Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 453617477.mp4

Downloads

Content

We've got a new video coming out next week on the Citicorp Center engineering crisis!

We’d love to hear your feedback and suggestions as we wrap up this video. Some animations and b roll are still in progress.Is there anything wrong? Any questions we didn't answer? Rough explanations that lack depth or clarity? Let us know!Thanks everyone!

-Sulli and the Ve team

Files

Comments

Kyle Nishioka

The part of the story about bolts vs. welds (basically time codes 15:00 thru 17:00) may be confusing to non-engineers and I believe it distracts from the main narrative . I don't know of an easy way to describe this without derailing the main story. I've heard this story before on a couple occasions. Those stories always gloss over or simplify the technical details. All the audience needs to know is that the structure was weaker than it was intended to be. The narrative of what was done to rectify the flaw is the important part of the story.

Dave Muth

Great story. Well told.

Alexis Gaziello

I wish they would have kept the gothic church! The mix between modern, clean, metal and glass from the new building and flamboyant, mystical, ornate from the ancient church would have offered an amazing contrast

Tony Winter

Excellent and fascinating story. Video looks good. Great job.

Gregor Shapiro

22:09 you say what sounds like "string gauges" which probably should sound more like "strain gauges". [String gauge is the thickness/diameter of a guitar string. It's measured in 1/1000th of an inch.] [A strain gauge (also spelled strain gage) is a device used to measure strain on an object.]

Gregor Shapiro

The stilts would have had to be MUCH taller and perhaps the central post narrower...

H C Adams

Not an engineer but understood the bolt vs welding explanation. More bolts = more strength. Welding is stronger than lots of bolts.🤓

Kimberly Green

1. Is continuous strain-gauge monitoring a standard practice now, for buildings over X meters tall? If not, why? 2. Are engineers now required to model air speeds in a wind tunnel, with existing buildings factored in, to account for effects like wind funneling, multi-directional wind forces caused by surroundings creating choppiness, probable direction(s) of castastrophic failure so that targeted evacuation plans can be formulated, etc?

Veritasium

I also wish they would've kept the gothic church! But LeMessurier is quoted as saying he hated the gothic church so I guess there was never any chance. -Sulli

Veritasium

Thank you! I specifically included the points about the bolts because other stories gloss it over. They tend to jump to the point 'They used 4 bolts where they really needed 14!' which is a crazy jump to me. I never understood how it got that bad, so I wanted to explain it. -Sulli

Lew Yobs

1. Curious as to the cost of remediation vs. the original $0.25M saved by bolting. If figures are available.

Charles S. Cook

Very informative. I recall seeing a story on this on one of those tv or streaming channels a few years ago, but your take has more detail. I appreciate your viewpoint and compliment you on your team's work, it seems flawless, but you better check against an oblique approach!

Dan_in_SD

My question would be, are there any buildings in the world right now that haven't gone through as much scrutiny but deserve to be?

Kyle Nishioka

That's not really the take away that a structural engineer should focus on. The real issue is that the contractor substituted bolts for welds in the first place. If there were a catastrophe I'm fairly sure that would have been identified as a significant deficiency.

C.J. Smith

7:42 Acoustical engineer here (we deal with building acoustics and vibrations as well) - The more proper term is "damping" rather than "dampening". My vibrations class professor would be very annoyed by "dampening" haha. You use the correct word (and forms of it) at 8:33 and other places. And boy am I used to getting annoyed at construction people deciding they want to save money by changing the plans... 16:25 I suppose you're likely aware of the unfortunate white board/verbal math error, since you put the correct number on the screen in a little. Though either way, those specific numbers don't quite round to 10, though maybe for rounding reasons that happen before getting those whiteboard numbers it ends up working out. Good video!

M0rsla

This was a really interesting piece. Well done!

Kyle Nishioka

I remember other tellings of this story. One of them said that Citicorp did eventually sue the engineer for remediation costs but voluntarily limited their claim to the E&O insurance policy cap.

Veritasium

1. No, definitely not! Those we just emergency measures. If fact, LeMessurier himself doubted the usefulness of the strain gauges since it would basically give them very little warning. It would be pretty excessive to monitor most buildings - and very expensive. 2. I'm not sure if wind tunnels are required (this very much depends on the area you are building!), but according to NYC code, you are now required to consider wind in all directions. I believe in some wind tunnels, they essentially do the worst case scenario, which is no other buildings around (basically, you aren't protected by any of your surroundings). That misses some factors (wind getting much faster through a narrow gap in two buildings and then hitting your building), but for the most part does the job. -Sulli, writer for this video

Veritasium

These are the numbers from LeMessurier - and he rounded to the nearest even number, probably due to the fact that the bolt design needs to be symmetric. I do wish he rounded UP to the nearest even number so yes that is unfortunate haha. I'll update that bit about dampening vs damping! - Sulli

Veritasium

Certainly, but that's usually a secret. Here's a quote from LeMessurier from his lecture (available on youtube!) -Sulli

Veritasium

Student: What is your opinion about the number of other buildings out there where people were quite as responsible as you? LeMessurier: Well, there are some. I can't tell you where they are because that's the secret. I have some very good friends in the engineering profession. And some of them, as in my advice from time to time. And there's a building in the major city. I think it may be going to get finished, but it is a very important building owned by a very important national corporation. I'm not going to give you any clues where the city is. It's not Boston in New York. But anyway, it was designed by perfectly competent engineers who who, because of the code, didn't say they had to do it, actually never even calculated the deflection of the building. Can you imagine that?

Veritasium

LeMessurier said that one original design, (kind of building a standard framed tower on a 'table' of sorts) which the bank agreed to, would have cost around 6 million more than this design that ended up having problems. So the 4 million cost for the repairs, were not that much compared to the overall cost of the tower. In terms of who paid, I believe the insurance of the architect and LeMessurier in total paid 4 million. Cost estimates range up to 8 million, but that's not confirmed. -Sulli

Veritasium

I don't think the bolts would have been a problem if they had been designed properly, which is what that section is trying to address. There were two fundamental mistakes: 1. They didn't look at quartering winds which is an increase in force. 2. They didn't use the right safety factor when calculating the number of bolts. The switch from welds to bolts wouldn't have been a problem if they hadn't made those mistakes. After all, LeMessurier heard about the switch in May and didn't think it was a big deal until he re-did his quartering calculations. Good notes- still trying to improve it with the footage we have. -Sulli

Dan_in_SD

Cool article on NY skyscraper 1 Seaport. I haven't heard of it but the whole saga fascinates me. I wonder if anyone would buy those condos in a leaning tower.

Timothy-Douglas Alvey

Excellent topic. As CAD Draftsman for a plumbing and HVAC company, I drew a lot of plumbing/piping and ductwork. Your show got me thinking about a project we did for fire sprinklers outdoors and in refrigerated spaces (using an “antifreeze” mix instead of water). The fire-sprinkler piping references do not take into account the viscosity changes that occur when various additives are used. l’m not Mechanical Engineer and you’ve got me wondering, if there will be a “trickle” to put out a fire, at the end of the pipe. I’ll try not to lose too much sleep.