Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everyone!

Our first Holy Post Book Club livestream will be next Tuesday, April 19, at 8:00 PM CT. Skye and Kaitlyn will share their thoughts on Cold Civil War, and take your questions about the book.

If you haven't read Skye's recent Book Club update, which will give some helpful context for this livestream, you can find that post here.

Feel free to share any questions and thoughts on the book in advance through the comments here. We'll also take questions during the livestream through the live chat.

Next week, we'll send out a livestream reminder with a link to watch. We hope you can join us!

Comments

Randy Limbird

I hope the livestream is still a go -- have not received any reminder of ilnk yet. Anyone else get something?

Jesse Coyne

On the whole, I found some of the political philosophy to be helpful. Not having much exposure to it, I thought the analysis of culture/creed and history/nature as well as the general breakdown of the quadrants to be a useful orienting tools. I’m not sure it attained quite the level of epiphany as the author describes - and somewhat less satisfying than Packer’s Four Americas - but it helps clarify the different ideologies and sets of values. With everyone else, the most frustrating aspect is the lack of balanced critique. What purports to be an even-handed analysis quickly slants to the right, with the discussion of immigration exemplifying the complete lack of engagement with any counter arguments. The proposed solution amounted to little more than having the Kuyperian church-as-organism train more people in the new vital center as statesman rather than in faithfully following Jesus as disciples. Keller’s proposed solutions in the 4th article in his Bible and Race series is more thoughtful and more practical. That being said, there were a few things I’d like to see discussed further. (1) Several times throughout the book, I found myself asking “why?” Why should Christians be devoting themselves to or chiefly concerned about this? There are valid answers, and I think David French and Curtis Chang hit some of this in their recent Good Faith podcast, but I kept wanting to move back to that more foundational question. (2) American exceptionalism kept rearing its head, and I wanted more comparison with other countries and political systems. Why is the”genius” of this system and vision the right/best one? It sure isn’t working particularly well at present.