Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello lovely Patrons!

The new episode of Philosophy Tube is here! It'll premiere on YouTube tonight at 20:00 British time. I'll be in the live chat from 19:30 answering questions and hanging out, so come along and watch it with me and all the other fans!

Can't wait! I'm super excited about this one!

Abigail XXx

Files

How Police Make Up The Law (ft. LegalEagle)

See the uncensored version on Nebula: https://go.nebula.tv/philosophytube Support my work on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/PhilosophyTube Subscribe! http://tinyurl.com/pr99a46 Twitter: @PhilosophyTube Instagram, TikTok, Tumblr, BlueSky, Threads: @theabigailthorn Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/PhilosophyTube/ MERCH: https://store.nebula.tv/collections/philosophy-tube Email: philosophytubebusiness@gmail.com CHAPTERS: 00:00 - 01:19 Intro 01:19 - 05:51Trying to Define Law 05:51 - 08:42 Let's Ask A Lawyer! 08:42 - 14:44 Hart's Legal Positivism 14:44 - 34:44 British Policing & the Law 34:44 - 37:43 Rules with "Open Texture" 37:43 - 41:40 Case Study - Operation Soap 41:40 - 48:56 Vague Laws MUSIC: The Dark Glow of the Mountains by Chris Zabriskie is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Source: http://chriszabriskie.com/darkglow/ Artist: http://chriszabriskie.com/ 'Illegal' by The Cucumbers BIBLIOGRAPHY: Giorgio Agamben, State of Exception Hrafn Asgeirsson, “On the Instrumental Value of Vagueness in the Law,” in Ethics John Austin, The Province of Jurisprudence Determined Iain Donnelly, Tango Juliet Foxtrot Ronald Dworkin, “Introduction,” in Taking Rights Seriously Ronald Dworkin, “Jurisprudence,” in Taking Rights Seriously Ronald Dworkin, “The Model of Rules I,” in Taking Rights Seriously Ronald Dworkin, “The Model of Rules II,” in Taking Rights Seriously Timothy Endicott, “The Value of Vagueness,” in The Philosophical Foundations of Language in the Law John Gardner, “Legal Positivism: 5 ½ Myths”, in American Journal of Jurisprudence John Gardner, “The Virtue of Justice and the Character of Law,” in Current Legal Problems Nadia Guidotto, “Looking Back: The Bathhouse Raids in Toronto, 1981,” in Captive Genders H.L.A. Hart, The Concept of Law Scott Hershovitz, “The End of Jurisprudence”, in Yale Law Journal LawExplorer Blog, “Dworkin’s ‘Law As Integrity’ Andrei Marmor, “Law as Authoritative Fiction,” in Law and Philosophy Jolyon Maugham, Bringing Down Goliath Jolyon Maugham, “No, The Legal System Isn’t Biased Against Men - It Allows them to R*pe with Near Impunity,” in New Statesman Tommi Avicolli Mecca, “Brushes with Lily Law,” in Captive Genders Michael Moore, “Hart’s Concluding Unscientific Postscript,” in Legal Theory Office of National Statistics, “Police powers and procedures: Stop and search and arrests, England and Wales, year ending 31 March 2022” Joseph Raz, “The Problem About the Nature of Law,” in Ethics In The Public Domain Joseph Raz, “Authority, Law, and Morality,” in Ethics In The Public Domain Joseph Raz, “The Politics of the Rule of Law,” in Ethics in the Public Domain Joseph Raz, “Legal Principles and the Limits of Law,” in Colombia Law School Scott J. Shapiro, “The “Hart-Dworkin” Debate: A Short Guide for the Perplexed” Judith Shklar, “Political Theory and the Rule of Law,” in Political Thought and Political Thinkers Jon Stone, “Liz Truss To Give Government Powers to Override Human Rights Court,” in The Independent Thoughtslime, “All Cops Are Bad” Daniel Trilling, “Not Much Like Consent,” in The London Review of Books Trashfuture, “Bad Boys” Wesley Ware, “Rounding Up the Homosexuals,” in Captive Genders #police #law #cops

Comments

Amyphist

Hooray, I’m finally free for one of these. :)

Kian MacLeod

Aw hell yeah that's like... 5am Australia time!!

Jo

Woop! Watching on Nebula right now, 'cept the subtitles are screwed up >.< Still loving it so far

Lilly McKye

How do I watch it early if I have access in my membership? The link only takes me to the trailer for the livestream.

Chibigodzilla

Might be due to my USAmerican bias, but this one is a rare miss IMO, too much time spent uncritically sharing a fascist cop's narrative, not enough time spent on the nature of "policing"

Crissa Kentavr

Like that police in NYC would hand out tickets for 'not riding a bicycle in the bicycle lane' for $50. There is no such law! But people paid the tickets, the magistrate enforced them, until someone lawyered up and... so the magistrate would let *that* person off and the police continued to write tickets for nonsensical infractions.

Serendipity

Yep. But someone has to lose and Australia doesn't have a problem with our criminal justice system... 😂🤣😂

Noblese Oblahaj

You knew you had to get Alice make a cameo on the cop episode

David Stosser

Is there something worth exploring in the 25% hit rate for stop/search (25min) vs the 16% charge/prosecution rate (18min)? Not measuring the same thing, but there might be parallels between the two.

Davina A.

