Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Does this video make sense? I think it does but I'd love to know your thoughts. What do you like/dislike? Anything unclear? Thanks for being first to watch this and offer your feedback.

Best,

Derek

Files

Intermediate Axis Theorem - Explained intuitively

The Dzhanibekov Effect & Tennis Racket Theorem explained intuitively. Part of this video was sponsored by LastPass, click here to find out more: http://bit.ly/2RZZTZk

Comments

Sreyleak

I love it. I love when you bring a topic that we don't usually see. And it is very detailed too 😊

Sreyleak

"...proving feymann wrong.." oh my 😮

SkaveRat

Now I wonder: what happens with 4D objects with 4 axis of rotation?

Candice Sheaffer

I think the video is extremely interesting. I will need to watch it a couple more times to make sure I understand it all, but that should be no problem because the topic and delivery was very compelling.

Riley Willis

This is exactly what I was waiting for

MATTHEW SLAGLE

I liked the video. Is the axis with the greatest moment of inertia the one with the mass farthest away from the axis? Also, I think you will get many more views if you give it a title about the Earth flipping over.

jubs

It's a really good video, but I think you need to have a decent grasp of inertia to really get the explanation. Not sure how much more intuitively it can be put though. I might have missed it, did you at any point specify that in a theoretical situation, where there's no air resistance and you can absolutely perfectly impart force on the object, you could make it rotate without flipping even around the intermediary axis? Oh, and 100 bonus points for having an Aerobie Pro Ring featured, those things are insane. =)

Daniel Wisehart

I think it is a very good start. What is not clear to me is why the small masses on the spinning disk start to accelerate instead of damping back down to their original position on the Y-axis. I think you later said the system needs to dissipate energy for this effect to be seen in satellites like Explorer-1. But dissipating energy would seem to return the system to the lowest energy state, which would seem to be with the largest moment of inertia.

Jorge Cazares

Woah my brain hurts. I still don’t understand why the intermediate axis keeps flipping. I see the animation but it’s just not intuitive to me. For example, it would have been simpler to say that the baby bottle flips longways because the fluid wants to push out in the farthest orbit and flips the bottle outwards along the path that helps the fluid have the largest orbit. I don’t get why the nut keeps flipping. Help! :(

IcyMidnight

Works quite well, though I found the disc animation during the centrifugal forces on the small masses section to be not very helpful. I might have chosen a different viewing angle. Additionally you're talking about the small masses accelerating, but the arrows seem to be staying the same until they suddenly start growing and then they're huge. Is the change in the arrows not there or just hard to spot?

Diogo Vincenzi

Interesting, and the explanation is clear! I especially liked that the physics was quite old, heh.

CharlieRose

I'm probably the only one but the background moving in the expectation gave me motion sickness but I am extremely sensitive to visual induced motion sickness. It's worth it though because I finally understand this. thanks!

Daniel Wisehart

One more thought. Wouldn't a planet be a lot like the spinning disk? If the largest masses are at the equator and the planet is disturbed by the nearby passing of a large mass, wouldn't that disturb the planet the same way the spinning disk is disturbed, causing the planet to eventually tumble? Sorry if this is a stupid question.

Sven Ottawa

Very well done! You did an amazing job creating this video.

Pavel Richter

Good job! I like it. Maybe show the same switching rotation from 09:25 but with stationary axes (like 07:40 for example). Thanks Derek for your work :)

Uri Rothschild

basically great video. a bit long, though. also i'd move the part about optmizing energy and looking for the maximum moment of inertia to am earlier part. also maybe mention that the extra rotation could be prevented by an absoluy perfect spin (for some objects at least).

Mike Hix

It was a bit difficult to understand the relationship of centrifugal and centripetal forces and the masses and why the small masses experience the forces they do. It might be easier to understand if you isolate the small mass on-screen and describe what forces it's experiencing - kind of like how people describe orbiting as continuous falling. This also seems to be loosely related to the way that inverted pendulums are unstable.

Shane Cline

Great video. The animated model was really impressive and provided a lot of clarity for me. Fascinating stuff.

Bruce Goren

While I would love to say that it all makes sense now, I agree that my brain hurts. I understand in concept, kind of, but not sure if the animation helped or made me a bit dizzy. And would this effect be eliminated if the object was perfectly balanced and spinning perfectly? All this makes me wish I had taken some physics classes in college...

