Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Author’s Note: Hey everyone! Here is the Work in Progress for Chapter 197 I hope you guys enjoy! :D The revised version for Chapter 196 will be out tomorrow sometime before the full release of Chapter 197!

Thalmin

Ilunor left without further discourse.

I could not blame him, however, as I could only imagine how it must feel for a Nexian of all people to finally be on the receiving end of their own wrathful pride.

If it wasn’t for our growing camredery… I would’ve probably chuckled at this turnaround.

That sentiment, whilst unvoiced, still made its way to my visage, as Emma was quick to point out.

“What’s with the grin, Thalmin?” She questioned.

To which I could only let out a long, solid sigh of relief, coupled with a bassy snicker that reverberated throughout the vaulted ceilings of the room. 

“You’ve just… obliterated, what was in effect one of the single greatest claims to dominance the Nexus has, Emma. Their command over such cataclysmic spells, their monopoly over the means of — as you have put it — ‘mass destruction’. This was the proverbial shadow that they had cast over every adjacent realm. This is what colors their every word, underpins their every demand, fills their otherwise vapid platitudes of civility and decorum. This is the strength which props it all up, the theatre, the stageplay, the entire song and dance. The power you possess… grants you the ability to completely circumvent such performative debasement. It grants you a seat at a table that the Nexus has never had to share in its history, it allows you the ability to dictate your own terms, to look them in the eye without the implicit threat of annihilation being a mutually exclusive recourse. Aethraships be damned, you have a counter to practically every single one of their tricks. You…” I started to trail off, realizing, perhaps through Thacea’s own reactions… my misplaced sentiments in the aftermath of a presentation colored in somber remorse.

This… defused my flighty aspirations, reducing it to but a whimper when it was otherwise about to reach a bombastic crescendo. 

“I… apologize if my overeagerness had gotten the best of me there.” I offered with a dip of my head.

“You don’t need to be sorry, Thalmin.” Emma responded immediately, causing my ears to perk up in rapid succession. “I… I get it. I understand the sort of thoughts that are probably swirling in your head right now. You’ve lived beneath the shadow, under the heel of the Nexus for your entire life. To be met with an outside context problem comparable to the overwhelming might of your tyrant is obviously going to inspire some degree of… enthusiasm.” 

I felt my tail starting to come to life. 

“Even so… I must stand by my own principles.” 

Only for it to stiffen up in short order.

“Atomic arms, as per the Armstrong-Tianxia Conventions, and amended in the Olympus Mons Accords, are strictly limited in their use to deep-space engagements between military vessels and any associated valid military targets, including but not limited to military stations, supply, support, and other logistical or survey craft.”

I narrowed my gaze, crossing my arms as I did so. “Are battlemages not considered valid military targets, Emma? Moreover, did you not say that the use of such weapons are now tactical in nature? What greater tactical target than a battlemage?” 

“In-atmospheric use of atomic arms have been banned under the Olympus Mons Accords.” Emma clarified with the tacit admission of a bookish scribe. “This includes any tactical atomic arms, as well as atomic arms employed in any capacity — tactical or strategic — within the confines of a planet, moon, asteroid, or artificial station and habitat. But!” She raised a finger towards the end of that ramble. “I… cannot say for certain just how our stance would change on this in light of recent developments. Because as much as we are an outside context problem for the Nexus, so too does the Nexus hold that same honor back home. I’m of course not guaranteeing anything here. Just that, well… legislation might change to allow for more varied use of arms. But again, that might not even be necessary given what else we can bring to the table.” 

This finally brought my spirits back up, as I simply gestured for Emma to continue.

“As I have stated before, wars of the contemporary era are shaped as much by technical enablers allowing for greater precision and concentrated projection of force, as they are the political and social landscape surrounding war. War, after all, is subordinate to convention, policy, and as a result, political will of the greater values of the citizen-society. All of which is to say, there’s much more to our arsenal than just the raw and messy power of atomics. I mean, we have even messier alternatives, but that’s a topic for another day.” She abruptly halted what clearly would have been another tangent. A welcome one at that. 

“What I mean to say is this — we have other, more precise means that can deal with a battlemage… or at least as far as I can tell. You’re going to have to fill me in on their capabilities, from within the bowels of the beast itself.” Emma audibly ‘winked’, and attempted to physically match that tone as well in her body language.

In this case, being the resting of an open palm against a cocked hip.

It didn’t take my sister to understand the implicit connotations engendered by such a roundabout suggestion. 

“Given the showmanship of the club, and how they’re an open book in almost every regard? All to the ends of intimidating onlookers and would-be candidates? I’d say I can do that, yes.” I grinned widely. “But in exchange… you’re going to have to tell me about these… other weapons, Emma. As well as the precipitating events leading to these conventions.” 

Emma’s posture straightened, if only at that latter request. 

