Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

The Sopranos 4x9 | Watch Along

Comments

Prune Tracy

I often get the sense that the larger part of the fandom believe Ralphie did do it, but I personally didn't think he did. Something about the way he says "no I did NOT" sounded very believable.

SavyJones

Remember their card dealer Sunshine’s last words? Something about if you can keep your head while those around you are losing theirs… poor Sunshine never got to the end of that sentence

Richard B

The priest quoting a line from Sympathy for the Devil. 🤣

Christophe

I don't know, these guys are all excellent liars. We often see Tony lie surprisingly convincingly even when we explicitly know he's lying. The timing of the fire is just way too coincidental for me.

Marcus Cato

The question of Ralphie doing it or not is a constant question in the fandom. I love the way that they leave it open-ended.

SavyJones

Tony was supposed to accept Ralph’s denial and the hundred grand with a smile. I think Ralph probably hired someone to do it.

Pyt

I'm going to miss Ralph. Maple mentioned the ducks during the discussion and it got me thinking how the show so far has shown that Tony really loves animals and has a connection with them. In this episode as soon as Tony showed up Pie-Oh-My walked right over to him. I'm leaning towards that Ralph didn't kill the horse but what made Tony so angry is that Ralph didn't really care about Pie-Oh-My at all and saw that it dying was a good thing. I think thats what really set Tony off.

Vasili Brasinikas

Awesome job clocking that Tony's description of Pie-O-My as he's killing Ralphie also applies to Tracee. Kudos to Joey Pants for his layered, infuriating, charming, overwhelming performance of one of this show's most complex characters. Can't wait for next week's episode!

Adam Vialpando

The thing about this episode is that Chase has hinted that Ralphie did kill the horse. But Joey Pants played the scene as if Ralph didn't kill the horse. So the actual truth we might never know.

RHPS

I always liked the theory that it was Paulie who killed the horse. He was angry with both Ralphie and Tony at the moment- what better way to get back on both them. Not personally since he had an alibi, but he had his guys

Christian

I never understood why Chris admitted to doing dent in that scene.

ATrustySpade

hot take but I choose to believe Ralphie didn't do it solely because it's more narratively interesting -- the idea that one of the most despicable characters in the show, one of the most deserving of punishment for his constant destructive cruelty (we talk Tracee but Jackie Jr was also a victim of Ralph) was killed not only for one of the few horrible things he DIDN'T do, but while he was even actively trying to improve (whether he deserves that opportunity and would have stuck with it or not), is just too delicious

Malik King

Great insight at the end there. You guys have a good perspective for being just first time viewers of the show.

Christophe

Of course Tony is going to "roughhouse" with AJ and give him an awkward bear hug, how else is he going to express his love for his son? Just hug him like a normal person and tell him he loves him, what are you, gay? I mean whatever happened to Gary Cooper, the strong, silent type? All kidding aside though, in light of all of these guys' fragile masculinity, I always find it so interesting (and a bit ironic) that they kept this traditional greeting between men from Italy, of giving each other two kisses on the cheeks, something that is otherwise commonly seen as weird or gay or just uncomfortably intimate for most American men.

Joe Rafferty

Tony: "She was a beautiful innocent creature, what did she ever do to you?!" Ralph's death rattle: "She was a hooah"

Veya

you guys touched on something a lot of other channels didn't, which is how each of the last couple of episodes deals with a different aspect of tony's relationship with women in his life: gloria's death, irina moving on from him, and beginning a new affair with valentina. then it's capped off by this episode with him subconsciously murdering ralphie over traciee, who he associates with his daughter. the entire season in general also focuses more on his relationship with carmela as well as broader money issues.

doomnuken

Started to catch up live with the watch along and loving s far except i have the longer cut while you're probably watching the tv edit so once in a while i have to re synch.