Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • The Worship Wars Updated.mp3
  • Getting_Schooled_-_The_W... - audiogram.mp4

Missing 4 full-res photos, 1 video, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Throughout the 80's and 90's, there was a church war over worship music! Contemporary seems to have come out as the winner, but how? And did

Throughout the 80's and 90's, there was a church war over worship music! Contemporary seems to have come out as the winner, but how? And did we leave too much behind? Kaitlyn breaks down the different schools of thought about worship music.

Recommended Resources

Ancient Future Worship: Proclaiming and Enacting God’s Narrative: https://a.co/d/38Q6klg

The People of the Truth: The Power of the Worshipping Community in the Modern World: https://a.co/d/35d6TiF

A History of Contemporary Praise & Worship: Understanding the Ideas That Reshaped the Protestant Church: https://a.co/d/6CtLYJ3

Files

Previews only

Comments

Adam McCoy Jones

A good discussion! My church’s problem is convincing people that we don’t need to sing theologically bad hymns (we three kings, Stars and Stripes forever) and can sing deeper contemporary songs.

Justin V

Thanks for this. Like many things in the contemporary church I think it's incredibly important to step back and consider where we're getting our current practices. I grew up in some semi-traditional circles (praise songs, but mostly hymns) but getting into mainstream evangelicalism I was taken aback at how much music was THE focus and how much of it was extremely of-the-minute and emotive. Nothing wrong with either of course, but that it was determined to be true and "authentic" worship over everything else was always concerning. Things like communion, repentance, preaching, and service to others seemed to be pushed to the side -- and it feels like there's a notable gap in people's understanding of worship because of it....and it can come of as very consumerist at times. As to Kaitlyn's point, there's good and truth in both the responsive worship music and songs that are more about declaring and presenting the goodness of God. For example: when want to sing along with music in praise I think of the late Rich Mullins: I LOVE his song Creed, but I also love a song like "Nothing is Beyond You" or "I See You." All of them get repeated endlessly in my home.

David B.

I can see why certain patriotic hymns have issues, but what's wrong with We Three Kings?

Felicia Phillips

Yes! You guys are spot on with the idea of our church songs being formative. We should put as much thought into choosing the songs we sing as a congregation as we put into anything else. I’m a musician, and my hope is that the songs will always be musically excellent as well. I’ve heard songs that were Scripture set to music, and that music was awful. Conversely, I’ve heard great music with heretical lyrics. 😖 I disagree with you about reverting to “song leaders.” In my last few churches (military family that moves a lot), we have had Worship Pastors. Only one of those churches was a big church with lots of flashy stuff. And those Worship Pastors were true pastors. They taught and shepherded thoughtfully through the music, along with managing legal CCLI stuff, keeping a variety of equipment working, and wrangling a group of volunteers who are prone to being divas (hence some of the need to shepherd 😉). Now I’ll get off my personal soap box. Thank you guys for discussing all these topics thoughtfully. I appreciate you!

Jim Black

Loved this discussion. I’m a musician and play on a worship team so it was really interesting to hear this perspective. I loved what skye said about how the songs are forming their theology and how important it is to not pick crappy ones. Would be really interested to know which current songs you guys find rich theology and which ones you find lacking. I’ve always wondered when you’ve mentioned it on previous episodes.

Esther Luna

I appreciated this conversation but I wish you had presented the point of view that music style, like the other elements of a worship service, might be made intentionally stylistically distinct from the rest of the culture to more effectively draw worshipers into the mystery of God and to keep from neglecting the rich Christian history of hymnody that would be a shame to lose. (Mainly pre-20th century) I'm indebted to Seth Luna, music director and organist of St. Mark's Episcopal Church in Glen Ellyn, IL, for these ideas.