Vincent Zalzal

Agreed. I had to listen multiple times to the part describing the forces on the small masses. The fact we're working in the spinning referential is also unusual, I must say I forgot how all of this work!

Bryce Clark

I really like this video man! I wonder if the moons gravity also keeps the earth from flipping? This is so fun to think about lol

Jeremy Schwartzentruber

Hi Derek. t's a great video, and like you I have always been curious about why this kind of flip occurs, ever since flipping a tennis racquet as a kid! But I did have trouble following a couple of the key points, despite watching the portion at 7 - 9:30 min a few times! This could be because I've never dealt with a rotating frame of reference. Still, there are two things that I think could be clearer. First, your explanation doesn't describe why the change appears as a sudden "flip". When looking at the screw in space, it appears to be so stable until just before it flips. Second, why does the tennis racquet make a single flip of its face? Maybe addressing that would make the video too long, but you did focus on the tennis racquet quite a bit at the start! (And that's the effect that I'm most familiar with... probably others too.) A couple other points: - At 7:46 I found it hard to follow the transition to rotating with the disc... the background lines just didn't make it clear visually what was going on. - At 8:50 you said that the small masses are more or less constrained to lie in the Y-Z plane. I guess you just mean - constrained to be close to the Y axis? Isn't the plane in which they're moving parallel to the X-Z plane? Despite these points, it's a super interesting video, and the history really adds to the story. Thanks for your great work!

Jeremy Schwartzentruber

One other comment. I understand why a rotating object would go to the lowest energy state... but I didn't understand why that had to be the state with the lowest kinetic energy. For example, why couldn't energy be dissipated as heat in a rotating water bottle without it flipping to spin on the long axis?

Adam Flareau

The explanation you give is clear, but I feel the animation doesn't add anything the way it is shown.

David Hale

Definitely post this! Fairly easy to follow. My buddy and I watched this together, we are first year engineers at Notre Dame very fascinated by this sort of thing; the graphic of the spinning disc with point masses was particularly helpful. Thank you, Derek.

Leonardo Aguiar

I think the disc animation is cool but the symmetry makes it confusing. I think 3 things could improve it. 1) a slower pace, 2 & 3) a non symmetrical object and background.

Ciaracanth

I think the animation might be more helpful for the intuition if you had more visual feedback on rotation than just the grid, like a "top" and "bottom" to the space that are different colors for example. I did really enjoy the video though.

David Bachetzky

Could it be, that it sounds a little bit like you're making bad Terry Tao for not appearing in your video? Seems slightly sulky to me, when you say "fair enough"!? ;) Just a feeling, great video anyway!! :)

Rony Gozes

Hi Derek, great video. Maybe at 9:00 when you explain that the small masses accelerate more as they get farther from the y axis, and slow down after they pass the half point, you can give a short explanation as to why that is. Maybe something about it not being a stable minimum, but a maximum point. Like a ball rolling down a hill just to stop at the top of the next hill or something.

Michael Lloyd

Well done. Feynman wasn't wrong, he just chose not to answer the question :) Don't believe me? Just ask him lol

Veritasium

The centrifugal force points away from the rotational axis so it leads to amplifying motion rather than damping it. This is quite different from the later discussion of why the first axis is unstable in the case of energy dissipation.

Stefan Grunspan

The animation and explanation were an excellent non-mathematical explanation of the Int Axis theorem. Also Terry was my advisor when I was a math major at UCLA. Terry rocks.

Norman Margolus

This is really lovely, Derek! Two tiny niggles. One is that mentioning constraint forces in the middle of the critical part of the explanation is perhaps distracting. You could just say the small masses are stuck to the disk. The second is that you might consider either foreshadowing or summarizing the critical point, that forces acting at the sides quickly amplify any small deviation from the intermediate axis.

Tobias C. Eikeland

Great video! But maybe a different (a tad more exiting) title would be more suitable for YouTube? Just a thought! "The very super weird spinning effect explained"

Kimberly Green

New title: Secret Russian Wingnuts in Space - And the Intermediate Axis

JAYTEE

Awesome, I understood it so it must have been good 😂 Cheers, JAYTEE

Philip Freeman

Excellent as always, but I do think that the explanation of the acceleration of the small masses is not as clear as it could be. The critical parts of that explanation (from about 8:30 to 9:10) is gone over very quickly and the forces involved are not clearly shown. For example the tension forces are shown as if they came from the large masses... it is not clear to me at least what this represents or what the relevance is. The net force on the small mass is not distinctly shown, so the nature of the acceleration is also unclear. Would it be reasonable to: 1) show down the process, showing the path traced by the small masses so it's circular path in this coordinate system is clear 2) show the force acting on the small masses from the tension as a single force, perhaps constructing it from other forces in the animation. 3) Show the TOTAL of the centripetal force and the tension force, which is causing the acceleration of the small masses 4) trace the path of the small masses during the flip (in suitable slow motion or steps) with the changing forces 5) Then show the whole process at the speed you do, so the overall effect and its relative rapidity can be understood. In general I think that the set up for this particular point is strong, but it would be worth tracing these details.

