"my screening for saltburn was free and i still want my money back" - saltburn (2023) review (Patreon)
Content
My screening for Saltburn was free. When I left, I still wanted my money back. This is another addition to the neverending list of critically acclaimed movies released in 2023 that I don’t just not vibe with but kind of think are…terrible. I noticed Saltburn had a lot of online hype mainly because of Jacob Elordi, partly because Barry Keoghan who’s turn as a main character is way overdue and partly for the air of homoeroticism in the initial posters and teasers for the film. Granted, the movie being penned and directed by Oscar-winner Emerald Fennell, of Promising Young Woman notoriety, also gave the film a nice buzz around festival season.
I didn’t say anything because I may be a hater but I’m not a vocal hater. I always like to wait and see what a movie is before coming to conclusions based on the trailer. I was extremely underwhelmed by the first Saltburn teaser. For me, it didn’t build any intrigue, it didn’t build any mystery. It just looked like a good-looking movie about the supremely wealthy, debauchery and sex. But even with the teasers and the initial trailer, I didn’t feel like there was anything holding it all together. Beautiful gowns, awe-inspired gowns but nobody wearing them, empty.
Still, like I said, I wait and watch a movie before hating it. I’m honest about being a hater, not the sneaky type. So, I gave it a chance and when I went to the screening, I gave myself a little talk like “I know it doesn’t look great but give it a shot, you may enjoy it” and I tried to leave all my preconceived notions at the door. The first ten minutes of the movie weren’t bad, a little clumsy but truly fine, and I was trying to stay positive but as it went on, the movie really didn’t do itself any favors.
Before I get into the negatives of which, for me, there were many, I do want to start with some positives. I think everyone is mostly pretty good in their roles even though the script itself is thinner than a 1-ply sheet of toilet paper. Many will walk away from this film praising Barry and Jacob but I think the real star here is Archie Madekwe. He was captivating, he was charismatic, he was funny, he was emotional. Even when everyone else’s parts were thin, he was full of complexity and he was always intriguing to watch. The scenery was so boring, the story was so boring, character motivations didn’t make sense, the writing didn’t lend itself to the art of foreshadowing, the movie was just kind of falling apart around him but he was still standing. I can’t say there’s a lot I enjoyed about this movie but I enjoyed him and he’s been really exciting to watch this year.
Now, for the negatives.
I walked away from Saltburn thinking about influence. I think the idea of originality is a myth perpetuated by those who have not consumed enough art to know what is and what has been before. Like someone who hasn’t seen a lot of movies may see Quentin Tarantino movies and think that he’s entirely original and fresh but that’s because all of the movies he steals from – keep in mind, I’m using steal in a good way like the saying “Good artists borrow, great artists steal” – but the movies he steals from, a lot of the time, those people haven’t seen them. When John Wick: Chapter 4 came out, I saw a few people commenting on the scene featuring the ethereal and beautiful and regal Maria Kokoma best known by her stage name Lous and the Yakuza. The scene is a closeup of her mouth in front of a microphone where she’s announcing the hit out on John Wick and updates of his location. She plays a song that’s dedicated to him, “Nowhere to Run” by Martha and the Vandellas. And the reason this is so cool is not because it’s original, it’s because it’s a reference to The Warriors. But placed in this movie, it adds another layer of complexity and intrigue.
When we’re talking about art, “original” never means it hasn’t been done before. It almost always means its influences are blended together so well that it creates something that feels new. Polite Society does this well, blending old school Bollywood films with old school martial arts films and Edgar Wright type energy. Barbie is literally just an amalgamation of things like The Truman Show, The Umbrellas of Cherbourg and, even though Greta Gerwig never said this, Life Size. I mean, Life Size and Barbie have very similar plots, the characters say similar things, maybe one day we’ll talk about it.
It’s not a bad thing to have influences so long as you can make it your own thing and so long as you have a story that’s substantive and more than just dazzling images with nothing behind them. That’s my main problem with Saltburn. It has many influences, wears each influence brazenly on its sleeve but can't deliver on turning that material into something that feels new. Saltburn's biggest offense is not its smugness about how clever it thinks it is, it's not the lack of attention to minor character details that could make the turn its protagonist takes feel like a worthwhile pay off to a slowburn set up, it's not the meandering runtime.
Saltburn's biggest offense is that it just reminds of all the movies it's influenced by, all the movies that better execute the same themes it's desperately trying to convince you are being approached in a new way. The whole time I was watching it, I was just wishing I was watching its influences instead. For the beginning portion when the characters are in college, I just wanted to be watching Kill Your Darlings. When Oliver makes it to Saltburn, I just wished I was watching Brideshed Revisited. For the rest of movie, I was just in agony thinking about how I've already seen Teorema and The Talented Mr. Ripley.
This combination of movies sounds interesting but Fennel does nothing to deliver on its potential. Instead, she becomes too engrossed in the act of shoving incongruent scenes of depravity into the film, scenes not intended to provide satire or commentary but to shock and awe and maybe get social media abuzz about how scandalous it is. When in reality, for all of its squalid attributes, it's about as scandalous as leaving a toilet seat up.
Where it tries to be sinister and calculating, it falls short. Where it tries to be satirical and biting, it falls short. I watched this in a packed theater and most of the moments that were intended to be funny…not a single person laughed. There was uproarious laughter at one point during the screening but that was only because an audience member yelled something that was really funny and it was the first time anyone in the theater laughed out loud.
The thing is I also didn’t enjoy Promising Young Woman that much. It was well-intentioned but poorly executed and kind of vacuous. The best critique I’ve seen of that film is that it tries to destroy the master’s house while using the master’s tools. But at least Promising Young Woman has a lot of redeeming qualities. Saltburn…has lovely gowns.
[I considered recording this review but I genuinely just liked how the written word looked so here's a standard essay. Hope you enjoy it]