Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Pluribus 1x6 | Watch Along

Comments

Christophe

I do enjoy this episode but it's not my favorite like it is for a lot of people. Seehorn's acting as Carol was top-notch as always and most of the scenes of her interacting with Koumba Diabaté were pretty fun. And of course, the last bit with Manousos was great, I love him, he's a great mix of being admirably principled while also being kind of ridiculously stubborn. But there were just a few things here and there in this episode that I didn't love. I think the extended fake poker scene was too long only to not really tell us anything that we didn't already know about Koumba or the Others. Yes it was technically impressive but as GoT taught us, that's not enough. They could have cut that whole scene and it wouldn't have changed anything. And that's rarely a good thing. As a non-American, the John Cena cameo also didn't do anything for me. I know he exists but he's not much more than "vague American wrestling celebrity" to me. On the contrary, it took me a bit out of what I otherwise consider quite a non-culturally specific show, at least as far as American TV goes. Also, and I realize this is a nitpick, but the blocking with the bubbles in the bath scene was just ridiculous, took me right out of the scene. Isn't this a streaming show? With an adult rating anyway? Americans, man, y'all gotta get used to some light nudity, this is just absurd. HBO knows what's up, but they seem to be the only ones, and they also occasionally overdo it just for the sake of it. But it would have been much more natural here to just have the women briefly be nude, like who cares. Anyway. Next episode is probably my favorite.

DTGstl314

I'm assuming there were surveillance cameras in Diabaté's suite, which is how they knew it was Carol calling and sent the call to the Howard Hamlin voicemail. Love how the hive mind went to the trouble of close captioning Carol's video in Spanish for the immune guy in Paraguay.

DTGstl314

I don't think killing other living things goes against the "values" of the hive mind, I think it's just something they are literally incapable of doing. They're not making a choice not to pick apples, they simply can't pick apples, because they have no free will. The reason they don't kill anything is because they can't kill anything, at least not intentionally. They don't have a choice, in the same way that a person cannot "choose" to not spontaneously levitate, because we are not capable of spontaneously levitating even if we wanted to do so. They can't even build robots to do mechanical farming, because ultimately it would make them responsible for the fruit and vegetable holocaust that would result.

Christophe

Well Carol did specify that they should add subtitles for the non-English speakers, that wasn't their idea.

Pyt

"They're not making a choice not to pick apples, they simply can't pick apples, because they have no free will." This is my read on it as well. Also they just kind of glossed over the fact that they said in 10 years most of their population will have starved to death even with the eating of the bodies.

Pyt

I don't think people are saying she is grieving, I think they mean that this is a time where she should be grieving but is unable to. Thats what I mean anyway. She can't grieve because the entire reason why her wife is dead is because of this joining, which once again they just casually mentioned also killed a nearly a billion (1,000,000,000) other people, who are now breakfast lunch and dinner. The more I watch of the show the more I am convinced that this isn't just a group of people joined and sharing minds, but one mind controlling husks. It feels so clear to me that they are trying to just manipulate the immune. Why else would they try to send the guy in Paraguay's (did they mention his name yet?) mom to talk to him. He clocked it right away that she wasn't actually his mom anymore because his mom was a B. I'd rather have my B mom than some thing that was pretending to be her. Carol clocked it the second episode when they sent someone who looked like her pirate character from her books lol. And again when Carol met with the other English speaking survivors when the kid couldn't not answer the medical questions even though his "mom" told him to stop. I really wonder what happens when someone actually agrees to join them. Also we kind of skipped over how because of their inability to pick fruit most of their population will starve to death in 10 years. Which feels like some sort of commentary on how with all the illegal ICE deportations (as in what ICE is doing is literally illegal because every person is owed due process under the constitution) and American citizens refusal to do farm work.

Pyt

I saw a head line some where that said that Vince Gilligan wanted the joined to be nude. I didn't click on the article because I wanted to avoid spoilers since I'm just watching episodes as this Patreon puts them out.

Christophe

Lol that certainly would have been a choice. Though regardless of any gripes some people might have had with the nudity, or how distracting it could have been, I think it's definitely much better with clothes, it adds something to the vibe of the Others. Having all of the people wear the clothes they just happened to be wearing at the moment of their Joining makes for this great uncomfortable dissonance between seeing remnants of their individuality and their otherwise complete lack of it. It reminds us of the fact that these used to all be people with their own lives and personalities. It's a great simple piece of visual storytelling that would have been lost if they were all just rocking their birthday suits.

