Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Pluribus 1x3 | Watch Along

Comments

BobJ

This is one of the most interesting shows to discuss. Really clever way to cover impact AI is going to have on the world moving forward.

Pyt

I don't think the drowning analogy is good. First, a drowning person is in actively in danger of dying. If you don't help them they will be dead within minutes. Which leads in to the second point, if Carol was left alone she ultimately would be fine. There is nothing that indicates that Carol is in immediate danger from anything other than the "hive mind." They aren't helping they're manipulating. At some point this "hive mind" is going to run out of food, how do they handle the individuals within the "hive minds" deaths? Because so far it doesn't seem to affect them? There are 8billion people in the world, well closer to 7 billion because they killed about a billion when they turned everyone. They didn't even bat an eye at that. They can say that they don't want to hurt people all they want but the clear lack of caring about life within their "hive mind" is concerning. I think what really bothers me about the "hive mind' is that they really don't care about the individual within the "hive mind", its not human. While I get it would be really cool to just instantly have all the knowledge of every human on the planet the sacrifice is your own independence and individuality. You no longer get to experience stuff for yourself just a memory of a memory from someone else. I really feel a point is going to come where the "hive mind" is going to start letting people starve or just outright kill them for the sake of survival.

Christophe

Carol is such an interesting choice for a protagonist because she's clearly meant to be frustrating to watch. She doesn't act rationally, not even after getting over the initial shock of "the Joining" and Helen's death, she seems to be permanently semi-drunk, and she was obviously never the most pleasant or easy-going person to begin with. And to make matters worse, her way of trying to maintain her ideological rejection of the Others to herself, is actively refusing to learn too much about them, like if she can just tell herself that none of what they do makes sense and they're evil and that's that, she can feel secure in her own stubborn moral convinctions. But obviously, to us as viewers, that just denies us answers to our own burning questions. The one big criticism this first season has faced is its pace, and the way Carol interacts with the Others is obviously a big part of that. She doesn't ask the questions we want her to ask, she doesn't try as well as she could to find out more, and even when she does try, she seems kind of inept and sometimes a bit slow on the uptake. But I think that's kind of the point. I think the main issue with the pace is just that season 2 isn't out yet and Vince Gilligan doesn't seem in a hurry to speed that process along. It's just that we're frustrated and don't have the answers yet. Now, if this show was written by George RR Martin, I might worry that at this glacial pace, the series would never finish, but it obviously isn't, and I have faith in Vince. So for me, the best way to enjoy this show, is to just enjoy it. To not really think of it as a science-fiction mystery thriller, but as a character study. The show is not about the Others, it's about Carol. Time spent with Carol, getting to know her, her insecurities, her emotions, is not a distraction or time wasted not finding out more about the Others, it's the whole point of the show.

Pyt

This might be a tell on me as a person, but everything Carol has done, I could see myself doing given the circumstances. I don't look at "the others" as people, because well they aren't. They are only allowing Carol and the other immune because they haven't found a way to force them to join. I disagree with the sentiment of "just watch and enjoy the show" part of your comment. Art is supposed to be discussed and analyzed. That kind of the entire point of art lol. Just shutting up and dribbling the ball is a detriment to humanity.

Christophe

Oh I think you may have just misunderstood what I meant in that last paragraph and maybe it was written poorly. I never meant don't discuss or analyze it, that's obviously half the fun with this show ^^ It's not like I don't want to find out more about what's happening. And I wasn't criticizing the girls and their discussion, if anything, I was criticizing other people that just equate this show with slow and therefore with bad, and obviously they are not doing that, they are obviously excited about the show. What I meant was more along the lines that, in order to enjoy the show more, if someone does struggle with the pace of its exposition, it can be helpful to consider the character study part of the show more and to let the story develop without needing to have exposition dump after exposition dump. To see the slow burn not as a frustrating failure of the show, but part of the fun, and yeah, discussion is part of that. Because getting all the info in the first 3 to 4 episodes might scratch an itch, but it would also be kind of boring. Also, obviously anyone can still criticize the show for its pace, I'm not dismissing that criticism as illegitimate. I guess I'm saying that I just don't agree with it, at least not as a criticism, that I don't view the slow pace as a bad thing and my musings were more about why and what I enjoy about the slow pace.

Pyt

Sorry, I definitely read too much into that last part of your comment. I shouldn't have assumed that's what you meant. Side note, you write beautifully. I love reading your comments.

james repka

Be careful w/ spoilers...

Pyt

I haven't watched this show before, I only watch episodes along side with their reactions. I don't know what I'm spoiling

DTGstl314

Not a spoiler - the name of the show is derived from the motto of the United States, E Pluribus Unum. It's a Latin phrase which means "out of many, one".