“I’ll see what I can do, Thalmin.” Emma nodded.

=====

Ilunor

The prince’s return to our shared domicile brought with it the embers of that revolutionary spirit which engendered nothing but a bitter taste in my mouth.

We locked eyes, his gaze of unfounded chipperness, and me… the sole presence of reason.

There was little in the way of the traditional round of conversational pleasantries to be had. This, perhaps the earthrealmer’s influence, did admittedly curtail much in the way of wasted time better used on more productive matters. 

“May I be blunt, Prince Thalmin?” I offered plainly.

“Yes, Ilunor?”

“We all know where this is headed, so let’s start with the obvious, shall we? You… prefer earthream as an alternative benefactor, correct?” I posed bluntly.

The prince’s eyes narrowed, understandably so, at this departure from my typical character.

“I’m afraid I don’t understand what you—”


“Cease with the games, Prince Thalmin. I think we both understand that such barriers have since been availed over the past month or so.”

The prince hesitated, averting his gaze for just a split second, before finally acquiescing, his shoulders slumping in short order.

“If we are to be blunt about it, there exists… shall we say, a sort of lurid, morbid sort of curiosity with such a prospect, yes. As a pure hypothetical of course. You of all people should realize that I have no real practical claim on the throne. De jure, yes. De facto? Not quite. Not unless an entire line clears the way for my ascent. Which I, myself, will fight to the death to prevent, let alone entertain.”

“Of course, Prince Thalmin.” I nodded facetiously. “Of course.” 

There came another pause, another break in the momentum of the conversation, but a pointed and rehearsed one. 

“Then let us entertain such fanciful notions, hm?” I finally posed. “Precisely what compels you to fall under the earthrealmer’s shadow? What exactly is she offering that entices you so?”

The lupinor stared at me as if I’d asked him a question which ran in opposition to life itself.

Which, it did.

He just wasn’t seeing it yet.

“I knew you were an ideologue, Ilunor. But I did not take you to be one so zealously blind as Ping would—”

“Just answer the question, Prince Thalmin.” I interjected.

To which the prince, the bullheaded man that he was, simply shrugged and nodded.

“If it must be spelled out… then so be it.” He sighed. “Respect. Mutual respect. Respect for the sovereignty of foreign powers. Respect over the sanctity of peerage. Respect not out of any pragmatic gain or utilitarian favor, but respect out of respect’s sakes; values aligned to forge idealism manifest. A naive sort of worldview reinforced not by platitude or prayer, but by metal and fire.” He allowed that last sentence to sink in, to truly draw out the strength of his newfound zealotry. 

“From this is birthed the possibility of a reality unbound from the smothering layers of suffocating fealty that is the current… arrangement; a genuine hope for a future where a realm of differing peerage can stand untethered and unbound, their knees unbent, and their heads held high. United in friendship forged in solidarity, not shackled through subordination and dominance.” 

I took a long, steady breath, all the while maintaining a single, uninterrupted stare at the prince.

A variety of thoughts swirled through my mind at this junction, a sort of… offense, taken at the prince’s seditious, treacherous, insubordinate mentality; a complete rebukement of civility itself.

And yet… I found myself unable to act on those thoughts any longer.

This was no longer a matter of reflexive indignancy, no.

Indeed, that wasn’t the point.

I needed to hear the prince’s current trajectory, as spoken through his own words. No assumptions, no miscommunications. 

It was with this then, that I cleared my throat, and stood my ground with nary a hint of hesitation in my voice.

“Therein lies the problem, Prince Thalmin.” I began with a confident raise of my pointer finger. “You have heard earthrealm’s grand proclamations over commoner rule, correct?”

“Yes, Ilunor.” The prince nodded affirmatively, and with clipped brevity.

“Where then, does this place you? Where do you, Prince Thalmin, of the House of Havenbrock, fit into the schema that is the rule of the masses? Will you be subject to their whims as any of their peers? Will they find themselves compelled, now that they are emboldened, to place your heads on pikes as a means of retribution?”

“The fact that you would even assume such a fate is possible, speaks more to the way you treat your people, than my own, Ilunor.” 

I paused, not so much out of shock or some admission of defeat, but due to the sheer and unrestrained presumptuousness of that rebuttal.

“My point remains unchallenged—”

“No, it does not.” He countered. “You assume that the rule of my house is that of the norm, that there exists a bloodstained boot constantly pressed on the backs of the masses. When in actuality, this could not be further from the truth. Ours is a system of patronage, of the sheltering and protection of the meak from the will of the strong. And in so doing, we forge a bond not too dissimilar to the tribal packs of old, except with the complexities of the contemporary incorporated for practicality’s sake.”