Joe Blankenship

I'd definitely be living it up like Mr. Diabate. I'd have all my favorite living musicians hanging out with me, giving me lessons and jamming with me. I still understand Carol's frustration and anger, but why she gotta be so difficult, right? Relax, Carol! It's the end of the world as we know it and we should feel fine. And if the hive people can't harvest food, why don't they just "undo" enough people so they can run the farms? Probably because if they undo those people, they might have negative things to say about their experience "in the hive." Hmmm.

Joe Blankenship

Why don't they just un-join enough people that can farm and harvest the food? I bet they can't because the unjoined people would have negative things to say about being in the hive.

Rheannon

I feel like every episode I want to reiterate that no one had a choice whether or not they were subject to the joining. Is it a "utopia" when no one has any agency or choice? Isn't that the theme of all dystopian stories.. A system claims to eliminate conflict, pain, or inequality but it does so by removing individual choice, dissent, or identity. The “perfection” only works because people can’t opt out. Its like the hive is saying "if no one suffers, maybe agency is overrated" which is just a crazy concept to me. Also, I think the poker scene tells us a lot about the hive actually. Even though it centers the french guy, it actually shows us how the hive truly operates when no one is around. The moment the Frenchman walked away, the illusion collapsed. Their smiles vanished, their voices flattened, and they slipped back into silent, efficient motion. Busy, but empty. The warmth, the quirks, the sense of personality all drained away. We’ve never actually seen them live, only serve the unjoined. So what happens when there’s no one left to serve? When the act is no longer required, what’s left isn’t a society. It’s a system. No striving, no creating, no becoming. Just function. And they can't even "function" right because their way of being will have them starve in 10 years. What would be the point of Carol accepting/adapting to that? Because if she turns, she's a part of a system who's only goal (biological imperative as they say) is to turn everyone they can find. They don't have a greater purpose than that, they've only ever said their biological imperative is to turn everyone. So what is the point? The only choice Carol has is to resist. Because if she doesn't she will die, and so will everyone else.

Kevin Landon

Ya'll know youd be in the penthouse jaccuzi with Paul walker look alikes, dont lie, lol

Kevin Landon

pretty sure she dialed 0, Diabate probably dialed 69

Kevin Landon

At this point John Cena is a valid actor, Peacemaker was great, but also check out Ricky Stanicky, so funny

Kevin Landon

I swear thats what they were laughing at before doing the intro

Kevin Landon

I dont think they want to live, i think their plan is to elimate the human population because they see it as a disease as well as other concious lifeforms, not animals. There is no discussion of reproduction, and they seem ok with starving to death

Pyt

I know the girls have questioned what the end goal of the hive is. And honestly I don't think there is one they've actually thought about. They are willing to starve themselves to death over the next decade because there is no reason for them to live. Its not a goal, but the end result is extinction.

Pyt

There is a part of me that says "fuck it its the end of the world and if these freaks what to indulge in my every fantasy fuck it." But I know I would get bored of that after like 3 days and miss being around actual people and not these husks.

Kevin Landon

Fk people, I'm gathering the cutest dogs I can find and living in glorious peace and happiness 😂😂😂

Kevin Landon

They are a "cancer" they are going to eliminate the human race

Joe Blankenship

Well, it all depends on what their ultimate goal is and who is controlling them. I suspect there's a higher being at play here. The goal might actually be to just wipe out the dominant species, us, so another species can colonize Earth.

Alex Aguilera

You know a tv show is really good when Arianna does that thing with her hands where the tips of her fingers all touch each other. Also I love Maple's description of Diabate treating the entire situation as some sort of free-range purgatory.

Alex Aguilera

I'd ask the Plurbs to start filming the new season of Severance immediately.

Kevin Landon

Lmao, and redo season 8 of GOT!

Robert Northrop

Your homework before the next episode is to research the Darien Gap. It's a 60 mile undeveloped strip of land with no highway that sits on the isthmus between South and Central America. No major roads, rough pathways, thorns the size of railway spikes, poisonous snakes, spiders, jaguars, etc. Diabeté is staying in the Elvis Presley suite. In many ways he is Elvis in this scenario - always surrounded, every hedonistic whim catered to and utterly alone.

