Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Pick a song, any song!

  • Bennie And The Jets, by Elton John 22
  • Immigrant Song, by Led Zeppelin 56
  • Back In Black, by AC/DC 18
  • Money, by Pink Floyd 60
  • 2019-01-06
  • —2019-01-14
  • 156 votes
{'title': 'Pick a song, any song!', 'choices': [{'text': 'Bennie And The Jets, by Elton John', 'votes': 22}, {'text': 'Immigrant Song, by Led Zeppelin', 'votes': 56}, {'text': 'Back In Black, by AC/DC', 'votes': 18}, {'text': 'Money, by Pink Floyd', 'votes': 60}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2019, 1, 14, 18, 0, 53, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2019, 1, 6, 1, 6, 51, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 156}

Content

Ok, well, let's do a poll! Vote for your favorite song/songs from below.

Some logistics stuff: I may change this in the future, but my current plan for these polls is to have four options, analyze the one that gets the most votes (obviously), discard the one that gets the least, and then keep the other two for next month's poll. That way I'm not burning through too many good options too quickly, and if a song happens to wind up in a month with an incredibly popular choice, it can earn a second chance. I figure songs that keep not getting selected will naturally fall off the bottom eventually, but if I see the same things persisting in the middle forever I'll re-evaluate.

Comments

Charles Gaskell

If you've not already done an analysis of it, could you consider adding Dizzy by Tommy Roe to the list one month?

Brett Haines

I mean, you didn't have to make it so hard to choose... those are 4 great songs!

Brandon Hamele

You chose songs with three of my favorite guitar parts ever recorded. How shall I choose? : P

blalo'u

Boy howdy is that a hard choice! As a bassist though I'm obligated to vote Money.

Jeff Patterson

I'd like to second "Bat out of Hell." Amazing track.

John July

How about something from Mahavishnu Orchestra, like Birds of Fire

Keith Moore

I agree, Mahavishnu Orch Birds of Fire would be a great analysis. Another suggestion in almost the opposite realm: B-52's Rock Lobster. I think it would be really interesting to analyze the way this is a masterful rhythmic and quirky harmony on top of a very simple riff. An ear worm hook that makes we want to whoot for my own private Idaho.

Jetzt

I had to go with Zeppelin. Such a great song, and it's about Vikings.

Sylvain Chevalier

I think you shouldn't automatically remove the last voted song. It seems those are already quite well filtered for quality. Maybe just put them back on the waiting list?

Dr Ms Kat

Oh god I want them all!

Kristoffer Lundén

Sad to see Back in Black being least voted, there's a lot of subtlety going on there

Siobhan Kiernan

I can't tell you how long the bass line for money has been on repeat in my head

Smackdab (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-07 03:00 Your democratic inclinations here should be applauded, for sure, But I for one feel like maybe this is a little too much democracy. I feel like we should trust your judgment in finding songs that have interesting theory underpinnings that us mortals wouldn't see without your help. Hey, there's an example just above this comment! There's something interesting about the music theory in Back in Black? Really? Hmmm . . . now I want to know more . . . .
2019-02-07 22:06

12tone

That's a fair point, but it's worth noting that I'm still curating the songs that go on the poll in the first place. Everything on there is a song I've already confirmed could make a good video, most of what's happening here is just letting people decide which ones get made first.