Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 445740134.mp4

Downloads

Content

How do you make infinite choices? - The Axiom of Choice

Files

Comments

iRick

So here's where my non-mathematician/obsessively pragmatic brain is at. Might just be a bunch of nonsense, but we'll see: I won't pretend like I've successfully intuited this yet, but accepting the axiom of choice/asserting you have a countable infinity feels *somewhat* familiar to the concept of imaginary numbers to me. That is to say: its physical impossibility doesn't mean it's useless for real world calculations. It's just another means of understanding. Like a sort of framework that allows us to model something beyond the limitations of the physical world, which allows us to make calculations and predictions that might actually be relevant to the physical world. Does any of that make sense? My mind is so angrily trying to answer the question "WHAT IS THE POINT OF THIS TOPIC?!", and I feel like maybe thinking that way points me in the right direction. **Anyway**, I actually feel like this (like many of our other recent topics) will be important to what I've been spamming you folks about via email and FAQ questions lol. The use of explicit and non-ambiguous linguistic definitions of terms to build a framework for the quantification and dimensionality of cognition. I really think these things can help us eventually create literally *quantitative* and *formal* representations of ideas and arguments. (Well, maybe figuratively...) But maybe that's all nonsense, too 😅

Edwin Pole II

As I stated elsewhere, when it comes to infinity, further "math" is mentalbation. X/0 is a concept, not reality. The danger comes when your math based description of reality hits infinity. This is why I claim that there is no inside to a black hole. The event horizon is just a single point that looks like it has size due to the warping of space. There is no such thing as the multi-verse. Hope I'm wrong. 😉

iRick

Hm. Your description of the size of a black hole is intriguing! I'll have to think about that a bit more! And while I agree that there's no such thing as the multi-verse for any conceivable intent or purpose, I am wondering if such a thing might "exist" (or, rather, not exist lol) in a sort of great, big superposition. Like... the only "real" universe is ours, but the only limitation of the possibilities is that anything that happened in the *past* can't be undone. I guess what I'm trying to assert is that what we call Time—the observation of matters' positions changing relative to each other as determined by the state of their energy/light/whatever/...stuff; that "law" of physics or whatever we want to call it—is what collapses open-ended meaning into reality. The same way that light collapses a quantum particle's waveform into an exact point. Which would mean the multi-verse *kinda* exists in the future in a theoretical, imaginary-numbers kinda way. Does that make sense?

Edwin Pole II

I think there are only 2 dimensions, space and time. Space can be mapped onto 3 axes and it is what prevents everything from being in the same place. Time can be mapped onto 1 axis and it is what prevents everything from happening all at once. I like to bring humor into my physics. 🤣

iRick

I feel like that's semantics, but I'm actually interested to get into it with you a bit! Like, obviously the mathematical definition of "dimension" means that there's 3 spatial dimensions, not one, but for certain concepts—certain intents and purposes lol—the exact position in space doesn't necessarily matter, right? (Heh. Matter. It's only a wave until it has to be a particle because it isn't matter until it matters!) Or maybe... for these concepts, the only *physical* dimension along which they really vary is time. And so, if we find *truly semantically meaningful* ways to represent properties of these multi-dimensional concepts in the physical world via language, then we can make changes to those linguistic symbols that would translate to re-thinking the concept in ways that we previously weren't able to because we were stuck in a subjective perspective. I guess I'm trying to start a discussion about the nature of objectivity vs. subjectivity. I've been talking to ChatGPT about it for months now. It's been super fun and interesting! Let me know if you have any thoughts or contributions!

Edwin Pole II

I don't view the mapping of space as a dimension. There are several different mapping, maybe many, but thing mapped is space and I think of that as a dimension. I think my somewhat humorous definitions describe space and time accurately.

Ben Galehouse

Why stop at X/0 as a concept, when 5 is also a concept? Natural numbers may feel stronger than some other mathematical concepts, but there is no actual 5 that you can show me. Science is science because it makes testable predictions, and we accept the theories which give correct predictions. Then engineering uses those models to build houses that are (usually) correctly predicted to not fall down, and to otherwise change the world. Math is an art of ideas which is both blessed and cursed by being unreasonably useful for building these predictive models that we call science. As in statistics, all models are wrong, some are useful. That predictive utility is the only truth science actually offers.

Ben Galehouse

One way to strengthen the analogy with choices of geometry is to note that there are more options than "no axiom of choice" and "axiom of choice". For example, Solvay built a measure theory on the reals in which all sets are measurable, but he need the Axiom of Dependent Choice which is stronger than bare ZF, but weaker than (implied by, but does not imply) the Axiom of Choice. Also, you argued that the Axiom of choice proves the well ordering principle for the reals. Then you state that they are equivalent - which is true, but a stronger statement than what was argued.

Edwin Pole II

Imaginary numbers are basically just a way of describing the magnitude and phase of waves and allowing calculations to be made. It allowed the calculations when capacitors and inductors had to be taken into account in electrical circuits.

RobF228

Goofy question: Can irrational numbers is base 10 become rational numbers in some other base?

Veritasium

Not goofy at all. The short answer is no. If a number is irrational in base 10, it is irrational in every base. That's because rationality isn't about how a number looks in a particular numeral system - it's about whether it can be expressed as a fraction of two integers. Rational numbers always have expansions that either terminate or repeat, no matter what base you write them in. Irrational numbers, like √2, have expansions that never terminate or repeat, again regardless of base. For example, in base 10 √2 ≈ 1.41421356... (no repeating pattern) and in base 2 (binary) we have √2 ≈ 1.01101010000010011110... (also no repeating pattern). On the other hand, the rational number 1/3 in base 10 is 1/3 = 0.3333... (repeating) and in base 2 (binary) we have 1/3 = 0.01010101... (also a repeating pattern). I hope this helps!

RobF228

Thank you. I have wondered about that for a long time and didn't know who to ask until your recent video.

Veritasium

Great points! You're totally right - there's a lot more nuance here. Beyond just accepting or rejecting the Axiom of Choice entirely, mathematicians explored various intermediate forms like the Axiom of Dependent Choice and the Axiom of Countable Choice. Also, good catch regarding equivalence: The video perhaps shows more clearly that the Axiom of Choice implies the Well-Ordering Principle, but these statements are actually equivalent in both directions. If every set can be well-ordered, then every set (and every subset!) has a first element. So, given any collection of nonempty sets, you can simply pick the first element from each set which exactly matches what the Axiom of Choice claims - that you can always make a choice. Your comment highlights precisely why the analogy with geometry and the parallel postulate is so appropriate: just as geometry can branch into Euclidean, hyperbolic, or elliptic forms depending on the parallel postulate, set theory similarly branches into different frameworks depending on which choice axioms we accept!