Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • SkyePOD - Skyedive.mp3

Missing 2 full-res photos, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Skye talks about how our certainty often conflicts with humility—with disastrous results, like declining churchgoing rates, alien doomsday cults, and dead bellringers.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Gwenda Thomas

I cannot tell you how many times I’ve recommended or shown the video TC Welcomes Skye Jethani. I was raised in a church where the phrase “we have THE TRUTH” was constantly spoken, meaning only OUR church is really right. I have influence with people inside that church but also in other churches where closed mindedness dominates and I have found that video is a wonderful way to crack that certainty. Thank you, Skye, for being a persuasive paradigm shifter for me and others.

Joe Stephen McNair

So, what you are saying is that we should blame Drew for this episode?

David Rogers

As a recovering handbell ensemble participant, I appreciate not being sent into towers during lightning events

Deidra Owens

This was excellent! Humility is the key word for all of us to live by. Thank you for this right on time message.

Amy Lewis

This week's Skye Pod was worth the admission price. Thanks for hashing this out, Skye. I love the picture of the beautiful irony at the end.

Heidi Chiavaroli

SO good! This is why I listen to the HP. Thank you, Skye!

Eddie Smock

I know he's kind of put into the "bad guy" box in Christian circles, but in his book, "The Demon Haunted World," Carl Sagan has a great saying to sum up a great posture toward new information. "Keep an open mind, but not so open your brain falls out." Certainty snaps you mind shut to the truth, then cognative dissonance will pour out your brain to retain the certainly.

DebD

Wow, Skye! If this episode was you rambling, I can't wait to hear you when you've prepared.

Jessica Thomas

Pete Enns wrote a book on this topic called "The Sin of Certainty"

Kathryn Zerbe

Thank you HP for dissolving so much of my stupidity over the years. 💟

Randalyn Kiltz

Really appreciate all you said. I'm tempted strongly to add HP+ for my children so they can hear this great content. All are late 30's. One does not identify as a Christian anymore and one is seriously questioning everything. I've learned a lot from the HP and am constantly being challenged in what I was taught and taught my kids. :(. I think it would break me if I didn't have this content.

Dorothy Turner

Skye, your thoughts this week were powerful. Feeling uncertain about some things has felt both uncomfortable and unexplainable at times. Thank you for the words of encouragement - I am learning to be a compassionate listener rather than a judge.

Mervin Bitikofer

Skye - in reading Russell's book "The Sparrow", you haven't read a story. You've read *half* a story! "Children of God" is the conclusion of her story. I remember thinking at the time that it only felt like a more complete story after finishing the second one. Great episode here! Thanks.

Julia Ruggieri

Skye Thank you for doing this episode. I read from church abuse survivors about DARVO. It tracks with your 3 components of denial. I would add however, in addition to young people, believers of Jesus raised in white Evangelical culture, the following: a) church abuse survivors b) domestic abuse survivors c) women who have needed to have abortions for medical or other reasons d) people with disabilities e) members of the LGBTQ community f) people of color g) immigrants and lastly Christians in other traditions. The othering and comments of CERTAIN orthodoxy, praxis (including the positive modeling of fruit of the spirit) are reasons why many leave the church or want little to do with those claiming to be Evangelical. Despite my disagreements, both theologically, politically, etc with many of the beliefs I hear each of you espouse I choose to continue to listen. You may not change my mind. However, I too follow Jesus’ 2nd Commandment. I try to do it-while sometimes failing- with curiosity, humility, and grace.

Kerry Martin

This is spot on. It’s been my willingness to have dialogue, ask questions, show curiosity, admit my lack of understanding, change my perspective, with my adult sons who have left the Christian faith, that has kept our relationship close and been able to hear them tell me that I “may be right” on my views too.

Gregory Dodge

Loved this! Thank you for sharing your thoughts and insights, Skye!

Bruce Gaylord

Thought provoking and interesting. Maybe the Vulcans can help us. The cognitive dissonance makes a whole lot of sense. I never thought about it that way before. 'There is nothing new under the sun'. This reminds me a lot of the late 60's and 70's when there was a lot of division over many of the issues. Back then the younger generation simply didn't engage. They started their own church (reference the Jesus Revolution Movie). Now many of those same people are on the other side.

Tyler

Thank you for this Skyedive, Skye! I lived through this exact process, step by step, a couple years ago when leaders of my church acted in fear and led the church to split from the denomination (and cause a whole lot of pain to a whole lot of people) because of it. All in the name of “the truth,” not The Truth.

Shannon Mejia

I think about when Jesus said we just come to Him like a child... What's a young child's favorite word? "Why". That's curiosity!!!

Jim Stauffer

You preached a sermon, even if you didn’t intend to. A darn good sermon too - with alliteration and a conclusion. Thanks

Jon Marks

This is what I thought about the whole time! It's been on my list for years

John Blair

Beautiful. Question, Skye: How did you learn this lesson around the sin of certainty? Or have you always been naturally curious and okay with not knowing? I really appreciate the Holy Post and the impact it has had, and continues to have, in my families life. Cheers to you👍

Kathy Deley

This is my favorite Skyepod episode so far. It was so insightful. Please do more more Skyedives!

