Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

How useful are on-screen tabs?

  • On-screen tabs are essential! 209
  • I use them every now and then... 41
  • I only use them when I don't have a printed version at hand. 60
  • I never look at tabs, I just go by the explanation and what you show in the video! 25
  • 2021-11-08
  • 335 votes
{'title': 'How useful are on-screen tabs?', 'choices': [{'text': 'On-screen tabs are essential!', 'votes': 209}, {'text': 'I use them every now and then...', 'votes': 41}, {'text': "I only use them when I don't have a printed version at hand.", 'votes': 60}, {'text': 'I never look at tabs, I just go by the explanation and what you show in the video!', 'votes': 25}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 11, 8, 10, 23, 28, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 335}

Content

Hi everyone!

About 6 months ago I ran into the copyright wall on Youtube. Since then things have been going increasingly well here on Patreon, for which I'm extremely grateful! I'm going to post a news video again soon, it's been quite a while since I got around to doing one...

I've recently started preparations for work on my own website, because I think Patreon's lack of organisational tools makes it already hard to navigate. Add one or two years of content on top of that and things will become really complex. But with my own website the  licensing of tabs/videos comes back up.

So the first question I want to ask you is: how useful do you think on-screen tabs are? Do you use them often? Or would you stick to a separate pdf or printed version if that was available?

The licensing fee will ultimately be the deciding factor, but if it turns out that most of you don't consider them essential... Well, that would make a lot of things a whole lot easier!

Comments

Valerii Shaulov

When I'm learning smth along, I'm always using on-screen tabs. Seperate pdf file come in handy when I forgot some parts :)

Thomas Glinz

Dear Tim, do you mean the tabs that show up during the tutorials or tabs on screen instead of paper in general?

David Hancock

Totally essential for me! I couldn’t follow along without them to be honest.

DAMIEN NEMETH

Screen tabs help me a lot during tutorial..i am Lost when they are not here ..... But when tout learn with a teacher IRL there is no tabs on is T shirt...then...

ColeJacob

Unfortunately I consider them very useful. Hope they can remain.

Griff Crutti

Not essential, but very convenient and helpful.

Daniel Howald

Very comfortable for orientation during your explanations. Later on I work with the PDF only until I know it at heart. But for a first approach in sync with your teaching it is very efficient.

Andy McCraw

I find them useful, but I could certainly print as a reference tool also.

Siegbert Sonnenberg

I find them more or less useless because I rather concentrate on what you're showing and explaining.

Raymond Barfield

Occasionally they are useful, but if I have a PDF next to the computer, that is just as good. They are not useful enough to make it complicated to create your own website. The ease of navigation on a personal website would be worth the trade. Thanks for creating such helpful lessons. They are second to none..

Gregory Vazquez

Tim remember you should have had an answer that says I use them in the beginning and then use the printed version after I have gone through the entire tune. Since that answer is a little long, I believe that is synonymous with your "I use them every now and then" which means they are essential until you learn the piece at a very basic level

Blake A Allen

One of the big reasons I subscribed to your Patreon is for that reason

Gennadiy Armashula

I always use a printed pdf, as there are both the tab and notation, which I find useful to get a more accurate comprehension of the music.

Barry

Your explanations are so clear, I rarely need to use the tabs. So for me at least, the on-screen tabs are not necessary. I do like to print the tabs seperately every now and then for reference or if I am struggliong with a difficult part. But not having tabs in the video is fine with me.

Jeff Hedderly

I use the on screen tabs and the PDFs about equally.

Sanjay Patel

A complete PDF tab sheet is the minimum I’d like. On screen is a plus but not essential to me.

James Talbot

It’s very helpful as sometimes I can’t see which strings you are playing.

don sires

I find the streaming tab part of your service extremely valuable. I do agree that Patreon is a cumbersome website I hope somehow you can incorporate your own website and the streaming tab version as well. Love your work and I feel lucky for having come across your tutorials

Michael Paling

Personally, I would rather have a printed version of the tabs that clearly states each section (verse, bridge, chorus). That way I don’t have to scroll through the video to find the exact spot I need for the tabs. However, you do explain things so well that tabs are not essential and I wouldn’t mind if they were gone completely.

Barry R. Reynolds

It is helpful to gave on screen, and printed are helpful to refer back once you sorta have the song down.

Joe Butler

I use them all the time. Especially when first learning a song. I also use the printed version, but the on video tabs are very handy when using your videos to learn a song. But whatever you need to do is fine as long as we have the printed version. Just FYI, I did quit using YouTube for your teaching videos because they didn't have the tabs. I use Patreon now because the tabs are on them.

