[personal essay] labor of love be(hind)tween the bars (Patreon)
Content
Sometimes getting that call means having to fight the rotten urge to ignore it.
She’ll call again, I'll tell myself. You can answer then. You don’t have to do it now.
When it rings a second time, I’ll hold my breath because breathing will hurt.
She gets out again tonight. She’ll call again tonight. Talk to her then.
It will ring a third time and I will pick up the phone because the fight between fatigue and guilt is a fixed one. Guilt is designed to win.
Sometimes she greets me with a simple, “How are you, sister?”
It began as a joke, I think.
As children, we watched so many movies together and we always laughed whenever there was a scene of awkward exposition (back then, we didn't know there was a word for the information dump characters vomited out on a dime). Two characters are interacting and, out of nowhere, one of them says, “Just because you’re my sister” or “Of course, I’ll do it. I’m your sister.”
It always made us laugh because we couldn’t imagine talking to each other like that. We would pretend we were in our own movie inspired by all the teen comedies whose spell we fell under. We acted out scenes as the mean girls (always as the mean girls because, according to her, the mean girls had better fashion sense) and we acted out scenes as best friends, as jocks, as cool teachers. Every archetype you can imagine, we played it. Somewhere in our game of pretend, we would drop in a bit of awkward exposition – “just because you’re my younger sister,” she’d say. “just because you’re my big sister,” I’d say – and we’d laugh loud and hard as if we’d never heard anything so funny. Playing off of that juvenile joke, she stopped calling me by name and started calling me Sister. After fifteen years, she still calls me that and only that. Unless, of course, she's mad at me. Then it's my full name.
“Sister, did you get the pictures I sent you?”
“Be safe, Sister.”
“Call me when you get back home, Sister.”
“Sister, why didn’t you tell me that my husband (Joseph Gordon-Levitt, usually) was in [insert movie my sister didn’t know existed]?”
I don’t think about these memories often. I try not to think of my sister often. Because once I dwell too long, I’ll become inconsolable. I’ll retreat into the memories from when we were 5 and 10, from when we were 7 and 12, 10 and 15 and I’ll remember all the plans we had for our lives. Our dreams ranged from the Ridiculous (starting our own super girl group), the Impossible (making our own planet) and the Hopeful (her a teacher, me a writer, living in houses only minutes away from each other). When I think of the dreams we’d shared, the ones we spent late nights building and trying to speak into existence, I cut my hands on the shards of what those dreams have become.
This time when the phone rings, I'll answer and try to sound chipper.
It was winter when my mom found that the window in the bedroom I shared with my sister had been corrupted. In retrospect, it was the only season skilled enough to have given away the secret of the screen’s damage. The flimsy mesh front was torn, ripped right through the middle, and the frame that had once kept it in its place was cracked at each corner.
My sister, who had, in her words, “adjusted” the foundation of the window to suit her nightly escapades out into our quiet suburban area, wasn’t a tactful fifteen-year-old. I didn’t see this as a flaw in her character though, because her lack of tact was the only thing she seemed to have in common with the other fifteen-year-olds I knew through life and through television screens. She had been tactful enough to keep the broken screen and its frame secret for a few months but the angry winter winds blowing a suffocating cold into our shared room were going to give her away sooner or later.
With the pieces of what remained in either hand, my mother stared at what was left, not saying a word. Upon seeing her expression, I, wrapped in a blanket and carrying a stuffed bunny, slowly retreated from the room. I was still young, still a child but old enough and wise enough to recognize rage when I saw it. My mother had an interesting way of expressing her anger. Hers was the silent kind of anger. I could always tell when someone was about to be in trouble or something bad had occurred based on the weight of her silences. I don’t look like my mother. I don’t always think like my mother. But I’m silent like my mother. In our silence lives emotions too raw for words to express. In our silence, we give away our feelings. Her silence, then, was the quiet before the storm, the peacefulness before the detonation of a bomb.
So, I left in search of shelter, walking away from the bomb that was about to go off.
“Hey, are you okay?” Stupid question. Is anyone okay in jail?
She says she’s holding on, being strong perhaps because she knows that I know that her grip is slipping. I say she’s been strong long enough. She asks me if I’m okay perhaps because she can tell from the hard edge of forced joy in my voice that I’m not. I lie and tell her I’m okay. She lies and tells me she’s okay. We both hold back tears, masking the wobble in our voices with unsteady laughter, as she tells me about her day.
The first time my sister ran away, I cried for days because I was convinced she was somewhere dead. The second time she ran away, I wanted to run after her to make sure she would be okay. The third time she left, this time for a juvenile facility after committing some petty theft, I wondered what had happened to our life. I watched the movies and shows we used to watch, listened to the songs we used to sing together and wondered when that stopped being enough for her.