“That does not preclude my point, Prince Thalmin. Moreover, I must… apologize for my brazenness in this discussion.” I offered, as I de-escelated the matter and shifted towards the real issue at hand. “You do understand what allying, and indeed, forging a union with these earthrealmers will mean, correct? Let us disregard rebellion and bloody revolution, and focus purely on the fundamental fact of the matter. Earthrealm, as with the Nexus, carries with them their own ruling ideals. They will not compromise on this, neither the former nor the latter, obviously. Ergo, should you wish to ally yourself with the former… you will merely be leashing yourself to a new master. One which — as you have so eloquently stated — carry their ideals within an iron glaive. And in their naivety, they shall see neither complexity nor nuance in your domain and its political structure. Instead, they will see a misshapen sculpture to be reforged, a clay pot to be remolded, in their image. And should this work already be fired and hardened... then you shall be met with the stubbornness of their starry-eyed idealism. In short, you shall be shattered, broken, and then glued back together as a macabre mosaic. No longer Havenbrock, but something new and unrecognizable. A spitting mirror image of the ideals of earthrealm.”

Comments

Teehee

FISRT

Teehee

FIRST

UC-79

"A spitting mirror image of the ideals of earthrealm" "You say that like it were a bad thing, Illunor" Hope the full chapter drops before I have to go to work tomorrow night. Thank you JCB!

Jose Colon

I mean I can’t say for certain, but respecting power structures in light of cultural significance seems easy enough should they not be hostile or malicious. I mean Spain, England and a litany of other “royal” nations exist in tandem with democracy, I see not why similar power structures couldn’t still find common Alliance in the modern earth governance Spain for example is (as I phrase it) a Decentralized Bureaucracy. The king is entirely a figurehead to rally around while the autonomous communities and regions hold the power to dictate at the federal level meaning no consensus choice can be made excluding the autonomous and regional governments

bruh

I guess its time to see if Thalmin will be based like King Juan Carlos. For those who don't know he was a spanish king who turned Spain into a democracy after he was given power after Franco's death. Anyway, point is I'm hoping Thalmin will understand the importance of transitioning from a monarchy to a republic.

TheEagerReader

There’s been discussion about the Nexus making democracy into a red scare style threat across the Adjacent realms. We finally are getting a preview. I do want to see Thalmin talk to Emma about their fundamental incongruent governments. I could see Emma acknowledge his concerns and basically tell him that the best case scenario is likely a constitutional monarchy and she tells him how when democracy first arose nobles made hybrid systems with it and feudalism.

TheEagerReader

There were monarchs during the enlightenment who adopted its principles. I could see Emma telling him about them and Thalmin wanting to mold Havenbrock’s monarchy to fit it.

Michael Halpern

therein lies the falacy Ilunor, yes some concepts and ideals will inevitably transfer over to any partners Earthrealm makes, but there would be fundamental differences between the hypothetical partner and Earthrealm, those who are privileged by the conditions of their birth will still be privileged, there's no real avoiding that with how magic works, not to mention issues of stability are very real, they may encourage more political activity amongst the commoners, but that in itself isn't necessarily a bad thing, after all, they have needs and concerns that would be inherently different from the nobility.

eskrelli

unless humanity are democracy zealot I don't think earthrealm would demand any change on an other planet

Jose Colon

Honestly after the 3 1/4th Carlist wars, Spain had zero options but to figure out how to prevent a continuation of the hell that was the previous dozen governments When I say Franco was the least bad option to win the civil war that should be an indication of how bad it was And the Spanish economic miracle is a deeply under appreciated part of history

LazyF0x02

I mean there's the simple, spiteful, reason against Illunor's argument fails. The Nexus is already doing trying to destroy Havenbrook's culture, hells they've already nuked Illunor's culture by shifting it to hate what they once venerated, the dragons. If, hypothetically, Earthrealm is going to destroy Havenbrook as Illunor sees it, it would still be the route they chose. Because when the choices are the Nexus' known tyranny or an unknown, there's very little choice.

TheEagerReader

The Director discussed this. GUN isn’t empowering abusive autocracies. She mentioned that any adjacent realms that wanted support would have to agree to become constitutional monarchies and undergo partial democratization.

Simon Pitre

They are ver very pro democracy. To the point it’s in the work place.

Willow Arkan

I mean at least in Europe, since my knowledge outside is limited, the royalty are more window dressing, the power that was always propping them up has come to the forefront and their myth mostly dispelled. The British house of lords means a far greater power resides with the nobility of that country then anything held by their monarch, more tourist attraction and propaganda tool then high powered political actor. Those with more actual power function like such kings always have as dictators, which is what a king is, the rest was always the lipstick on the tyrannical pig. However usually they were the leader or even just figure head of the oligarchy, what the high nobility was, where the lesser was essentially just middling bureaucrats, heck some of their damned titles even trace back to stations in the roman bureaucracy.

