Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello lovely Patrons! As a great man once said, "Here's an Idea!" - Philosophy Tube merch.I've been thinking for a while about the possibility of getting some, designed by a proper artist as well (who I'd pay) - I love what @skutchdraws has done for ContraPoints, designing some awesome T-shirts for her channel.

First of all, I wouldn't have T-shirts made unless the supplier could guarantee me no sweatshop labour went into making the shirts themselves. Not gonna budge on that.

Second, it'd have to be worthwhile, obviously, so if nobody's interested then I won't. So far my cursory research on Twitter tells me that a few people might, if the designs were nice.

Third, I'm wondering whether selling merchandise is antithetical to the spirit of the show? I don't think it is: I mean it's consistent to give away free education and sell T-shirts, but that's why I thought I'd ask you - you were all motivated to support me making the show by something. As Patrons, I feel like you're to an extent the moral guardians of the project. (Is that weird?) Would it be counter to that something, whatever it was you saw in the show that motivated you to sign up, for me to sell merch?

So these are my two questions to you; your honest feedback would be really, really appreciated. I doubt there'll be unanimous consensus but I do want to hear your thoughts:

1) If there was merch, would you be interested?

2) Should there be merch?

Comments

Mikael Hall

T-shirts are always great, if they are discrete.

A looming creature of darkness

I'd buy merch if I liked the designs. I just ordered one of Contrapoint's shirts (the this cat kills fascists one). I mean, I don't think being anticapitalist means you can't support yourself. We all engage in capitalist exploits, here. There's no way to extricate yourself from the system. All you can do is try to minimise the harm you do as best you can. I feel like ideally it would be nice to sell shirts through some sort of cooperative enterprise. But well. Good luck finding one. But I can't judge ya. I bought clothes from Forever 21 the other day. Let he who has not shopped fast fashion cast the first angry comment!

TalysAlankil

I don't see why you couldn't sell merch. As for whether I'd buy any I guess that'd depend more on what merch there is. Also if the store that sells the merch has an EU-based location to ship from, because I've been burned a few times on merch coming from the US where upon delivery it's like "surprise! import taxes!"

Cecile

A very good idea I think, You're not merely a spirit you need food on your table and this fact has nothing to do with being a capitalist! if this helps you supporting yourself then It's the most sensible thing to do I suppose. Besides do you know what? I think Christmas is coming...

Kevin Wallace

I say I'd probably be interested (gray or black shirts are great), and yes, there should be merch.

Alex Goldhill

I know what I want for Chanukah!

Troy R

I like the idea, but how much investment is risked to make a line of merch? What's tough is balancing the inclusivity of the inside joke with the relatability to share it with others. Of course, it has to be pretty and useful, too... (actually not sure about "useful"). What makes philosophy fun for everyone? That might have a million answers, too. This wasn't very helpful.

Tyler Graham

I really like Jennifer Ward's idea of going through a co-operative to get merchandise. That fits well with the spirit of the show. I mean, if you're going to avoid sweatshops, you might as well go the whole nine yards, right?

Ree Fournier

I've never been a fan of merchandise, if you do do merchandise you should look into buttons, which have been on the rise especially for college students with backpacks

William Heathcote

Starting with 2, I don't think it would be an issue if you sold merch. Especially if you could assure people that it might raise additional funding for the show/your survival and thus the show's. As for 1, I know shirts can be somewhat burdensome, especially if you overestimate demand and are then saddled with a surplus. Personally, I own a lot of t-shirts, so it would need to be a very compelling design for me to pick one up. You might consider starting smaller, like with stickers or buttons. Just to get a feeling for merch management and such.

Tristian Wiles

Merch would be a good idea. Gotta keep you alive for the channel to operate after all. I would be interested if the designs were cool.

Tucson Richelson

I don't think there's anything antithetical to the show. At the very least, you could offer it as a reward to certain tier patreon supporters. 1) I personally wouldn't buy a shirt, because I already have too many shirts 2) I think you should give it a shot.

Ben Sima

1) Yes! 2) I support you because you are risking your own skin to advance the education of the masses. Given that you are taking the risk of putting yourself out there (and missing out on good money you could be making as a lawyer or whatever else you could otherwise be doing with your intellect) you deserve to reap *some* rewards for it, so selling some tshirts is totally fine and ethical. Plus I like your videos and want to spread the word!

Taran Plamondon

1. I would kill for a J.P. Sartre shirt. 2. I think you should do merch, as there's no obligation for fans to purchase it but as a content creator I imagine every little bit helps put food on the table. You should be able to sell merch in good conscience, especially if you avoid pitching it hundreds of times per video!

Peter Hansen

1.) Probably not, I try to keep life simple, and stay away from stuff I do not need. 2.) It is absolutely okay, just try not to mention it too much, have a linke on the end screen and you will be fine. If people would like a mantra, quote or words to live by on a T-shirt, Coffee mug or poster way not. As long as the use it, we do not need to fill this world with even more useless crap. Thanks for asking

V

1) I would be interested in well-designed merch with cute philosophy references. I wouldn't buy a shirt with "PhilosophyTube" written all over it. I'd love to support the channel, but I won't advertise for it. I have PBSIC's first shirt with the butterfly and lightbulb, for example. Beautiful and only subtly branded. 2) I don't see any moral conundrum with selling ethically sourced T-shirts. 2a) Concerns about sweatshops are often just quasi-nationalist excuses to avoid doing business with non-OECD countries, so I hope "No Sweatshops" isn't just code for "No South Asian Workers". 2b) Is it antithetical to the spirit of the show? You aren't directly involved in making T-shirts, but would be financing their manufacture and selling them for more than they cost to make. So it I strikes me as an irreducibly capitalist exercise. I think that's a great idea, but I also don't see capitalism as inherently destructive. I'd actually be really interested to hear your thoughts. Would you see yourself as entering the T-shirt market as a capitalist? Is that bad?

Ukali Mwendo

First of all, I 'stumbled' upon your show and became a patron because I like it — not because of t-shirts, mugs, posters, or a fancy logo. There are probably five thousand other people who feel the same way, but you have to find them. With doses of savvy MARKETING your chance of attracting them is greatly enhanced. Second, I'm not so much interested in merchandise... unless it's an in-depth ebook about the ideas shared on your channel. Too often merchandise amounts to branded trinkets that get thrown away, never really feeding one's mind. Investment in an improved show (web presence) might be the better long-term decision. Word-of-mouth is more valuable than t-shirts, mugs, posters, or a fancy logo. Third, selling merchandise is NOT antithetical to the spirit of the show, especially if the show is your primary occupation. But "selling stuff" needs to be kept in perspective and not become a higher priority than educating your growing audience. I've committed to one year of monthly support, believing you'll continue to provide high-quality, plain-spoken explanations of your ideas about various topics. If you betray the trust I have in you... bye-bye! In sum, sell merchandise if you want to but don't sacrifice or corrupt the meaning and purpose of Philosophy Tube in the process of making a few more pounds.

Jon

I probably wouldn't purchase a shirt, but I definitely think making one is okay and not at all inconsistent with your overall mission.

Jeremy McMillan

If there were merch, it would fail as a charity. It would succeed on fiercely crass and eminently clever but understated, provocative, but thoughtful (thought provoking?) humor. Go for that.

Emma

yes pls

Megan Ellison

I would not be interested, but I think it's perfectly fine

Jordan Bollag

Yes and Yes. But also have some merch that is not obviously a 'youtuber' shirt. like Nathan Zed has shirts that say "good enough" with a cool design.