Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It's that time again. I'm rushing to finish a video before tomorrow morning. If you have a chance, I'd love to get your thoughts. I find the feedback here on Patreon always improves the quality of the videos. Note: I'm planning a section on applications for the end.

Files

World's Lightest Solid!

There are applications coming at the end... Please put comments on Patreon. Thank you!

Comments

William W Smith

What's the solid in the aerogels you examine? I didn't hear what the CO2 is embedded in.

Alipasha Sadri

Cool video! (I saw Tyson's video a few days ago showing off his stash of aerogel to Adam Savage) At about 0:48 you say if we removed air, what remains (for some types of Aerogel) can be less dense than air; but to me that implies that the remaining "material" is less dense than air... which means there are solids that are less dense than air. Since I cannot see how that is an impressive fact, I assume you meant that the object defined as the convex-hull of the aerogel block minus air, can be treated as "being less dense than air". But the way it is created, suggests that the "void" parts of it are "connected" so unless we are sealing the boundaries of the block, the block cannot be considered less dense than air. Perhaps there is a convention out there when talking about "material density" that I don't know so this might be an ignorant comment! :D In which case, I see myself out :D

Mark Tea

I think he said its Silicon. Also, super cool video. Nice clicky thumbnail making me think you were going to make it levitate.

Glenn Watson

The start of the video seems very dull and low contrast

Charles Bosse

I am so sharing this. Also, maybe I will try to make some aerogel... I agree with the comment above that I was hoping to see you make it float by blowing on it. Maybe for the end screen? "Post credit" scene?

Glenn Watson

Also the "we are going to put two bunnies over a Bunsen burner" seemed a bit abrupt and out of place, eg there was no real introduction til that point.

Alipasha Sadri

I think it might be just me having that take on the "Density". It probably comes from my soil mechanics class in which the "solid" structure of the soil has one density, and the "soil" as the whole solid+gas+liquid can have other densities.

Alipasha Sadri

start and the kitchen parts seem very low contrast.

Glenn Watson

A very interesting video though, I always wonder what aerogels feel like to touch.

John Gagan

Fascinating subject and great video! My only suggestion is that you might move the segment at the end (where you discuss the insulating qualities of the aerogel) to an earlier part of the video - because for the entire video I was wondering about why it insulated so well, and I almost thought you weren’t going to discuss it. Thanks!

Bruce Goren

I am assuming that your section on applications will discuss the cost of making the material as well.

Kimberly Green

How about telling us where we can get our own little sample to play with?

Eric Kennedy

"What is it like to hold a piece of the sky?" while holding the aerogel so that it appears blue as in your kitchen. That's an attention-getter. I'd like to know more about the practical uses of aerogels, especially for industry and everyday use. I saw an animation of the LHC (I think) while you mentioned uses but I don't remember hearing you specifically mention this. Fascinating stuff!

katgod

I just want to second this, I suspect that there are a number of people who would be interested in purchasing the material assuming it is not too expensive.

katgod

I am going to mention this and you can remove it if you don't think it is appropriate but there is a guy on youtube that goes by the title "applied science" who will show you how he made aerogel. It is not easy.

Madison Bombardier

I second that click baity title about holding the sky

Uwe

could you go into real-world applications into detail? this seems a bit too much like a scientific playground

Gary Russell

I saw a glimpse of NASA near the end. I wonder if the thermal tiles which protected the space shuttle during reentry are similar gels or are they ceramic? What different or similar manufacturing method produces the thermal tiles?

Eric Jensen

The cold open is a bit abrupt. I would show the aerogel on your hand in profile against a black background and something along: "this is aerogel. A fascinating material with terrible thermal conduction". I really liked the color explanation and the supercritical explanation. It might help with a phase-diagram showing the liquid-solid-gas relation

Veritasium

I can link to a site in the description

Veritasium

I'll do some applications in this video but I will likely do more in a future video.

Veritasium

so interestingly, aerogel was considered as a material to embed in the tiles and also a material to use underneath the external tiles. But neither ever came to fruition...

wolph

I loved the video but I found the ending a bit abrupt. Perhaps a tiny outtro telling us where to go for more info about aerogels? Will this be a series perhaps?

Mordecai Glicksman

For those viewers who haven't heard of Forward-Looking InfraRed, you may wish to define "FLIR" when you use it. Since you don't want to insert a discontinuity to your narrative, I guess the text "FLIR = Forward-Looking InfraRed" would appear on the screen as you are introducing the camera to the viewers (or vice versa…).

Ken Schwarz

Very interesting! Suggest you spend a bit more time on the concept of super-critical liquid and the autoclave. Would be interesting if there are methods for producing this at scale and/or on-site. Also, in many places contrast is too low—hope you can fix that in post. Thanks!!

Chris K

Ya. I saw the JPL logo at the very last second and was like: YES, now we come to aerogel being in satellites! and ... dark. which gave me two things: zero applications and what has the vid to do with JPL? probably the labs are there, so i just missed it, no?

Andrew Newhouse

Overall great! Clear, understandable, and fascinating. I'm curious how durable the finished aerogel is, and how it feels. You describe the silicon-based material (before liquid CO2 treatment) as quite fragile, but how does that compare to the aerogel? I see it's packed on bubble wrap, but it seems sturdy on the ring stand. How variable can it be? There's a brief mention of different materials that can potentially form jellies, but how many of those can be transformed into aerogels, or is there only one unique formula? Also interested in applications - and related to that, costs or limitations of producing it at scale. Thanks, very interesting!

Cristiano Toncelli

Very good. Two suggestions. 1) Jumping back and forth from the bunny to the process of making aerogel with CO2 was a bit confusing. At least for me. 2) I was left with a question. Aerogel is made removing the liquid from the "jelly". But how is a jelly made? Except in a kitchen, of course.

Emil Suleymanov

- I wanna try that chocolate - ~~gross~~

Tim Ternstrom

With that cover shot, I thought it was going to be about sleep or something like that. That was an interesting video. You should talk about some of it's strange uses, like trapping comet dust.

Miles

I have some pieces of aerogel at home. Very cool stuff. :-)

Nomubiku

So cool! I wanted to know what the density felt like. I wanted to see you squeeze it. Would the slightest breeze whisk it away? How big a piece can be made? How fragile is it? Could you make something out of it that is extremely durable in addition to all it's other wonderfully beneficial properties? The quick flash of the NASA sign at the end felt odd.

Vittal Rao

Wow. The video on shadeballs was really counter intuitive. Looking forward to receiving one.

Yves

Dan Kennedy

I’d probably delete this off here if I was you, I wouldn’t want my address posted online, he’s going to send them to people from their address which is on their profile, make sure it’s in there!

Rob Alinder

I bought some areogel on ebay 10 years ago, or so. really fun stuff to play with, although boy is it fragile. I always likened the texture to microscopic styrofoam... it even makes the same squeeky noise when you rub it. Now I understand why!

Patrick Čalija

So you are Head of e-commerce at HP, impressive, however, you should be a bit more careful about sharing your personal information online... Btw your daughter looks really cute, congrats! :)