Pyt

Hot take, I think Severance would have been better as a one season 12-15 episode show. I really think that after season one they didn't really have any idea where they wanted to go with the show.

Pyt

People like to shit on just season 8 of GoT but the quality of the story started to noticeably decline during season 4. Their entire rejection of there being actual magical elements in the world was so weird and detrimental. How could you go from having a pussy demon to just ignoring any magic is such a stupid choice.

Pyt

I didn't even consider how the guy from Paraguay would make it past the Darien Gap.

james repka

In episode 1 they said that the source of the virus-containing message was 600 light-years away. At the time it was discovered it had been traveling though space since the early 15th century, shortly after the reformation before the renaissance. If we answered back the senders wouldn't know until the 27th century. There are no aliens coming after this. It can't be an interstellar plot to take over planets because the overseer has no way of telling, in real time, what planets are infected. To the extent that any of that part of the plot is ever dealt with it seems that the most likely scenario is that the virus was sent in order to destroy any life capable of receiving and interpreting the message and cooking up the recipe. The final act for the joined then would be to use human resources to send copies of the virus message out into space to infect other planets with intelligent life. The source planet for our message isn't some alien culture looking to take over Earth, it's an Earth-class planet that used to be dominated by intelligent folk until they received their version of the virus. -------------- Dark as that sounds, it's ok. Because the show we are watching is about a well-drawn, complex character reacting to fundamental changes in the world that she is not prepared for. She is emotionally compromised, she often makes poor decisions in the moment, and is really, really bad at politics. I look forward to spending a few years watching Carol learn to deal with other people (or not), perhaps come to grips with her issues, and maybe even being the first organism in the universe to lead a movement and defeat the "Pluri-virus" and save her world...

Christophe

I mean I'm not going to check out Peacemaker because I don't really care about superhero slop but that's kind of beside the point. I don't care if he was good in that role, or any other role, because he wasn't cast here as an actor to play a role. He was cast as a celebrity to do a cameo of himself, he literally played himself.

PopeScooby

I think we find out a lot about Diabeté's character when he reveals what he learned about the stem cells. He says he doesn't think their life is that bad, and that they enjoy it. He's willing to use the bodies of these people. He is fine with the rest of world losing it's agency but he is unwilling to give up his own. I think he knows most people would not choose to do that to themselves and yet it's more important to him to feed his own hedonistic desires then even try to find a way to give people that choice.

trysmo324

The breakfast scene between carol and diabate is so telling. The way his face lights up watching her make her lil sandwich, the way he copies her immediately and realizes it's fire. He's so starved for real connection and original thought. The hive can satisfy all his hedonistic pleasures, but it can't replicate the simple joys of being human

Jorgalorg

Very nicely put. The hive is no more benign than in its eventual consequence than the cordyceps in Last of Us.

Mark Lecuyer

Such an important scene...this is what we (humanity) is about to loose. No new ideas, thoughts or change of perspective. If they convert the remaining 13 - this is all gone.

Mark Lecuyer

Interesting...kind of surprised, but understand. This show is so excellent. Vince at top form.

Athasin

I think Carol really was gonna stay in a suite in Vegas then she saw his face and decided to lie and tell him she was kidding and she can't wait to leave.

Kyn

At its core, they are manipulative. They are telling Carol that it’s the happiest she’ll ever be, but the truth is that Carol would be dead, and a foreign entity would inhabit her body. And she realizes that more than anybody because her partner is dead. So anybody who comes up to her, she knows it's BS, and they are cosplaying care because they don’t know her for real. But the other people have family that cared about them before joining, so it doesn’t set off red flags when “they” know intimate details that your mom would know anyway.

Teyon Alexander

They already have her stem cells. She had her eggs frozen. So they can keep their promise and still convert her.

DrBubba

The viewers currently don't know that, so this is pretty much a spoiler. Not very cool.

Teyon Alexander

It was stated in the third episode that Carol froze her eggs. So not a spoiler

Ardalah

The eggs' existence was stated, the connection between the two has not. It's a major point of realization for both Carol and the audience at the very end of the series that sets off a major shift in Carol's trajectory. So this very much is a disappointing, annoying spoiler on your part.