Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello lovely Patrons!

I like to be as financially transparent with you as I can, so going forward I'm going to try to provide cost breakdowns for each video once they're all paid for so you can see where your money is going! There are a few things to bear in mind:

Firstly, you'll notice that I can give percentages of the total budget but not amounts. The reason for this is that I'm sometimes contractually obligated to not disclose how much something cost; like in this case I can't say how much the music licensing cost me because I signed a standard NDA as part of the deal. Also, even when I don't sign that kind of deal some of the folks I work with prefer not to have their rates listed publicly. Because of the power of maths, if I gave you an exact value for any slice of the pie you'd be able to figure out all the other values, so percentages is what I've gone for.

Secondly, videos tend to vary hugely in how much they cost and what they require. This one had big expenses for animation and music licensing but I don't expect all future videos will, so each month the pie chart will probably look quite different.

Thirdly, sometimes I buy stuff for a video that I then keep and use in my personal life, like the dress I wore in Identity. Does that technically count as part of the show's budget if I'm now using it for non-show purposes? If I buy some makeup that I use both on the show and in my life, does that come under business expenses? I'm not sure what the right answer there is; in this chart I haven't included those costs, so the 'Costume' slice appears smaller than it arguably really was.

Fourthly, the chart doesn't include things like editing equipment and software, which I bought a while ago at large one-off expenses but which obviously go into making the video.

Fifthly, this chart can't say how much I actually get paid for my work! If there's any budget leftover after the episode then I live off that for the next month, and if there's any spare I put it towards the next one; it tends to fluctuate a lot and the money is always kindof earmarked to go into the show, so I don't really know how I could express that in a chart?

Anyway, those limitations aside, the chart might be mildly interesting at least! You can see some of how the sausage is made I guess! This post is public so anyone can come and read it.

Abi XXx

Files

Comments

Matthew Nyx

patreon revenue still hidden though?

Bethany B

we stan financial transparency!

Sarah Twist

Very interesting especially for aspiring content creators in this and related fields. The words Identity, Cost, and Breakdown have never had such banal meaning in the context of YouTube philosophy!

Ted Spikes

38% for black star, damn

Hristo Kolev

The one thing that I get from this is that music is fucking expensive.

Alexis Bushnell

My mind is boggled even trying to imagine the cost of that music! Incredible video though, it deserved incredible music.

Lomky

interesting! For being able to capture the amounts passing from video to video, or to yourself, I really like sankey charts for showing that sort of in/out flow

Dan Q

Wow at the relative cost of licensing music! O_o

Sohastalitha

The people pressuring patreon creators to justify every penny they spend make me really uncomfortable. It gives me the same vibes as people complaining when folks on benefits dare to spend money on nice things rather than beans and lentils. This isn't tax money, and it's not an investment where you get returns either.

Dylan Northrup

Yowza, that music licensing cost! It was the right choice artistically, but that is pretty massive in comparison.

Jim Brimstone

Wow, I can't believe that the animation cost was almost the same as the music licensing.

David

Wow. This transparency is awesome. I would actually say you should include your own "salary" in this chart. Alternatively, I guess you could do a "year-round-up" where you put your salary and video expenses "totaled up" as well.

Dominik Michaelis

I so appreciate that you actually pay subtitlers. And that they even get more than the actors. ... ... ... Less than hair and makeup though.

The Staff of Harmony & Strife

Do the things you buy for a video and use in your personal life count as show expenses? Seems like aaaaaaaaa... philosophical question! No, seriously, you could probably do an entire episode on the philosophy of thriftiness to try and answer that question. It is certainly something I consider when purchasing items for a LARP / other such fun event -- can I also use this for work/real life events? Am I a horrible person to buy something only for a special event? Also, good on you for doing something really special for a really special video!

Argentsignal

As an illustrator seeing the biggest chunk going to animations warms the heart a bit. Animators and illustrators are so grossly underpaid for hours and hours of labor that can be very hard on the body. I know the crew and actors work hard too and that you can’t tell all that much but I’m so used to people going to fiver for the lowest rate they can get on the kinda art me and my friends do and idk, it was just a nice thing to wake up to.

Maddy Gressman

ooooo i love data! honestly i could care less how you actually use my money (im a very small donor of course so 🤷) but seeing the breakdown is EXTREMELY interesting so thank you! loved your last video Abi, so happy to have you here ♥️

Liz Mednick

How does hair and makeup cost more than actors? Good grief Abigail, you're pretty enough as is.

