Orb Weaver: Investigations, 9 (Patreon)
Content
The biggest problem facing me, as I prepared to speak, was that she was right. Not simply generally right, but specifically right. I had arranged things so that Purity, Hookwolf, Cricket and Stormtiger would be made use of…
But the families of those they had harmed would never receive justice in a courtroom, not unless things went very wrong.
Was it beneficial?
Yes. I expected that ultimately, they would do more good than harm, if for no other reason than I expected Alexandria to get full use out of her investment.
Was it just?
I—
Once, I would have said no. But if Purity saved a child from Leviathan, or just an ordinary criminal, what would they say? If I had arranged for her to die or be sent to the Birdcage, would they agree that it was proper, even if they knew that she could have saved their child?
“Before we start with my request…” I tilted my head. “That is a very impressive accusation.”
“Really?” she replied. “The moment one of their golden children trigger, you’d be amazed at how soon court cases go away.”
“I would…” I paused, looked at her, and glanced around her office. Awards, professional certificates, a few stories. “No.”
“Pardon?”
“I was thinking that as a defense attorney you would be happy, but that’s not the issue, is it?” I shrugged. “I doubt you gained many friends by getting four E88 gangers a not-guilty verdict.” I hadn’t done nearly enough research on it, it seemed, but finding out an outline of her career had been easy enough, as it had for everyone else in the office. The rest…
Well, looking at her, reading some of her expressions, it was elementary.
“Do you know what the adversarial system of justice is?”
“Prosecution and Defense function as opposing ah, teams,” I said. “The judge primarily serves as a neutral arbitrator, as they attempt to convince the jury of their rightness. That is, when the system works as intended.”
“And that means I do my best. And if the DA’s office sends an idiot that didn’t even bother to check the chain of custody…”
“They lose.” I nodded. “And of course, there were many people arguing that you should have helped him. They were gangers, and…” Calling them guilty will not sway her. “They had quite possibly performed the act.”
“So I should have cut down every tree?” she asked.
I brightened. I knew this. “So, now you give the Devil the benefit of law!”
She paused. “You know the play.”
I nodded. “My Mother liked it. But let’s get to the meat of the matter. The PRT has put pressure on you?”
“Parahumans need to be treated differently.” She looked at me. “Do you know Shadow Stalker? I can’t provide her civilian name.”
“Nor can I, but I know it.”
“She was ready for a plea deal. Full supervision, six months in juvenile hall, supervised release, and then the PRT came sweeping in with the kind of deal you give someone who has an overdue ticket. And we know what she did with that.”
Well, she is a lawyer. And if you were a defense lawyer in the Bay, I expected you used every tool you had—including bringing up the fact that had the Bay’s justice system been allowed free reign… I might never have been in a locker.
Never Triggered.
Never ended the E88, or helped out with Leviathan, or just brought closure to a family.
Even a few months ago, the barb would have landed. But now…
“Do you know what Sophia and her friends did to me?” I asked.
“Yes.”
“No.” I tilted my head. “Jammed in the locker, I couldn’t breathe. Insects, maggots, other things, less nameable crawled on me, while laughter echoed in my ears.” Under the building, bugs started to twist. I fought them back under control.
“I—“ She fell silent.
Nobody expected capes to talk about our trigger events. It was taboo.
But I was stronger than that event. Stronger than the locker. It may have helped make me who I was, but now… It was my tool, not the other way around.
“A monstrous crime, even if not the worst the Bay has seen, capping two years of torment… But…” I shrugged. “Twenty four people. That is the number of people that Shadow Stalker, making use of her ability, recovered while she was on search and rescue for Behemoth. Ranging in age from six months to sixty-five years. If the PRT had not had their way, those people would be dead. They offered her a chance, and while I agree, they badly dropped the ball in supervision, the offer was an honest one, and had she taken it, she could have saved many more people—and even throwing it in their face, well, as I said, twenty-four people.” I smiled. “And of course Atlas, who is no longer in juvenile hall…and saved several hundred people from death by drowning.”
She didn’t expect this. That was plain. I might be in uniform, but she knew I was a teen, not yet even legally able to drive. Very likely she assumed Orb Weaver had been taking the lead on the destruction of the E88.
Well, I was…
And her strategy was to fluster witnesses, that was plain. And she was pissed, assuming that I was here to demand some kind of favor.
Just how dysfunctional was the relationship between the PRT and local law enforcement?
“You are upset because you see parahumans getting special treatment. We do. Because parahuman skills are irreplaceable and unique. Doctors, police, lawyers… can all be trained. But Shadow Stalker? Her specific power may never, ever appear again. Which doesn’t excuse the PRT’s failings—because now, in addition to her crimes, they have also lost her as a possible hero.” Not that it will keep them from using her in the future…
“So a get out of jail card?”
“A one use, show us why you don’t belong in jail card,” I said. “And it comes with hefty downsides—after all, Shadow Stalker was on the same field as Behemoth.” I paused. “Forgive me, but I observed this structure—and the DA’s office. People do not enter your particular career path unless they have a strong belief in the law.” I tilted my head. “Because even when you do everything right, you must facet the fact that possibly… a guilty man has walked free.”
“That is for the court to decide.” But she was clearly on the backfoot.
“Which is why I am here. I have no interest in getting a “favor”. Because if I really needed one, I have much better placed sources. Not that I was going to bring that up. Now she was more flustered.
You expected someone coming in and making demands.
“What do you want?”
“Ah. You know Bitch? Or Hellhound as the PRT has named her, but ‘Bitch’ is her own name and she becomes angry when it’s not used.”
“She currently has an outstanding warrant for Murder in the Second Degree, attempted murder, multiple cases of assault with a deadly weapon, assault with a parahuman power and…” She shrugged. “I could go on. But they are all documented.”
