Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello lovely Patrons! The next episode of Philosophy Tube premieres tonight at 8pm British time, and I'll be in the live chat from 7.30pm! 

I hope you can come along and watch it live, it should be a fun one!

Abi XXx

Files

Does Anybody Really "Get" Art? | Philosophy Tube

https://curiositystream.com/philosophytube THE PRINCE: https://www.southwarkplayhouse.co.uk/show-homepage/the-prince/ Patreon: https://patreon.com/philosophytube Subscribe! http://tinyurl.com/pr99a46 Twitter: @PhilosophyTube Email: philosophytubebusiness@gmail.com 00:00 - Intro 01:45 - Part 1: The Artist's Intention 09:41 - Part 2: Feeling the Right Emotions 20:25 - Part 3: The Art Market 26:50 - Part 4: Art and the Audience BIBLIOGRAPHY: Roland Barthes, “The Death of the Author” Michael Baxandall, Patterns of Intention Clive Bell, “The Aesthetic Hypothesis” Thom Bettridge, “Hiding Out In Montauk With Lucien Smith,” in Ssense Walter Benjamin, “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction” Noel Carroll, “Interpretation and Intention,” in Metaphilosophy R.K. Collingwood, The Principles of Art Steven Connor, “Doing Without Art” Ryan Coogan, “Why Are Right Wingers So Afraid of Modern Art?” in The Independent Arthur Danto, “The Artworld” Arthur Danto, The Philosophical Disenfranchisement of Art George Dickie, “The New Institutional Theory of Art” Lindsay Ellis, “Death of the Author” Stanley Fish, “Is There A Text in This Class?” Folding Ideas, “Annihilation and Decoding Metaphor” Michel Foucault, “What Is An Author?” Jacob Geller, “Who’s Afraid of Modern Art” Harry Josephine Giles, “Give Up Art” William N. Goetzmann, Luc Renneboog and Christophe Spaenjers, “Art and Money,” in The American Economic Review Alan Goldman, “Interpreting Art and Literature,” in Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism Andrew Goldtsein, “The Figure Is Back, Baby! At MoMA PS1's Greater New York, Artists Vanquish Zombie Formalism With People Art,” in Artspace Sarah Hegenbart, “Zombie Formalism: Or How Financial Values Pervade the Arts” Eric Hirsch, “In Defence of the Author” Arnold Isenberg, “Critical Communication” Matthew Kieran, “In Defence of Critical Pluralism,” in British Journal of Aesthetics Paris Lees, What It Feels Like For A Girl David Mamet, Theatre Vladimir Nabokov, Pale Fire Adam Phillips, Missing Out Walter Robinson, “Flipping And the Rise of Zombie Formalism,” in Artspace Sam Rose, Interpreting Art Sam Rose, “The Fear of Aesthetics in Art and Literary Theory,” in New Literary History Tim Schneider, “Who Survived the Zombie Formalism Apocalypse? We Surveyed the Wreckage of the Last Great Art-Market Fad,” in Artnet Lisa Schiff, “Is This the Victory Lap We Were Hoping For? Why We Must Keep Women and Artists of Color From Becoming the Next Victims of Market Speculation,” in Artnet Shaun, “Paul Joseph Watson Is Wrong About Art” Richard Shusterman, “Beneath Interpretation,” in Monist Susan Sontag, “Against Interpretation” Patricia Taxxon, “The Kunst Saga: how the right wing views modern art” Leo Tolstoy, “What is Art?” Trashfuture ft. Jessica Eaton, “The Hanseatic Art World” Wendover Productions, “The Art Market Is A Scam (And Rich people run it)” W.K. Wimsatt, Jr. and Munroe Beardsley, “The Intentional Fallacy” Unfoldment, Revealment, Evolution, Exposition, Integration by Chris Zabriskie is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Source: http://chriszabriskie.com/reappear/ Artist: http://chriszabriskie.com/ LOOKS: BLUE HAT & SLEEVES BY CHERIE CHUN: https://www.instagram.com/chezzachooun/?hl=en PICASSO EARRINGS, NECKLACES AND BANGLES BY CAPULET&MONTAGUE: https://www.instagram.com/capuletandmontague/?hl=en, https://capuletandmontague.ie/ #art #education #artist

Comments

c.paul bettridge

Hey Abigail, I've been wanting to mention what great taste in music you have. I find myself downloading alot of the tracks at the end of your videos. And I think I've seen every one once or thrice....

Liz Mednick

Oh I'm really looking forward to this!

Liz Av

Excited for this! Also my own answer is: I usually don't!