Trixie Mephistopheles is, quite frankly, goals. 🖤🖤🖤

Diana

LOLZ.

Frank Davis

Adds new meaning to “I fought the law, and the law won”.

Silent Shadow (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-14 12:00 As someone who works security - And I plan to leave THAT profession behind and head off/immigrate to England - I used to believe that the police were supposed to be the good guys. However... I learned quickly that wasn't the case. Actually, I only met ONE person in the security field - Which is, for all intents and purposes, a subsection of the police, just more limited - That was an honest person. Having done research on police corruption and those associated with them, ONE particular incident comes to mind -  Community Resources Against Street Hoodlums (CRASH), from 1979 to 2001. As of May 2001, the Rampart investigation had brought fifty-eight officers before an internal administrative board. Of these, twelve were suspended, seven resigned, and five were terminated. The rest, I'm not sure. However, I think the State Librarian, Kevin Starf, said it best in the History of California, "CRASH... became, in effect, the most badass gang in the city." This wound up being one of the most documented cases of police corruption. It became so notorious, that this had inspired Dan Houser, James Worrall & DJ Pooh to write a story that involves a fictionalized version of C.R.A.S.H. appears as the main antagonist faction in the 2004 open world action-adventure video game Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas. Seriously, compare the real life CRASH with that fictional world's equivalent. It's interesting and surprising. I don't think we're EVER going to see an honest police officer. Like with a noncorrupt politician, it's like finding a unicorn... Made of diamonds... named "Butt Stallion." Exceedingly rare. Sorry if this comment went on a tangent, I just had quite a lot to say. Keep up the good work. ^_^
2023-08-13 13:08 As someone who works security - And I plan to leave THAT profession behind and head off/immigrate to England - I used to believe that the police were supposed to be the good guys. However... I learned quickly that wasn't the case. Actually, I only met ONE person in the security field - Which is, for all intents and purposes, a subsection of the police, just more limited - That was an honest person. Having done research on police corruption and those associated with them, ONE particular incident comes to mind -  Community Resources Against Street Hoodlums (CRASH), from 1979 to 2001. As of May 2001, the Rampart investigation had brought fifty-eight officers before an internal administrative board. Of these, twelve were suspended, seven resigned, and five were terminated. The rest, I'm not sure. However, I think the State Librarian, Kevin Starf, said it best in the History of California, "CRASH... became, in effect, the most badass gang in the city." This wound up being one of the most documented cases of police corruption. It became so notorious, that this had inspired Dan Houser, James Worrall & DJ Pooh to write a story that involves a fictionalized version of C.R.A.S.H. that appears as the main antagonist faction in the 2004 open world action-adventure video game Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas. Seriously, compare the real life CRASH with that fictional world's equivalent. It's interesting and surprising. I don't think we're EVER going to see an honest police officer. Like with a noncorrupt politician, it's like finding a unicorn... Made of diamonds... named "Butt Stallion." Exceedingly rare. Sorry if this comment went on a tangent, I just had quite a lot to say. Keep up the good work. ^_^

As someone who works security - And I plan to leave THAT profession behind and head off/immigrate to England - I used to believe that the police were supposed to be the good guys. However... I learned quickly that wasn't the case. Actually, I only met ONE person in the security field - Which is, for all intents and purposes, a subsection of the police, just more limited - That was an honest person. Having done research on police corruption and those associated with them, ONE particular incident comes to mind -  Community Resources Against Street Hoodlums (CRASH), from 1979 to 2001. As of May 2001, the Rampart investigation had brought fifty-eight officers before an internal administrative board. Of these, twelve were suspended, seven resigned, and five were terminated. The rest, I'm not sure. However, I think the State Librarian, Kevin Starf, said it best in the History of California, "CRASH... became, in effect, the most badass gang in the city." This wound up being one of the most documented cases of police corruption. It became so notorious, that this had inspired Dan Houser, James Worrall & DJ Pooh to write a story that involves a fictionalized version of C.R.A.S.H. that appears as the main antagonist faction in the 2004 open world action-adventure video game Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas. Seriously, compare the real life CRASH with that fictional world's equivalent. It's interesting and surprising. I don't think we're EVER going to see an honest police officer. Like with a noncorrupt politician, it's like finding a unicorn... Made of diamonds... named "Butt Stallion." Exceedingly rare. Sorry if this comment went on a tangent, I just had quite a lot to say. Keep up the good work. ^_^

Augustus

I think I’m In Love

Grey

You are gorgeous! Your outfits always seem so meticulously crafted and are always aesthetically pleasing / eye-catching. You wear them well. Great episode - interesting and engaging. I really appreciate how accessible you make philosophical concepts esp with framing them in current contexts. Many thanks for the work that you and your team put into these.

Paul Bauman

Such a fantastic episode. Thank you, Abigail!

Brynly the Younger

While I appreciate this is primarily an episode on jurisprudence, I do take issue with Iain Donnelly's text being the only one used to represent what is actually a surprisingly ideologically pluralistic profession. He had a 30 year career in the Police, and represents what is quite a niche "Old Guard" with 'Commonsense' views - the lack of justification that comes with that being something you noticed. Happy to get in touch if you want a fuller picture of the 'Inside'.

Carolyn Larke

Fantastic! I'll forward this off to a philosophic, American, former Sheriffs Deputy. Maybe he will use it to elevate the level of discussion around training and enforcement. Thank you.