Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Chapter 46

Standing on the wet grasslands, Davos calmed himself as Renly approached. As if the gods themselves were watching, the rain stopped with their appearance. Yet the dark clouds were ominous.

Ashford was behind Renly. Just as King Stannis had predicted, Renly couldn’t let one of the Reach strongholds fall, so he rushed to meet them. Behind Renly were twenty thousand men. Behind Stannis, there were barely ten thousand, and only three thousand of them were cavalry.

“So, he agreed to a meeting,” Lord Gulian Swann said.

He was over forty, and although he wore knightly armor, he didn’t look like he wanted to fight. Still, Davos could say nothing, as he and his house alone bolstered Stannis's forces by almost three thousand men. He was one of the few houses that had stayed neutral through this conflict.

And only joined Stannis when Storm’s End fell. There were others too. Smaller houses and landed knights joined Stannis one after another. And with them all, they had barely reached ten thousand men. And yet it was still just half of what Renly had behind him.

Again, Davos could only think of the numbers. To him, that was all it came down to. But now he understood that it was just that he couldn’t see the bigger picture. King Stannis seemed to have already seen through things and prepared for everything.

“Let’s go.”

Just as Renly started to ride towards them, so did Stannis ride forward to meet Renly. Wearing full plate armor, with a yellow surcoat with a black stag on the chest representing his house, Stannis stopped at a safe distance and waited.

King Renly, too, wore his armor, green as the grass beneath them, with a yellow stag on his chest, his shoulders adorned with a yellow cloak. Both of them had the same banner of a crowned stag; only Stannis had a deeper yellow. Far deeper, to be mistaken for being the same.

The two crowns shone on their heads. A crown of golden roses girded the temple, and a jade stag's head with golden eyes and antlers on Renly’s head made Stannis grind his teeth. Meanwhile, his own crown of red gold, wrought with points that looked like flames, seemed to have darkened to a bloody red color.

This wasn’t a meeting of brothers, nor was it a meeting to foster peace; both of them were prepared for war. Both of them were enemies. And one way or another, it would all end soon. That is, if what Stannis said would come true.

“Can that truly be you, Stannis?” Renly asked as they now stood face to face. “I heard rumors that you can change faces; I wonder if you are nothing but a Faceless Man, pretending to be my brother.”

“Very funny,” Stannis's reply was dry and cold. “You have forgotten my face already, it seems. Or have you simply forgotten your own House? Wearing Tyrell’s colors and roses like their whore is insulting to everything that House Baratheon stands for.”

Davos glanced at the lords around Stannis and Renly. Most of them were from the Stormlands. Their faces were ugly when Stannis spoke. But Renly didn’t take the words seriously as he glanced at Melisandre, who was silent.

“You speak of our house's dignity, yet you are here with a heretic,” Renly replied calmly. “A red priestess. I have heard that you even burned a sept on Dragonstone; did you do the same with Storm’s End?”

Stannis didn’t reply, and Mellisandre stayed silent. She had regained some trust with Stannis, but now she was very careful about what she said. So, her eyes only observed Renly and the others.

Davos also stayed silent; this was the play of the kings; he had no place in it. Both tried to find each other's sore spots, riling up their men. Davos sighed as he now had confirmed his worries. This wasn’t peace talks; it was two commanders sizing each other up.

“Will you deny my rights to the very end?” Stannis asked.

“With all my might, just like the rest of the realm does the same,” Renly replied. “From Dorne to the Wall. From old men on their deathbeds to the babes in their mothers' wombs. Look at yourself. You claim you might be better, but it is I with a bigger army; it is I with more swords fighting for me. You can’t win.”

“Maybe,” Stannis didn’t deny. “But I can fight. Something I can’t say about you. And where were your armies when I took Storm’s End? You sat with that fat lord of yours, forgot our past, maybe even forgotten how to wield a sword, too.”

“My army is here now,” Renly replied. “You soon will find out how good I am with a sword. Unlike you, I have allies, not some rabble that's forgotten who their lord is.”

“Lord Renly,” Lord Gulian's face became ugly. “I might not have agreed with King Stannis before, but now I see it is true. You have abandoned your lands. And you have failed your duty; I couldn’t stand idle in my old age anymore.”

“An old man who said himself that he was in no health to fight dares to insult our king?” A young knight came forth, glaring at Lord Gulian. “Watch your mouth or meet my sword.”

There was no point in this. Davos didn’t even know why he was here. Why were they there? But then he glanced at Stannis. His face was cold, but his eyes curved slightly. He was smiling. Only Davos, who had known him for a long time, noticed it.