Fmily

Very interesting. Makes me wonder about planets like Uranus that spins on their side. Is it possible their spin could be a result of the affect on the liquid bottles? Uranus is a gas giant and we sometimes treat gasses as liquids. Am I stupid or is that possible?

DJ Martinez

Feels like some of your older, more technical explainer videos. I liked that a lot about it.

Light ReLeaf

Agreed! It did seem to blow over a little quickly. Wonderful suggestions, Philip.

Michael Aichlmayr

Very good! Also, best sponsorship pairing and integration yet!

James McLean

Well I really enjoyed the video!

Marco Smith

Or why it won't flip over?

Marco Smith

I had that as well to start with.

Adam Berkan

Can you add an explanation of what the big masses are doing during the flip? It feels like whatever forces are applying to the small masses should also apply to the big ones, but I guess that's not true, probably because the big masses don't approach the axis or something. Is that right?

Randy B

8:24 This is all fine and good, but what if the disc is *never* bumped (or at least undisturbed for as long as possible)? Can an intermediate axis rotation be sustained without flipping?

Rob Nichols

Nice video. Here are some humble comments. When you move to the rotating frame of reference, it could be that the phrase "spinning with the disk" becomes a little confusing after you perturb the disk since we're no longer "with the disk." The isometric view when in the disk's frame is a little confusing since the background grid swishes back and forth. I have no idea how not to have that happen. You say that the disk is bumped while you are also moving the camera's position. It seems at first like a huge bump instead of just a change of perspective. After the bump, the camera moves back to its isometric location. The background grid does let the viewer know that this happened, but it was a little confusing. For the large masses, the centrifugal forces are yellow, and the centripetal forces are red. The centrifugal forces on the small masses are red, instead of yellow. Why the color change? Durring the "flip," what is going on with the centrifugal forces on the large masses? ​ "Spinning is not a specialty" is awesome.

Dragi Raos

I wasn't aware of this effect in its most dramatic form (I did watch your phone flipping video). I think that in this category of your videos, shall we call tham "non-philosophical", this is a strong candidate for the first place.

Pamela Wissenbach

Maybe be a little clearer about what the Moment of Inertia is.

Jonas

It would also be nice to explain why the forces on the big masses do not cancel the effect - or putting it another way - to which degree they participate.

Vipul Kapoor

Yup. I always need an explanation of this.

Jase Smith

Done well I’m pretty sure I understand it, would even attempt to explain it now in my own words, and glad you’re able to show off your humanness with you super spin ability :)

Jim Cruwys

I understand it from your explanation well done. I will just point out a couple of things you may want to look at. First one: When you say "bump" the object, maybe you should explain that no object ever spins exactly on its axis and that's why this effect always happens. Because you would need to have the object spin perfectly and that is impossible to do. I only say this as the objects like the wing nut and the t handle don't get any "bump" so this may cause confusion for some people. Second one: could you also do the explanation from an inertial frame of reference after the one from the spinning frame of reference. because then you would see the forces moving as though you were the astronaut observer.

iñigo

Derek, very nice video. Definitely worth to upload. Keep it up!

Joshua Rodman

I don't really understand why the forces accelerate the wobble and then decelerate it from this explanation. You state it does, but I don't have any idea why.

Chris K

When the disk was flipping, I lost track of which side was up. Maybe color the little masses differently or the two sides of the disk somehow. looking at your wood-disk-with-hole was okay for me and i could keep track of what was happening

Mike

I have discovered this thing when I was in school when I flipped table tennis racket in hand. Also same with my smartphone. This is funny that this is the same phenomenon.

Mike

I really like the video Derek. However for a simple human like me with busy but smart brains at work -> I did not fully get it. Interesting however! :)

David Beaumont

Yeah, explaining the "bumped" means "any imperfection in the stability of the rotation" would be nice.