These first few instances of her running into trouble with the law are a vague blur to me. My sister was home and then she wasn’t. My sister was home and then she wasn’t. My sister was home and then she found a new one and I was alone. The planet died. The girl group disbanded. The writer and the teacher burned up, bodies charred to a crisp and unrecognizable, in identical house fires.
When I pictured going to high school, I wasn’t afraid because I knew my sister would talk me through things. She would help me come out of my shell, tell me to be careful of who I trusted, and remind me not to wear white pants when I’m expecting a visit from Aunt Flo. By the time I got to high school, she was nowhere to be found. Not yet in jail, not home in years, just out in the ether of drugs, trouble and the unknown. I envied -- and still envy -- the friends who spent time with their sisters just because they felt like it. They could go to the movies with their sister, go over to her house or call her anytime they needed help. It was the life we dreamt up but it felt so far from reality that it no longer felt like a dream. It felt like an impossibility, a thing of fiction. At most, if I needed to find my sister, I knew what state she was living in. Georgia, Texas, Alabama, Missouri. But I never knew cities or exact places. A house or an apartment? A shelter or an hotel? A motel or a car?
The worst part about not knowing things is getting used to not knowing things. Somewhere down the line, I just accepted that I would never come to know the things I wished I knew or that some things, no matter how much you may think you want to know them, are better left unknown. To this day, I don't know if my sister did what they say she did. Or maybe, deep down and buried under bodies of immense denial, I do know but would rather pretend I didn't.
"I need you to put money on my books."
"Make sure you send the pictures."
"Don't forget to write back when you get my letter."
Letters, money, pictures and gift baskets. These are the tokens of love when the person you love is behind bars because hugs, kisses and handholding are not allowed. When visitation is permitted (on those increasingly rare occasions), all gestures of affection are strictly prohibited. I haven't hugged my sister in four years. Maybe that's why, on visitation day, I feel such dread in the pit of my stomach. People aren't supposed to be dreadful of seeing their loved ones but I have to admit that I sometimes am. It's not that I don't want to see her. Like with my struggle in picking up the phone when she calls, it's not that I don't want to talk to her. It's just that it's hard to love someone with such limitations. It's hard to see them, hear them, maybe be fortunate enough to smell them (if the guards let you get close enough) but not be able to touch them.
My sister is older than me but I'm taller than her and, when I see her behind the pane of glass, I miss what it feels like to rest my chin on her head when we embraced. I miss the callouses on her hands from years of hard work and a life of hard times. I even miss fighting with her. The first punch I ever threw was directed at my sister and I'm fairly certain that it was fighting with her that gave me such a powerful right hook.
Loving someone in jail is a constant battle. It's emotional warfare which is exactly what the prison system [all of its forms] is designed to be. people who think jail is easy or that seeing someone you love go to jail is easy probably have no experience with it up front. Imprisonment doesn't just isolate the person serving time for the crime. It wreaks havoc on their families and friends, especially the ones who put in the effort to visit.
When my sister was jailed in 2017, we had to drive an hour and a half out from our home to visit the county that had her custody. There would be days, too many to count, when we would make that drive, all the while my sister would be giddy to see us, only for the officers to turn us away and tell us visitation has been cancelled for the day. Those failed visitations were gutting. For my mom and myself, the pain was tripled. There was the pain we had, the pain we had for my sister's children who were looking forward to seeing her and the pain we knew my sister was being agonized by. The ride back would be quiet. We would try filling the silence with music or jokes but they did little, if anything, to rid our bodies of the despair weighing us down.
One day, after my sister reminded me of our childhood fantasies, we shared a laugh that faded into a somber silence when I asked her why she did it. "It" was a shapeless, heavy thing that encapsulated everything her attorney shared with us about the case and everything else we didn't have the stomach to learn. "It" was a repeat offender, a destroyer of lives and potential and the happiness that she deserved.
We are not children anymore. We grew up a long time ago, too soon for our ages. Still, we mourned the life we were supposed to have together. The girl group, the planet, The Teacher and The Writer. When I ask, I no longer have the strength or the willpower to keep up the ruse. I let the wobble of my voice show itself unmasked by feigned laughter or held breaths.
"Why?"
I think about all the things that we were supposed to do and the milestones that we should have shared, ones we didn't get to share either because of jail or because of the constant mystery of where she was. Two graduations, weddings, births and deaths.
In 2020, when my great grandmother passed away, the entire family reunited in Alabama for the funeral. Cousins and aunts and uncles I hadn't seen in years were gathered together in the house my grandfather built, generations upon generations talking and reminiscing under the weeping trees and Spanish moss hanging over the front yard. I looked at everyone, awed to see so many of us together and desolate because the picture wasn't complete. I took two roses from the funeral, pressing one for myself and one for my sister to make up for what she missed.
She's quiet. She sighs heavily and, even though I can't see her, I know -- because I know her gestures better than my own -- that she shakes her head. She probably shrugs, too. "I ask myself that every day."