Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • Getting Schooled Integralism.m4a
  • Getting_Schooled_-_Integ... - audiogram.mp4
  • Getting_Schooled_-_Integ... - audiogram.mp4
  • Getting_Schooled_-_Integ... - audiogram.mp4

Missing 5 full-res photos, 3 videos, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Kaitlyn schools us on integralism, its effect on our political future, and why it's foreign to so many American Protestants

Kaitlyn schools us on integralism—what is it, what are its current implication for American politics (especially with with J. D. Vance in the race), and why is it so foreign to many of us modern Protestants?

Why Liberalism Failed Patrick J. Deneen: https://a.co/d/dGaiq6t

Christ and the Common Life: Political Theology and the Case for Democracy by Luke Bretherton: https://a.co/d/bMZV8uV 

Laudato Si by Pope Francis: https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/encyclicals/documents/papa-francesco_20150524_enciclica-laudato-si.html

Christianity and Democracy: The Rights of Man and the Natural Law by Jacques Maritain: https://a.co/d/jcNjJOR

Files

Previews only

Comments

Rod Kuehn

Anti-Catholic feelings didn't arise from nothing. The Protestant Reformation sparked a variety of wars which included the St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre, Queen Mary's burning of 300 Protestants, the 30-Year-War and the French Religious Wars. The Founders were well familiar with Catholic attempts to impose compliance - it was one of the reasons for the First Amendment (to prevent religious conflict). Catholic hegemony also played a role in sparking our Revolution. There have also been various Vatican pronouncements claiming authority over the US and directly opposing religious freedom. This includes Quata Cura (Syllabus of Errors, 1864) and Casti Connubii (1930). It also needs stating that arch-Catholic Leonard Leo managed to install many conservative Catholics so that now the entire Republican (insurrectionist) Supreme Court is composed of Catholics (including 1 former Catholic). Scalia was Catholic. There is a powerful wing of Catholicism which, although not formally integralist, seems to be consistent with it. Is there reason to think J.D. Vance is not a part of it? I'd like to know how much of the uprising against Pope Francis is, at some level, integralist.

Adam Shields

Anti Catholic sentiment didn’t arise out of nothing, but it also arose out of very real xenophobia as well.

Chuck Thompson

It wasn't until the election of Pres. Kennedy that Catholics started to be viewed as true citizens of the U.S. I grew up Catholic I remember the prejudice and suspicion we were treated with. Being a military brat my siblings and I often had our new friends tell us that their parents said they shouldn't associate with us. All because we were supposed Papists.

Dean Thayer

Why exactly does Kaitlyn have a tiny diploma? I have never seen a diploma from Dallas Theological Seminary, but I have no reason to believe they would be significantly smaller than those granted by other institutions. Does she carry a wallet sized one just in case, or something?

Susan

I appreciated the thorough and thoughtful breakdown of the concept of integralism. On the other hand, I am weary of the continual insistence that shifting norms around gender and sexuality have caused the fabric of society to completely unravel. Queer people advocating for their own civil rights, safety, and acceptance should not be blamed for the authoritarian backlash against them, any more than any other marginalized group should be blamed for the backlash they have received in the past for seeking more just treatment in society. I believe you are coming at this in good faith, and the question of how to create flourishing in a pluralistic society is an incredibly important one. And at the same time, the impression I am left with when I hear you discussing it in these terms is that queer people are hindering society from flourishing by their very existence, and that if they had just stopped demanding so many rights, the world would be a better place. I’m confused as to what you think the solution should actually be, and whether your vision for a flourishing church as well as a flourishing society has a place for queer people in it.

Christine L. Boatman

Personally, I have the biggest problem with this explainer than with any of the prior explainers for two reasons. First, the immediate assumption that the "common good" is inconsistent with same-sex marriage seems like it skips several steps in the middle. I disagree completely that the "common good" is better advanced by an exclusionary, heterosexual only version of marriage. Marriage confers not only religious benefits, but significant societal and governmental benefits, and it is better for, without question, the children of same sex parents - and there will be children within same sex relationships - to have the unions of their parents recognized. I do not see that there is damage to the "common good" by allowing same sex marriages, but I certainly do see that there is significant damage to the "common good" by marginalizing those relationships. Second, I have real issues with the appeal to natural law when there is zero discussion of the basis of that natural law. For centuries, "natural law" held that one half of your conversation - and frankly (no offense, Skye) the smarter and more articulate half - was an inferior, brainless creature with no value beyond her reproductive capacity, who was the property of a man. Before simply throwing "natural law" into the conversation, there needs to be a shared understanding of what that means. And how, if we are going to use it as part of our modern social framework, it is consistent with the full humanity and personhood of the individuals it previously excluded. Because I have no interest in a natural law that turns me into something of lesser value, and I think it's likely that most of the individuals who are in my shoes would agree with me. If that's natural law, then natural law needed to be deposed.

William Wood

Thank you for an explainer on a subject about which I knew very little. (Normally I am at least conversant with the subject.) It would have been helpful to have started the introduction with an explanation of the relationship between Integralism and J.D. Vance. I thought I followed a lot of politics (not as much as you two) but this is the first I have seen any reference to these two together. My big takeaway is to explore a theological basis for classic liberalism. Like Skye I have been a Classic Liberal, believer in democracy, and an American all of my adult life. I believe that I am primarily a Christian and secondarily an American and work to keep my thinking in that order. However I have never considered my acceptance of classic liberalism and democracy and where it fits in my theological perspective. I have wondered sometimes about the vision of the great statue of Daniel's dream and wondered if our democracy is pictured by the feet of iron mixed with clay. Since I believe that the new earth will be ruled by Jesus, not a democracy, why do I believe that democracy is a good answer now? I have practical reasons for preferring a democracy, but what are the theological ones? Thank you for encouraging me to think.

William Wood

And the question I meant to ask - What does the significant political figure from Notre Dame, Justice Coney Barrett, think/believe about Integralism?