Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

There are four lights. Nothing less. Nothing more. Put Captain Picard back on the damn Starship Enterprise!!!

Thank you all for being here with us on these watch throughs and thank you for always being a supportive and wonderful community!

https://vimeo.com/754313267/48b3f54494

PAULA DEMING

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/PaulaDeming

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/paolobandita/

Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@paulademing?

Twitter: https://twitter.com/PaulaDeming

IMDb: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm2984865/

KATRINA ALYSHA

TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@kat.attack8?

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/KatrinaAlysha

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/katrina_alysha

Twitter: https://twitter.com/katrinaalysha

IMDb: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm8371578/

Gallifrey Gals Theme Song by:  NoAnie Music 

https://www.fiverr.com/noaniemusic

Copyright owned by Gallifrey Gals

All the videos, songs, images, and graphics used in the video belong to their respective owners and I or this channel does not claim any right over them.

Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

Files

GG_TNG_S6_11.mp4

This is "GG_TNG_S6_11.mp4" by Gallifrey Gals on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.

Comments

Bob Hughes

Obviously They needed Beverly because of her tap-dancing abilities.

Joe Concepts

If you ever watch DS9, you'll learn that calling Cardassians "mean" is an understatement.

DC

I know it's no surprise at this point but I've always been impressed with the non-verbal acting from the supporting cast in this episode. Geordi in the Ready Room early on with Jellico, Worf in Sickbay, Beverly in the staff meeting, Troi in the final scene on the bridge. They do so much with looks and glances. It's one of the joys of having stuck with a show for years as a viewer and having actors that really know their characters.

Kane Is Able

My stupid closed captioning showed Kardashians every damn time!!!

Mike

I'm surprised the Gals haven't slipped up and said that as well.

Mark Ten

Its not personal with the Borg. Cardassians are just bad people- I think its due to their neck biology - I bet they are in constant pain because they cant stretch properly. The point about the lights is not to just get Picard to lie and say there are 5, but to break him until he is no longer able to tell what is real, his body rebels against his mind. Thats the point that the Cardassians could begin to reprogram him. This is the kind of BS psychological warfare the North Koreans did to captured soldiers during the Korean War. When you no longer can tell what is real, then someone else can reprogram your reality. Manchurian Candidate stuff.

Mike

The only part about this I don't like is they pulled the whole "Riker is the best pilot in the Galaxy" thing out of nowhere.

Ben Chan

I can appreciate that they didn't feel a need to have Jellico be wrong, or make an outright mistake. Riker was correct in everything he said, but Jellico also won the day in the end. (with the crew's support of course, which is the only way to get things done)

Mark Chrisco

This episode started a conversation.back in the day that asked the question of "How much can a man take?" Meaning after the Borg incident and now this, how can Picard just step back into his position as Captain without a lengthy evaluation period?

John Welch

I have to say that I was more on Jellicos side in this two parter than Rikers. Riker was way out of line to his commanding officer with his backtalk and attitude. Jellicos only sin was not being Picard. Having a different command style. That's it. He wasn't a tyrant. Data said that everything Jellico asked from Geordie and the rest of the crew was doable it would just require more work. Riker stomping his feet and whining about everything Jellico asks him to do would not fly in the real military. It is not a democracy. Good that Picard allows a more back and forth process in some decision making, but that is the captains prerogative. Jellico has a different style and it is not the crews place to push back against their captain. Having an asshole as a boss doesn't make the things he tells you to do inherently wrong. I once told an old boss I didn't understand why he wanted me to do something he had told me to do. He asked me if I understood HOW to do it. I said yes. He then said "good, you do the how and leave the why to me. You don't get paid for why." He was a total dick. But here's the thing...he was right. The thing he told me to do 100% needed to be done. Now it would have been NICE if he had taken the time to explain why to me, but but in the end my job was to do what he told me to and his was to know why everything needed to be done that way. Riker is a whiny baby in this episode.

Joe Concepts

Maybe just maybe Riker could get away with disagreeing, but standing up and screaming in a commanding officer's face like that? Can't imagine any military would stand for that. Though I think a lot of it is his personal feelings for Picard.

Joe Concepts

Yes, I'd think in "reality" Picard would not have just taken command again so quickly. That's one of the problems with "episodic" style of TV shows. Need to hit that reset button at the end.

Joe Concepts

Can't deny that Jellico's mine trick was pretty bold and clever. He just acts more like a military commander than Picard. The guy knows what he's doing, but may not be as good a 'leader' as Picard.

