Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

Hi everyone!

A little extra today! Giorgio, one of the long term Patrons here, recently asked me to do a comparison video between my two main guitars: the Mayson MS7 and my Martin J-40. So here it is! I'm playing through Amy, the most recent song I've covered, and I've edited the video in such a way that I switch between guitars roughly every 4 bars.

Let me know what you think, maybe I should have switched every 8 bars instead of 4, giving you more time to take in the sound.

Files

AB Comparison Amy

This is "AB Comparison Amy" by Tim Van Roy on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.

Comments

Tom Fran

Martin sounds mellower and deeper. Mayson is sharper tone.

Tom Fran

Anyway, the real moral of the story is "its the carpenter not the tool"! You are awesome in both.

gary nugent

Correct Tom. Both are lovely. Martin is a bit warmer, Mayson sounds more like Tommy, with that focused melody he loves from Maple tone woods.

Giorgio DELLA VALLE

This is the perfect comparison! I agree with Tom Fan....in your hand both sounds great. My favourite is Mayson for the brighter sound....maybe ideal for not nailed palyers.....with nails or flat picking probably Martin sound more equilibrate. Ideal to have both.

Matthieu LE ROUZIC

First of all it's beautiful ! Secondly I have to admit that I prefer the mayson guitar sound !

Sabine C. Seidler

Beautifully played, but I think I like the Martin a bit more...

Karl-Wilhelm Schreitz

Really loved both guitars. They sound very close. Liked the Martin a bit more. But after 50 years of playing guitars I have to agree with Giorgio about the fact, that the Maton sounds better for players with no heavy nails and I have to agree with Tom Fran that the player makes the sound. Played other peoples Gear because I loved the sound and never sounded like them, - and the other way around.

Karl-Wilhelm Schreitz

In addition I have to say or confess, that I never got used to play with a thumbpick and just pick with the flesh of my thumb. So the Maton in this case would be better for me because the the bass is more clear on a guitar with a more pronounced (not so boomy) bass. But that is just me.

Keith White

Gotta agree with ALL the comments I've read. Both sound GREAT. The Martin only slightly more mellow.

Josh and Angie Hoffman

Beautiful! That's the first time I've heard the whole track. The real question is, which one is your logo based on? I'd say it looks more like the Mayson. These kind of tracks are what drew me into playing Tommy songs in the first place

Allan Patrick

I enjoyed listening to both. My preference is the Martin, I thought I heard warmer and richer overtones. Ditto on the carpenter comment.

Kevin Tallent

They both sound great to me. If I had a chance to buy one or the other, it would most likely boil down to cost. Can you tell us about what that is for each? Thank you.

Robin Pitigliano

Great playing as usual Tim. I find the Mayson to be more balanced in the overall sound, with the bass, mids, and highs all ringing equally, whereas the Martin with its more mellow and darker tone doesn't accentuate that balance as well. Totally agree with the 'carpenter' comment.

Carmine RADICE

Hi Tim, in my very personal opinion I think the mayson is more clear and resonant

giladrefael

in my opinion, the martin has a much better tone

Max Jackson

both beautiful guitarsa. would like to know more about your recording set up, microphones etc

Raphael Vilardi

Hi Tim,I'm sorry I'm late to this conversation. Would you please let me know how would you compare these instruments with the Maton TE?