Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

A Knight Of The Seven Kingdoms 1x6 | Watch Along

Comments

ZitherManifesto

Okay, Egg is the Mad King's grandfather and the Little brother to Aemon the Blind Night's Guard in the original Game of Thrones,

Alex Aguilera

I love how Dunk didn't tell Raymun about Rowan. He is poor too, just wanting a better life for himself, same as her and Raymun is happy.

MiddayDisco

So what is next week ? You guys usually reveal it at the end but didn't this time.

Christophe

The fact that Egg lied and Maekar didn't actually send him to Dunk is kind of a big change from the book. It's not technically confirmed in the book, we don't see Maekar sending Egg off, but it's more or less implied that that is what happened, that Egg wasn't lying. Basically, that last scene is invented for the show so in the book, we have no reason to suspect Egg was lying. And I don't know how to feel about it. I don't love the way it changes Maekar as a character and it definitely changes things for future seasons and there seems to be no reason for it other than a quick joke to end the season on. Bit weird. Otherwise, as faithful of an adaptation as this is, I love most of the other stuff they added in this episode that wasn't in the book. There's like 3 or 4 pages to wrap things up in the novella after the trial but here, they gave it so much room to breathe, it's great. "Focking bee magic" has been living in my head rent-free since this episode came out.

Silver Hawkins

I think Egg definitely has incentive to lie. Even in the book. Just like he had incentive to conceal his identity from Dunk. He has been deceptive before and shown the extent he is willing to go to in order to get away from his family. There is definitely reason to suspect he may be lying. Just like there is reason to suspect Dunk is lying about Arlan knighting him, even though that's never directly addressed either. It's left purposefully ambiguous, so I wouldn't really say it's a "big" change. It's just a choice that goes against how a lot of readers interpreted that scene. I suspect the choice to show it unambiguously ties into future plans for including Egg's family.

Kevin Landon

I would love watch Queen's Gambit with them, i think its an equally amazing 6 part series

Kevin Landon

Yeah, I still dont know how i feel about that, lol, she is sticking him with somebody else's child, and Dunc knows it. But at the same time, if you see me getting baby trapped by a hot red head, dont save me! lmao

ZitherManifesto

Queens Gambit is fantastic, but I hope for Sons of Anarchy or The Magicians

Joshua Luzania

I hear people say this, then I went to look at the text, and it's literally just Maekar says his wits are addled for suggesting such a thing, then dunk implies living their lavish life didnt help his other boys, then Maekar just walks away. I'm not sure that implies anything on the part of what Maekar would do. Although I havent read the rest of the books so I'm not sure what else they say. I would suggest that if GRRM is involved and on good terms, it seems more like that Egg did lie and thats what GRRM wants to be the truth in his story.

Christophe

Well I won't spoil anything specific from the future books but we do in fact know with certainty that at some point, he has official permission from his family to be with Dunk and it's not addressed at all how he obtained that permission. So if Egg did lie at first and Maekar didn't at first give him permission, that would mean that at some point he would have had to have that discussion and somehow convinced his father after the fact and that all that happened off-page in between novellas without a further mention, which I just think is highly unlikely and almost a willful misreading of the text. Not to say the show isn't allowed to change that and actually have that discussion at the start of the next season. Maybe that would even be good, I don't know. Though Sam Spruell, Maekar's actor, has said that he will not be returning for season 2. But at any rate, I do feel comfortable saying that it is actually a change, that it's not just different interpretations. And it just changes Maekar's character to not be willing to let go of Egg in this moment.

Barrett Rayan

She isn't actually pregnant. She lied to him. She plans on getting pregnant, but told him it already happened to lock down the marriage

Callie W311

We don't know he doesn't have permission. Maybe Maekar didn't want any peasant to know his son is out in the world almost unprotected except for partially trained Hedge Knight. It's not crazy to think he wants Egg to go off with Dunk, but also maybe Maekar's father wouldn't have liked that, or any reason in the world to keep it a secret. Either way, we don't know.

Callie W311

Hey, remember Maester Aemon that told Jon Snow he was a Targaryen...right before he dies he says "Egg, I dreamt I was an old man...". That maester is Egg's older brother. It goes the drunk, the dick, the maester, and then Egg as far as oldest to youngest.

Callie W311

Ya but in this series they are making Egg his father. The writers wanted it to be "easy" for us to get the family tree.