Arek Schneyer

Yeah, this is a phenomenal episode, and I adore it, even with the awful subject matter. The "You called me Picard" scene is SO wonder. I feel so much vindication.

Arek Schneyer

That does make sense. I personally am not on either of their sides (Though of course, I like Riker more than Jellico). I do feel it worth mentioning, however, that despite the similarities, Star Fleet is NOT a real military. It has different functions and a different purpose.

pickupthepieces

There is a reference in there to a future episode.

John

People also like to forget how much of a dick Picard was to Riker the first time they met in Encounter at Farpoint with the manual docking. The friendship came later.

Mark Ten

Yeah, but they make pretty decent tailors.

pickupthepieces

I don't know what line of work you are in, but (assuming you are from the USA) the general workplace over there is much more hierachical than here in The Netherlands. Keeping you mouth shut and blindly doing what your boss says is not the best way to run a company. Having people provide input, being open to discussion and respecting the opinions of the people in your team is much more productive for a variety of reasons.

Shelly

Cardassians have a more than a little in common with Russians at the moment

John Welch

Starfleet 100% is the federations military. Gene Rodenberry modeled them on actual naval structure. Yes the ethos of the federation would make them prefer to be primarily explorers and diplomats but there is a reason starfleet has a naval command structure and that their ships are so heavily armed they can go toe to toe with the dedicated warships of military powers like the Klingons and Romulans. I read an article once comparing Roddenberry's vision of starfleet with modern Americas view of our own military. Americans love to think of themselves as a peaceful people, who only maintain the worlds most powerful military purely for defense and not to further our own political interests. But the reality is that in it's 240 years history america has engaged in over 100 armed conflicts. That averages out to about one every 2.4 years. In star Trek we hear about the dozens of conflicts the federation has engaged in. The Klingons, The Romulans, The Ferengi, The Tholians, The Gorn, The Xindi, The Borg, The Talarians, The Cardassians, The Dominion, The Tzenkethi, The Breen... the list goes on and on and everytime the federation are written as unwilling participants who just thankfully happen to have hundreds of heavily armed ships on standby. I call BS just like I call BS about America always being cast as the "Good Guy" reluctantly fighting evil. Isn't it interesting the vast majority of the federation conflicts happen much farther away from earth and much closer to other peoples borders. Just like how many people in the US always claiming we just defend American Freedom yet most of our wars are as far away from America as you can get. Spooky coincidence. If you arm yourself to the teeth then go "exploring" around where other people live and notice you keep having to kill all these "hostile aliens" maybe you should ask yourself some questions, lol.

Wilshire1701

Not necessarily. Remember in “Encounter at Farpoint” he was able to manually reconnect the saucer by verbal commands, a task I’d imagine is not particularly easy (or at least not intuitive) since it’s normally automated. I’d wager only a particularly accomplished pilot would be able to do that.

Matt O'Keefe

The Cardasians called Deep Space 9: Terok Nor. Unless I missed the comment somewhere above which is completely possible and most likely probable, I can't believe I am the first to the comment this here.

Terrell Kirkman

My fave 4 lights meme is the Wheel of Fortune. LOL

R. Chang

So I have a pretty different read on the scene where Jellico goes to ask Riker to fly the shuttle. I know this is the moment where we are happy because Jellico has to eat crow and humble himself, but when I think about it, I think it shows real character on his part. He cares more about the success of the mission than his own ego. He's willing to humble himself before Riker, someone he strongly dislikes, because he understands that it is critical for the safety of the Federation and also might give him leverage to save Picard. It would have been pretty easy to give the assignment to the second-best shuttle pilot on the ship just to avoid the embarrassment. They probably would have also been successful. But he didn't. He sucked it up and took his lumps from Riker because his first concern was the mission and even the slightest improvement in the success rate was worth it.. And listen, I don't like Jellico. I wouldn't want to watch a show where he was captain. But in that specific scene - I think he was being a really good captain and Riker was kind of being a dick.

Wilshire1701

I pretty much agree. Jellico demonstrated he did indeed know how to handle the Cardassians, which is why he was given the command. Despite the actions he took to prep the crew for a battle, he managed to resolve the situation without one. This is why there was one line back in P1 that I didn’t like because it unfairly cast doubt on his competency. After Jellico’s first round of mind games with Lemec, Riker actually gives him a compliment, telling Troi “I’ll say this for him, he’s sure of himself,” to which Troi replies, “No, he’s not.” This is never really expanded further in either episode. Jellico never actually wavers or even mentions his true feelings (which could have made him a more sympathetic character), so Troi’s line only serves to further drives home the crew’s (especially Riker’s) and the audience’s lack of trust in him.

