Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Electric guitar tutorials as well?

  • Yes! 57
  • No! 48
  • 2020-12-21
  • 105 votes
{'title': 'Electric guitar tutorials as well?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Yes!', 'votes': 57}, {'text': 'No!', 'votes': 48}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2020, 12, 21, 11, 50, 33, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 105}

Content

Woops, I did not expect this to pick up so fast. I was messing with a few settings to see if I could link this to a Youtube video I was uploading today, but that does not work as it should. I'll leave this up to see what your thoughts are on this!

As will be made clear in the video I'm posting later on Youtube: absolutely no worries on the acoustic (or Tommy Emmanuel) material! That will remain the backbone of the channel and the Patreon page. It's where my heart is, and what I love doing most...

I had a meeting with a digital marketing agency last week, and we looked at expanding the channels reach. While they do recognise that the very specific nature of the tutorials is drawing in viewers, diversifying and reaching a wider base will be necessary to guarantee the long-term success of the channel. I'm still looking at how I can get this to work, and exploring all options. It could for instance be a more songwriter oriented series where I teach accompanying techniques as well!

Comments

Miggy’s Music

Absolutely! You’re a great teacher would be a shame if you were to limit yourself to acoustic only

Tim Van Roy

Easy guys, this one isn't "final". I'm messing with some settings to see if I can make this public on Youtube. The real poll will be published as soon as I know everything is working!

Tim Van Roy

You'll see what I mean with electric guitar tutorials when I upload my "One year on Youtube" video later today!

Ian Gallagher

Not sure, desperately awaiting "The Man With The Green Thumb" tutorial though ;-)

Tim Van Roy

It doesn't work like I hoped it would on Youtube, but I'll leave this up and running, as I'd love to see what your thoughts are! I've put it back to "Patrons only" so we can chat privately about the future plans...

Marc

While it would broaden your content(which is good), I think what people keep coming for is your acoustic stuff. Maybe give it a try to see what happens?

Michael Yaacov

Hey Tim. Maybe you should make an easier accustic stuff. Tommys song are very difficult to play for most amateurs. It would be nice if you could make more accustic stuff fo intermediate players

Flemis Druble

I found your site searching for ‘how to play....’ TE songs. There are so many guitar sites for electric. I am impressed by your fingerstyle & accoustic prowess; your touch, your articulation. I am an electric blues player who has always wanted to tackle fingerstyle which is demanding and fulfilling. But YOU should play & teach what fulfills YOU and what attracts Patreon $ub$criber$. The exclusivity of tutorials and low cost of subscription is better here than any site I’ve searched. Congratulations Sir.

Jakub Zimoch

I do agree that you should do whatever you want to do, but also take the marketing team opinion with a grain of salt. You have gained quite a "hardcore" fan base which I don't think that the marketing team would have predicted. I'm personally not interested in electric guitar tutorials as I only play acoustic. The only "problem" I would see is that you might be trying to mix 2 different audiences. For a lot of the channels that's ok because their tutorials are about 15 minutes long so they can upload 2/3 a week whereas your tutorials are much more in-depth and it's roughly 1 song every couple of weeks. My only worry would be that if you split your attention between the electric and acoustic you would also double the time between the uploads for one category, essentially halving the content for each audience. There are plenty of acoustic things you can do that are not TE as well. There is a ton of electric focused channels on youtube. I think that part of the success on patreon was the fact that TE tutorials are rare and the ones that are there are not always the easiest to work with even though a lot of people want to learn these songs. You could also look at expanding into other areas of acoustic. But with all that being said, if electric is one of your interests and you want to make videos for that as well, you can of course do it. I'm not against it. If you have some fun ideas for that then by all means share them, but don't try to "force" different content out just because the marketing people suggested more content. (ps. you have my patreon support either way! these are just some thoughts)

Brian Candon

Personally I would watch your acoustic videos much faster than electric. I have no doubt that you will still create electric lessons with as high quality as all of your acoustic lessons but it's just not what I'm interested in. I would love to see you tackle the repertoire of some other great fingerstyle players in as much detail as you have with TE.

Jonas

I’d love electric guitar tutorials. Been wanting that for some time. Will definitely expand your audience a lot, and it’ll probably keep your content more interesting and fresh to you as well long term

zero one

I currently do not have the needs for electric guitar lessons but if you are able to gain more patreons please do so. Anything that will help to keep your business running is appreciated as long as I have my fingerstyle stuff ;) I still have a lot of your TE tutorials to do. I am simply not that fast to start a new song every 2 weeks. You´re te best Tim. So what do I vote now? Hmm.. Cheers Helmut

David Priestley

I would enjoy some electric tutorials as well, but would be more interested in maybe some Leo Kottke(Mona Ray, Fisherman) or Stephen Bennett(The Most Beautiful Sky) for instance. But for me, there is already a lot of material on your site that will keep me busy for a long long time. Do what interests you, your passion will shine through.

