Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello lovely Patrons!

It's finally here! My new episode premieres tonight at 1930 British time - join me in the live chat from 1900!

Thank you for all of your pledges in making this episode, it really came together nicely!

Abi XXx

Files

Social Constructs | Philosophy Tube

What are social constructs, and why do some people get so upset about them? 🚗🔧🚗 https://www.patreon.com/PhilosophyTube Paypal.me/PhilosophyTube Twitter: @PhilosophyTube Email: philosophytubebusiness@gmail.com BIBLIOGRAPHY: Ásta, Categories We Live By Ásta, “Précis: Categories We Live By,” in Journal of Social Ontology Katie J.M. Baker, “The Road to TERFdom,” in Lux Simone De Beauvoir, Le Deuxième Sexe Talia Mae Bettcher, “Trapped in the Wrong Theory,” in Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society Richard Boyd, “Homeostasis, Species and Higher Taxa,” in Species Judith Butler, Gender Trouble Kevin Duong, “Gender Trouble in France: An Interview with Camille Robcis, “ in Jacobin Lori Gershick, “Out of Compliance: Masculine-Identified People in Women’s Prisons,” in Captive Genders Jules Joanne Gleeson, “How Do Gender Transitions Happen?” in Transgender Marxism Aaron Griffith, “Individualistic and Structural Explanations in Ásta’s Categories We Live By,” in Journal of Social Ontology Sally Haslanger, “But Mom, You’re Wrong. Crop-Tops Are Cute!” in Resisting Reality Sally Haslanger, “What is a (Social) Structural Explanation?” in Philosophical Studies Katharine Jenkins, “Conferralism and Intersectionality: A Response to Ásta’s Categories We Live By,” in Journal of Social Ontology Rosa Lee, “Judith Butler’s Scientific Revolution,” in Transgender Marxism Ron Mallon, The Construction of Human Kinds Plutarch, Theseus Amie Thomasson, “Foundations for a Social Ontology,” in ProtoSociology Special Thanks to Edd China and the Workshop Diaries Team! https://www.youtube.com/user/TheEddChina Adorable Platypus Footage By Getty

Comments

Marianna Adamou

I really like your videos! Keep up the good work!!

Sonja

That was fantastic!

Samuel York

That was awesome. Thank you.

Peter Larsen

Are color coordinated outfits a social construct?

Glyph

Loved it. Absolutely lost it at "everybody did not love socrates". The abstract examples seemed like a really effective way to lower the temperature on an incredibly fraught and emotional set of discussions; I don't hold the requisite (bigoted) views to understand whether the folks who *need* to hear this the most *will* hear it, but this has gotten closer to bridging that understanding than any other piece of media I've seen!

Tony Coan

Thank you for the video!

Ben Masters

awesome video Abby!!! minor audio feedback: peaks during certain word sounds, often S's, which is a bit sharp (example: 9:41 'suppose'). again, awesome and thanks!

Chibigodzilla

Describing baseball within the context of cricket was *chef's kiss.* It's still a subtle example of how some constructs can get distorted when trying to make them fit into other frameworks.

greendies

Hey Abby! Loved the video, and thought of an interesting 3rd sort of "neutral" example that might bridge the gap between the example of the platypus and what might be considered more 'fraught' examples: Pluto (the one in space, not underground). Like the platypus, there has been historically a lot of debate over how to classify Pluto in the scientific community, debate that was settled only 15 years ago. And like some *other* categories, when it was decided by an authority on the matter that Pluto was not and never had been a planet, there were many people outside said authority who were quite angry about the decision (and still are!), and who even took it personally, even though they'd never been to Pluto and didn't really know anything about it. Just some interesting parallels, I think.

Aidan Kelly

That sign off line hits SO HARD!

Eric Herman

I so look forward to your content. Please continue to do this work. It's excellent.

LonMcGregor

That was a great short punchy episode. I hear people talk all the time about "social constructs" but I admit I never actually knew what they were talking about. The multiple earths image was particularly helpful in illustrating the video.

Alexis Bushnell

This was, I think, my favourite episode so far. And I binged watched almost all your content during the not-hot lockdown summer!

Callum Kemp

How is every video your best video? Loved it! Whoever chooses your outfits is killing it!

Bretten Sullivan

Were I teaching an Intro to Philosophy course, I'd show my students this video, even if I didn't also include metaphysics (or the word "metaphysics", at least) on that particular syllabus. I haven't (in my own pitifully limited philosophy education) found a more simultaneously entertaining and edifying primer on the subject. Thank you for the meta-argument

Bretten Sullivan

....about the politics of metaphysics, as well. You are correct that, though ontologies are humanly constructed, they're so often taken for granted--and dogmatically guarded. In conversation, popping someone's concept-bubble often means starting an unproductive, hot-gas driven argument

Bretten Sullivan

For instance, I've had bad luck using the word "socialism" with some people. They seem to fear the term "socialism" despite their obvious support for socialism's political ends. In such arguments, I rarely get to the point of saying, "What does it mean to be a socialist?", because they've already checked out. And even when I'm not so naïve as to be talking politics specifically, I see people's hackles rise in discussions of distinctions among dog breeds, or even ice-cream flavors. (Hell, one person--special case, I admit-- emitted an almost-scream at my suggestion that ice cream isn't meaningfully different from frozen yogurt.)

Owen Morawitz

Great video Abby! Really engaging and great examples, lots of humour and it made something that's normally fraught through the facts/feeling dichotomy super relatable and understandable. In thinking more on the video, it got me thinking about a philosophy of science unit I took in undergrad, and how much of the debate around social constructs has significant overlap with Althusser's 'aleatory materialism' and Kuhn's concept of the paradigm shift. It's trying to explain to people that at the core, most of the shit we subscribe to for the structure of society and civilisation is quite literally made up. It's not static or innate or "natural"--everything exists in a state of dynamism and is subject to change if the political/social/cultural will exists to do so.

Sarah dolezal

I think I may be from earth -0.5. Not quite -1 (but close). I have a whole host of perspectives on myself that have lead me to my beliefs on everything else that also don't line up with what society says I should believe. I suppose that's what being an aphant, anarchist, RA, gender-pudding will get you though... or is my way of thinking what gets me to all of those things?

Alyssa Hallister

I had been slowly watching a few of your more recent videos over the past... period of time, after getting recommended from... I want to say a Rowan Ellis video, I think, and being aware of you thanks to following Lindsay Ellis since her NC days. This video finally motivated me to go back and binge watch some of your older videos from before you came out publicly, and I felt I just had to become a patron, and you're even on the one social media platform I use, but which is totally dead, don't anyone tell people on Twitter and such that it's still alive and going.