Erin

I appreciated this discussion as this is a real issue in churches today. I come from a tradition of mainly hymns, but now attend a church which is a bit more pentecostal and sings more worship songs than hymns. The point about "responsive" worship vs. songs which literally speak words about what we believe, i.e. creed resonated with me. I don't think it has to be solely one or the other. Some music can serve the purpose of being instructive and spiritually formative, but what's wrong with some music which simply expresses to Jesus how much I love him, what I "feel" about Him? Sometimes emotions are seen in Christian circles as evil, but they are a part of who we are as humans created in the image of God. I resonate with a worship song which expresses my deep emotion toward God in response to deep theological truth. I also fully agreed with Skye's point that hymns are often viewed as the "theological" music whereas worship songs are just emotive. That is not necessarily true at all. The theology of some old hymns is really problematic and the theology of some more contemporary worship songs is theologically rich. As with so many other issues, it's important that we look at the heart of the matter, in this case the music. Does it reflect what we are trying to accomplish during a worship gathering? Many different styles of music can help us reach our goals. We should stop pitting the hymns camp against the worship songs camp.

Carlos Torres

I absolutely agree. The few dozen hymns that we still sing regularly, that have good theology, are pretty great.

Regina McCurdy

I’d love this discussion again but with a guest steeped in the Black American church music experience. It would be an interesting perspective on light of this conversation.

Carlos Torres

Also the idea that individual focus is any more of a unique hallmark of contemporary songs than doctrinal profession is of hymns is…with all charity…wild.

Hannah Mackie

I was so disappointed by Skye and Kaitlyn’s dismissiveness in this episode. I guess it shouldn’t come as a surprise, given that they’ve both previously stated their negative feelings towards music as worship. I’ll have to give it another listen to see if there are any good takeaways, but this one felt like I was listening to a conversation between the two critics in the balcony from The Muppets.

Michael Sheldon

Appreciated the conversation and some of the historical context that was new to me but I felt like maybe there was a bit of strawmanning going on I grew up with very traditional hymns and traditional music that was elevated to a “doctrine of music” and defended with many of the arguments you state about contemporary worship songs. I’m now at a church where there are a team of people including ordained pastors who are selecting and even writing contemporary songs with amazing theology that very much factor into the larger worship service. Sure there are many bad songs produced every year but there are gems too that will stand the test of time and become those classic messages in song that will last generations. The same is true in any genre of music. One historical angle that you did not cover was how music has evolved as part of culture more generally. With the invention of electronic and eventually digital recording, radio and mobile music players, streaming and mobile broadband, the human relationship and exposure to music has changed drastically in the last century. Yes like most everything there are pitfalls, bad actors, and bad theology, but I’m someone who has deep theological understanding in my head but is really spoken to when that theology is expressed in creative poetry and excellent modern music. I think your personal preferences may have colored the conversation and made it a bit more cynical than intended. I appreciate all you do and talk about as there is much that I’ve learned from you and even when we disagree I know it’s with a charitable spirit. I just wanted to share that this particular conversation felt a bit unbalanced.

Michael Sheldon

Even hymns were once contemporary and leaned on contemporary music styles. What I’ve observed in the past decade is that many leading contemporary artists are in fact referencing and even refreshing some of the best hymns with music and bridges that reemphasize their theology. There is beauty in older styles and beauty in newer styles but distinction from “the world” in music is not going to come in style as much as message and the spirit with with it is sung/played

Adrian Anderson

I would love it if the HP crew added some voices from other rich traditions to flesh out these discussions. When views are so homogeneous, we miss out on what God has to say to us (an help provide wider perspective) that the larger Body has to offer. I would LOVE to learn more from experiences different than my own. When Esau McCaulley spoke at the live taping, you could have heard a pin drop when his comment was that the black church has moved on and has better things to deal with than the constant introspection of how the white church has become so malformed. When he encouraged us to move from theorizing toward actually engaging with the broader community of Christ to learn what other needs are in the Church, it was a message sorely needed. I imagine views on the role of music from the black, hispanic or even orthodox church would be helpful.

Adrian Anderson

When the dispensationalist church I was raised in and the evangelical church I was married in have only been concerned with checking one box, namely, getting people to flip the lever from "damned" to "saved", there is little to no interest in spiritual formation beyond getting that person to get another person to flip a lever. If the only thing that matters is getting off this planet into heaven, then whether or not a person is spiritually mature evidencing the fruit of the spirit (love joy peace gentleness kindness etc), doesn't matter. All that matters is marketing to get people"into the church" and to keep them feeling like going back. It all becomes marketing-centric. And, let's consider, that that really has become the definition of the evangelical church, whether from big tent revivals to smoke machines and feel-good songs, it does whatever it takes to get people to check off a single box. "Saved." And cares little else about formation beyond getting those same people to replicate that process. One and done. Which leads to a very shallow, very anemic community. So what do they push? Competition (get the biggest and best); pride (learn how to know all the right answers to argue why others are wrong); entertainment (keep people coming back); self-help theology (give people the illusion of a care-free life); relationships (feel connected, belong, and raise a perfect family to live the perfect American dream). Shallow music that appeals to emotion? Just part of the packaging evangelicals have been peddling ever since dispensationalism and predestination took over its heart and mind.