Jeremy Thuillier

Hey Tim. I do not own an electric guitar, so I naturally prefer acoustic guitar tutorials. I agree with some people here, who ask for "easier" guitar lessons. Most of your content is for good intermediate/advanced players, but there a lot of songs, for beginners who can also be very nice and who are good for the "Boom-Chick" practicing, for example Baby's coming home or freight train. Anyway, this was just an idea for your Channel. I am very happy with your content and keep up the great work.

Josh and Angie Hoffman

Hey Tim, Thanks for doing the straw poll to see which patrons would like Electric. If you are passionate about expanding to electric, out of your own interests and passions, go for it! It's always good to do market research to provide the support and care your audience needs. Currently, I love how evenly split the poll results are. There doesn't seem to be a clear winner here, so the choice will ultimately fall on you. Regarding the agency advice - are they someone you know who deeply cares about you, your vision and your well-being? Or are they just trying to make something bigger (audience, channel, reach) for it's own sake? I think it's safe to ignore "expanding the reach of the channel for long term success" Your word of mouth approach and focus on TE and acoustic tutorials speaks volumes and is giving you 10x patrons and much faster rate than you'd anticipated. And likely much quicker than any digital agency thought you'd be able to grow.  Your refreshing focus and clarity for being a "Guitar in your lap channel" is paying dividends. If that means sitting with an electric in your lap. Then go for it. However, the nice thing about an acoustic channel is that all you need is a single acoustic guitar. No pedals. No Amps. No fancy setup. Expanding to electric may mean more talk and less playing. Have you read Kevin Kelly (Wired Editor) advice on "1000 true fans" ? https://kk.org/thetechnium/1000-true-fans/ You already have 229 of us. We'll all support you no matter what. I think if you just build for the core fans, others will come / go as they please.  But if you are only considering it because the agency told you to, I think you can safely ignore it :) You have a target demographic and part of the market no one else is addressing. I think you are completely fine not trying to be anyone else but you. Happy to support you in 2021 and beyond.

John Lind

Hi Tim - If I have my vote, I would love to see an occasional lesson on a "non-Tommy" arrangement such as when you offered the Chris Issak tune. I would love a lesson on any arrangement by Martin Tallstrom or Emil Ernebro. Thanks and Happy Holidays, John

Elliot Taffin

Hey Tim. I'd say go with what you want to do. I personally would love electric tutorials. If you'd want to stay unique, you could just do electric guitar arrangements. I started on transcribing "Mr. Sandman" by Chet Atkins, but never got around to finish it. It'd be cool if you did a tutorial on that song and others like it. I think you're a perfect channel for guitar "arrangements", and there totally is a big audience for that. I do agree that non-Tommy songs would be perfect for growing your channel as well. Though I love his songs, there are a ton of others out there. Keep up the great work as always!

Michael Whiteside

I came for acoustic after coming across the Chris Isaak tutorial. But Tommy is what kept me! That said, in the time I've been a member and watching your vids my repertoire and skill set has improved massively. This year I've picked up where I should hav been 20 years ago until work got in the way. Feel very inspired by what you've turned my guitar abilities into. Your easy going manner and the way you describe things is really very good. I'd be up for some fingerstyle electric yes, i realise i'm never going to be a rock god so that type of stuff I'm not that bothered about. Came across El Twangeuro doing minor rag/spanish rag the other day - that I'd love to learn

Markus Rämö

I don't even have an electric so it's a no from me ;) I love the Chris Isaak song. I would like to see you do some classic songs like that. How about Andrea Valeri: Sultans of swing? Greetings from Finland

Matthieu LE ROUZIC

I feel like saying "Why not?". Indeed, even if I'm more of an acoustic lover, I think that initially, doing tutorials on electric guitar will also attract another audience, which could be good to make your YouTube channel grow! Then in a second time, I think that as long as it doesn't affect the acoustic tutorials, especially the "Tommy Emmanuel" program, I don't see any problem for you to diversify! Friendly, Matthieu

Tim Van Roy

So much comments to go through! I will take my time with this, guys. Since you have all taken the time to write down your thoughts the least I can do is weigh off the pros and cons in each opinion. Your input is greatly appreciated, I'll get back to you with replies as soon as I have processed everything!

Jonathan Duffin

I was brought to the channel by the Close Enough to Hurt video, so you know my vote