“I offer you one last time: lower your weapons against me,” Stannis said. “Renly, for the sake of our past and future, give up on your foolish ambition. Kneel before me and pledge your loyalty to me; I will make you my heir until a son is born to me, and forgive everything that you have done.”

“You are right, we are still brothers,” Renly smiled sweetly at Stannis's words. “I will forgive you if you kneel before me and pledge your loyalty to me. I will name you my heir until a son is born to me.”

Such an insult. Davos never felt such anger rise through his heart. He was no warrior, but his hand naturally reached for his sword. Renly was the first man Davos truly wanted to cut down. The first man Davos felt such deep hatred for.

“I see, the Tyrells have fattened you up to the point that you can’t even think,” Stannis replied calmly. “Before anything else, do you even realize what position you are in?”

“Of course, that's why I am here,” Renly replied. “I will crush you and stop this little struggle of yours. What did you intend to achieve by coming to Ashford?”

“Calling you,” Stannis replied. “And I have succeeded. Now what will you do, my dear brother? Your army is now probably facing Robb Stark. And you are here.”

“Hah,” Renly burst into laughter. “You concerned about Robb Stark? Sure, he is great and all. But once he faces Ser Garlan and the Reach’s army, he will not dare to stand before them. And even if he does, what can he do? I have the might, and I will crush you first before moving to Robb Stark and what is left of the Lannisters.”

“You are blind. Don’t you see the rocky terrain behind me? Don’t you know the mountain range further back? I only need to retreat, and your cavalry will be of no use. In the mountain range, a thousand men can easily block ten thousand. You still have much to learn.”

“We will see.” Renly didn’t laugh anymore. “You won’t even have a chance to flee tomorrow.”

With that, Renly turned around and left. The grey sky was now getting dark. Stannis stayed in his place, watching Renly retreat. Davos knew his king well, but even he couldn’t tell now what he was feeling. He didn’t grind his teeth in anger; he looked sadder than anything else.

…

“We must strike tonight,” Lord Mathis Rowan said. “Stannis is right; if they escape to the rocky terrain, our horses will lose their mobility. And the mountain range further back will block us completely. He will most likely fight a defensive battle, trying to slowly dwindle our numbers.”

“Lord Mathis is right,” Lord Bryce Caron agreed. “If Lord Tarly were with us, he would say the same. Our men still have enough stamina. If we run through their camp in a surprise attack, even if Stannis manages to escape, he won’t have enough forces to block us anymore.”

Looking at King Renly’s relaxed expression, Brienne didn’t offer her advice. She was here to guard her King, nothing more. And she trusted her King to make the right decision. She believed that King Renly could lead them to victory.

“Hmm, we have to act fast then,” King Renly finally replied. “I am sure that Stannis is watching us. The moment we move, he will notice. So, we will attack when it is fully dark, and we will attack fast and decisively. Going straight to the camp center.”

“The gods themselves are on our side,” Lord Mathis said with a satisfied smile. “The dark clouds will obscure the moon. Stannis won’t see us coming. I beg you, Your Grace, give me the honor of leading the attack.”

“Very well, once we reach Stannis’ camp, I will leave it to you to clear of any obstacle standing before me.”

King Renly had many things to worry about. Robb Stark was one of them. The Lannisters only held King’s Landing and had no allies. Stannis was just a thorn in their backs. Brienne believed that their victory was assured.

At first, they might have taken Robb Stark lightly, but now Renly acknowledged that he was the only one who stood between him and the Iron Throne. That's why he sent most of his forces with Lord Tarly and Ser Garlan leading them.

Only a small force was left at Highgarden with Lord Mace Tyrell. Even with all the men Robb Stark had, he would be outnumbered at least two to one. It was simply impossible to win these odds, and Brienne was one of the people who admired what Robb Stark had accomplished.

Many did, especially knights and those who wanted to be knights. They heard of someone so young standing up against the injustice that had struck his family, standing up for the lands that were ravaged by the wave of war.

And winning. Winning and winning again, against opponents that others would struggle with. Armies fell before him, so did castles. Many things were said about Robb Stark, but the most important one was that he was just.

He was only a few years younger than her, and he was her role model. She heard how, even though he went to the Westerlands, rather than exact vengeance for the Riverlands, he didn’t burn farms or pillage villages; he even spared his enemies and led them to return home.

Some called it foolishness; others called it the fancy of the young king who in the end couldn’t handle the cruelty of the war. But many others didn’t think so. They saw a righteous person who fought for justice. It was just that he stood against Renly.

