[bonus] My Best Friend’s Wedding and Reframing Romance Original Script (Patreon)
Content
i cut out the third part of the video because i felt it was repetitive but i thought i’d share what was written.
3. Why Do We Like Unhealthy Romances?
I can’t just leave it there though, can I?
Because I can criticize the situations that have come to be almost a staple of romance itself but I have to ask: why do we like it? Why do we seem to romanticize abusive and unhealthy relationships in media? In 2016 when Suicide Squad was still new and all the rage, it seemed that many people were taken and enamored with Harley Quinn’s relationship with The Joker.
“God help anyone who disrespected the Queen. She was crazier than him, and more fearless”
Despite the fact that their relationship was just awful on so many levels and began with the Joker saying, “Oh, no, I’m not going to kill you. I’m just gonna fuck you up.”
And even now Twilight is experiencing a renaissance. People love it again. Edward is controlling and manipulative and awful but the baseball, man! And from Wattpad fanfiction to Episode stories, I’ve seen this display of questionable behavior come up on more than one occasion. An overprotective, insanely jealous boyfriend. A controlling love interest that the main character isn’t even with yet but who tells her who she can and cant’ talk to and how not to dress. We call these things out for being unhealthy and...toxic but there’s so much of it prevalent everywhere that it leads me to believe that a lot of people idolize it. Why?
The simple answer is that we’ve been conditioned to think that this persistence is an act of love and that if someone is possessive of us, we should be flattered. I love The Temptations, man, and I love “Ain’t Too Proud to Beg” but that opening line would be a red flag in a real relationship.
“I know you want to leave me but I refuse to let you go.”
We’re meant to be charmed by things like this. If someone is violent with you whether that violence is physical or emotional, it just means that they love you and you should be honored. Famous abuser and murderer Phil Spector produced a song about this in 1963. Written by Carole King and Gerry Goffin and performed by The Crystals, it got little airplay before it was dropped because the lyrics were causing too much controversy. What were the lyrics?
He hit me / And I knew he loved me / If he didn't care for me / I could have never made him mad / But he hit me /And I was glad.
What we see with “He Hit Me” is what we see with movies like Fifty Shades of Gray. There was an outrage about this song and about this movie because in both abuse was romanticized and aggression is painted out as love but these are just more in your face versions of what we’ve already seen and heard in countless other movies and songs. So, what is it exactly? There’s a thin line between red flags and abuse and it seems to many that those red flags, in movies and TV, can be endearing. Even attractive.
“It’s just a movie.”
But it never is. Art is never just art. It has an effect on the people viewing it.
The study Julie Lippman conducted, the “I Did It Because I Never Stopped Loving You” study, involved having a group of three different women watch six different movies. The first group watched movies where a woman being stalked was framed in a positive light. There’s Something About Mary and Management. The second group watched movies where this stalking was framed negatively, in a scary thriller like Sleeping with the Enemy and Enough. And the third group, the control group, they watched something neutral like a nature documentary.
In the end, these women took a survey to determine their agreement or disagreement with common misconceptions about stalking and/or abusive relationships. A statement like *An individual who goes to the extremes of stalking must really feel passionately for his/her love interest. Of course, the group that watched movies where these things were framed negatively disagreed with this statement entirely. And the group that watched movies like There’s Something About Mary mostly agreed with the sentiment. That if someone does all of that then they must really love you.
It’s not a secret that the media affects the way we look at the world and how the world looks at us. Look no further than medical shows. A lot of professionals in the medical field recognize that movies and TV can be very influential on people’s awareness of health issues like sexually transmitted diseases. Which is why it’s common practice for medical shows to serve PSAs about health hazards and growing epidemics. People are more likely to get information out of a fictional show than the news.
“An important aspect of health communications today is working with the entertainment media to include or improve health messages in popular programs."(Deborah C. Glik, ScD., "Health Communication in Popular Media Formats," American Public Health Association Annual Meeting presentation, 2003, p. 2) This is because "[m]any groups have come to believe that entertainment media can play an important positive role in educating the public about significant health messages."
It’s never “just” anything.
And since the start of cinema, these framing devices were used again and again. And when they’re used that often, always framed that way it’s only natural that you get generations of people who think a person not taking no for an answer is desirable. These devices are inescapable. They’re in romantic comedies, fuckin’ manga, fuckin’ dramas, fuckin’ telenovelas, fuckin’ science fiction movies about space traveling and -- oh, you thought I was gonna get through this video without mentioning Passengers for a second. That’s cute. Passengers sucks ass.
[And here I went into an unscripted rant about Passengers for about two minutes]
And maybe that’s why I have respect for My Best Friend’s Wedding. During a time when a lot of these actions were still admired and adored, thanks to decades of conditioning, this movie managed to not only go the route of ensuring its lead characters actions were never okay but it managed to do it while still retaining a comedic lens. It’s admirable. There’s lots of things you could fuss about. Maybe Kimmy and Michael don’t need to be together. She’s young and she wants to finish school and she should finish school. But if there’s anything that’s not wrong with this movie it is it’s fucked up nature and its ability to embrace an unlikeable protagonist.
Also, Dionne Warwick.