Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • HP508_BONUS.mp3

Missing 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

This bonus segment was recorded after our news segment from episode 508. Phil, Skye, and Kaitlyn continue their conversation and go even deeper into the analysis of the leaked Supreme Court ruling and the history of abortion.


This segment is also available to watch on YouTube (as always, this video is unlisted and exclusive for Patreon supporters). Click here to watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xs2VilKeFY8


Resources mentioned:

"This Really Is a Different Pro-Life Movement" by Daniel K. Williams - https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/05/south-abortion-pro-life-protestants-catholics/629779/

"If Roe is Overturned, Where Should the Pro-Life Movement Go Next?" by Tish Harrison Warren - https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/08/opinion/abortion-roe-dobbs-pro-life.html

Comments

Camille Dillard

Thank you for thoughtful conversation around the first draft of the Supreme Court's ruling on the Roe V Wade decision. It is good to be among thoughtful, willing to examine the details people. Phil was right on target with the crucial role racism plays in this entire drama. However, I would like to stress further the southwest/west Barry Goldwater Libertarians were very much infested with the disease of racism. First, start with how the "hallowed ground" these states stand on came into existence through the Missouri Compromise: "SEC. 8. And be it further enacted. That in all that territory ceded by France to the United States, under the name of Louisiana, which lies north of thirty-six degrees and thirty minutes north latitude, not included within the limits of the state, contemplated by this act, slavery and involuntary servitude, otherwise than in the punishment of crimes, whereof the parties shall have been duly convicted, shall be, and is hereby, forever prohibited: Provided always, That any person escaping into the same, from whom labour or service is lawfully claimed, in any state or territory of the United States, such fugitive may be lawfully reclaimed and conveyed to the person claiming his or her labour or service as aforesaid." Reference: https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/missouri-compromise The Missouri Compromise was "in the line of fire" with the infamous Dred Scott v. San(d)ford case denying citizenship to any enslaved African an his/her descendants. Reference: https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/dred-scott-v-sandford) Lastly, Barry Goldwater himself at best was ignorant to the challenges his political philosophies posed to African-Americans and the race question. Reference: https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/encyclopedia/goldwater-barry-m The pre-emptive strike aborting our "wholistic approach" to abortion is our national unwillingness to put to death racisim. Hence, we are very much hindered in our conversation unless we deal with our current day original sin of the church (nation)...racism. BTW: It was the church that codified and promulgated the concept of racism through its errant doctrine Dum Diversas. Reference: https://www.tylerhistory.org/2018/08/27/1452-papal-bull-dum-diversas/

Ken Foster

The recent furore over the imminent threat to Roe v. Wade has exacerbated the divide within the Christian community. There seems however to be something missing from the discussion as it relates to the source of the divide. Debate swirls around second order questions and generally fails to deal with the underlying assumptions on which the positions are built. The anti-abortion position is based on an ethical principle derived from the value of human life, but the problem remains of defining the concept of human life. In the modern western world it is essentially a question of biological [human] life as illustrated by the push towards earlier and earlier definition of a person as starting with a fertilized egg. The Semitic worldview that informs the Scriptures is derived from the narrative of the whole people of God and the individual has meaning primarily within and as a part of the whole community. By contrast a Platonic worldview derives meaning or value from the individual as an individual. Even more tellingly, meaning is derived from the abstract idea(l) represented by the individual. It is the neo-Platonic influence (especially Plotinus’) in the third century that shifted the worldview of Christianity away from the more corporate metanarrative of the people of God towards a prioritization of the individual over the community and the disembodied spiritual state over the physical world of creation. NT Wright elucidates this clearly in Surprised By Hope. This Platonic fixation with the abstract idea behind the physical reality rather than ‘the whole thing’ has led to an overvaluing of the spiritual over the physical. In turn this has allowed or caused much of North American Christianity to ‘worship’ biological human life taking the focus away from people as people living in a physically embodied community. Not only does this dualism make processing loss at the beginning and end of life more difficult but it also increasingly drives a wedge between the conscience and conscious mindset of the majority of the population and the followers of this worldview. Just look at climate change and creation care to see what the effect of this dualism has done, not to mention the way Christians justified slavery. The old chorus says it all, “This world is not my home, I’m just a passin’ through…” Elucidation of how our worldview influences our thinking and especially of how it informs the way we read Scripture should help us all to be a little more humble. The recent attention to the history of how Christians have dealt with abortion in the past is helpful but going further back and deeper down into the underpinnings of our thought processes and assumptions should be even more helpful. If nothing else it should build the space for respect when consensus is not feasible.