David Litvak

so Abby, what you're telling us is that we *shouldn't* expect classic bangers by world-famous music icons in every video? ;)

LofiSofi

This is so cool for you to do! I've never had creators I support be this upfront with their finances. Much appreciated.

Probably An Owl

i really appreciate this break down! it's also very useful to any of your patrons who are curious about doing things like this themselves and what thoae costs would look like! thank you

kalleigh heffernan

The amount spent on music was so hecking worth it 😤 it was amazing

Beth Allen

I'm glad you are saving something to eat and pay rent! Not being starving and stressed about money is part of being able to do creative stuff. (within reason, I guess, that said... F**k it! Buy toys, give it away, have a week off sometime! Just... keep making videos :)) (oh wow, I've just realised having a week off is listed in my Head as a luxury... Yikes)

Morgana Ignis

This is EXTREMELY helpful! Thank you, Abi!

Finvaara

I would request that in the future you consider including any objects purchased for the show whether you plan to use them for other purposes later or not. It would be madness to insist that all parts of a show should be consumed by the time it wraps.

Kayla Montgomery

Abi, (that's how you signed the post) I would really advise caution here. I love that you want to be this transparent with the show and if you want to provide a one time look at the financials of the operation that's fine. However, Providing this kind of data opens you up to more scrutiny and possible attacks by malicious actors. For example, it's not difficult for someone to simply interpolate a reasonable cost for the music licensing and come up with a reasonable metric that would then apply to the show and be fairly close to what was actually spent. But then they would use the same calculations in evaluating your other videos and use it to damn your show for being profit seeking. To defend against that you would have to release more financials to counter the bad actors and defend your credibility. In response, they would just use those to again misinterpret the data and cause further head aches. All the while, the accounting and reporting would become a larger and larger burden. not to mention put pressure on you to violate the NDAs you have agreed to. If you can handle that burden, so be it. But nothing is lost from the show by not releasing this information. Instead, it's only going to bring attention away from what you are trying to do: provide education about philosophy. It's going to make it even more tedious. Don't do that to yourself. You don't have anything to gain by releasing this. We are not entitled to your financials. You may think you are being deceptive, but you are not. You are protecting the integrity of the show, and your mental health by keeping this aspect private and it is your right to do that. Don't be too hasty in relinquishing that right.

Angela Watt

How to say this in the spirit I intend. I fully expect that you should be paid for your work, your intellectual content and your time. It shouldn’t be whatever is left, you should be paid a wage!

Adam Roy

I am concerned by the implication that you only pay yourself enough to get by, and the rest goes back in the show. You deserve to be compensated adequately, including savings and some luxuries, and as far as I am concerned the idea that you don't deserve those things is capitalist propaganda. Or, maybe I'm reading too much into it, and you adequately compensate yourself, and are on track for retirement, (Should we all survive that long). Just take care of yourself, you are the best part of the show.

jasonandandrea

Another vote for making sure you get paid for what you put into the project. This isn't entry level, low effort work here. Professionals get paid a superior salary for their superior results.

Naomi Ferree

I greatly appreciate the clarity and forthright honesty of this post, and it just demonstrates that I made the right choice in the first place.

Jason Ronson

It physically hurts me that using music that already exists costs far more than anything else, even original music or animation.

Dr. Mary C. Crowell

I like supporting other artists, and I value your work. I realize you need to know these pie chart percentages for budget reasons and so forth. But I do not. Meaning, it might be needed for example if you were sharing the budget info to educate another person interested in making educational videos; or I could see sharing it for a Kickstarter project in which you are trying to explain to people who are supporting a specific project. But for something like patreon, I’m just happy to contribute some money and appreciation.

Silhouetters

Always good to see where and how the funding is used! Go, Abby <3

Danny F. Mainville

How music cost so much?! For your own good, I sugest paying real-life musician on your scene. It would help some folk in need and, maybe, add some groove. Anyway, I am always, amaze by your video. It’s great to see someone with so much talent! (By the way, english is my second language. So I am sorry for the innacuracy of the use of mine.)

Jennifer Czechowski

Wow, these comments really vary from “accountability is good” to “this is unnecessary” and I think it brings up an interesting philosophical question. Are supporters on Patreon... A. Tippers - Saw something that made them smile and left a tip, B. Subscribers - Paying for a continuous stream of content, C. Benefactors - Patrons of the arts that give financially to further artistic endeavors, or D. Co-collaborators - Those that that help out as they are able to further a common goal? I think the closer to A someone is, the less they are interested in financials; whereas closer to D, there is more a sense of wanting to participate in the details.

