Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

i was thinking about aaliyah a while ago so i started watching some of her music videos for comfort and, even though i know not to look at the comments of any aaliyah video (for reasons that will soon become clear), i looked and babes it is genuinely disheartening how people have been weaponizing aaliyah since she died. they weaponize her as a tool to "humble" and put down other women, mainly other black women and, as you may have noticed, the person usually compared to aaliyah in order to be "humbled" is beyoncé.

as with most things that stick out in my mind for an inordinate amount of time, i started writing about it and about female rivalry in pop culture (feigned feuds, malicious gossip, etc) and about how these two women are often compared despite their huge differences and despite the fact that neither aaliyah or beyonce wanted any part in that comparison culture (remember when aaliyah shut down attempts for her to feud with brandy? she wasn't about that)

it's called Weaponizing Aaliyah | The Culture of Female Rivalry

i've been trying to make a thumbnail that makes sense but i need help. here are the things i've come up with so far but part of my hesitance is that i'm not sure if i should have beyoncé in the thumbnail...

...even though she's part of the topic, i worry people will misconstrue what i'm saying before they hear me say it and assume i'm contributing to pitting these women against each other. feedback please and thank you

it's also weird to have a thumbnail without any speck of color, it feels weird but i don't know what colors to implement yet

also remember that poll i posted a while ago between a tyler perry flick and a music biopic in the 2010s? she's almost ready for viewing but when i started making the video the biopic one had won but now the tyler perry one is slightly in the lead so...my bad

Files

Comments

Lootpack Jack

I understand your dilemma. It's tough though, because a fraction of the Internet is always committed to misunderstanding and complaining before actually consuming, o matter what. It's frustrating. Anyway, the first thumbnail with the both of them is better as the longer title explains things well. But if you really didn't want Beyoncé in the thumbnail, the second one could work. I would just make the text pink for that pop of color you want.

Aishyo

I think the first one will get you more clicks because it's Beyoncé and Aaliyah and a good portion of people who only read the headlines will rush to the comment section. I like the black and white, maybe the font can be in your signature pink?

Clouds in the Sky

The first one would probably get more clicks, but I agree with you this might get people get the wrong impressions. I think the 2nd thumbnail is communicating better the goal of the video. I'd choose the 2nd option.

Steven Clark

I like the second one better, personally. Also, I only recently heard about the conspiracy theory that Aaliyah was assassinated so that Beyonce could have her career, so I guess the topic is fresh in the cultural consciousness right now.

Jaycee

Agreed with everyone else here (with your siggy pink, too!). I vote for the second. Because although yes Bey's pic will attract lots of viewers, I think Aaliyah has had a resurgence in popularity the last few years since her uncle finally released her songs for streaming, so I wouldn't underestimate the amount of viewers that would go to the link for Aaliyah!

Ella Wheatley

I would go with the second thumbnail. It has more of a mysterious vibe to it and people will likely not be sure of what your content will be about. Aaliyah always held people's interest and I think the thumbnail by herself will definitely attract viewers.

Sinna

I like the 2nd one, the first gives the Impression of an comparison between the two & quite honestly if folks knew their work well the only thing they have in common is that they are both black & sing & did choreo but they were very different artist. The second one keeps Aaliyah as the focus which is the point. I often think folks doing the comparison are younger stans cuz honestly that Aaliyah & Left Eye death if you were around at that time that shit was devastating, especially to have to both go back to back. And I feel the comparison to Beyoncé comes into two camps. The first being the exhaustion that black women feel in regards to that Beyonce is now seen as the standard that all black women are pressured to feel to live up to or the ways that every Black woman artist is pressured to aspire towards especially if they do pop. And the second being young stans who believed that Aaliyah's legacy might be at risk of being forgotten or that she is underrated so (which she was not, we love giving her flowers she was on the cusp of having the bouqets thrown at her which is what made her padsing so crushing) they constantly pit her against Beyonce that she would of been bigger than Beyonce...I find all that shit gross. They are great artist but both are in different lanes. I do think Aaliyah if she was still alive I think her music sound would of became more niche overtime, it would have certainly expanded in some ways I think Janelle Monae's archandroid picked up that torch that was left behind. But I also think Aaliyah was going to go more into acting & film stardom if she was still here.

Lefty Blanks

I agree with everyone above that the 2nd requires people to actually watch the video before forming an opinion about what you're saying, which feels like what you're looking for. If you did want to include both of their faces, maybe rather than side by side, you could superimpose the pictures -- either through transparency or alternating segments of each face -- blurring (figuratively) the comparison aspect and forcing people to look at least a little bit closer to see what you're actually talking about?

Jeremy Impson

I like the second one, because even though Beyoncé is important to premise, it's about Aaliyah. That said, both are good. Going black and white looks great, but maybe you have cause to be concerned regarding the algorithm? And don't sweat the poll. For real we are here for everything you do, the polls just help you make a decision in those moments when you need a little push of reassurance.

golove.

Numba 2!