the stats work right now, it is actualy worse that they are numbers. When you create your character you dont yet have context on "how much magic" you need to be a mage for example. BUT when you go into the game, you can see that your 4 magic is actualy a "Good" rating, and the fact that the scale goes only from 1 to 5 being clearly visible during the creation process would better contextualize what stats you want, and how much of that stat you want to invest in. Knowing that putting 5 points into a stat is "as good as it gets" and knowing that most classes require atlest X points in a stat DURING character creation would make the choices clearer and more meaningful.

Dartanis

Another issue for the immediate early game is that you it takes WAY WAY too long to get anything meaningfull done, it took me 20 days to get a vegetable farm going and thats me just setting up 1 part of the basic food supply. Early game buildings should either cost way less than 50 wood and 30 stone, or basic resources should be coming in at a much faster rate. And the actual building/upgrading for initial/setup buildings should take way way less time.

Dartanis

I created a bit of a wall of text and Im not entirely sure how clearly I managed to explain some of the problems and solutions, but Ill pop back here later to see if any clarifications are needed. All in all it seems like a good start, but there is a clear need for UI improvements and keeping an eye on what features make for engaging gameplay, and what should really be passive mechanics that you need to keep an eye on only every now and then or when things change, rather than something you need to keep repeating every. single. day. without any real meaningfull choice or thought being invloved.

Maverik

Thanks for the tips. I'll be changing some parts of the gui naturally, but it might take some time, as the priority will be at other places first.

Dartanis

Oh, almost forgot, mind reading from Strive1 was a fantastic feature that let you see a lot of "under the hood" stats if you wanted to on any character. Something like it for Strive2 would be great.

Dartanis

I would be suprised if you get any of these fixes into 0.2 as a lot of stuff is probably still placeholder etc. Take your time, good games arent created overnight (no matter how much I might personaly want to play a finished product right now!). Keeping an eye on streamlining and reducing the number of screens and clicks during the development and creation process will save time later down the line.

Maverik

Yeah, but making completely new systems for that is not exactly time saving :) Mindread is a neat feature, but there's really nothing "under the hood" anymore, hence why the option is gone.

Lutz the Clumsy

For my two cents. The nature of constantly using the skills etc on slaves without a readily apparent progress or relationship thing where there was some hope I wouldn't have to keep up the micromanagement.. made it feel kind of like a 'clicker' game where i was farming up resources rather than establishing any form of relationship. if I could analogize the feeling of difference, It's felt like going from playing Huniepop to Huniecam. Even your most trusted or best trained girl opts the hell off the plantation if shes not being micromanaged. Certainly a factor that makes me not like them as much. And this gets painful when the other major aspect of the game is time spent crafting and gathering, which takes time. So the desire to pass time is constantly at odds with all the micro stuffs, which doesn't really have a fun factor assosciated with it. (at least in the current build.)

r

I think Dartanis' comments on UI are quite good. Regarding character creation Maverik, presets aren't the only solution that RPGs go with. Two other solutions are surfacing additional information and delaying character creation until later. Surfacing additional information: eg list what spells are available and mana cost, list the damage formula (so we know those stats), list obedience decay/day for different levels of obedience, etc (see Fire Emblem series which has very simple combat formulas) Delayed Character Creation: Provide attribute points as characters level up later in the game or add a respec option. (eg Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning)

Tommi

That's a really good way of explaining.

bf1x

the new mechanics are interesting however I liked how the original game felt personally if maverick where to just add the new mechanics to the original game with new area's and quest I would enjoy it but who knows how the sequel will turn out

Maverik

Thank you :) Stay in check, I'll be explaining my goals for sequel in next few days.

Buckey

Dont suppose we could get MC origins? In strive 1 I always headcanon'd my own.

Maverik

Like selectable origins? Perhaps eventually.

Buckey

Yeah, I mean the headcannon I always went with was some variation of: "I'm me, get pulled in to that world by the 'uncle' character doing some illegal ass interdimensional magic. As things do when you do forbidden magic the uncle got himself killed, Mage order sells off most of his stuff (furniture slaves etc) to pay his debts gives me whats leftover (the mansion, the ring, one leftover slave) as a "please let this go away quietly gift" And so the game starts... as for any other potential starter origins, it would depend on the setting of the sequel as to whats appropriate.

Maverik

Well technically speaking start is open-ended. I could add a couple of options which would ultimately do nothing, but give some flavor, but I never thought its necessary.

Buckey

honestly, you're probably right, on a list of priorities origins would be like number 200. Not having it in the first one never impacted my ability to play and enjoy it.

michael smolen

But yeah, having a real way to interact with the slaves would be perfect.

michael smolen

God damn it I wrote all that stuff down and it didn't save it. Long story short: Love everything! Miss the old interaction button, the skills just are too inpersonal

Maverik

You mean the dating system?

Buckey

Just finished a couple of hours of play, further to this guys point... I think it would be a good idea to be able to lock obedience at high either with an 'in love with master' thing (for people who want low fear, non-sociopath playthroughs) or a 'mindbroken' (for the assholes) After about 20 mins having to constantly praise and threaten each slave every day just to maintain gets old fast

Kevinati

I'm not entirely sure if this has been asked before. But is there a reason why one of the age options for the slaves has been removed?

Maverik

I plan to move it to optional mode side.