Carlos Torres

Oh, it’s more than a *bit* of straw manning. This was grade A, top tier, James K. A. Smith level straw manning.

Pam Baker

Yes. My family and I have been having this conversation for years. And what is the purpose of soft music at the end of the pastor’s message?!? Our pastors seem to think it’s necessary. Do other churches do this?

Josh Hasak

The song leader to worship leader piece was fascinating.

Melynda O'Brien

I appreciated this discussion a lot and loved what Kaitlyn and Skye had to say for the most part. That being said, I would’ve loved to hear another perspective from someone who experiences the world in a less academic sense. While I tend to get stuck in my head a lot, I cannot tell you how much God has used worship music during the hardest seasons of my life. When you discussed finding comfort in theology over experiences, I wish there was more space for both/and instead of either/or. Because I find most comfort during hard seasons from theologically rich worship music (both alone and corporately with my local church) and recalling experiences in my life that God has shown himself faithful to me. I don’t think either one of you were intending it to be dismissive, but I do think it would be important to hear from other traditions (like the black church in America, etc…) on how they view worship as it relates to music.

Jennifer Stucki

Good conversation in general but I wish you would include trained musicians into these conversations. It is not just the theology that sometimes is lacking, it is also the MUSIC itself. As a professional classical musician, I can say most praise and worship music, as well as CCM is garbage. I would like to see higher quality of music of all genres have a place in our churches, as well as other artistic mediums. It is not that God cannot work with this music, but he deserves better than what we play MUSICALLY as well as theology. I am surprised that you have not sought out Professor Jeremy Begbie for a discussion of this topic. He is perhaps the world's leading scholar on the confluence of theology and music, and he teaches at Duke Divinity School! Also some of Makoto Fujimura's books are quite good (from an artist's view).

Sara Plumley

I loved this discussion! As a worship leader (oops, song leader) I wrestle with finding songs that are rooted theologically AND are singable. Just know it us something that many of us DO see as a need on the church. Blending the deepness of, say, Come Thou Fount, with the doctrine of I Believe (Phil Wickham- and is a recitation in many ways of the Apostles Creed) can be done?

Meaghan

As a former music director for a church, I’ve been in a number of denominations (and non-denomination) where soft music at the end is meant to allow for contemplation and reflection; a way to allow the Word of God to settle in your heart. That being said, I’ve also been in settings where it’s about emotional manipulation. I believe the Holy Spirit makes it obvious which is the intent. Perhaps it would also be good to ask a pastor what their purpose is.

Amanda

What if, instead of "demoting" worship leaders to song leaders, we elevate that position to be MORE than just a glorified song leader? Maybe the way to hold worship pastors to a higher theological standard is by taking their role seriously, and expanding their duties to encompass the wide variety of forms of worship that happen (or should happen) in a church.

Patti Bowden

I was raised in a liturgical church that used hymns exclusively until the late 80's when contemporary music became the focus in a weekly service that used the more contemporary version of the liturgy. Today I am part of a different congregation that is totally similar to my experience 30 years ago. All that to say: Yes! There are some wonderful hymns and equally wonderful contemporary hymns. And I totally agree with your comments about theology within any song.

Jennifer Pfluke

I'm sure you would probably count Hillsong United in your "garbage" proclamation, but I'd like to remind you that what you dismiss is formative in the lives of others. I've struggled with depression since my early 20s. About 10 years ago, there was a night so dark that I seriously considered taking my own life. I couldn't even muster the strength to pray. What I did was put their album Of Dirt and Grace on repeat. I listened to it all night long. And I was able to make it through. I'm obviously not a music sophisticate like you are. The church United is attached to has all sorts of issues. But God used their music to deliver me, and I will never stop being grateful. And I will never stop listening to them.