Richard Yates

TIm: I always use your tabs because they are right there with the current bars you are teaching. I have learned songs by listening and following on a separate tab and to me it is quite difficult trying to pair up the music with the specific tab to match. Your current mode showing both the music and the tab makes the learning so much easier as I can go back to a certain phrase, listen and make sure my fingering is correct on the tab. Please continue to keep the tab with your lessons!!!

Tom Lester

Hey Tim- I mostly rely on the printed pdf music as it shows both tab and notation which helps with understanding the more subtle aspects of the music. That said, I find the tab displayed on your videos to be of helpful, particularly early on when learning a song or when a song has 4-5 sheets of music; easier to follow the tab on the screen than to follow along with the multiple sheets of music spread out in front of the computer.

dunoyer pascal

Same here, Tim. Having the tabs on screen with the video allows to pause and work on the specific passage until it gets into your fingers! Once it gets fluid, I continue the video. If I had to go back and forth from a pdf to the video, it wouldn't be as easy. I would if I had to, but it is great as it is now, sorry ; - )

Karl-Wilhelm Schreitz

Essential to me is the audio and video point A to B repetition/repeat funktion, not were the tabs are. I print those out for me anyway.

Ian

I find having tabs on-screen is convenient for learning the fingering, but pdf hardcopy tabs/notation are absolutely essential. If you clearly stated in the video which measure you were teaching, the on-screen tab would be redundant. For those who find it awkward to refer back and forth from video to paper copy, they could open the tabs in a separate window and "hey presto!", tabs on-screen!

Ron Gerhardt

I agree the Patreon sight and lack of tools is not the best. I have encountered numerous problems in locating certain videos that the sight says is not available. Videos such as Rubys Eyes and Song for a Rainy Morning are examples. I also am not able to open or use certain videos once I’m able to locate them. I have found a work around solution by logging in through my email account instead of logging in through google seems to work and I can always find the song and tab I want using my email account. I don’t understand why it’s different between the two but it is. I like having the tab posted with and while learning the songs. It is extremely helpful in working on specific parts and in memorizing songs or merely difficult sections. I also use the pdf file by downloading and running them through a viewing app program called Forescore. Tim, your videos are the best out there and I’ll walk barefoot through broken glass and fire to be able to access all parts of them. I’ve learned so much so I thank you from the bottom of my fingers and callouses.

Karl-Wilhelm Schreitz

Again, I would not mind if you had no tabs on screen, maybe just downloadable or printabel. I think if removing tabs from your videos helps you to get a good navigatable page of your own, - not on this confusing patrion base -, I will happily not have tabs with the video, just printable. Sorry for my english. I generally have no problem reading and rechecking tabs for a couple of measures, It takes a lot more time to get it in my fingers. Reading (where ever it is) is not a problem, playing takes more time!

Zach

I wouldn't rebel against you if the tabs weren't on the screen, but for a person like me that is nomadic I don't own a printer or have an area I can leave printed material laying out for when I have time to study. It really does make the videos more usable for me to just have them on the screen since I am limited in this capacity. But, I know that with a little effort I could make it work. Thanks Tim.

Norbert

If you add the teaching videos to your own web site you could consider having the video without tabs but the pdf underneath/next to it so a viewer can see the part you discuss in the video at the same time. This is also how TrueFire does (or at least used to do it) it in explanation videos. For me this would be absolutely sufficient

Michael Dow

I can download the tab -- I do find the online/displayed tab useful, but not so much that I wouldn't appreciate better layout and organization as a tradeoff

David Gregory

Like others, on-screen tabs are a useful reference point for knowing where the lesson is. I also print out. Eventually when the song is in my head and hands I separate from everything as I imagine others do. But right out of the gate, I find on-screen tabs essential.

Christopher Nelson

If they're your main concern when it comes to the legal aspects then I'd say let them go. Beyond the first watch of a tutorial I'm more likely to go from the downloaded score (I use forScore on an iPad to read sheet music). I can just as easily have my iPad propped up on my desk while I'm working through a tutorial. I actually prefer that because I can see things in context rather than just a couple bars. Plus, in forScore you can do cool things like highlighting the bars you want to focus on and put page turning on a foot pedal, etc. I do like how you put the section and range of bars in the upper right corner of the video. That really helps me to keep my place in the score while watching the videos.

John tenR

I would love to support your website. Patreon is a mild pain for me as well

Alan DuBoff

Having the full printout is ideal, but I often don't have it at hand. I can print it out if needed, but I find the on screen helpful when I'm learning a song. It's not that I need the onscreen, it just makes it easier to play along with you while I'm learning.

Louis Schütz

Tabs on screen are essential. They are the reason i got into your channel mad started to support you on patreon. With printed tabs or pdf tabs everything gets messy