Gordon Woods Jr

Where is your YouTube cut of the first episode? I can watch copyright version.

Joe Blankenship

Carol's an alcoholic whose wife died 4 days ago. And the world just ended. She's a mess. We want her to be asking all the questions to get to the bottom of how and why this all works, but I guess she needs to lay around and watch Golden Girls.

Joe Blankenship

has anyone mentioned that the plane Carol was on was a "Wayfarer" plane? like what fell on Walt's house in Breaking Bad.

Dani

I think a great thread through this first season is Carol's apathy toward cultures other than her own

Joshua Luzania

Your comments about Carol aren't necessarily wrong, but it's still only 4 days out from her losing her wife, and the hivemind she's interacting with is the entity that killed her. It taking some time to move along and ask questions makes sense. and I think Carol did eventually sit and take in the Northern Lights, but it took Helen to motivate and put her in the space to do it. And she's no longer with her, so it makes sense she's not good at this stuff alone.

Mark Lecuyer

I have always wondered if Helen was the Golden Girls fan and she brought that love to Carol. It is either that or GG is Carol's comfort blanket. Like if I was in a similar sadness state - I would be binging Firefly so hard.

Alex Aguilera

Maple and Arianna having a 20 min post-episode discussion was great. I can't wait to hear their takes on the rest of the season.

trysmo324

Carol is such a frustrating character (intentionally) that I feel like it almost blinds us to the fact that no matter how benevolent this hivemind seems to be, it did forcibly take possession of the entire human population. Is taking away a person's individuality effectively the same as murdering them? Yeah, it's almost definitely a net good for the planet, but those people's bodies aren't acting of their own free will anymore (I think). Maybe that trade is worth it, but for who? I guess it comes down to whether you think all these people are still fundamentally themselves. I don't blame Carol for feeling like they're trying to manipulate her, def annoying how she handles it though. At her core she's a selfish and privileged person, which is pretty relatable even if it's hard to watch. Such an interesting writing choice

TheYo Show

When will the YouTube edited vids go up? Just wondering. Thanks

Rheannon

It's so funny because I was MUCH more skeptical of the joined people than ya'll! I really understood Carol's skepticism and pessimism. I mean, her partner just died because of the joining, which was this imposed condition onto the masses which no one had a chance to consent to or opt out of. She's not only grieving the physical loss of her partner, but also the loss of privacy, as the joined people keep using her personal memories with Helen almost as a tool to gain her trust. Imagine if your loved one was killed and the people who did it tried to befriend you by using memories they stole from them as they were dying. And then, on top of that, they keep telling you that, no matter if you say no, we are going to take away your autonomy and make you one of us. I would probably feel scared like Carol. I love this show because it brings out so many different interpretations based on who is watching. I wonder if opinions will change throughout the course, love the reactions!

samantha jones

You would need to understand that a lot of the decisions Carol made after the joining are because she's grieving her wife and feeling very lonely

Joe Blankenship

After I lost my mom, I laid in bed with Simpsons DVDs playing. That's my comfort show.

Pyt

100%. They aren't being nice, they are manipulating you.

Joe Stüll

The Sprouts scene is so clever. Yes, Carol, you’re so independent by being a consumer buying all the stuff marketed to your particular demographic. She’s fooling herself about the independence she’s so defensive of. Her career points to this as well. She wasn’t independent minded enough to put out writing that she believed in. Instead, she pumped out slop she hated for people she hated.

Isa cotovio

It’s been 4 days!!!! Jeez they killed the only person she loved and she clearly has no family…where is the empathy ?? Yikes imagine the world ended and your loved ones killed and you want her to be nice to the people that killled said loved ones??? Smh 🤦🏻‍♀️

Simon M

This show isn't as fictional as it seems. I see it as a metaphor for AI taking over. When you think about, it's exactly that. A collective hive with everything stored that is known of humanity and history and we all have access to it. Sure not the same situation but the similarities are there.

Butters

The actress who plays Carol does a great job making me not like Carol, I dont know how the story will end but I will not be rooting for her.Im still watching because of Diegesis and the story is intriguing,even the other survivors dont care for her

Heilige Taube

i think these beings are telling the truth, because if they were evil why not just kill those last 11 they control earth anyway so what would be a good reason for them to lie ?

Heilige Taube

they lose their humanity tho. no humor, no taste, 1 opinion. so whatever it is, it doesnt seem human

SabotheHunter

I appreciate how far the show goes to give us such a complicated mc to follow. frustrating but real interesting.