Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • why im still a christian philip yancey audio.mp3
  • Why_Im_Still_a_Christia... - audiogram.mp4
  • Why_Im_Still_a_Christia... - audiogram.mp4

Missing 3 full-res photos, 2 videos, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

In this bonus episode from our Why I'm Still a Christian series, available exclusively for our Holy Post Plus subscribers, Skye sits down with Philip Yancey to learn why, through the ups and downs of his life, he is still following Jesus.


This episode is also available to watch on youtube here - https://youtu.be/lri2PtYdX20

Files

Previews only

Comments

skipclarke

Nice conversation, but as someone who is deeply struggling with my faith, and struggling with "church" moreso, I found Philip's answers about why he stayed a Christian lacking. At least they don't speak to me. The response of "the people I wanted to be like were Christian" leaves a lot to be desired, and I'm glad that Skye followed up with, "What about all the horrible people that do things in Jesus' name?" (paraphrased). I didn't hear a real answer to that, other than, "You think those people are bad, let me tell you about the bad Christians that I know" and to simply ignore them. I feel a corollary follow-up question would also be, "But what about all of the wonderful people that I would want to be like that are Muslim, Hindu, or 'None'?" I find as many (and often more) of the kind people I meet aren't Christian. They may have some other faith, no real faith, or are actively atheist. Simply choosing to follow the faith of the "good" people who happen to be Christian, and not the faith of other "good" people" seems to be circular logic at best. I realize a lot of people may not agree with me, but these are the thoughts of someone who is deeply struggling.

Rachel Stanton

Skip, I believe Philip would say that he did not simply look at the lives of all those around him who claimed to be Christian, which in his southern rural community was just about everyone. Rather, he looked at the lives of those who were actually following the teachings and example of Jesus and it was there that he saw something true, good and beautiful.

Barb Reed

Hey Skip! I’m so glad you are here!! These are great questions and reasons to push back if you are in that space of questioning/discerning. I don’t know if I or anyone else can offer additional insight to Phillip or Skye’s personal thoughts on your questions, but I will say it is OK and reasonable to provide the feedback from your unique perspective. I found Phillip’s book “soul survivor” was really informative on how he views people who were not Christian but were integral for him as he navigated his own faith. In the end- we all need community where it is safe to bring all of your doubts, questions and concerns, and discuss & work out our faith. Just wanted to comment to offer a thanks for your genuine questions and concerns. This is a great place to engage and listen as a start- and praying you find an in-person community where you can also do the same!