[essay] joy bryant, honey & the thankless best friend (Patreon)
Content
Honey, the 2003 dance film inspired by the life and career of professional choreographer Laurieann Gibson, was a fixture of my childhood. It's a technically competent movie with a predictable story -- though many will claim predictability to be a fatal flaw, it's a mostly offenseless consequence of storytelling -- and, in spite of poor reviews at the time of its release, it has gone on to become, not quite iconic but, significant. An integral part of the dance film frenzy that characterized the 2000s, sandwiched between Save the Last Dance and You Got Served, Honey was equal parts cheesy and endearing. In my youth, it inspired dreams of becoming a dancer, my lack of rhythm be damned. In my adulthood, however, it now stands out as an approachable story about exploitation in the entertainment industry. Comparable to Mariah Carey's infamously disastrous film Glitter, Honey follows a young dancer named Honey who works two jobs and dreams of having a career as a professional choreographer. She's given the chance of a lifetime to dance in a music video which quickly opens up door after door until she's soon living her dream of choreographing for popular artists such as Ginuwine and Tweet.
Honey is kind, Honey is immensely talented, Honey glows with goodness, Honey is loved, adored and admired on all fronts. But watching the movie, in my youth and in my adulthood, my eyes are always drawn to Gina, Honey's best friend who is played authentically, tenderly, and hilariously by the ever-talented Joy Bryant. Gina is kind, Gina is fiercely loyal, Gina is funny as hell and Gina is stunning. Gina is also invisible. Whether Gina and Honey are at the club where Honey spends her nights bartending, whether they're both working their day job at a local record store, whether they're out having a good time, people gravitate towards Honey. They never see Gina. Rarely do they acknowledge her. In fact, there are too many instances to count where people interact with Honey but seem to look right through Gina. It's not out of the ordinary for the often overlooked best friend character to blend in with the wallpaper and the extras, only standing out long enough to offer the lead character some choice words of wisdom before retreating back into the shadows.
Many best friend characters are hidden well, barely memorable. And screenwriters Alonzo Brown and Kim Watson tried to keep Gina in her place, going so far as to give her the line: "I'm just your friend. You're the one with the goods. You're the one the people want." But Gina is not hidden well because Joy Bryant does not hide her.
From the outset of the production, Bryant gave what could have easily been a non-character so much life that she became the heartbeat of the film. By first basing the character on a close friend of hers and then by deciding how she was going to style Gina -- the entire wardrobe, hair and makeup department apparently had little say in how Gina looked as Bryant brought them collages of outfits and paid for Gina's Fulani-esque braids herself. Lastly, just by bringing her infectiously joyful energy to the role, Gina became a standout.
I was always put off by Honey's character, even as a child, because I knew she was a Black woman and it confused me that she wasn't being played by a Black woman. The story was famously written with Beyoncé in mind though for many years, it was thought that the role was written for Aaliyah. Although director Billie Woodruff would later say this wasn't true, the fact that both Ginuwine and Missy Elliott, frequent collaborators of Aaliyah's, had cameos in the film would make fans rather hesitant to believe the late singer wasn't involved with the film in some way. Instead of giving the role to another Black woman or changing the race of the character, the role of Honey was offered to Jessica Alba. There's so much unpacking to do there, especially when we consider how the subsequent Honey sequels, one box office failure and two straight to DVD releases, starred either a Black woman or a half Black woman.
Because of the confusion I felt about Honey, I couldn't really identify with her although I would be lying if I said I didn't think she was beautiful or that I didn't appreciate her style. I did. I still do. But I was attached to Gina. Not only was she absolutely effervescent but she was so confident, so outspoken, knew how to advocate for herself and for others. And yet she still saw little value in herself, at one point even relegating herself to just being the best friend (a blatant lie if there was one) and even though it was merely a consequence of the best friend trope, it reminded me of how so often in life, whether creatively or socially or what have you, we have no problem igniting the light of others just as we have no problem dimming the light of ourselves. I don't believe for a second that a character like Gina would say something like that about herself. Each time I watch the movie again, I want to jump into the screen and tell her that she has the goods, she's the one people want. More than anything I want to say, why can't the both of you be deserving of love and acknowledgement for the way you shine?
Among the many, many, many characters relegated to the invisible best friend, Gina stands out because Joy Bryant allowed her to shine. I deeply admire anyone who can take what they're given and make something amazing out of it. This character could have been wallpaper, could have blended in seamlessly with the blurred extras milling about, could have faded into dance movie bestie obscurity, but when I think of the legacy of Honey, I can't do it without first thinking of Gina.