Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • Skyepod Episode 2.mp3

Missing 3 full-res photos, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Lately, there’s been lots of talk about diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI)—sometimes as a virtuous initiative and sometimes as a boogeyman. Even Elon Musk weighed in, presenting it as a threat to our safety. Is this just another baseless moral panic? What are the potential pitfalls of DEI? David French joins Skye Jethani to discuss the issue. Plus, David French introduces, “The After Party," a new curriculum to help Christians engage politics in a more thoughtful, humble, and hospitable way.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Ben Peltz

It was ridiculously disorienting not to hear the French Friday intro song... 😅

Daniel

I liked the intro and outro music. The fusion of Indian rhythm and Spaghetti Western sound track grabbed my attention.

Christina Smith

This episode was so good . Something to think about and chew on

Steve Collins

Very good! Was Skye speaking really fast on this episode or is it a setting on my phone? Asking for a friend.

Michael Waldorf

I like the idea of race neutral policies but I'm also skeptical. The Texas top 10% sounds like a good step however in my home state of Florida we've done things like put honors magnet programs in predominantly minority schools so the top 10% is skewed towards people that have means. Yes they do pick a valedictorian from the honors program and from the non-honors program so that does erase some of the impact but ultimately the presence of that honors program means the school district doesn't have to spend money to mitigate low test scores.

L B

This was a great episode. One thing that wasn't mentioned about DEI is that the Diversity is not just racial, but differently abled as well. Also I loved that class inequality was brought up. I believe class solidarity and addressing the massive income inequality in this country will help to heal all the cultural divides. That's what MLK was killed for, for holding a March against poverty that would bring all groups together.

Mark Norman

Mr. Musk is probably unaware of this, but his company, Tesla, also has a DEI policy, which can be found here: https://www.tesla.com/impact/people#:~:text=67%25%20Underrepresented%20Groups,67%25%20of%20our%20U.S.%20workforce. I wonder if I should worry about the doors falling off my Model 3. 3 letter acronyms really freak out conservatives for some reason. Texas and others were going after ESG for a while, then they realized preventing companies from factoring real risk into their portfolio decisions (ESG) was costing them tons of money. Don’t hear about it much anymore, weird.

Peter Boynton

Enjoyed this episode. Always good to sit in on a conversation of you and David French--and I don't miss Phil's silly intro French Friday music which I think would be out of place for a serious topic. (I think Phil's great when he gets serious, , but I'm not a fan of a lot of his humor.)

Sarah F

If you want to know about DEI in corporate America, McKenzie is the last thing I would quote. That organization does nothing but stir the pot and the come back 4 years later to “fix” the problem they created. No one is trying to get the exact same % of female coders as the US population. You look for the best candidate.

Sarah F

It’s so much more than race or gender. It’s differently abled, neurological differences, class, etc.

Aaron SirLemming

I was hoping to hear more concrete examples of DEI gone wrong. I'm personally biased toward thinking the right is making a mountain out of a vague "what if" that never actually happens, so I was looking for some examples that could convince me. Aside from the Harvard one, but even that seems like an outlier, since they appear to have actually known on some level that they were doing something they weren't supposed to do. I'd be interested in hearing about other specific incidents where someone followed genuine DEI practices and it clearly infringed on someone else's rights.

K H

Equity in disparity outcomes was mostly applied to free speech in this episode and it seemed that the argument was that whoever was more persuasive would naturally have their voice heard. 1) I think actually one of the intrinsically Christian ethics is laying aside my own power & privilege to promote the voices of people from marginalized groups. Not only do I profoundly benefit from hearing a different perspective but whatever group I am a part of also has the benefit of new & different perspectives that are more inclusive of the society in which we live. 2) Equity in outcomes applied to health means that the disparity between black and white preterm births is something we work towards or equity in morbidity from chronic disease or mortality.

Peter Boynton

So now I'm confused. This turns out to be the same podcast available through the regular free HP!

Mike Stralow

Just on French Fridays! As Skye said in the intro, we’re incorporating French Fridays into Skyepod, but still keeping French Fridays available for everyone. The other Skyepod episodes will only be available on Holy Post Plus for now.

Carlos Torres

Today’s top story: Steven Pinker is on "tHe LEfT”! The evidence? He *checks notes* hates Trump, and has given thousands of dollars to the Democratic Party. I…conic. Skye, David, never change. 🤪

Tiffany

In a previous episode about if the kids are ok, it was discussed that boys are allowed two emotions - anger and enjoying a joke at someone else’s expense, if I remember correctly . In this episode it seemed that Skye agreed with David that men are biologically more violent than women. I’m curious how you reconcile these ideas, and if you think the violence of men could be related to anger being one of the only emotions they can socially express? Do you think equality of outcomes is the same thing as expecting an equality of the distribution of outcomes? I don’t think it’s fair to say people on the left expect a true equality of outcomes. I think most people, even pretty far left, are always going to expect a distribution of outcomes.

Josh Hasak

This was great and really helpful for some conversations I’ve had lately with a friend who was complaining about DEI, and I thought was coming from a far right perspective, but French’s dividing up the reasons was informative and very useful, helped me appreciate my friend’s perspective.

Pam Baker

As a retired employee of a global corporation, DEI is not only about hiring equity, but training colleagues in understanding how to become a better coworker in an increasingly diverse and global workplace.

Elizabeth Trejo Yudho

Restitution: recompense for injury or loss. Please don’t forget about women’s right issues in America and how women especially in the church are still dealing with this. It’s hard for a woman to imagine being something she hasn’t seen another woman do. Fighting against the restrictions she’s being taught at home or in society that her role is in the home alone. It’s insanely difficult for women to enter a field that is male dominated. (For so many reason…one being some men don’t want you there, you are judged harder, you are stonewalled for being female) Providing that opportunity to women NOW may have to be forced because you are assuming all men are open to the idea. They are not.

Mark Norman

Update: Mr. Musk threw a tantrum when he discovered the “Majority minority” statement on Tesla’s website (link above) the statement was removed immediately. Im surprised the website that talks about Tesla’s DEI Team is still up

Kelly Sattler

Thank you! I am a female computer engineer and was a little concerned about the way the discussion went on this episode. It was sounding a little like Skye and David believe race had nothing to do with a person’s abilities to fly a plane, program a computer, or care for a child, which I agree with, but also, that gender does impact a person’s abilities for those different roles, which I completely disagree with.

Kelly Sattler

Also, throw in equal pay for equal work. The woman will have to work twice as hard, fend off me, who will make passes at her, or actively thwart her efforts, or even just ignore her and not provide her with the information she needs, and she’ll be paid less.

Carlos Torres

Even we lefties’ Lord and Savior, Karl Marx, didn’t think that quality of outcomes was achievable, and certainly not practical or good, even if it could be achieved. But y’know… Springboarding off of your actual question, it is interesting that so many people (mainly the right of center coalition) will say things like, “men are really struggling because they don’t have an identity outside of provider. And that’s bad because men are natural providers *citation needed*” It’s like ok… let’s say that that’s definitely the case…what do you want to do about that?

David B.

What happened to the French Friday song? Please bring it back...