Danielle

As I get older, I’ve become more confident in admitting “this just bounces off my brain and doesn’t stick.” I try to keep an open mind, but I don’t force it if it doesn’t fit. Then again, I remain open to revisiting a piece of art/music/writing at a time when I might be better able to receive it. Sometimes, it really is a journey. (Side note: love the tangerine/violet combo at the end.)

Hans

Joined your Patreon bc of this video!

Oliver 'Kannik' Bollmann

Nicely done. For those looking for more, The Art Assignment YouTube channel has a number of episodes exploring many of these same themes/ideas and I think they make a great companion piece. How we relate to art in all its facets (meaning, feeling, movement, experience, monetary, etc) is so fascinating and a good lens into the wider aspects of who we are being as humans. Thank you for this dive into it!

ben taylor

I don't know if this would be called "constructivist", but it does seem legitimate to me that quality of art must be, at least to some degree, objective because perception of it will be dependent on physical senses and the observer's knowledge and comprehension. If someone asked me to judge an exhibition of farsi love poetry I would apologize that I cannot read the language and most unfortunately am totally unfamiliar with Persian romance. Any value judgement I might make about those verses would be less interesting for my lack of preparation to enjoy the art at all. I think you made a similar point but I wanted to share this reflection. Another most entertaining and thought provoking video essay, thank you!

Veronica C. Morgan

I've posted some meatier thoughts on Youtube, but here I'd just like to offer hugs to all of you who viscerally understand these lyrics from the song "Painted Rocking Horse" by John Coleman: I ride a painted rocking horse And I'm too frightened to let go There's a holy stallion stamping at the door And if I ride the wild horse tonight Well, I wonder where I'll go; Would he leave me, broken, bleeding, in the snow? In dream I rode the nightmare And in dream my heart was strong; I was lifted by the stallion and his song. But it's light and I'm still haunted By the winter of a fear Of a stallion gone forever, and I'm still here.

Victoria Borges (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-14 12:00 Another fantastic video! Also this is a bit of a weird comment but it's so funny that both Alfred Molina and a painting by Leonardo da Vinci were both featured in this video-- I just (as in, finished last week) listened to an audiobook about Leonardo, and Alfred Molina did the narration! The whole time I was also like "oh! :) Alfred Molina :)" And if Abbi or anyone else is curious-- the book is by Walter Isaacson, and I really enjoyed it! It comes with an attached PDF with the images he talks about, and he often invites the audience to look more closely at the art-- not just its meaning, but how certain effects were achieved, and it's kind of a cool exercise that could pair really well with this video! For me, I think it really influenced how I saw the Seagram Murals in the beginning-- I just kept thinking of what it might have been like to make them. How long did Rothko spend trying to get just the right shades of desaturated reds and grays? Was he painting them close to the ground, in a small room, with off-white walls and low lighting? I do feel a bit trapped looking at them, but it's not because I'm in that room-- I'm watching a youtube video, after all!-- it's because I'm trying to look at art through the perspective of the person who made it. Anyway, great work, I love how much these videos make me think! And I can now say with some amount of confidence that if Leonardo da Vinci were alive today, he'd also be a big Philosophy Tube fan, lol <3
2022-08-20 20:49 Another fantastic video! Also this is a bit of a weird comment but it's so funny that both Alfred Molina and a painting by Leonardo da Vinci were both featured in this video-- I just (as in, finished last week) listened to an audiobook about Leonardo, and Alfred Molina did the narration! The whole time I was also like "oh! :) Alfred Molina :)" And if Abbi or anyone else is curious-- the book is by Walter Isaacson, and I really enjoyed it! It comes with an attached PDF with the images he talks about, and he often invites the audience to look more closely at the art-- not just its meaning, but how certain effects were achieved, and it's kind of a cool exercise that could pair really well with this video! For me, I think it really influenced how I saw the Seagram Murals in the beginning-- I just kept thinking of what it might have been like to make them. How long did Rothko spend trying to get just the right shades of desaturated reds and grays? Was he painting them close to the ground, in a small room, with off-white walls and low lighting? I do feel a bit trapped looking at them, but it's not because I'm in that room-- I'm watching a youtube video, after all!-- it's because I'm trying to look at art through the perspective of the person who made it. Anyway, great work, I love how much these videos make me think! And I can now say with some amount of confidence that if Leonardo da Vinci were alive today, he'd also be a big Philosophy Tube fan, lol <3

