Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

(... but hopefully not for Patreon!)

Hi everyone,

A quick word to all of you who make the Youtube channel possible, before I actually make it public over there.

As I have told several of you (during livestreams and private lessons), I have been worrying more and more about the legal aspect of the lessons. More in particular the way the lessons are presented: with tablature on screen. This potentially violates copyright laws, and we all know how that turns out in the long run on Youtube: copyright strikes and deleted channels.

To make a long story short: I decided to go for the quick pain and get in contact with Tommy's management. After a few failed tries I got a reply today from Tommy's manager and... they will be shutting the current format down. In a, might I add, very friendy reply they informed me they want to see the lesson videos on Youtube taken down as soon as possible. No copyright strikes or lawsuits were filed, but the demand was quite clear. 

The Patreon page will remain online, and in the coming days I will be trying to strike a deal in which I pay mechanical rights to the music. That was, after all, the reason why I got in touch with them in the first place: to pay my fair share. But there is no guarantee they will accept this...

When there is more news I will get it to you as soon as possible, but I wanted you to get it here first, before I post it public on Youtube in the coming days.

Thanks for being a part of the ride so far. And rest assured, the ride is far from over ;-)

Kind regards,

Tim

 

Comments

Josh and Angie Hoffman

Thanks for the update Tim. Assuming you can keep the lessons up behind a pay wall on Vimeo right? As patrons, we'll keep the access to all previous lessons? More importantly, to soundslice?

Miggy’s Music

Fingers crossed it all works out well for you

Martin Garbutt

A shame but honourable of you to be proactive about it. I had wondered about the legality of the tabs in the lessons after seeing another YouTube guitar teacher, Gareth Evans of Goliath Guitar tutorials, go through the same thing, having to take down all his lessons. Could be worth reaching out to him to see how he resolved it?

Brandon kear

What a bunch a pricks! much love Tim, keep up the great work champ!

Christopher Nelson

I'm not sure if you're familiar with Kelly Valleau, but he's another really cool guitar virtuoso/instructor on YouTube. His model is that he provides the lessons through a subscription to his website, but the tabs you must purchase separately through MusicNotes.com which handles all the legal royalties BS. He's able to offer discount coupon codes to his subscribers to get them at a discount over the list price on the site. Anyways, just an idea I thought I'd throw out there. It seems to have been working for him for a while and I've been glad to pay for any of the transcriptions I want to learn as well as the subscription to his site for the lessons. It's still a great deal as far as I'm concerned to have that level of instruction and professional notation/tablature. It might be worth reaching out to him for some advice. He's been doing it for a long time.

Martin L

Kudos to you for being proactive about this, Tim! In case people are curious, here’s a link to Gareth Evans discussing his channel’s legal challenge from publishers: https://youtu.be/6F63x345mCA. It sounds like the main issue is the tabs embedded within videos, which YT doesn’t automatically pay royalties to publishers for like it does for audio contained in videos. Good luck, Tim!

TM

Disappointing news, Tim, but I hope you can reach a favorable result with Tommy's team with respect to the Patreon page. The irony of these sorts of disputes is that I think its very possible that you're driving more revenue to Tommy, not less, because of your work. I found Tommy sort of by accident, and wouldn't be nearly as interested in his work if I didn't have someone like you to break down what I needed to do to learn some of it. I ended up buying all of Tommy's tabs from his website because your videos have taught me that I might one day be able to actually learn how to play them. That's not something I'd have been able to do on my own, and I surely wouldn't have bothered buying Tommy's tabs if I thought I wouldn't have a resource like this channel to help me work through the arrangements and techniques. I hope Tommy's management sees the value in that, and is able to see their way to working out a mutually beneficial deal with you.

Ian

I'll echo Tyler's comments re irony. As a result of your YouTube lessons, I purchased some of Tommy's CD's which otherwise would not have happened.

Joe Butler

Tim, really hate to hear this. Such a pain. If there is anything I can do to help, don't hesitate to reach out. I would be interested in paying for private lessons if that helps. Also, just let me know if there is anything I can do to help. Here for you Tim. Sometimes these things have a way of actually morphing into something bigger and better. Chin up. It's going to be OK.

Jeremy Thuillier

Thats really annoying Tim. Lets hope they will be allowing the videos at least on the Patreon page.

Toddy

Hey Tim, if possible, try to meet Tommy himself and talk about that with him and his management. In germany we say: "Warum mit dem Brötchen sprechen, wenn man auch mit dem Bäcker reden kann!"

Michal Zorkovsky

Hey, Tim, that happens as you grow, fingers crossed that all is soon resolved.

Tom Fran

Too bad. But worth pursuing for a business arrangement for both parties. You might be better having an agent pursue this.

James Lau

We are behind you on this but understand both ends of the business deal. Let us know what helps you need. We need your lessons.

Giordano De Franceschi

I don't know...it seems so strange...in the end we are all Tommy's worshippers, and Tim, you are doing such a great work by giving us the possibility to learn his songs (and more). If you need any help (like I don't know...sending mail to TE staff) just ask man! Giordano

Derk Stolwijk

Hopefully we can keep enjoying your videos Tim. You (and Tommy of course) realtime give me a lot of energy to improve my guitarskills. Fingers crossed that your patroon website can continue untouched. Your video’s are more helpful than my weekly guitar lesson. Highly appreciated!!!

Thierry Stallknecht

I really appreciate the way you handle this problem and how you instantly got in touch with Tommy (managers) out of respect. Shows, you're not only a great teacher but also a awesome guy (something we all know already) Hope you get the rights and we can enjoy your tutorials for the years to come!

Benjamin O

Can these videos be downloaded for personal use? I’d like to have them stored in advance in case you need to take them down.I have bought all of Tommy’s TrueFire lessons; these have been very helpful. Thanks Tim!

Daniel Masters

It speaks volume about your integrity Tim. I have to say I have purchased all of Tommy's Truefire lessons, books, (and even his maton signature guitar). Subscribing to your service Tim did not diminish my desire purchase his lessons. However, In comparison, your lessons are so much easier to learn from. Just because Tommy is an amazing guitarist doesn't mean he is an amazing teacher - they are two different skill sets. Perhaps you could provide these lessons under license on a larger platform.

Flemis Druble

Here’s what I’m doing; increasing my tier of support to you. In Virginia USA we would call you a gentleman for doing the right thing. The right thing is often the hard thing. As an attorney of 40+ years I wondered about these issues; not my area of expertise. But I believe the new model may be your covers on YouTube will drive folks to Patreon and you will see a big income boost. Tabs are nice but Patreon videos formerly on YouTube are simply the best. What’s wrong with adding to the 3 min YouTube cover ‘for detailed videos (forget tab maybe) join my Patreon page to see complex fingerings you can slow down loop etc. … and buy some Tommy CDs too’. Maybe TE management can make you a licensed teacher; you opened for him after all and you have great respect for him. It’s gonna work out. 🙏

Zach

This kinda ended up being a Jocko Willink “good” moment for me. I saw the news today on YouTube and was pretty upset by it. Then I decided to join the Patreon. First time I’ve ever paid for any type of guitar instruction, and I’m hoping this actually helps me become more dedicated to my goals as a guitarist. Thanks again.