Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello lovely patrons!

This one took a lot of effort: a lengthy research phase, lots and lots of writing as well as a tough shoot and an even tougher edit, but it's here! Something fun and creative to start the year off. I realised during the research phase that a regular episode on this topic would be extremely long and technical and dull, so the best way to get the philosophy across was in a bit of different format. Don’t worry: I don’t plan on making them all like this! I hope you enjoy it!

Olly XXx

Files

Data | Philosophy Tube

When all you have is a hammer all your problems look like nails - https://www.patreon.com/PhilosophyTube Subscribe! http://tinyurl.com/pr99a46 Paypal.me/PhilosophyTube Wanna get me a gift for the show? http://amzn.eu/5JAYdOd Check out my other videos on: The Trouble with the Video Game Industry https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IYkLVU5UGM8& Queer✨ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Hi6j2UXEZM& Climate Grief - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqCx9xU_-Fw Men. Abuse. Trauma. ★ - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AeGEv0YVLtw Abortion & Ben Shapiro - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c2PAajlHbnU Sex Work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DZfUzxZ2VU Jordan Peterson & The Meaning of Life https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEMB1Ky2n1E& Brexit: What is Democracy? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vr-ZeToI4R8 Steve Bannon: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wO6uD3c2qMo Why Does Britain Still Have A Queen? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x2W7P3wGBI8 YouTube: Art or Reality? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kVav1ri65Ws Is Philosophy Just White Guys J3rk!ng Off? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=weiz9wbIcGQ Transphobia: An Analysis - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCxqdhZkxCo Suicide and Mental Health - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQNw2FBdpyE Twitter: @PhilosophyTube Email: ollysphilosophychannel@gmail.com Facebook: http://tinyurl.com/jgjek5w realphilosophytube.tumblr.com BIBLIOGRAPHY Bennett Cyphers and Gennie Gebhart, “Behind the One-Way Mirror: A Deep Dive Into the Technology of Corporate Surveillance,” in Electronic Frontier Foundation Carissa Véliz, “Privacy is A Collective Concern,” in New Statesman David Ives, Sure Thing Evgeny Morozov, To Save Everything, Click Here https://tinyurl.com/vnf39fe Frankie Mirren, “Are UK Nightclubs Breaking Data Laws By Storing Your IDs and Fingerprints?” in Vice Jeremy Bentham, “Proposal for a New and Less Expensive mode of Employing and Reforming Convicts” Joshua Adams, “Getting Cash For Our Data Could Actually Make Things Worse, in One Zero Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish https://tinyurl.com/wbwwhoq Nick Couldry and Ulises A. Mejias, The Costs of Connection https://tinyurl.com/u8uz6sm Percy Bysshe Shelley, Queen Mab Peter-Paul Verbeek, Moralizing Technology https://tinyurl.com/tnnaym2 Philosophy Tube, “Foucault 2: Government Surveillance & Prisons” Robert Elliott Smith, Rage Inside the Machine https://tinyurl.com/t57ln3m Robert Howell, “The Peeping Tom Effect Makes Us Worry About the Wrong Threats to Our Privacy,” in OneZero Stuart A. Thompson & Charlie Warzel, “12 Million Phones” in The New York Times Stuart A. Thompson & Charlie Warzel, “How To Track President Trump” in The New York Times Stuart A. Thompson & Charlie Warzel, “How Your Phone Betrays Democracy,” in The New York Times Stuart A. Thompson & Charlie Warzel, “Total Surveillance is Not What America Signed Up For,” in The New York Times Stuart A. Thompson & Charlie Warzel, “What’s The Worst That Could Happen With My Phone Data? Journalists Answer Your Questions” in The New York Times Stuart A. Thompson & Charlie Warzel, “Where Even The Children Are Tracked,” in The New York Times Tim Herrera, “You’re Tracked Everywhere You Go Online. Use This To Fight Back,” in The New York Times MUSIC ‘Final Chapter’ and ‘Closure’ by Snake City ‘Affliction’ by Nina Richards http://www.ninarichards.co.uk/ #Data #Privacy #Computing

Comments

Anders

When are you going to stop calling your stuff "videos" and start calling them "films"? I find the word "video" to be less and less fitting with each new release.

