Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 452303828.mp4

Downloads

Content

Why does energy disappear in General Relativity? - Noether's Theorem

Files

Comments

Dave Muth

Great video. Fun video! Number two will be da bomb!

paercebal

That is, without any doubt, one of your best videos. And you did a lot of awesome ones! The explanation about symmetries, and how they result into conservation laws, is AWESOME. Also, good reminder, about a scientist who never got the recognition she was worthy of, because she was not a white male. Thanks!

Tristan Ursell

Love the video, Casper's derivation of energy conservation is great, but having "v" and "V" will confuse a lot of people ... and it's never mentioned that you're talking about two different "v"s.

Terry Bollinger

Derek Muller, your video reminded me why the assertion that cosmic redshifts break energy conservation has always baffled me. Launch two probes at close to light speed by having them push off each other really, really hard. (Do not volunteer to ride in these probes!) A while after launch, a third that stayed at the launch point sent blasts of gamma rays toward both launch satellites. The moving probes look back and detect not gamma rays but microwaves. Both conclude that the gamma bursts’ energy was lost and energy conservation has failed. Three questions: (1) Was energy conservation broken? (2) If not, why not? (3) If not, does the explanation for why energy is conserved (it is) for acceleration in flat Euclidean space apply to the expansion of space in General Relativity or not?

Veritasium

Thanks for the feedback, hope you and others were still able to follow throughout!

Edwin Pole II

I'm skeptical. How long does it take for the rock to slow down to 0? How is the deceleration of the rock related to the expansion of the universe? Is the perceived deceleration merely an artifact of there being more "space" being created between you and the rock?

Veritasium

Hi Terry, thanks for the question! I hope this might clear some things up for you. In the situation you describe the probes see microwaves due to the Doppler effect. Since the probes are moving relative to the source, the gamma rays emitted by the source are redshifted from the perspective of the probes who see them as microwaves. But an important thing to note here is that energy isn't lost so long as you describe everything relative to the same reference frame. From the reference frame of the source, the source emits two gamma rays and (assuming a static spacetime) these are gamma rays for all of their lifetime. But from the perspective of the probes, the light was a microwave when it was emitted and is still a microwave when it reaches the probe. In each frame, no energy is lost or gained, but if you switch between frames the inherent energy of the photon is different. The same thing happens when you shift frames and consider the energy of any object. If you have a rock on a table, and you're in the reference frame of the rock, then the rock is stationary and has no kinetic energy. But if you move relative to the table, from your frame of reference, the rock (and table) will be moving and you'll say they have a kinetic energy. That doesn't mean kinetic energy has been created - it's just always the case that the amount of energy you assign to different objects will change if you change reference frames. The key is to keep track of all the energy changes relative to a single frame of reference. So in your example (assuming we're not in an expanding spacetime) energy conservation is not broken because the total energy in any particular frame does not change. But in an expanding universe the situation is different! Now, even if you consider everything from a single reference frame, a photon travelling through the universe will redshift over time and lose energy. So the redshift isn't a consequence of changing reference frames now - any single observer will see the photon lose energy. That energy is gone. Cosmological redshift does break conservation of energy. - Matt D. Writer for this video

Veritasium

Thanks Edwin! The first thing to mention is that technically the rock never slows down all the way to zero (we were a little imprecise about that), but it will always be getting slower and slower. We did some calculations assuming a constant rate of expansion, and after about 80 billion years the rock will be at 1% of its original speed, and after 210 billion years it will be at 0.0001%. In terms of what it means for the rock to decelerate - what we technically mean is that the rock will come to rest relative to its surroundings. We say that it becomes "comoving" with the universe. In cosmology we have two kinds of velocity - let's call them peculiar and comoving. A distant galaxy, for example, gets further away from us, not because it's moving, but because the space between us is expanding. It has a comoving velocity (how far away it's getting from us because of the expansion of space), but no peculiar velocity (the galaxy isn't itself moving). Think about a stick floating on the surface of a river. The river's flow is like the comoving velocity, the stick itself isn't moving relative to the flow of the river, it's carried along by it. For our rock, the rock begins with both a peculiar and comoving velocity (peculiar because it's moving relative to its environment, and comoving because everything feels the expansion of space to some extent). Then over time, the rock's peculiar velocity is reduced further and further by the expansion until eventually it only has comoving velocity. Like if you threw the stick in the river, at first the stick will be both carried by the flow and also moving faster than the flow (force from your throw caused this). But eventually the stick ends up being carried along. -Matt D. Writer for this video

Edwin Pole II

Then my interpretation is correct. What, then does that imply wrt the conservation of energy? Also, in reality the math says (I'll bet) that the rock only "stops" moving when t=∞. This conforms to my position that math is only useful to describe reality as long as it doesn't divide by 0. At that point, one cannot continue "mathing".