How great it would have been if Robb Stark stood beside her King. Like King Robert and Lord Eddard. No forces could stand in their way. But alas, it was not to be. Robb Stark foolishly decided to stand alone.

…

King Stannis's camp had thousands of tents. Lights from hundreds of fireplaces illuminated hundreds of guards patrolling and hundreds more standing still, holding their weapons straight. This was it.

Moving through the complete darkness of the night, Renly led his army. The few scouts who were to watch them were captured, and even if some of them ran, they weren’t fast enough to warn Stannis. This was the end.

“Charge!” With a yell, King Renly led them through the grasslands to strike Stannis's camp.

Like thunder, they pushed their horses to the extreme; the men protecting the camp stood still, unable to move. Fear bound them as twenty thousand cavalry moved through them. Brienne’s sword slashed through one of the unprepared men.

The helmet flew off the man, revealing a straw-stuffed man dressed in poor armor with a spear attached to a stick that looked like an arm. Horror filled her as she realized what this was. But it was too late.

At least ten thousand men were already in what they thought was Stannis's camp, and most didn’t even realize what was happening as the few hundred men who were flesh and blood ran away deeper into the camp, making Lord Mathis and the others chase them.

“For Stannis!”

“Stannis!”

“Stannis!”

“Stannis!”

Their voices were few, but they filled her with dread. While others were killed, some of them took logs from the fires and threw them into the tents. There were only a dozen of them who managed to set the tents on fire, but that was enough.

“My King!” Brienne only cared about one thing as the world exploded into blazing fury.

She grabbed her king, who could no longer control his horse, and pushed him to the ground while protecting him with her body. She felt unimaginable heat on her body, but her large body at least managed to cover her King fully.

She endured the searing pain as she heard countless painful screams echoing around. She didn’t dare to move, as she held her King and protected him with her body. She was willing to endure the pain. To the very end.

“Brienne!” Ser Loras managed to find them.

She didn’t know how much time had passed, but now the fire had subsided. And most importantly, the King was safe. As she looked around, she saw that of the ten thousand who were the first to enter Stannis's camp, maybe only half of them had survived, and they were on the ground, with horses running rampant.

The rest? It was then that Brienne, with her armor covered in soot and her skin terribly hurting from the burns, looked beyond the fires. A cavalry of thousands split the unorganized and confused army.

The cavalry led by Stannis crushed everyone in their path as they entered the fires, yet the flames didn’t touch them. Cutting down anyone who could still stand. And thousands of other men blocked the rest of the cavalry outside the camp, who now didn’t know what to do, or some were already running away.

“Protect the King!” Loras yelled.

The only reason they were alive was luck; the moment they entered the camp, they had led Lord Mathis to take the lead, and he, with thousands of his men, was now burned to ashes. And now the ones who survived had to fight to protect the King.

Brienne, Ser Loras, Ser Guyard, and Ser Robar: of the seven who guarded King Renly, only the four of them remained. And Brienne and Ser Robar were heavily hurt, barely even able to stand. But they held their swords and were ready to face their foes.

“Stannis,” Ser Loras said, standing at the front, as Stannis and his knights approached them.

“Surrender; you have all lost,” Stannis's cold voice echoed through the flames.

“Die!” Loras didn’t listen and rushed at Stannis, only to be blocked.

“You should listen when the King speaks.” A knight jumped off his horse as he faced Loras. “I am Ser Richard Horpe, and I will be your opponent.”

Brienne knew very well how skillful Loras was. He might have been defeated by her once, but that didn’t mean he was weak. So, it was quite a surprise to see him being completely suppressed by Ser Richard.

Then another knight blocked Ser Guyard, who tried to stop Stannis from approaching. Maybe because both of them suffered some kind of injury, they couldn’t seem to win their battles and were overpowered by their opponents. Still, Brienne stood to block Stannis.

“Are you going to watch them die?” Stannis asked as his sword faced her, but it wasn’t her whom his eyes were set on. “Surrender, and I will spare them. How many more are you willing to let die because of your foolish ambition?”

“Shut up,” King Renly said, holding his sword. “I will kill you!”

“Foolish little brother,” Brienne could barely stand because of her burns, so she was only able to block a few strikes before she was knocked down.

Renly rushed at Stannis in a last desperate clash. Their swords clashed, one, two times. Renly was furious, showing the fury of the Baratheons. Yet, it did nothing against Stannis, who defended himself.

“Wake up, you have lost,” Stannis said as he blocked Renly’s desperate attacks. “My men will continue to kill them. Your knights, your men who fought for you, who pledged themselves to you. Are you going to abandon them and let them all die?”

