Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

not the official title

as i was finishing the video though, i was strongly considering adding a portion about how fraught our relationship is with the idea of critique. in general, critics are hated on for dampening the mood or being negative but recently i've seen a new development where criticism gets dismissed as misogyny. with negative reviews of saltburn, a vocal minority said that the bad reviews were sexist. when verilybitchie and broey deschanel posted reviews of barbie that were less than glowing, their comments were flooded with folks insisting they hated women. and, of course, there's taylor swift whose fans dismiss almost all criticisms of her as being sexist. i don't think it fits in with this video but who knows i made add a teeny bit about it.

Files

more saltburn discourse because why not?

Comments

Michael M

Watching Saltburn just made me wanna rewatch Talented Mr. Ripley.

Miss Jess

It made me wish I WAS watching Talented Mr. Ripley.

Miss Jess

I think Fennell can really direct. She gets beautiful shots (the "dead wife" montage of Jacob Elordie, the labyrinth overheard shot, etc), has a strong visual sense overall, and can get great performances from her actors (I didn't know Richard E. Grant could do what he did in the red room scene). That said, she could REALLY use a writer, bc her work seems to lean hard on style over substance while vaguely gesturing at substance, and her endings are about as good as Stephen King's.

Candice

Re: critique, totally agree. I think it also just generally has to do with People On the Internet kind of in constant “performing coolness” mode (at least on certain platforms) and also viewing media consumption as inherently reflective of their morality and themselves. Like if you watch this movie/show, they’re being a feminist the right way and any (valid) criticism of said thing is a direct criticism of them as a person.

Clouds in the Sky

Re: the suggested sexism discourse portion I mean I knew this movie had like a very passionate fan base that was weird about it like what happened with Babylon and Licorice Pizza but I wasn't aware of like the whole sexism accusations discourse until now. I feel like that's more of a topic that deserves its own video tbh. One thing I often find really annoying when people talk about critics and negative reviews is that as if all of them are one thing and have one specific type of quality and not the fact that reviews like every other art can be both great or just suck based on the execution of it. Like not every negative review is a mam child cringe tantrum made by y*s, c******l d*****r or D**G W****r. Heck, I'd say that those critics are still bad at their job even when they recommend something because the ways they describe what they review are so embarrassingly boring at best (you know, when they don't offend a marginalized group intentionally or not lol). And also, I guess in the case of these people, they're just so incompetent at being funny. My point is these people suck not because they hate a specific movie- they suck because they suck lol. There are like "vicious reviews" that are absolutely terrific and rewarding to read or watch from great critics like Roger Ebert, Maggie Mae Fish and yourself for example because you all have knowledge on how films and literature work, understand there are times it is important to talk about real life struggles/events surrounding the topic of the art being reviewed, and also know how to be like actually funny. Anyway, my point is that I hate how people see critics as a one singular being and judge them on whether they liked a thing or not instead of like judging each to their own based on how they deliver their opinions on an art regardless whether they agree with them or not. Like I really enjoyed All of Us Strangers and Barbie but I still found Allison Willmore's review and verilybitchie's video pretty compelling. That being said, I actually also didn't like Saltburn and agree with everything you said especially about the stupid boring twist. But I think even if I didn't actually watch the movie or even somehow like it, I'd probably still enjoy the video itself lol.

luke maw

very nice getting a shout out and you also naming the video after me

crayker

I was pleasantly surprised by this movie. It's not a topic I've ever seen anyone comment on before outside of a few tongue in cheek jokes that poke fun at the aristrocacy and the class system deferentially, nor is it subject that could ever play to a wider audience so I'm surprised that they went ahead with it given that constraint. I think that they made some attempts to address that issue, for example, making Farleigh a mixed race character, because a being mixed class wouldn't make sense to anyone who wasn't raised inside of that structure. I also fell for the 'rich devour the poor for sport' horror set up, so I enjoyed the switch up half way through, but I understand that a trope on top of a niche might be a step too far.