If life is a leaf

This is not a criticism, or implying you shouldn't get money. You clearly should. You need to live. In paying a patreon, I think most people intend it to help support creators, not just to cover their production costs. We support you because we value you (as a person) and your creative talent, and/or the work you do to spread values and information. That said: Not sure, but are you including what you get in "actors" or is that only for Rhys? If it doesn't include you, perhaps you should show what percentage you make. I certainly expect you should make money, as creator, director, editor, and primary actor. It should help you to at very least not have to have an external job.

Melissa DAlia

I have always wondered what goes into YouTube productions like yours! Thank you so much for sharing!

jared pitts

The most expensive parts are definitely not what I was expecting them to be lol

RiotingPacifist

Have you considered doing a video on copyright? I think it would touch on some very interesting topics: * Who should own knowledge? * What the point of civilization is? I think that for many philosophers and scientist, the assumption was that civilization was a vehicle for the amassing of knowledge, for others collective knowledge is but a tool to improve material conditions * The history of copyright, started as an arguably good idea, almost immediately turned to shit hurting the very people it was meant to help (reminds me of cops TBH) * The copyright lobby, forever - a day, Bern convention, international copyright lobby, the impact on pirate bay, raids on Mega CEO, etc * How it absolutely does not work: Netflix, Spotify, DMCA takedowns (blizcon & literally ruining youtube as an option for many creators^1), artists losing control of their content anyway (Alan Moore, Musicians vs Trump, Nixon walking out to the Boss) * How it has never worked: I think Teachers are a good example, where pre-internet there was so much piracy of content, through photo-copies, etc, but nobody cared because copyright owners knew they'd kill their own industry if they tried to enforce their rights. * The current flip-flop between artists using tours to promote content sales and content to promote tours. * Software copyright, what are you actually paying for when you buy software?, FLOSS, the internet (and how big companies like Amazon, Google, etc, run almost everything they do on mostly free software), the gates email, etc * The difference between Free Software and Open Source * Alternatives to copyright, creative-commons (wikipedia, NIN, Al Jazeera, Cards Against Humanity, that 1 creative commons porn film by Erika Lust that feels like gets referenced everywhere (black mirror, etc))), etc * Alternatives to funding artists, leftists comedians (Stuart Lee, Alexei Sayle, etc) have a couple of times mentioned that even in the Thatcher era you could get by on various grants + Dole money as a struggling musician/comedian^2 Also: * The Pirate -> dominate market -> force content producers to cut you a deal -> Legit -> Legit + ban hammer hypocracy pipeline (Youtube, "Other"Tubes(e.g Pornhub/MindGeek), etc) * Academic copyright and how utterly ridiculous it is (textbook prices, textbook authors being unable to use their own content, etc), the problem of funding the advancement of knowledge (nobody wants to do it, so you end up with Student Debts & Publish or die (thanks to Maxwell & Thatcher) * It's IMO a good example of how capitalism eats itself, multiple industries that depend on copyright are crushing the pipeline of talent and killing themselves (Software is a pretty good example, but It feels like a pre-cursor for the music industry & film (big studios gobble up small studios, then nobody is taking risks, content gets work, industries make less money, or that's what I foresee happening anyway) ^1 my goto example is botchamania which uses clips for wrestling in a way that would not impact WWE's revenue yet youtube has banned his account so many times he nearly gave up on the entire idea and went back to working in a call centre (nothing wrong with working in a call centre but pretty sure maffew hates it) ^2 I might be mis-remembering what they said or it might not be accurate, but I think that's the Gist of what they both said (Lee recently made a movie about a semi-successfully band, I've ironically not watched as I don't have sky). I dunno I could rant about how bad copyright is for everybody except big business (and always has been) for hours, IMO it's up there with Ownership of the MoP & The right to kill that states assume p.p.s apologies if I've suggested this before, I don't think I have but I sometimes internet drunk and find how bad copyright is as EVERYTHING really interesting

RiotingPacifist

Oh and also the whole "alleged" gates pressuring the Oxford lab to keep the vaccine copyright, effectively killing potentially hundreds of thousands by slowing it's rollout thing too.

Kensai777

Hold up - so roughly 70% is animations and licensing? So confused, what animations and what's licensed?

Kensai777

Love your content, bated breath waiting for your next vid, but for reals? That's just crazy town for me