Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

full transparency: i'm not happy with this video but in the words of keyshia cole i need to let it go

Files

weaponizing aaliyah & the culture of female rivalry

Comments

Lootpack Jack

You're being hard on yourself; this is phenomenal. I mean The Brothers Johnson have the better Strawberry Letter 23, but every single other point you made was spot on. Instant classic.

Casey Lindberg

Amazing. Thank you thank you thank you thank you. In my love of Aaliyah I’ve done so much research over the years and it has always bugged me just how often commentators bring up Beyoncé. You aren’t imagining it- I’ve been an uber Aaliyah fan for over a decade and I’ve seen those comments since the very beginning. You don’t even need to dive very deep into the rabbit hole to see the absolute craziest sh** said about Beyoncé in comparison. You did an amazing job really nailing the point on the head. They are so different musically, what is there to even compare? It’s really just the misogyny/noir that is the reason people feel so compelled, it’s very much an attempt to punish Beyoncé for her success. Don’t get me wrong I’m not the biggest Beyoncé fan, but even as a casual listener it’s hard to not believe she did the work- just like Aaliyah did- and BOTH deserve their due. What is even more insulting to Aaliyah’s memory (and to her fans!) is that any true fan of Aaliyah knows Aaliyah is on RECORD as liking Beyoncé and Destiny’s Child. She was there rooting for them since they came out. Any true fan knows this. For me I think what I miss the most about her as an artist was her desire to work hard for herself and her own benefit, and how she was always so supportive to anyone who had the same dreams as her. I even remember a Toni Braxton interview where Toni brought up the time she was going through her bankruptcy and Aaliyah personally called her to offer support, even though she wasn’t as big as Toni was at the time. That really goes to show just how much she cared about her music and her dreams, and how much stock she put into other peoples dreams as well. No one can know what Aaliyah could have been or done, and that is heartbreaking. She was a very private person and so little is known and can be known about her, and it’s tragic that so much of her legacy has been tainted by people that were around her at the time that were so inappropriate and exploitative of her. It’s truly heart wrenching to understand now that I’m an adult myself that she likely went through it, and that it’s likely those experiences that were where her darker themes were influenced from. She clearly went through a lot, and you could see it in her work and how she spoke about herself and who she wanted to be. At the end of the day, the manufactured Beyoncé riff to me has always been an insult to Aaliyah and her memory. Per her own interviews, Aaliyah wanted to be remembered for being herself and for being a good person; to attempt to bring anyone down through weaponizing her is so disrespectful to her legacy and spirit. Sorry for the long post- you could say I’m a little passionate about Aaliyah and music from that time 😅😅😅 I think this video was amazing and I’m so excited that you took it on. I found your channel years back through your video on the Aaliyah/Britney biopics, and I have been a fan of your deep and thoughtful analysis ever since. It kind of feels full circle in a way 🤔 Thank you for giving this topic, and truly all the topics you explore in your videos, the depth and care that they (and Aaliyah) deserve. 💜

Mark Schwagner

I really enjoyed what you brought here for what that is worth! I feel you really tapped into something in the interpersonal that we are now seeing on a large scale. With all the union strikes from the UAW, to Starbucks, to the WGA & SAG_AFTRA, to CVS pharmacists, where everyone is fighting separately for what they deserve in compensation in almost a weird sub conscious form of competition over whose cause deserves more public attention instead of in solidarity. That Labor is now confined by the parameters neoliberal capitalism set up even as they fight against it. & the forced Monica & Brandi / Aaliyah/Beyonce stuff shows those who would pin us against each other are earworming people into believing that is natural and true. I hope some that made sense. You put out amazing work, thank you!

saddestsalad

Great video. I know I thought I was insane seeing all the comparisons to Beyonce.