Elizabeth Meredith

Wish I could share photo of a Peanuts comic strip from long ago. Here’s the conversation: Charlie Brown to Snoopy: I hear you’re writing a book on theology…I hope you have a good title. Snoopy: I have the perfect title….”Has It Ever Occurred to You That You Might Be Wrong?”

joanne sullivan

Without a doubt this is my favorite skyepod episode. You so clearly articulated what I have been thinking for quite sometime. Thank you.

Hayley Simoneau

I believe God led me to, “We’re all gonna die wrong about something.” I’ve been thinking exactly along these lines, Skye. I joined the Episcopal Church recently, but I grew up PCA. And there are good, sincere believers in the PCA. However, I revel in the idea that I’m in a church that didn’t get started and doesn’t continue because they thought —and think— they were right about everything. They were a branch of Anglicans, and politics interfered with the ordination of priests and bishops. The statement I hear now is, “It is the practice of worship that unites us.” It doesn’t matter that we disagree on theology. It’s okay for things of God to be mysterious.

Christa Gregg

Yes this was clarification about what has happened in extended family. They have opted to distance from us who carry cognitive dissonance and questioning our certainty. Thank you for this podcast. It was very helpful and encouraging to keep being curious.

Julie Ulm

Thank you for sharing this- as a parent of college kids and a youth pastor it is so hard to communicate that our kids need to be able to question, doubt, and be curious. God can handle it! If we act like it’s going to be too much for God, we diminish who God is.

Pam Baker

This is spot on. Thank you, Skye.

Frederick Blesse

This was a WONDERFUL episode, Skye! I recently read Pete Enns’ book, The Sin Of Certainty, and your Skydive really complements in a very helpful way what he wrote. Thank you for your “rambling”!

Julia Ruggieri

I loved the story of the lightening rods!

David Hoffman

This might be my favorite episode so far

Daniel Thompson

It would be a gift to many more if this could be shared publicly. This episode was outstanding!

Steve Watson

But you don't have a problem with a church that got started so a king could divorce his wife?

Mickey Lang

Agreed, I wanted to share with my daughter. I believe it can be a great conversation starter. Maybe a blind link to YouTube that could be forwarded.

Beverley Christie

I so want to share this with my siblings. So well said!!

Steven Slaughter

Skye, do you have any specific book or resources describing this whole lightning rod story? I've been outlining some novel/play ideas around flat earth teaching over time with some of the same themes of certainly-stupidity, but I think I like the lightning rod story better. A little less well-known.

Scott Russ

This has been the best episode so far! Do you have sources from your illustrations? You need to expand this specific episode into a book! If this is you just riffing after vacation and not having a guest, I’m very impressed!

Timothy Metz

This is so important and needs greater visibility. During my time teaching biology at a Christian university, I saw so many young Christians entering college with way too much confidence in what they thought they knew. Over time, I developed curriculum to put information in front of them which confronted their certainty on several fun topics including human sexuality and the origins and evolution of life. I began with William Perry’s research at Harvard in the 1960s (published in his book, Forms of Intellectual and Ethical Development in the College Years), recognizing that many persons reside in an intellectual category Perry named dualism (basically, a black and white; right or wrong view of reality). The absolutism Skye references, I believe emanates from a dualistic mindset about reality. Many people don’t have the experience or awareness to see that most issues are very complex, and not simple dualisms. Yet, a good way to alleviate cognitive dissonance associated with uncertainty is to frame issues as dualistic, choose a side, and have absolute certainty about being right. I love uncertainty and cognitive dissonance and attempted to help my students be comfortable in that space as well. While many students had a great time having their minds freed, others really couldn’t handle the uncertainty (they expected me to give them the right answers they were seeking for the exams, because they were entrenched dualists and the right answers to questions reside in authorities, and I was supposed to be the authority giving them the right answers). I made good use of 1 Corinthians 8:2 as well! Great episode!

William

Thank you Skye. This was one of the most helpful pods I've heard. Humility is so absent today in every walk of life and in *myself*!

William

I’ll also echo others saying I’d love to share this one. Heck, I’d pay to share it!

Jeffrey Stewart

Loved the monologue. I'd really enjoy hearing you do more of these.

Charlotte Sievert

Skye: This was an absolutely brilliant piece. So coherent and focused! Profound and sorely needed content in these times. On top of that, it was brilliantly written and delivered. I wish I could get everyone I know to listen to it. Am definitely going to share! And yes, if there is a way to turn this into a book, please do!

Meaghan

THIS!!!🙏🏻

Amanda Boozer

Since this just came out on as a French Friday I’m sharing it with everyone. I wish I could make everyone I know listen to this.

Kurt

I just spent a refreshing and stimulating long weekend at the annual meeting of the American Scientific Affiliation (asa3.org), an organization of Christians in the sciences. A key value of that organization is intellectual humility, which was practically defined for us on opening night as "being curious about why others might disagree with you." And then we were challenged further to have "courageous curiosity" during the weekend. But unfortunately, all too often in our churches, as Skye has noted, the message or metamessage is, "this isn't a place for curiosity, it's a place for certainty." So if intellectual humility is tied to curiosity, then those spaces aren't places for intellectual humility either. I guess what I'm saying is, it's always seemed self-evident to me that certainty and lack of intellectual humility must go together. The opposition of both of these to curiosity provides a new useful heuristic for me to analyze situations.