Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • 302385346.mp4

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 video, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Kaitlyn schools us on the doctrine of Cessationism—what is it, where does it come from, and do she and Skye think it’s right?

Kaitlyn schools us on the doctrine of Cessationism—what is it, where does it come from, and do she and Skye think it’s right? What is its history and what are its implications for how the church is structured? And, most importantly, why is the word so fun to say?

Are Miraculous Gifts for Today: 4 Views by Wayne A. Grudem: https://a.co/d/bcJpaAP

Surprised by the Power of the Spirit by Jack Deere: https://a.co/d/1tn9fJd

Why I Am Still Surprised by the Power of the Spirit: Discovering How God Speaks and Heals Today by Jack Deere: https://a.co/d/9CtBYJ8

Dwell: Life with God for the World by Barry D. Jones: https://a.co/d/bmu5g8z

Files

Previews only

Comments

Andrew Kirschenman

Schiessationism. Now that should have been the name of the new podcast!

Steve Thomas

This was so helpful, thanks. I will be re-listening to this episode for sure. I am really concerned that cessationism puts God in a box, domesticating the power and purposes of God. It's also convenient if we don't see the gifts in our circles, so we don't need to ask why (do we need to repent of something holding us back from a fuller relationship with God, etc.)?

Aaron SirLemming

I feel like there was a missed opportunity to discuss what at least in my experience/opinion is a major driver for Cessationism: the simple fact that most of us *don't* see miracles happening like they did in the Bible, despite praying for them to happen. It's kind of a version of the cognitive dissonance response that is so often talked about here. We believe miracles can happen but they usually don't, so we try to figure out an explanation to help us through the disillusionment. Hard Cessationists have it the easiest here, in a way -- except all those missionary stories, which then leads to the compromise position where America just doesn't need or deserve miracles for whatever reason you pick. (I kind of fall into this camp; I think when there's a well-established church that could be doing so much more to help people, God is wanting to push us to shoulder more of that burden.) And lastly of course there's the full Pentecostal position which gets really dangerous when you pray for something to happen and it doesn't, and then you get a guilt trip over not believing hard enough. I really think this is the heart of the whole thing and it's much more of a deeply personal thing rooted in anxiety and disappointment.

Dick Young

Thank you so much for covering this topic! My wife and I have now been listening to HP for 4 years and often felt that the only contexts in which "charismatic" individuals came up were negative ones, and that's been so disheartening. I truly found this segment to be balanced, and with good references. Well done. We are part of a church which believes the gifts still operate, but which steers away from the hard-line position that healing *must* happen whenever we ask, or else the pray-er or the pray-ee "didn't have enough faith". (Which I regard as one of the classic abuses.)

David Kilborn

It isn't just teenagers that fake speaking in tongues, etc. I've been in several Pentecostal churches and it is almost like peer pressure to speak in tongues. I never understood it when I was a kid and when I grew older and saw what the Bible says about it, it really transformed my view of the Pentecostal church overall, which is perhaps unfair, but my experience is that most people are trying to show others their piety through the "spiritual gifts" they have, but when nobody is interpreting (or the same person is interpreting), you know its fake, yet this never seemed to get called out.

Bruce Gaylord

Well done as always. I have a couple of comments, first, it's been my experience that Pentecostal churches that trace their roots to the early 1900's believe that any prophecies, messages in tongues with interpretation, words of wisdom etc. must never contradict the Scriptures. They believe in the closed canon and authority of the Bible like other Evangelicals/Protestants. Second, another view on prophecy is that it is just another word for preaching and that our Sunday morning service is an example of prophecy. That's a way many dodge the question.

Peggy Sherman

This was very good and helpful. I was raised in a devout Irish Catholic family. In my early 20s I began going to Bible studies at a Calvary Chapel and also some healing services at a Vineyard Church. I finally landed at a non-denominational charismatic church. I met my husband at this church and he's been the pastor of our non-denom (though affiliated) charismatic church for 30 years. Believe me, I've seen excesses and have become somewhat jaded towards many of the popular charismatic groups out there. I am now embracing many of the aspects of my Catholic upbringing along with those of other streams of the ancient faith. That being said, I couldn't imagine trying to live a life apart from the active involvement, empowerment, and gifts of the Holy Spirit.

Bruce Huseby

As a former cessationist I was quite disappointed with the lack of scripture used. 1 Corinthians 13 specifically and the difficult interpretation of, “when that which is perfect is come” was ignored. I am not sure how teaching is done is seminaries today but this was more of a lesson on history and opinion. I no longer hold to strict cessationist viewpoints because as missiologist Paul Borthwick says, if you don’t believe God does the supernatural through gifts of the Spirit don’t travel. I have personally seen in my travels to over 70 countries globally God at work supernaturally. These have been to majority world countries and some of the most restricted access countries on our planet. I have also seen many of these churches mature as they pursue a more excellent way that edifies the whole church.

Timothy MacDougall

I spent a large part of my youth in a pentacostal church. I never had a "charismatic" experience myself. I've never spoken in tongues (which seems to be fine according to Corinthians). I only encountered cessationism when I was in university and I found it quite baffling intellectually. The argument I heard was that God speaks through scripture, so why would he need to say anything in addition to that. I must confess though that I've grown more skeptical in recent years. Seeing the fruit and political affiliations of charismatic churches has cast some doubt on some of the stories I was told, and some of the organizations I would have trusted in the past.