Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 532816998.mp4

Downloads

Content

DEADLINE FOR FEEDBACK 16/09 - 4:00 PM UK TIME We've got an exciting video coming out very soon!We’d love to hear your feedback and suggestions as we wrap up this video all about Alfred Nobel! It's rough around the edges as we still need to shoot some MOTS (Man on the street) and finish final anims etc. but as always we appreciate you watching and reviewing this cut! Is there anything wrong? Any other questions? Anything more you'd like to see? Explanations you think don't do a good enough job or lack depth? Let us know!

Thank you so much!-Team Ve

P.S. Make sure to double check if the final version is up on YT before you watch and comment!

Files

Comments

Gregor Shapiro

The lake west of Stockholm, Mälaren should be pronounced correctly: The pronunciation of "Mälaren" the Swedish pronunciation being roughly MEH-lah-ren (IPA: [ˈmɛ̂ːlarɛn]), featuring an open 'e' sound and a slightly rolled 'r'. Google "Mälaren pronunciation"

Liam

Definitely clarifying I never knew the story of Alfred Nobel the last thought of mine was that maybe he was a real world Tony Stark. Nothing to complain about but I am not an expert on this subject mabey do a video on rockets and I'll go to town on you.

Gregor Shapiro

32:19 three repeats of "... unlike dynamite it is highly water resistant"

Eric M

I was going to post this but I wasn't sure if it was a glitch with my playback but I can attest to the same problem

Vishal Bondwal

Very nice video. Micro stuff: In the location at 4.23, 20.36, 25.33, Derek's voice is a bit echoey compared to other places, but acceptable. When Henry comes in ~5.24 , it feels like he is not properly introduced. Took me a while to realise he was Henry, just without the hat. Some kind of halo or shadow on the camera/lens around ~25:07, before the big explosion. Others have commented on the triplicate voice around 32.19. Macro view: The parts where Derek and Henry are sitting around the coffee table start to seem staid after a while, and Derek seems like a sidekick to Henry, both due to location in the frame, the slouched pose/chair, and the impression of low energy. In some of these segments, it might be better to have Derek speak directly to the camera, or have animations or pans over newspapers/photos/chemical formulas etc on the screen. For most of us, Derek is Veritasium, it feels odd to have him seem like an also-ran in his own video. This is just my two cents, the wider audience might feel nothing different. Henry's parts are good to watch as well in both presentation and content. Usually when Derek is repeatedly shown having such extensive discussions, it is with various external experts, which seems more authoritative. The body language is more positive towards the end, in the segment in the 45-46th minute. The video is overall pretty solid in terms of content and portraying the scientific, human, and historical angles. Very nicely scripted.

Charles S. Cook

As usual, very informative and well done. You produce some very good stuff that is well-thought out and I do appreciate that--you also attract people who are very detail-oriented and who offer very good observations. In comparison, I find it difficult to find anything noteworthy. Bravo!

Kate Proctor

About minute 45, you two express your opinions about WHY Nobel created the prize. That was wasted time. Much better is the end where you pose the question for the audience to form their own opinion. Veritasium is about truth, fact. Your opinions about the motivations of a dying man are... superfluous. Also, then, your conclusion at the very end (that it doesn't matter WHY Nobel created the prize), makes ALL of that discussion moot, and therefore more wasted time? IF you wanted to shorten the video, less detail about all the different forms of explosive, and the details about why they work differently, could be shortened or even deleted. IF you are going to have all the chemical detail, I think expanding a bit about the differences between dynamite and trinitrotoluene would be good. That section did not clearly answer the question of their differences.