Christophe

Wait @Callie you're saying that that last scene of Maekar could have been him pretending to be upset about Egg but secretly he did send him off with Dunk and now he's just performing for the sake of keeping it a secret? xD that's so insane that I kind of love it. I mean obviously nonsense but I love it.

Daymee

Alright, here's my main gripe about this series so far. It's not about plot, or acting or anything like that. It's about what a show is nowadays. In the 90's , shows like ER and X-Files were an hour long (minus commercials and credits about 40 minutes) but there were 22 episodes in a season. Then, there was a renaissance of television shows where they were more cinematic and thoughtful like the the Sopranos and Breaking Bad, so the season was around 13 episodes. Fine. Game of Thrones brought it down to 10 episodes a season, but dire wolves and dragons were involved. Still fine, I want it done right, not fast. The last season of GoT is only six episodes, but they're longer. Why do that instead of 8 or 10 better episodes? No idea. So here we are, roughly 30 minute episodes, six of them, that's a season? And the battle scenes looked great and all, but we're not rendering dragons and dire wolves here. There are marvel movies longer than the entire first season of this show. And dammit, just give me more Lionel, I love that guy! Great show, but that four hours isn't a season, alright gripe done.

D. S.

Counterpoint: not giving the showrunners hours upon hours to add frivolous content to the story makes it better, actually

Daymee

@D. S. That is absolutely a valid point. I still think that a season of a show should be longer than two average length films. But you aren't wrong, cut the fat, for sure.

Barrett Rayan

I think a well written, shot, acted, and overall produced show is worth significantly less episodes. As D.S. said, less chance for BS filler. Miniseries also aren't a new concept and have been done for ages at varying lengths of episodes and number of episodes. This show especially is based on a single story, it wouldn't make sense to have stretched it into more episodes. It would have just watered down the quality significantly. Quality > Quantity

Daymee

There is going to be a season two. HBO has confirmed that. So it's not a miniseries. "Adolescence" was a miniseries. "Chernobyl" was a miniseries. This is probably going to end up being a multi-season show. I think everyone is making valid points about filler and not loading the episodes with fat, but if there's a second season coming, I think I'm justified in feeling like this was too short to be a first season., that's all. And we can agree to disagree, over all, I really liked those roughly 4 hours of great TV.

Vet-San

This is how you cap a show. It is a beautiful denouement for the last three shows AND the entire series. Even though he's kind kinda rough around the edges, it's nice to see that Maekar loves his kids in this and previous episode. I also think one of the reason's that Dunk became such a great knight was not only his personal righteousness and the training and upbringing he got from Ser Arlan but also the guilt and need to right the death of Prince Baelor. You also see a lot of mirroring with Dunk and Egg. But my favorite is the earnestness of Egg calling out to Dunk, and he comes back. When Dunk is calling out to Ser Arlan, he also comes back. It's also never revealed if Arlan actually knighted Dunk before he died, though it's a safe bet that he didn't. When Dunk pauses while Raymun is waiting....He may not know the words. Like he didnt know what to say over that guy that died. It may also be that Arlan never knighted him, because he himself was not a knight. It may also be inferred that Dunk never knighted Egg, until it fell upon him to be King and then it was too late. A king cannot be a knight. And Egg wanted more then anything to be a knight. Incidentally in the European feudal system, there where two ways to become a knight. Knight of the Bath and Knight of the Sword. A Knight of the Bath was a ceremony, kinda like a baptism, I think meant only for nobleman. A Knight of the Sword was knight to knight out on the battlefield. A field commission in modern parlance. Also the ending was just beautiful, a Missing Man Formation tribute. Like in the Fast and the Furious for Paul Walker.... I think they are planning for two seasons, maybe more. i think there is only one novella, but George RR Martin said that he had multiple unpublished stories written. Like nine or so. They go all over Westeros. I think they mentioned the Wall. Which brings up some fan theory. Old Nan was young around that time, and she is Hodor's grandma or great grandma... She may have hooked up with Dunk. There is a lot of speculation on Dunk being the progenitor of Hodor, Brienne of Tarth, the Cleganes... Maybe he became a real Lothario... Another one is that Dunk became Cold Hands, being that he was such a good guy he was able to resist being a thrall. There there are many rumors about the identity of Cold Hands (who rode a Stag in the books?) Benjin Stark, Ser Arthur Dayne, etc... I hope they don't make the same mistake they did with GoT. With such short episodes and only six per season, I hope they film at least two a year...preferably three. Just the filming... Kids grow fast... omg...I cant even remember all the things I wanted to say... I gotta go get some food...