“My services have been secured to attempt to…convince her to surrender herself and obtain proper representation.”
“And we’re back to needing special assistance?”
“No. I am not certain, even if I could do it, that she would take the proper lesson from a ‘get out of jail’ card. I’m investigating her case, but I wanted to ask you, as a Public Defender, how would you handle her case?”
“Try to convince her to go for a guilty plea, first.” Sims gestured at the bookshelves. “Judges aren’t supposed to hit you harder if you’re found guilty after pleading not guilty… but they do. Especially if the crime includes scary monsters. If I put her in a court in front of a jury, the DA would be… asking her if her powers had any similarities to Nilbog or Bonesaw’s powers. Even if the judge shut him down…”
“The comparison would stick in the jurors’ minds.”
“Yes. So the right judge might be less likely to be influenced by that, and since a guilty plea would also save the court time…”
“The judge might be more lenient.”
“Maybe. But… Okay, in return for a guilty plea, you might be able to get the DA to drop the second degree murder charge. Get it down to manslaughter. As part of that we’d have a psychological evaluation, which would determine her state of mind.”
“She was only 13 when the murder supposedly occurred.” I nodded. “I have my thoughts on that, mostly being that it was very fortunate I didn’t have an immediately lethal power express when I was in the locker.”
“Possibly, and the youth angle works as well. But the problem is the trigger defense…”
“Doesn’t work for things done later.”
Much of this I knew, but I didn’t work as a lawyer, and this was someone who did this for a living.
And unlike Carol I wouldn’t be annoying them—I doubt Carol wanted to be reminded of the time Bitches dogs had tried to use her as a chewtoy.
“Correct. And the fact that she doesn’t just go running down the street attacking people, rules out mental incapacity. ‘I’m super pissed at people who mistreat animals’ isn’t what a jury is going to accept.”
“But there are emotional defenses…
“No.” She shook her head. “Look, if you want to get someone off due to mental issues, you need to accept they’re not walking free. They’re going into a criminal mental hospital, which can be worse than prison and I don’t use that comparison lightly. And they don’t get out until they’re better. But that wouldn’t work here. So what you’d do would be to claim: her emotional state didn’t make her incompetent, but it did… influence how she acted. Like oh, fighting words.”
“Which are very restricted.”
“Yeah. Nobody is gonna accept that for a guy walking his dog and yanking it, because if she’s that hair trigger, you get back to being sent to the asylum.” You can use it for cases of actual animal cruelty—but it has to be an example that people not named Hel—er, Bitch, would see as animal cruelty.”
“Like Hookwolf’s rings.”
“If she’d kept her attention focused on them, I could get her found innocent without the jury leaving the box… presuming the E88 hadn’t gotten to them.”
“Not an issue right now,” I murmured. Sims frowned at that. “So if this case fell into your lap, and I was the concerned friend what would your first bit of advice be?”
“Call Quinn Calle.” She gestured at her desk. “I currently have 20 cases on my docket, ranging from felony assault to rape. I have two investigators that I share with three other PDs—and the DA? Their average case load is 5 cases a week, and each attorney has a full time investigator assigned to him. I expect from what you’ve said, that Bitch is gonna be in the category of difficult, and Calle is used to that.”
“Thank you.” I nodded. “I will continue to investigate, and keep that in mind. As to…” Well, Director Piggot deserves this. “The issues. I expect that there have been times capes have been treated differently for no good reason. But about the play?” I leaned back, “Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned 'round on you, where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country is planted thick with laws, from coast to coast, Man's laws, not God's! And if you cut them down, and you're just the man to do it, do you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety's sake!” I glanced back at her. “The problem is, we have devils already turning on us. If you had walked into the room of the man who nearly destroyed the Bay with a chemical explosion, you would have walked out convinced there was nothing to be done, and just accepted it. Believe me, if you think Emily Piggot or any other director of the PRT likes this you are wrong—but they are forced to use every tool they have.” I chuckled. “Perhaps another quote: If Hitler invaded hell I would make at least a favorable reference to the devil in the House of Commons. “
“That’s a very slippery slope, Investigator.”
“I know, but the best we can do is try not to slip.” And I know that from experience. “But I will take your advice, and try to ensure that in this case, Bitch receives justice.”
“That’s all we can hope for.”
And how often are our hopes dashed?
Later, outside, I sat down on a bench and considered, some people glancing at me.
Sims was wrong. Oh, I could understand her reasoning, but that kind of inflexibility… The PRT didn’t have that luxury.
And if they say that Sophia has been rehabilitated, and here she is in the Bay? How willing would you be to accept that when it’s you facing your tormentor?
I don’t have to be her friend. Just work with her, if it came to it. You couldn’t tell someone that the desperate state of the world demanded sometimes justice take a back seat—except when you wanted to see justice done.
And with that, I got back to the matter at hand. Both my research and a PD agree, trying to get Bitch found innocent is likely impossible. So I need to find out as much as I can about her, her history, and use that to craft a sympathetic narrative. Then I need to have an attorney, Calle, if possible, to use that narrative in a way I could never do so. Then I need to convince Director Piggot to play ball.
And I’m doing this for a girl who tends to respond violently to anything that trips her lines for animal abuse, and who in several conversations loves to be confrontational, when the best strategy would be trying to look contrite.
Joy.
Well, the first thing to do would be to contact Lisa and tell her to not spend all of her money, since she might need to hire Calle. Second, start tracking down the PRT’s records regarding Bitch, and lastly…
Create a biography.
Then directly interview her.
And after all that, decide how—or for that matter, should Bitch be treated.
“A very slippery slope” I murmured as I got up. “So I’d better be very careful and not slip.”