Unorthedox_Doggie117

"-you shall be shattered, broken, and then glued back together as a macabre mosaic. No longer Havenbrock, but something new and unrecognizable. A spitting image of the ideals of Earthrealm." Just as the Nexus does?

ANTIcarrot

Illunor has a point that Thalmin is being overly optimistic, and not considering that there may be things that Earth finds fundamentally disagreeable about his culture. "What do you mean we can't eat our prey while it's still alive? That's a sacred part of our culture that is!" It doesn't need to be a real thing that real wolves really do. Most RL nations used to have (or still have) pretty shitty cultural practices which are pretty awful. It's a little silly to assume that Thalmin's won't, just because he's a main character.

ANTIcarrot

I think Illunor is might be somewhat right for the wrong reasons. Trade with Earth is going to be pretty damn dangerous. Just for starters, think of all the times a realm is going to stumble across something like asbestos. "It's, like, super awesome, and has no downsides. Let's use it for everything!" A lot of Earth and Nexian knowledge about dangerous things is 'safe' to share because the doing is much harder than the knowing. Making plutonium is hard for us. But for the Nexus? They have elemental alchemy. And Emma's mana-pump could give every realm, and potentially everyone in every realm access to nexian mana levels, and thus nexian mana spells. Integrating the two tech-trees without accidentally creating Instant WMD, Just Add Water situations is going to be a complete nightmare. Earth is probably going to realise that faster than anyone else, as they already have gone through situations like this due to the way tech advances. "Don't worry. DNA printers are harmless. What's that? Some just published a super deadly viruses as a CAD file? Oh shit." Etc. In the short term they might have to take a very Nexian attitude towards anything more complicated than WWII technology. Because the alternative is a Willy Wonker "stop wait come back" approach that will inevitable lead to major industrial woopsies, and potentially major loss of life. And any realm given even that level of tech will probably have their own nukes in under 100 years. Only they might not have quite the same level of self restraint that Earth does. In which case you are likely to get a very Ukrainian distinction between Your Tech/Our Tech when it comes to complying with externally imposed rules of engagement. Earth is going to know that too, and again have to choose between the Nexus or Willy Wonker route.

ANTIcarrot

Illunor would probably argue that increased political activity amongst the commoners isn't necessarily a safe thing either. If given unrestricted access to Emma's tablet for five minutes he could probably find oodles of examples where it all goes horribly wrong. Especially in societies where voting was new.

Valderan

It would be a bad thing for humans to put human rules in place for non humans without taking that difference into account. There would have to be some very, VERY, careful social examinations to ensure that things line up properly. What if Havenbrokians go into heat, or literally cannot form long term pare bondings or alternatively are strictly monogomous and can't for relationships with others after their partner dies. These would have massive, societal downstream effects that human rules would not fit with and that is just one aspect. If it turns out that Havenbrokians need to spend three months of the year in isolation, just living off the land to get their primate brain realigned before going back into society then labor rights have to reflect that and office holders need to have alternates accepted and ratified into position. It would get complicated real quick.

Andrew

Illunar's scenario sounds more like what The Culture's Contact would do. But there was also one of the greatest scenes in Star Trek, where Quark and Garak talk about root beer... and how insidiously sweet and bubbly it is, like The Federation. So while Illunar's typically the heel, he's kinda bang on in this case.

Marshall Scholz

It's also pragmatism. "Which type of government might allow havenbrock/their people to retain the most of themselves and their culture". Even if one isn't perfect, the endpoints are significantly different.

Destinum

Illunor is completely right though. You gonna tell me the average voter in an extremely mature democratic society will find it acceptable for their own government to actively sponsor a feudalistic dictatorship just because its current ruling elite says "trust me bro, the peasants totally like being ruled by us"? Even if that somehow *actually* is the case, it's the exact same "argument" dictators have made throughout Earth's history, and we all know how much bullshit it's always been for us. Lupinors may be a different species, but their social structure and psychology as a whole are way too similar to ours for anyone to reasonably assume they'd be different in *this specific area.*

Xylophone Smith

the nexus elves are just a bunch of savages pretending to be civilized.. and they're not even good at it

T_witch21

People fear in others what they see in themselves, Illunor. Thalmin is right in this. Illunor has solid point, but he is too idealogically locked to be objective about it.

Michael Halpern

while true, its not like Earthrealm will be blind to the risks,

ANTIcarrot

Agreed. Though I'm not sure the same is true for Thalmin.

Canaries

But that wasn't always the case. For smooth transitions of government and cultural systems, you need to take a slow, deliberate approach. Often you need to first apply massive force, but the real work is done in the rebuilding and rehabillitation. The German government by the end of ww2 had been in power for over a decade, and yet the prevalence of fascism and antisemitism was worn away over decades of external pressures from the occupying forces. Mostly done through constructive, not destructive means.