John Cox

@37:02 "what he thinks back to is guncotton" Too early? "Guncotton" not introduced yet (by name, at least). Also this whole section is very interesting. I didn't know that Alfred was also involved with the creation of smokeless gunpowder. @39:02 "...silencers," Careful: "Suppressors" is the modern term and many people will call you out, but "silencer" would be more historically accurate. Correction: He didn't actually patent a silencer (if I'm reading this right). He didn't finish the application according to the list of his patents on https://www.nobelprize.org/alfred-nobel/list-of-alfred-nobels-patents/. Specifically, Swedish patents, 1894: "Patent number 845. Sound and recoil inhibitors for firearms. (Application not completed.)" I found this in Swedish Patent Database entry from 1894 (unlabeled, no name), and I wonder if it looked something like this: https://tc.prv.se/spd/patent?p2=qKpq7tlFwtE&hits=true&from=1894&to=1894&lang=en&tab=2&hitsstart=0&start=2 The first "silencer" patent (that I could find) for the US was US-0880386-A in 1908 to Hiram Maxim for a "Silent firearm." (period officially included in title). He filed a second patent in 1909 under US-0916885-A, also for "Silent firearm." Note: If searching US Patent Office, only use the number. @39:15 "allegedly captured this image" So he invents a rocket camera too? Impressive. @39:58 "Samuel Colt, I guess, invented the automatic gun, essentially" Correction: He did not. He is credited with inventing the revolving cylinder, which is part of the reload mechanism, but is not an automatic cycler. The inventor of the automatic gun is credited to Hiram Maxim, who also patented the "Silent Firearm" mechanisms. @41:46 "The entire modern practice of terrorism..." Correction: This was a copycat, not the first. Some 40 years prior in 1881, Tsar Alexander II was assassinated by dynamite. @43:14 "In 1888" You sure this was then he broke? The Nobel Prize website lists patents lists something for firearm sound and recoil inhibitor as late as 1894 (application not finished). @43:16 "read that paper, 'The Merchant of Death'" Does "that paper" mean we were supposed to know about this?

John Cox

@10:37 "Yet Sobrero..." Lost the continuity. He hasn't been mentioned for over 5min. Maybe say, "Alfred's mentory Sobrero" to reintroduce him? @14:28 "In 1852, when Alfred returned to Russia..." Time paradox. Painting @3:15 says that the naval battle at Sinope was 1853, and was said to be before Alfred was sent off to Paris. @15:19 "By the summer of 1862..." How big was this time gap since he left on his own? @17:04 carved out the exact imprint of the bottle" Not seeing it. Can we get a highlight? @20:07 "on a floating barge" Where is the barge in the inset photograph? I see what looks like a shoreline workshop. @20:57 the temperature inside can increase by thousands of degrees Celsius in an instant." Is this hyperbole? That is a huge increase in a near zero time frame. @23:00 "drifting over the banks of the [something]" Could we get a subtitle for it? @24:08 (mixing nitroglycerin) Careful you don't get demonetized with this footage over "instructions on making an explosive" or something like that. @25:09 (explosion) Is this footage of the dynamite? This looks like a conflagration, not a detonation. @26:09 (tony stark pose) I see you artist, whoever did that, and I appreciate you. @28:30 (sweating dynamite) This answered a question I had forgotten. Fascinating. @28:47 "...in his home lab..." When did he stop using the barge? @33:00 "and business boomed" I see your pun writers and appreciate, but if gelignite was so useful, why don't we hear about it much after this? Is it because dynamite is easier to throw at people? @36:06 "up until that point people had been (mild violence descriptions)" Careful: People may call you rude things if you say that this kind of violence was the worst that humanity had seen until that point. I hear you making a point that the speed and ease of use and destruction of these explosives was new, but including "bruising" on the list with weapons of war doesn't sit right. @36:29 (re-enactment of Confederate forces from Civil War) Careful: Display of Confederate grey will be very divisive for US audience. Mistimed footage?: Discussion sounds like present time, but Civil War in United States was 1860s.

Liam

Same here

Doctor Why

When I was teenager late 60's I saw short film about him on TV. I'm pretty sure it was a 1939 MGM production. One of the things I still remember from that old film is that dynamite was sort of discovered by accident. Amazingly, I found it! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RN7dNUg2Jow I think yours is great. The MGM, hmmm! With that said, I do not think that the last few minutes are a waste of time. In general I don't care much about opinions, I care more about facts as in verifiable facts, not the alternative kind. There are times when solidly informed opinions and reflections after the fact can be valuable educational tools.

Derek Muller

thank you for the detailed feedback!

Derek Muller

thanks for the detailed feedback! This is really helpful

Derek Muller

I did look at this pronunciation - I thought I had it for when talking to camera. When I was doing VO, I had a different phonetic spelling in front of me. We will fix

Ryo One Shoe

The background music seems a bit overpowering in several areas. Though it could just be me since i am very hearing impaired. The amount of time spent with Henry and Derek talking together makes it feel more like a podcast as a opposed to a video. Im not personally opposed to the idea, but probably not the best format for an informative video meant to grab peoples attention.

Autumn Leonard

I'm too late for this one, I know! When showing slow-motion footage, it would be helpful to see a multiplier in addition to camera FPS. Without knowing playback speed, camera speed doesn't mean anything (I'd assume 24fps, but it could just as easily be 30 or 60). It gets even more complicated if, say, you master the video at 60fps and upload it at 30. Great video, BTW!

Timothy-Douglas Alvey

“Gelignite” is unfamiliar, however, Plastique has been known (from spy movies) for years; that grey “Playdough”.