“Silence!” Renly was then knocked down. “You know nothing!”

“I know I don’t want to kill my brother,” Stannis's voice was clear. “So, I beg you, don’t make me.”

It was said that Stannis was stubborn, but Renly was no different. Brienne, who couldn’t stand up from the ground a second time, saw that Renly couldn’t accept this loss. He seemed ready to die.

Ser Loras and Ser Guyard were already on their last legs. And more and more of Stannis's men arrived through the path that the flames somehow couldn’t reach. The rest of Renly’s army was still blocked by Stannis's soldiers and fire. They couldn’t reach them.

It was over for them. Seeing that Renly wouldn’t relent, Stannis swung his sword, only to be blocked by Ser Robar, whose one leg seemed to be broken. Yet he still pushed Stannis away. But rather than continue fighting, he turned to Renly and hit him in the head with the hilt of his sword.

“You can kill me in your anger, but will you harm your brother, who is unconscious?” Ser Robar asked as he finally seemed to lose strength and knelt before the King. “I will accept any punishment.”

“Ser Robar!” Brienne tried to stand, but her arms and legs felt very weak.

Ser Loras fell too and was barely able to defend against Ser Richard. Ser Guyard now lay on the ground, not moving. And the rest who survived the fires were either killed or had surrendered. Stannis stood victorious.

…

The camp that they had used for days, prepared for the fight at Ashford and then for Renly when he and his forces were noticed, had turned into ashes. The devastation was unreal. Even now, the fires smoldered and filled the air with smoke.

From what he could see, at least five thousand had been burned to death. And the fires had isolated the rest of them who charged into the camp first. The confusion that settled next was devastating for Renly’s force, especially when Stannis smashed into their rear.

The darkness worked well for them, as they could hide their forces easily. Renly didn’t even question how easy it was to approach the camp; Stannis wouldn’t have been so lax in any other scenario.

He easily managed to cut down thousands before reaching Renly. There were those who wanted to get to Renly, but they were stopped by the foot soldiers led by Lord Gulian. And the rest ran away after Stannis appeared.

Feeling sorry for the three hundred men who chose to stay at the camp and burn for Stannis, Davos carefully moved through the ground covered in ashes. Everywhere he looked, he found burned bodies. Melisandre.

The King had used her power to make this victory a reality. He didn’t like it, but this battle, from beginning to end, was Stannis's plan. He baited Renly into attacking his camp, but even if that hadn’t worked, he would have lured him here still.

That would have cost them many more lives. But that wasn’t necessary; Stannis had baited Renly brilliantly by telling him what he would do. Renly and his men had no choice but to attack and try to defeat Stannis in one move.

“My prince,” As Davos was observing the battlefield, he met with Renly.

“What do you want?” He wasn’t very pleased to see Davos as he looked around, trying to find out how he had failed.

In the end, when Renly woke, he had surrendered. In exchange for sparing the lives of those who followed him, Renly bent the knee to Stannis and proclaimed that he would serve Stannis and Stannis's heir, even if it was Princess Shireen.

He also pledged that he would never aim for the Iron Throne again, nor would his descendants. Stannis made Renly pledge many things. But with this, Ser Loras and many others were spared. They also pledged themselves to Stannis.

The ten thousand men who remained intact from Renly’s forces were now Stannis's. And each day, more and more men had returned to kneel before the king. It was a complete victory, and with Ser Loras and Prince Renly in their hands, the Tyrells would have no choice but to surrender too.

“You should be resting, my prince,” Davos continued. “Once the rest of the forces have healed, we will be marching towards King’s Landing. The King has already sent his ships to block Blackwater Bay.”

“I am fine,” Renly replied. “It isn’t like Stannis will put me in a dangerous position. He knows my value well enough.”

There was one thing Prince Renly didn’t know. Although King Stannis loathed killing Renly, he would have killed everyone else for their treason. But he didn’t, because he knew he would need their strength when he faced Robb Stark.

Although many believed that even Robb Stark wouldn’t be able to match the enormous army led by Ser Garlan and Lord Tarly, Stannis didn’t think so. He deeply studied Robb Stark and his tactics. Though he never said so, Davos got the impression that Stannis admired the King in the North.

He believed that even though Robb Stark might not win, he wouldn’t lose. At the very least, he would weaken the Reach’s army by destroying their supplies and siege weapons. At least, that made Stannis very wary of Robb Stark. And Davos agreed.

There was simply no other way. They had to take Renly’s forces to win this war. But finally, it seemed that the tide had turned in their favor. This battle was Stannis's complete victory. But they couldn’t rest yet.