David Beaumont

Skateboarders have known this theorem intuitively for many years (which is why some flips are so much harder than others) :)

Richard Kalhöfer

I think your explanation makes very clear why rotations around the first principle axis are stable and rotations around the second principle axis are not. But I guess that many people will wonder why rotations around the third principle axis aren't unstable as well after watching your video.

Richard Kalhöfer

The centrifugal forces are pointing away from the y-axis so the small masses decelerate while approaching the axis again.

Carl-Henrik Kristoffersen

Good video, good explainations, but I think the intro is to quick and too 'directly on'. Adding a few seconds at the very start, would help.

Ivan Gomez

I jumped on my chair when you reveal why the russians kept this a secret. That happens 10 minutes into the video. I immediately pictured the dilemma: - If you were to hint this thing about the earth way earlier in the video, you'll catch the attention of people that would otherwise not wait 10 minutes trough the explanation... - But doing that changes the flow of the explanation. :D

Richard Neilsen

Two bits of feedback: 1) If the explanation is true, why doesn't the same flipping effect happen when you spin it around the axis with the heavy point masses (the x-axis)? And why doesn't the flipping happen constantly, why does it happen at periodic intervals? 2) I really dislike explanations that are like "the bottle of water has no other choice but to spin about the axis with the minimum kinetic energy". It's like saying "balls roll down a ramp because they are seeking a low energy state". They're not sentient!

daan brinkers

I like it. It is a dificuilt subject but you made me understand it.

Hallejohn

I also think so. How it is right now - it's a real quick start.

Fabian Rosdalen

As stated before, different colors on the two different sides of the disk would help. But maybe also a light pattern to get the depth perception. :) Otherwise, awesome!

Michiel Ladenius

the part about the earth flipping was really interesting. But it felt a bit out of place. I thought it was odd that such a clickbaity topic was introduced that late into the video. Overall I think it is a really good video though :)

Mr. Hunter Jones

That is a good startling discovery at the beginning when humans see an effect of the laws of physics outside our experience. I enjoyed the journey of explanation that led to (guess what!) an explanation of how this fits exactly into the rules we already know.

Artur Metasov

Awesome video. A little bit unclear at which moment of time the flip will occur and why.

David Sherier

As soon as you start talking about a rotating frame of reference, it gets confusing. Besides that its a great video.

Lukaluke

So, I got a bit lost at times but I generally followed your explanations. If I understood correctly, the reason it flips is because when something is spinning it's not really perfectly rotating or weighted so that the small variations cause it to flip this weird way because that's where the forces push.

Bruce Grembowski

Great video! I'll echo others in saying that it starts a little abruptly. I am reminded of a book my wife had me read, "The Hab Theory." It is all about the Earth flipping.

Zachary Hammond

Fantastic video! I am a huge fan of the dynamics phenomenon videos that you have posted over the years. I'd love to see one on the rattleback some day.

Christopher Reichert

It makes sense to me, and I enjoyed it. The colored panels on the tennis racket make me think that the disc could do with having one side painted, but it isn't necessary and it might be a while before you can take it back to a zero gravity environment.

Phil Moyer

I really enjoyed this. The simulation with the masses on the disk helped make sense out of it. I also thought your explanation was good, and the sidebar information was quite interesting!

Noel Braganza

Amazing video Derek, I really like this one. I got lost a little in the middle when you were talking about centripetal and centrifugal forces with the 3D diagram, but that's because I've forgotten all my physics 🙈 but I still learned a lot.

Noel Braganza

You might also want to consider the name of the video to create more obvious intrigue. I'm not sure I was aware of this phenomenon until now

Rob Law

plays out (right around 8:35) is correct, but it took me a few views to get it... I kept thinking the arrows for the centrifugal forces should be pointing away from the center of the object. You say "away from the Y axis" (correct I think). Maybe further highlight the Y axis? And how the arrows show centrifugal forces away from that axis...NOT the center of the object (as with the prior analysis)?

Rob Law

Ugh...comment wouldn't post...then copy/paste didn't work. The first part of the message above is that I think the video is super close to being superb. I think the explanation of how a "bump" affects the rotation is correct (right around 8:35), but it took me a few views to get it..

Ricardo

Very nice video, could follow it until the conclusion that the centrifugal force ends up stabilizing the small masses again after the flip. Maybe elaborate on that a bit more? Great video otherwise!