Fox the enby

I'd LOVE to see more videos in this style- this is amazing!

Spock's BDE Goatee

I decided to become a patron this month as a penance for working in targeted digital advertising. Sorry, guys.

Frère Tempête

You've completely revolutionized the Socratic Dialogue in style and substance. This is the stuff I pledged for.

Words Greenwood

Excuse me for swearing folks, but this is fucking excellent work. Thanks Olly. Hats off to you x

Lucas Guarnieri

I love every aspect of it, the atention to the details is simply awesome, like the club guard filmed from below to give him some autorathy over the regular guy. Well done, Olly! Looking forward to see more videos like that.

PalomaMB

I finally had some time to check your new video out, and let me tell you it was great! It is an excellent material to use in an educational context, but also done in a very creative and entertaining way. I am planning some contents related to data and online security in our society for my classes, and I think this video could be a great addition to my materials (if you don't mind me using it).

Michał Sporzyński

I know that's not the main point of the video, but the (now ex-) cop character is surprisingly sympathetic. I think it's cool to acknowledge, even implicitly, that even people who actively work to uphold a harmful system have very little power over the system. Which is not to say the guy is a "good guy". He's effectively the villain of both videos he's been in, because you can't exactly make a country, or a company, or a government the villain in a video like this. Knowing he can't do much is not a get-out-of-jail-free card to do nothing. But he's understandable in his actions, and for some reason I think it's really cool.

James Feole

Ok, I need to rant. Data, its collection, and abuses is such a nightmare of a topic. The news aggregators and social media sites know who you are, your likes, and your views. A simple model would prioritize stories more relevant to your opinions, locking you into your existing perspective. A more cynical view is that the sites actively hide stories that would challenge your views. Instead of growing more knowledgeable from reading the news, you become more extreme and locked into your original bias. It becomes far worse if the powers controlling these algorithms have an agenda and want to actively form public opinion. Once this site is done with your info, they are free to sell it off to the highest bidder. Most news sites these days allow you to read a few articles over a certain period of time and then require you to log in (some skip the grace period). This makes it easier to track you across systems and locations, makes it easier to filter and funnel stories by relevancy, and makes their data more reliable so they can make more money from advertisers. I think the ridicule of people who only read the headlines is deserved, but it is also frustrating to navigate the barriers to every website and understand the consequences of reading their news. Informed consent is never actually asked for or it is buried so deep in legalese that normal people will never find it. If it does state anything about data and privacy, it usually says something along the lines of "any and all data is under the sole ownership of the platform", without detailing any ramifications of what that means. What data is collected? How long is it stored? If you start collecting new data, do you you inform your users? Do you sell the data? Do you have other sites/platforms/companies that make use of the data? Its not just websites that use tracking cookies and other means of detection. Random advertisement platforms will track you as well. These will not always be visible on a page and blocked with an ad blocker. A few years ago people put bitcoin mining software on ad platforms and people only knew something was wrong because their laptop fans suddenly started running for static web pages. There is far more processing that goes on than you see on the page. Your phone tracks your location, whether or not it shows you that it is doing so. Your phone, facebook app, smart devices (alexa, google home, etc.), and any IoT device with a microphone (many not informing you of the capability) are constantly recording your conversations and uploading it to servers. Your credit card company, credit ratings agencies, banks, and likely all of the processing companies in between track your purchases, spending habits, and locations. Any member card at a store or gas station gives your discounts as a reward so they can track you. Health companies are starting to join the practice. All of the genetic testing companies package and sell your data. This is then cross referenced for signature markers, personal data, and any information that can make your information usable. These banks have already been used for criminal cases to find DNA matches on evidence to identify suspects. Some doctors have started the practice of sharing data with researchers, either within their network or sometimes to outside clients. This happens less often due to the number of health related data laws, but not enough to prevent abuse. How many of the ways they track you can you really opt out of? Sure, I could ditch my smart phone and try to work only with cash but coming into contact with anyone more connected adds you back into the system. The disconnected options are becoming fewer and harder to rationalize. When you take into account data breaches and careless management of data, it becomes clear that there is more info floating out there about you on innumerable servers that you couldn't even begin to fathom. Its not just your social security number to gain access to credit card, but now the habits and tendencies that can be sold. The problem is not necessarily the algorithms that can go bad, but that the data is collected and shared with no thought to consequences, scope, or consent. And it will only get worse because it is one of the only ways for a lot of companies to stay profitable. Hosting a website is not going to make money unless you sell something to your customers. The users of your website generally aren't your customers, but rather your product. This business model has spread outside of the software and into so many other fields. This is only the beginning. I could probably write pages about each of the different examples listed above and still only be skimming the surface. Unless laws are changed to give the user ownership and stewardship of their data, it will continue to be mistreated. We have not defined the way we wish to talk about our data, what data can be collected and when, or have any common tools for working with it. As long as companies rely on their data collection to be profitable, they will continue to collect as much as they can. And they will actively lobby to prevent this stable part of their income. We slammed hard into 1984 and Brave New World. Our dystopia will be personally catered to our individual needs and value systems. We will be shaped and molded into the most salable product. We are the domesticated humans to our capitalistic algorithm overlords.