John

Yeah. Geordi already told Jellico he could do it, but Riker was the best choice for the job, so Jellico swallowed his pride and ASKED Riker to do it. Pretty much everything Jellico did was right for the mission. He's not likable, but he successfully completed the mission and secured Picard's release. We see how upset Riker got when Jellico was willing to sacrifice Picard for the mission. You know, put the needs of the many above the needs of the few. I'm sure I've seen that in Star Trek before.

fcast17

The gravity of this episode makes me forget that this wasn't a season premiere.

Firefly24601

I love that scene when they tell each other exactly what they think of each other. And they're both right.

Firefly24601

I too liked that the objectives Jellico was trying to accomplish were the right things. His mistakes lay in how he went about doing them. He's not just a "mean person" archetype, he's more like a real person with things that he does well and things that he doesn't.

Jonathan Bruser

Hey there! Thank you so much for sharing your reactions! I have to agree that Patrick Stewart and David Warner's performances really, REALLY sold this episode. And it's clear that they cut the budget like you said in part one, but the simple dialogue between Picard and Madred was so compelling without any special effects that the extra dollars weren't needed. I do hope you eventually watch Deep Space Nine, perhaps after you're done with TNG. Regardless of whether you do or not, I'm happy to watch your TNG reactions. One last thing about a comment you made at the start of the video regarding the woman who wanted to put a content warning... You said it was Jeri Ryan, but she's an actress with nothing to do with TNG. Jeri Taylor, on the other hand, was a writer and I believe a producer as well with TNG and other Trek series. Just want to make sure you don't get pounced on by anyone for miscrediting anything.

Artemis Zeidman

Before I get into the heavy stuff, I must say that Paula looks fierce with her new haircut. The theme of dehumanization is an important one to explore, not just as a reminder not to repeat the atrocities of the past, but also to wake us up to the atrocities that never stopped and that we tolerate every day. Tolerance of and complicity in dehumanization is everywhere you look. We live in a country (for those of us in the U.S., anyway) where conversion therapy is the most popular “treatment” for autistic people. We live in a country where someone can be murdered in the street for being BIPOC. We live in a country where transgender people can’t even use the bathroom without defending their very existence. We live in a country where people step over the unhoused like garbage. In a world this cruel, where complete disregard for the humanity of others is the rule rather than the exception, can we hope to ever achieve anything close to what Star Trek tells us we can and must? I don’t think we can.

Sal Sanchez

David Warner is an old hand at Star Trek, as u said. He was 'St. John Talbot' on Star Trek V and 'Gorkon' in Star Trek VI. He played Gul Madred in this episode and was gonna play in DS9 but his wife talked him out of it cause they were on vacation. Whenever u put a POWERFUL actor to match Patrick Stewart, its gonna be explosive. Great reaction as usual. Since losing the job I had, ive had to cut expenses. Galliifrey Gals isnt one of those. LOL!!!! I'm keeping this channel

Brett Whittaker

One of my favourite characters is a Cardassian

David Brown

Paula about Jellico: " What a dick." Exactly. Dick Jones (and Cohaagen rolled into one).

Artemis Zeidman

I think one way Trek fails is to play into stereotypes based on race (e.g., all Klingons are aggressive brutes, all Ferengi are amoral hypercapitalists, all Cardassians are fascist monsters, all Romulans are deceitful and cunning, etc.). While we do get some episodes where those stereotypes are challenged, Trek largely plays into them. It may seem benign when we call a fictional race of aliens “mean,” but how would it sound if we referred to an entire non-fictional racial/ethnic group of human beings in the same way? It’s something to think about.

Saucy

Now that Kat has seen this. I REALLY want to see her reaction to the DS9 episode Duet.

Peter

I think it was in the first part when Picard briefed Crusher and Worf on the mission that he explained what their roles were. I may be mistaken. Picard was there because of his familiarity with the technology for the delivery system of the weapon, Crusher was there in her medical capacity to make sure they could effectively locate and destroy the metagenic material and Worf was the muscle.

Artemis Zeidman

It does seem unlikely. Even if Riker were a crack pilot before coming on the Enterprise, how often would he have the opportunity to practice that skill? I doubt it’s like riding a bike. Of course, the writers probably just needed an excuse for the scene where Jellico had to humble himself and ask Riker for help. Considering how the scene turned out, I can live with the inconsistency.