Paul Giles

I'm watching Dianna's (aka Physics Girl) latest video and she has this brilliant guest on talking about Mars. One piece caught my attention after watching this video last night - Mars' axis tilts from 0 to up to 60 degrees. Is it possible that is because of the massive volcanoes shifting the center of gravity - changing the maximum moment of inertia? She seems like a really intelligent woman - I think you should marry her :)

Thomas Mackerley

From what I’ve seen Derek, yes, this video makes a lot of sense. It takes a very “physics intelligent” mind to understand this in simple terms in the first place. I’ve notice quite a few people on here still don’t get it. It’s the very subtle imbalance that is exacerbated while in space. It’s easy to see the tennis racket on Earth. It mainly has to do with the heavy sides overcoming the light sides. You see it clearly in the T in space. Once it starts to spin, it wobbles before the first flip, then it’s stable on subsequent flips

Veritasium

ok I'm working on it. And maybe it's confusing because the liquid filled bottle and the intermediate axis nut are different phenomena

Veritasium

Thanks for this point - I'm reworking the animations...

Veritasium

my wife got motion sick watching it too...

Veritasium

not a stupid question - the Earth is like the disk spinning about the z axis - stable with maximum mass going around.

Veritasium

Thanks Pavel - I'm rejigging that part of the animation so hopefully that will be fixed.

Veritasium

I really like that part and would like to move it earlier. Maybe I could cut some things...

Veritasium

Good idea! I'll work this note in...

Veritasium

yes, spinning perfectly. But that's basically impossible, especially for any length of time.

Veritasium

the angular momentum can't change so as the kinetic energy decreases, if it kept spinning in the same orientation angular momentum would decrease too - therefore rotating about a different axis allows angular momentum to stay constant even as KE decreases...

Veritasium

Got it - I'll work on those things.

Veritasium

yeah, they were projected behind me (this was a conceit of much of the video, but I can add some nice images of them)

Veritasium

I think the point being he's doing really important stuff. I didn't feel sulky about it at all. Just wanted to say I asked but the man is busy!

Daniel Wisehart

OK, I can see how that could be true. But how do you distinguish between the planet spinning about the z axis and spinning about the y axis? Couldn't the big blocks be the Americas on one side and Europe/Asia/Africa on the other side with the small blocks at the north and south poles?

Veritasium

yeah I was wondering about rephrasing that part. I'll stew on it some more...

Veritasium

Great suggestions. I'm working on a revision of the animation now...

Veritasium

My videos are like a box of chocolates... ;)

Veritasium

In theory yes, in practice I don't think so - because even a tiny bit off axis and the deviation will amplify.

Veritasium

haha - great notes. OK I will fix as many of these as I can

Veritasium

yes! This could definitely be explained better...

Veritasium

I'm working on it - hopefully I can make it more clear

Norman Margolus

Cool title! Maybe add a subtitle, like: an intuitive explanation of unstable rotations.

Uri Rothschild

the fact that you reply to these comments is yet another proof why your channel is awesome (and you as well of course :-) )

Jorge Cazares

Or Unstable Rotations: Will Earth Flip Over?

Irae Carvalho

I can follow the whole video pretty well. But I did have to watch 2 times for the flipping part. Even with red arrows, it was kinda hard to understand 2 seconds of balance, then a quick flip, then resting in balance again. Why it looks like it can "rest" from the axis flipping, exactly? If I trust you that this makes sense, the rest of the video is brilliant. And now that I am thinking about it, it seems to me that the unbalance might have an exponential factor? So it is barely visible most of the time, grows exponentially really quick, then breaks exponentially really quick, and spend another cycle again with barely visible unbalance?

Sven

Cool explanation. Got me exited for more of this kind of video. The spinning animation at around 8:20 was kinda dizzying though. I guess the distance to the grid wobbling got to me. Could be fixed by some animation trick that smoothes out the movement or something.

Jerrad Pierce

I like it, but the end begs the question: What about plate tectonics? Would Pangea or other supercontinent arrangements not have induced flipping?

Kolin Behrens

One thing I was confused on was that I didn’t realize the third axis was different from the second because they are spun in the same handle position, I was anticipating one of the axes to have the head parallel to the ground at all times, so maybe clarifying this would be helpful. The first two axes have a different racket starting position from the third.

Matt Dunlap

I have been wondering about this for 20+ years. Thank you (!!!) for answering the question in a way more satisfying than my physics 2 prof!

Veritasium

very good point - I'm reworking these arrows now...

Veritasium

whoa - I had no idea about that book! I have lengthened the intro now...