Comments

Dan

I think this is the first time I ever seen in a story where Renly bent the knee to Stannis after he is declared King and Stannis sparing him I'm definitely excitedly intrigued to see how this all turns out and also I really wonder what the hell Robe will pull out his bag of tricks for his battle against the reach

Chris7A (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-10 09:00 Renly is has such a weak personality. I can’t believe there’s people that like him.
2026-11-09 22:01 Renly has such a weak personality. I can’t believe there’s people that like him.

Renly has such a weak personality. I can’t believe there’s people that like him.

Blackmarketrep

Very unexpected now the Question becomes how Robb will deal with Stannis's force and before that take Kingslanding. Though this also closes the last of Robb's local marriage options that make sense. I can't remember but I don't think anything that would change Danny's story over much has happened yet so I guess the funny option of him marrying her and fulfilling the other half of the Pact of Rhyneara's bastard is still open. Though again the Robb vs Stannis fight is what I am most interested in. I mean history has shown more than once a much smaller force shattering a massive force so its not like its unrealistic just look at Baldwin shattering Saladin's forces for my favorite example.

Jonathan Black

Under any other circumstances, Renly would have won the war. He had by far the largest army, while the second largest (Lannisters) were being worn down fighting the North and Riverlands. He was not cruel or vindictive, so would have been most able to unite the realm behind him. So long as people bent the knee to him in the end, he would have been generous because he wanted to be liked. Doesn't mean he would have been a good king, but probably no worse than Robert. Just a pity he (quite reasonably) couldn't account for crazy magic priests.

beck

Same, I don't think anybody has done this in a fic, really well done, wonder how Mace and the rest of the Tyrells and Reach Lord's will react, Lady Oakheart for instance.

Mrsean22

Yeah this is a big win for Stannis. Good strategy, tactics and a bit of magic got Stannis a complete victory against Renly. Actually surprised that Renly got captured and bent the knee. With that action most of the army heading to Kingslanding will join Stannis. Maybe a few who won't and go Team Lannister but it be a small number from the Reach. Stormlands are definitely Team Stannis now. Stannis reputation and stocks going through the roof. Renly reputation is probably very mixed now.

Ashok Dodaballapur

I didn’t expect renly to survive this. Unlike any story I’ve read.

Chris7A

Large armies don’t translate to winning wars. He could only feed that many men because he was in the reach, as soon as he moved away he would have faced serious supply issues. Skilled commanders can also choose terrain to negate numbers somewhat. I think he was pretty cruel. The gold cloaks where incredibly corrupt under his management. Criminality in kings landing had reached unimaginable levels. Whether that was from wanting to deliberately spread pain or apathy doesn’t matter, it’s incredibly cruel. Unlike Robert, he was also a coward, who was indifferent to the misery happening in the river lands despite having a the largest army around.

Xodarap4

Renly is a mix of childhood trauma and grooming with adoration of Robert leading to his decisions. Trauma from living through the Siege of storms end with starving men looking at him with hungry eyes due to just how close to cannabism they were followed by losing his brother stannis to Dragonstone getting sent across the Stormlands where one of the lords molested him into a homosexual preference that led to experimenting with Loras Tyrell. Renly at Kingslanding watched Robert be a piece of shit to everyone close to him but was widely loved and adored by the lords and peasantry with his eccentric actions and feasting which he took lessons from in his Reach Kingship.

Chris7A

If he were traumatized by the siege he would not be so quick to forgive the fat flower for feasting in sight of the walls of storms end. When was Renly molested? I don’t remember that at all. Defending Renly, after literally grooms Loras into his lover, is pretty wild. They shared a lord and squire relationship and he took advantage. Baratheon’s are disgusting that way, they like their lovers young, like Dothraki.

Xodarap4

Renly was charmed by the Tyrells as lots can be said about them but at the end of the day they are a functional loving family. There's a difference between hearing about a person being responsible for your suffering and actually seeing them do it. For Renly the Hungry eyes of the guardsmen and Gruff treatment from Stannis followed by his disappearance to Dragonstone can deeply affect a child as abandonment while the pseudo-adoption by the Tyrells after years of fostering across the Stormlands can create a close loyalty. As for the Molestation I've seen mentions of it happening though can't remember in detail. As for the Grooming of Loras the age difference isn't a large obstacle when they convince themselves they care for each other

Chris7A

Bro, that’s like defending Dany’s love for Drogo. Renly was wrong to attempt anything with a near child who he had power over. Not only as his knight, but as the favored brother of the king and lord of the stormlands.