Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I have long been fascinated by the intermediate axis theorem and I've come across it a few times when I wasn't expecting it. Here I think we've animated the best intuitive explanation of the effect.

Huge thanks to Patrons who reviewed an early draft of this video and provided very helpful feedback. I tried to incorporate it as much as possible.

This is an unpaid post because of the sponsor.

Files

The Bizarre Behavior of Rotating Bodies, Explained

Spinning objects have strange instabilities known as The Dzhanibekov Effect or Tennis Racket Theorem - this video offers an intuitive explanation. Part of this video was sponsored by LastPass, click here to find out more: https://ve42.co/LP References: Prof. Terry Tao's Math Overflow Explanation: https://ve42.co/Tao The Twisting Tennis Racket Ashbaugh, M.S., Chicone, C.C. & Cushman, R.H. J Dyn Diff Equat (1991) 3: 67. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01049489 Janibekov’s effect and the laws of mechanics Petrov, A.G. & Volodin, S.E. Dokl. Phys. (2013) 58: 349. https://doi.org/10.1134/S1028335813080041 Tumbling Asteroids Prave et al. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.icarus.2004.07.021 The Exact Computation of the Free Rigid Body Motion and Its Use in Splitting Methods SIAM J. Sci. Comput., 30(4), 2084–2112 E. Celledoni, F. Fassò, N. Säfström, and A. Zanna https://doi.org/10.1137/070704393 Animations by Iván Tello and Isaac Frame Special thanks to people who discussed this video with me: Astronaut Don Pettit Henry Reich of MinutePhysics Grant Sanderson of 3blue1brown Vert Dider (Russian YouTube channel) Below is a further discussion by Henry Reich that I think helps summarize why axes 1 and 3 are generally stable while axis 2 is not: In general, you might imagine that because the object can rotate in a bunch of different directions, the components of energy and momentum could be free to change while keeping the total momentum constant. However, in the case of axis 1, the kinetic energy is the highest possible for a given angular momentum, and in the case of axis 3, the kinetic energy is the lowest possible for a given angular momentum (which can be easily shown from conservation of energy and momentum equations, and is also fairly intuitive from the fact that kinetic energy is proportional to velocity squared, while momentum is proportional to velocity - so in the case of axis 1, the smaller masses will have to be spinning faster for a given momentum, and will thus have more energy, and vice versa for axis 3 where all the masses are spinning: the energy will be lowest). In fact, this is a strict inequality - if the energy is highest possible, there are no other possible combinations of momenta other than L2=L3=0, and vice versa for if the energy is the lowest possible. Because of this, in the case of axis 1 the energy is so high that there simply aren't any other possible combinations of angular momentum components L1, L2 and L3 - the object would have to lose energy in order to spin differently. And in the case of axis 3, the energy is so low that there likewise is no way for the object to be rotating other than purely around axis 3 - it would have to gain energy. However, there's no such constraint for axis 2, since the energy is somewhere in between the min and max possible. This, together with the centrifugal effects, means that the components of momentum DO change.

Comments

Flout

Hey man. My Ball hasn’t arrived yet. You know what’s up with that?

Crocs

Not that intuitive for me and I didn't really get the explanation with the disk and the different masses on it :-S

krankitup

Does this alternative intuitive explanation make sense? If we consider this frame of the video, starting at: https://youtu.be/1VPfZ_XzisU?t=452 we can see the centripetal forces applied on the big masses. This situation looks to me as a ball up at the top of a hill: it is in an unstable equilibrium, and the minimum perturbation will make it fall towards one side of the hill. Now, back to the disc: those big masses are pushed towards the center by centripetal forces in a similar way. The smallest perturbation will make the masses "fall" towards one side or the other, thus minimizing their moment of inertia, causing the disk to flip over. That will not happen when smaller masses are at the "top" since the big masses keep the system stable.

Patrick Čalija

Actually, the wooden disc with the hole in it made me understand it :)

Mike

Derek, you made some changes and video became clearer. Thank you!:) P.S. My ball has arrived weeeeeeeee! Thank you a lot. I feel like touched something from far away, like an asteroid from space.

BurnThe

it was a good video and i finally got my shade ball today number 3321

Steve Ruis

Awesome! Well done! You are a national treasure (strike that ... international treasure!)!

Daniel Turner

I was simply throwing shade about his ball issue.

Flout

Bruh

Paul Matthijsse

I got it weeks ago (the Netherlands) so something must have gone wrong with shipping.

Kiffaer

Hmm... this is the second vid in a row referencing flipped planetary bodies... I think Derek is trying to tell us something. 🤔

Tristan Ursell

Nice job Derek -- will show to my classical mechanics class at some point :)

Rob Nichols

Very nice video! Thank-you!

Poker Chen

It's really striking how an additional few sentences at 8:40 on how the large masses constrict motion will clarify why the flip occurs. This half-turn has to occur along the 1st/smallest axis (within the rotating frame), since the inertia of the large masses inhibit new rotations along the third/largest axis.