Veritasium

I think it's a gradual thing that builds up as those centrifugal forces build on the small masses

Veritasium

I don't think we'd get close to intermediate axis territory

Noel Braganza

How does 'Why does the nut (another word perhaps) keep spinning and flipping indefinitely in space - the intermediate axis theorem' ?

Noel Braganza

Also I had a question about why the tennis racket so quickly flips around when in fact your explanation talks about the gradual increase of forces in one direction keeps increasing till the flip happens. The tennis racket doesn't have the same spinning cycles since it flips almost immediately as it's thrown upwards

Magnus D. Magnus

I may be late to the party about suggestions but I think a diagram or an animation that explains the 3 axes of rotation of the racquet and their different distributions would be handy here. When it comes time to single out the intermediate moment, having the maximum and minimum moment's rotations would make a nifty wow pop for the viewer. Thanks for asking your patrons about this, it's fun.

Magnus D. Magnus

I just started a document a few nights ago that bumps up against this problem. I was trying to list some instructions for finding the centre of gravity for bilaterally symmetrical versus radially symmetrical objects. I'm just an enthusiast with no official education. Is there a proper lexicon for talking about differences in mass distribution of opposite segments of a symmetrical object?

Adrian Ritchie

I was just wondering how significant a shift of mass would be required in to to make the earth's rotation unstable? I assumed any tectonic movement would be so slow or small that the rotation would adjust with it, and any external addition of mass would be catastrophic to the planet... So nothing for me to worry about!

Tony Charlton

Great video, really interesting and the animation is really well done, it really helped. As for the Earth flipping im glad although would we feel it? And it would also be cool to get to know a different set of stars !

Bryce Stoddart Esquire

Excellent video. I wont say I totally understand it all but yes it done make it understanderable.

Bradley Crawford

I'm not sure if there is any left but he already shipped them about a month ago.

Jerrad Pierce

No idea, but since you mention Mars' wobble, it is a question that arises. Maybe somebody's done some modelling...

D N

make the bottom and top of the disc different colors

Norman Roldan

I recommend showing how the flipping eventually stops to better illustrate how the Earth may have done this billions of years ago, or how an object, like those shown in zero gravity, eventually end up spinning end to end.

Omer Demir

I have been waiting for the answer to the Intermediate Axis Theorem. However, one question: When the disk with point masses spins along the x-axis so that the small masses are moving, why don't the big point masses experience increasing centrifugal force (like the small masses in the video) and flip to the other side? In other words, why doesn't an object flip when spinning with the least moment of inertia?

Omer Demir

The "head being parallel to the ground at all times" axis is the same as the axis where the head is always parallel to the side. It's just rotated.

Omer Demir

It does; it's just that first of all, the shape of the tennis racket probably has an effect on the length and appearance of the cycles, and second of all, gravity overpowers all other forces by the second cycle and you need to catch the racket before you can see the second cycle in action.

Omer Demir

He did explain that the flipping only happens when the disk (in the explanation, not the Aerobie Pro Ring) is bumped, so I suppose that it is slightly implied that it is possible to make an object spin around the intermediate axis without flipping.

Omer Demir

Also extra note: Spinning things may not be your specialty, but it is mine... :D

Poker Chen

My current internal visualisation of this phenomena is a continuous transfer of angular momentum between the intermediate axis of rotation, and the other axes of rotation - somewhat like doing an elliptical orbit in phase space. I don't really understand the microstate explanation provided in the animation. It seems like not all of the forces are drawn once you bump the circle, so that it seems that the small masses are the only ones responsible for triggering the transition. The large masses should also play a part, right? Would you be able to explain in more detail the forces on each point mass?

Dmitry Zinenko

I did not understand why the large masses, experiencing even larger centrifugal forces are not able to stabilize the system similarly to what happens in gyroscopes. Intuitively, I also understand this phenomenon as an elliptic motion in the phase space between 2 unstable attractors.

Veritasium

They do stabilize it about one axis (but have no influence over perpendicular motion. What the animation shows better now is that they are more or less unaffected by the rotation of the small masses (this is in the extreme case where the small masses have negligible mass compared to the big masses)

Veritasium

I definitely looked at the phase space explanation. Hopefully the new version of the video cleared up some confusion. I think the role of the big masses is basically to set up and maintain the centrifugal force field, which they continue to do after the disk is bumped, so it is the small masses existing within this field that are responsible for the flip...

Veritasium

I think there are more to ship out...