Prudent Penguin

Great work with the research on this one! I work in AI and I'm impressed how well you understand how it works. I and some of my colleagues have been thinking about the societal impact of the technology that we help build for a while now and some of the discussions in your video sound very familiar. But I still got several new perspectives and arguments out of it that I hadn't thought of before. I'll share the video with my colleagues, so we can discuss it internally. Minor nit: The things that you call "algorithms" that recognize things in pictures or make decisions or predictions are called "models" in the AI community. I know, they're usually called "algorithms" in literature targetted at mainstream audiences (and using that same terminology probably makes your video more accessible to such audiences). But I did want to clarify the difference here because it's somewhat relevant to one of the points you're making. An algorithm is a set of instructions written by a human programmer, so that programmer would be able to tell you exactly how the algorithm works and what each part does. A model is more like a black box because it's essentially a very complex mathematical function that has been automatically constructed by a computer (through machine learning), so it's often difficult or impossible for humans to tell which part of it serves what purpose. (There are models that are easier to interpret for humans, but they typically don't do as well on the predictions or decisions they're supposed to make, so they're not used a lot.) Your argument still holds though because regardless of what you call these black boxes, the fact that they're black boxes is a problem.

Alien6981

Hey Olly, this video was great! Sorry to learn from the credits captions that you're going through depression, hope you can find support and get through it. But the video was amazing, it really works as a fiction short, it's cool, the people waiting in line in the background really add something. People are great props, I guess? Also loved seeing Ellis back too, his ominously creacking leather jacket is a great sidekick. Video was great, it's an ongoing joy to support you work. Love.

Sascha Erni

“I used to be a police officer!” ~ Greatness.

Jo Lee

Olly, I love all of your videos, but I'm so impressed by the creative risk you took with this one. Also much love from a fellow depression buddy - hope you get feeling a bit better soon.

Ida Kirstine Jensen

Yeah so my name in the credits made me realize that Patreon has my full name... whoops

John D Ruddy

Excellent video! Hard to beat a good Socratic dialogue! Nice subtle dig with the €50 note ;)

KayVee

Great video and such a good song choice at the end!

Adria

Format is brilliant. Love this. You make philosophy and critical thinking so accessible and relevant! You're my favorite parasocial relationship. :D

Tango

This video is insanely good. I love the format, since it doesn't ever stop and become Olly talking about things at the camera, it's a great intro to Breadtube/video essays. Several uninitiated friends have already enjoyed this video!

Eden Ladley

The direction you took it in was really engaging! V good content