Jay Fleming

Jellico is a jerk, but its good to remember that in an actual military or just a job, sometimes you have to work with arrogant people who think they don't need advice or dismiss others if they feel they have more expierence. These folks are tough to work with, and of course can get on your nerves, but everyone is deserving of a chance, and while he wasnt nice about it, He did get the job done and humbled himself when He had to. We cant always choose who we work with but with patience even when it isn't returned you can still complete the mission. But yeah, there were a few times i wanted belt him for being so impatient and arrogant.

Jay Fleming

Ps. My favorite scene is when Madred brings in his daughter. I mean ive heard of bring your child to work day but come on. Such a sick thing to do to the mind of a child.

Ben Chan

Well, it all depends ... I remember being taken to the zoo a bunch of times as a kid and while those kind of zoos are considered inhumane now, at the time there was nothing wrong with it.

Brad Barter

The only lasting and good thing Jellico did was have Deanna switch to the standard uniform. Her awful (colorless outfits as L'Waxanna called them) came in on season 2 after her drab grey (actually made of denim) first season outfit. With the exception of her flowing blue/green dress or off duty she was pretty much only in those same outfits. Her change to the uniform will become a focal point and necessary in a future episode but I will leave it there so not to spoil anything but certainly Marina Sirtis must've hated wearing those same outfits for years on end.

Matthew Scrivens

This episode definitely had more of a DS9 feel to it, likely to prepare viewers for what to expect. While there is no TNG farewell for O’Brien, he does get his send off in the DS9 pilot. I don’t know if it’s too spoilery to say, it if you go on to watch DS9 then there are a whole subset of episodes that have simply been branded “O’Brien must suffer”, so make of that what you will.

Mostly Harmless

Are you going to start watching DS9 too? Or finish all of TNG first? (If so just like 3 and a half years to go till you react to In the Pale Moonlight :D )

Firefly24601

They've stated in previous TNG reactions that they will not be reacting to DS9.

Christopher Hayes

They sometimes act as the military but they are quasimilitary at best. Being the military is clearly not the primary mission if you listen to the opening credits lol.

John Welch

Yeah and like I already explained...I call BS. Rodenberry's vision of starfleet was schizophrenic. Let's start with a naval command structure, give them a large fleet of heavily armed vessels, have them fight dozens of species but make clear in all our scripts they are "explorers". I am pretty sure any white man born in 1921 would have also considered Columbus, Coronado and Pizzaro as "primarily explorers." To be clear I am not saying the federation is evil. But they could be viewed as implacable. They spread everywhere. "Peaceful" but insistent. Then when they inevitably provoke a reaction from cultures with different morals and beliefs, then it's "isn't it lucky we have all these ships with phasers and torpedoes for our war of "defense?". There is an old saying...if you wake up in the morning and have an argument with one guy, maybe you just bumped into an asshole. But if you spend your whole day fighting with half the people you meet...maybe YOU'RE the asshole. Maybe the federation should just stay in it's lane and there wouldn't be so many "unfortunate incidents" with hundreds of civilians stuffed into heavily armed "exploration vessels". Yes, I know we are talking about a fictional group. But it is an ethos that is VERY much real world based.

John Welch

Have they definitively said that? I missed that? Shit.

Nolan

Man, what a torturous episode... 😏

Mark Chrisco

'I've always wondered how subversive it would have been adjusting the opening credits of this erpisode to feature :"Starring Ronny Cox as Capt. Edward Jellico."

Andrew Hogan

You make a lot of valid points and while I don’t disagree with much of what you say, the fact remains it is a TV show that isn’t complete in all it’s history. It’s being made up along the way and by different people, not to mention all the inconsistencies we run into throughout the franchise. I’d like to keep this brief, so let’s just say I’m playing devils advocate and while we certainly aren’t without our transgressions and missteps, would the alternative have been better?

Andrew Hogan

I’ll take a different view on this, and for the record I didn’t like Jellicho either at first, but the older I’ve gotten, I respect honesty so much more than being told what I might want to hear, as long as I have respect for that person and I know their track record. It could be Jellicho needs to be right and has to win at their little game (Federation v Cardassia), so in order to do that he chooses Will, even if it means looking humbled, for him it’s about winning the game.

Andrew Hogan

They did look more comfortable compared to the uniforms though, and let’s just say I didn’t mind the view either.

Andrew Hogan

I realize Paula is out in this, but would Katrina be against watching it, or has everyone decided it would be too much for her?

Andrew Hogan

Very much. I thought I heard or read somewhere there was a possibility of Patrick Stewart not returning due to contract issues and this was one of the reasons for the switch.