Another fantastic video! Also this is a bit of a weird comment but it's so funny that both Alfred Molina and a painting by Leonardo da Vinci were both featured in this video-- I just (as in, finished last week) listened to an audiobook about Leonardo, and Alfred Molina did the narration! The whole time I was also like "oh! :) Alfred Molina :)" And if Abbi or anyone else is curious-- the book is by Walter Isaacson, and I really enjoyed it! It comes with an attached PDF with the images he talks about, and he often invites the audience to look more closely at the art-- not just its meaning, but how certain effects were achieved, and it's kind of a cool exercise that could pair really well with this video! For me, I think it really influenced how I saw the Seagram Murals in the beginning-- I just kept thinking of what it might have been like to make them. How long did Rothko spend trying to get just the right shades of desaturated reds and grays? Was he painting them close to the ground, in a small room, with off-white walls and low lighting? I do feel a bit trapped looking at them, but it's not because I'm in that room-- I'm watching a youtube video, after all!-- it's because I'm trying to look at art through the perspective of the person who made it. Anyway, great work, I love how much these videos make me think! And I can now say with some amount of confidence that if Leonardo da Vinci were alive today, he'd also be a big Philosophy Tube fan, lol <3

Grey

Obviously not the correct take away from this, (yet another excellent, thought-provoking video) but how have I gotten this far never having heard the British pronunciation of "urinal" before?? 😂😜

Ava

Again, the makeup and styling, absolutely stunning, amazing work from the whole team! I've two minds on interpreting art. I studied film at Uni, became familiar with stuff like post-structuralism, mise-en-scene, auteur theory, cultural and historical contexts, etc. etc., all fun and interesting concepts that can provide deeper understanding of a work. It is a fun cognitive puzzle to play with these ideas. But then having a mother who is an artist, I've been taught to trust intuition. When I saw the Rothko pieces at the Tate some years ago, I remember connecting deeply with a sensation of doom and peace, similar to how you describe in this episode; cataclysm but calm. Beautiful work to me for no other reason than that intuitive experience. Similarly I once saw a piece by an artist I had never heard of at MONA in Hobart, Tasmania and it shook me. It was from 'Choral Fields' by Emma McNally, and it was the first time I felt someone had visually depicted what the insides of my brain feel like as an autistic person. It communicated something to me elegantly, and wordlessly, distinct from whatever intentions she had as the artist. Tl;dr I feel is that there is 'getting' art, knowing the intellectual, cultural, technical context. Then there is 'feeling' art, connecting on an intuitive, emotional level. Both have stimulative properties in different ways, maybe for the art we don't 'get' we can learn about a new culture, or technique, satiate the desire to learn. And sometimes we just feel seen in art. To conclude, Alfred Molina is a gem whomst we stan ♥️

Annie Hanlin

Casual or dressed up, you are so stunning. Loved seeing you as a literal piece of art

Ira Kroll

When I was going to college, I, a hard science nerd, was forced to take an art history class. It went fine until we got to modern art. I confided to the teacher that I felt that modern art was, well, not art at all. It was non-representational, etc. She made a deal with me. If my final paper (about modern art) was fully researched and the arguments within it were cogent and relevant, then she would give me a good grade despite my misgivings about modern art. At the time, I was working in downtown Washington, DC, and the Hirshhorn Museum was within walking distance. Over the next several weeks, I spent roughly 50 hours in the museum. I looked (and pondered) most everything in the museum. Eventually, I was no longer looking at the artwork itself, but watching the patrons of the museum, and their reactions to each art installation. My paper documented this, and, not so much my emotional reactions to the art, but the reactions of the folk looking at the art. Needless to say, my teacher gave me a good grade, even though my opinion about representational vs. non-representational art hasn't really changed. The thesis of the paper became that the artist is intending to have an emotional or sensory effect on the experiencer of the art. Some may be straightforward (a la representational art) and some may even be unintentional (some artists have claimed that the interpretations of the art intelligencia are wrong -- even though the intelligencia claim differently).

Cleo McKeever

that's a really interesting story. reminds me a little bit about the game of looking at passersby and guessing what their name is, marital status, career, dreams, etc. I think I'm about on the same page as you on modern art--brief funny story, I took three semesters of a jewelry making class in college, and had a raging crush on the teacher, this gorgeous soft-spoken redhead. She was a big fan of modern art (actually contemporary art, which is apparently different?) and even lent me one of her favorite books about it--I never came around to liking it, but I lied and said I'd loved the book, just so I had an excuse to talk to her more ^-^;; I will say the giant art installations, especially when they're built into actual useable buildings, can be kinda cool.