Terry Bollinger

Hi Derek Muller and company, [This is far too long for a comment. However, you made me think a lot, so I’ll add it “just for the record.” The issue is interesting enough that I may address it in an Apabistia paper or even (sigh) a YouTube video.] Thanks! If I may add a little more to your spot-on analysis, one can also convert photon energy into long-distance momentum-pair energy, allowing for the tracking of energy budgets entirely within a single observer frame. Staying in one frame makes it easier to see the details of what’s going on energetically. Call the at-home launch point Alice, A, the left-moving probe Larry, L, and the right-moving probe Roger, R. Alice, who has read Einstein’s 1911 paper on the Twins’ Paradox, already has her fully synchronized and calibrated close-contact instruments positioned along the L and R paths. Preparing ahead allows her to observe and record, as irreversible events, everything that happens to the L and R probes and the photons she launches toward them. Furthermore, close contacts eliminate the lightspeed delays that would otherwise introduce simultaneity ambiguities. After later collecting all her data, Alice watches her gamma rays chasing and striking left-probe Larry, L, and right-probe Roger, R. Because L and R travel very close to lightspeed (it’s a race), she sees her up gamma rays struggling to catch up with L and R. This struggle to catch up slows the arrival of wave phases and causes them to impact L and R in the same fashion that microwaves would look to her. Thus, delightfully, A, L, and R all agree that the gamma rays look like microwave photon impacts when they strike L and R. This is good because only the timing of events is relative, not the nature of the events. For example, all three must agree that the atomic excitations created by the gammas must look like microwaves from any frame. Still curious about what happened to the gamma energy from her perspective, Alice calculates the tiny mass equivalence of the microwave photons after L and R absorb them fully, and then calculates the resulting momentum-pair energy created by those added masses traveling in opposite directions at L and R velocities. She finds this: The total momentum-pair energy added to L and R — the energy they would release if their tiny microwave-photon-equivalent masses could collide head-on — is identical to the energy of the original gamma rays she sent. Her gamma ray energy didn’t disappear after all! Instead, absorption by L and R as microwaves converted them into a long-distance momentum energy pair with the same energy. Thus, despite A, L, and R all agreeing that the gamma rays turned into weak microwave photons when they collided with atomic matter, the system conserves total energy. Instead of being lost, the gamma energy transformed into long-distance momentum-pair energy. A lovely symmetry! That does, however, add a curious twist to the question of space expansion. Suppose Alice, Larry, and Roger are galaxies separated by space expansion. In that case, Alice finds that the energy-to-momentum equations behave similarly to those in the earlier case of conventional L and R acceleration. Thus, if her gamma rays from 13 billion years ago strike L and R as microwave photons, they still convert into tiny amounts of mass that, in turn, add small amounts of momentum-pair energy to the two fast-moving galaxies. Thus, Alice sees her gamma energy conserved even in the case of space expansion. I’ve scratched my head about this seeming equivalence of the results of conventional acceleration and space-expansion acceleration, and the only path I can see to losing energy is to redefine the meaning of “velocity” for space-expansion velocity. You have to say that even though distant galaxies _look_ like they are hurtling away from us, they are not because they never underwent acceleration in the conventional sense. I find that highly unsatisfying. The simplest explanation for what we observe in telescopes is that the distances, velocities, and redshifts are all equally real and correlated, regardless of the details of how they acquired those velocities. Consequently, I don’t see any easy path by which cosmic redshifts lose energy. All they do is convert electromagnetic frequency energy into momentum-pair energy between very distant fermionic matter partners. I don’t know why Noether’s equations don’t capture that. I suspect the difficulty stems from whether cosmic spacetime is smooth or has structure. If cosmic spacetime has structure — and I’m one of a small group (just me?) who says it must — perhaps those “fissures” in Noether’s fabric reflect this less-than-ideal spacetime structure. But even if so, that doesn’t mean energy is lost, but just converted into another form, in this case, distant-pair momentum energy. Also, amusingly, far from losing energy, the opposite appears to be happening. More specifically, the dark energy that drives expansion converts into real, observable net momentum energy for opposing pairs of fermionic galaxies. The electromagnetic energy merely tags along for the ride and eventually converts into long-range momentum pair energy. I realize that’s not a standard view. Nonetheless, if you take galactic redshift as real and proportional to galactic velocities, I don’t see an easy way to avoid some version of dark-to-momentum-pair energy transformation. I need to conduct a literature search on that idea, as I would not be surprised if someone has already written a paper on it. ---- Regarding the tossed rock, I’m fairly sure your result is wrong: The rock speeds up. Let’s say Alice is your exceptionally old astronaut who resides in some galactic proto-void where galactic gravity is negligible. When Alice was young, she had two pet rocks named Larry Left and Roger Right. At about the same time that galaxies started sailing apart, she became angry with Larry and Roger over something or other (think Wilson in Castaway) and tossed Larry to the left and Roger to the right. You can see where this is going. Far from slowing down, 13 or so billion years later, the disowned pet rocks, Larry and Roger, are both moving at close to lightspeed in opposite directions relative to Alice, who has missed them terribly for the last 10 billion years. In other words, any discussion of how tossed rocks move over time must also account for the relative velocities added by space expansion. That makes them accelerate, not stop.