Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I have been working on this video for most of the month. I really like this topic but I also feel like it's a little fiddly.

So I'd love to get your feedback - what's working, what is confusing or could be done better. Also if you have ideas for titles and thumbnails, I'd love to hear them.

Thanks for helping me make these videos better!

Derek

Files

This Hidden Equation Pops Up Everywhere

Comments

Juveri Setila

Man, I feel like u are too critical about this stuff. Imo the video is great and there is nothing to be fixed ☺️ Keep up your great work and greetings from Finland

Mo Hassan

Fascinating insight into chaos and randomness. Thanks for explaining the Mandelbrot plot in easy-to-understand terms. I don't think it was too hard to follow, and you had my attention to the end (even during the plug for Fasthosts :) ).

Kevin

4.669. Nice.

Dragi Raos

Again, no suggestions... Great!

Mark Bryant

I'm not certain what you mean with fiddly, but if you're worried you didn't communicate the nature of the Mandelbrot set, the bifurcation along the real line, or the ratio... well, the only thing I can point out is that I remember all that but not the name of the scientist... or was he an engineer... who figured out 4.669. But I'm certain it'll be in the video citations in the description. 😉 Otherwise, this is a good introduction to some very complicated mathematics. But it is only an introduction. I'd be disappointed if you didn't follow up with some more detailed examples/possibilities for application. If you're familiar with PBS Space Time, then you know how they'll put together a short series of three to six videos on a topic that all lead further and further down... the rabbit hole. SWIDT? I would not mind at all if you started doing something like that, where you expose us to a topic, and then delve more deeply into it's meaning and impacts on science and society. Thanks for all the hard work!

Uri Rothschild

like it a lot. idea for thumbnail would be the image where you see the mandelbrot set from the side. title could be ''controllig chaos'' or ''controlled chaos''

SkaveRat

Really love this video. Maybe an example for the "jumping around" values in the mandelbrot set? That connection blew my mind

Line Wolff

Great video on a very interesting topic. I was hooked from beginning to end and even though I'm no mathematician I held on with no problem. I don't think you should change anything. It's great.

Scott Lowe

- Aspect ratio seems very wide? - 6:22 : Change "Looking at this diagram..." to "Looking at this bifurcation diagram...", because you immediately talk about a bifurcation diagram with the Mandelbrot set, without having defined the term previously. - I don't understand why you say the bifurcation diagram is part of the Mandelbrot set. To me, that makes it sound like the Mandelbrot set is self-referential. Actually, its just that the Mandelbrot set is defined as the values which converge for the fn and you can expand the diagram to show how they converge. So it's more like the Mandelbrot set is part of the bifurcation diagram, not the other way round! Certainly its interesting to see, but I think the relationship between the two is not currently described correctly. Good video, I like it, probably not going to go be viral though, I think. PS: If you want to do Brady a solid, you could link to one of his numberphile or Sixty Symbols videos on Mandelbrot set and/or Chaos. Maybe the one on The Feigenbaum Constant would make most sense. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETrYE4MdoLQ (make sure to "accidentally" mispronounce his name or the channel name if you do)

Madison Bombardier

Part of my undergraduate thesis was on the logistic map equation! (specifically using it to explore various visual characteristics/behaviours of chaos and the transition from non-chaotic to chaotic spaces) I was so excited to see your visualization of it here. A thing to add: some labelling when demonstrating the bifurcation aspect of the mandelbrot set. You say things like "z-axis" and "boundary between numbers that cause convergence and divergence", but the image wasn't oriented contextually, so I wasn't sure what type of space we were in. By the end I think I gathered that the z-axis is actually the imaginary axis. I think using that terminology, like "the mandelbrot image is the complex representation of the bifurcation diagram" or something. James Gleik's book Chaos is a fascinating and accessible resource for folks who are interested in this topic, I was glad to see a walk-through of many of his examples and a shout out to his work. I think this is a fantastic video and a good intro for this material. Relatedly, you mention the word "complex" right at the end. If you are interested in this kind of stuff, you might peruse the wikipedia articles on complexity science/complexity theory/complex systems/systems theory/emergence, and similar topics. The youtube channel Systems Innovation has many playlists on these concepts. This material follows naturally from this video, and actually your videos in particular over the past 8 or so years are partly what inspired me to look into these topics during my undergrad. It always seemed to me that you were dancing around these topics without realizing it, as many people do, and it helped me narrow in on the terminology and research related to these ideas.

Eric Jensen

I think we need a better explanation for how the Xn+1=r*Xn*(1-Xn) gives a parabola and a steady state. Maybe start at a point on the parabola and follow the iterations. Make it clear that the parabola is the y = x and the steady state is the iterative Xn+1 = Xn.

katgod

I agree with Mark Bryant and think Scott Lowe made some good comments. If you did a deeper dive on some of the things you mentioned it would help people understand some of the terms you used. I suspect that some casual watchers might find it hard to understand. Over all a very interesting video for someone who has read James Glick and other chaos authors.

Saketh Kasibatla

Love it! Only thing I would change is to add a couple sentences about why exponential growth is infeasible. Maybe something about how if left unchecked at that growth rate, rabbits would colonize the world or something lol

Florian Linscheid

Well I felt like you were a bit insecure in the beginning about how to introduce the whole topic. It worked in my opinion, but the whole flip chart and screen graphing was a little rough. Like you weren't really convinced how to do it. I don’t really have a solution to this, but I think it’s a noticeable difference from your usual style of presentation. From the technical point of view the echos in the rooms could have been dampened a bit more and your mic makes a lot of noise especially at 10:17. But it's not so bad that it's distracting. I feel like the bifurcations could have used at least one concrete step by step calculation to see how the values start splitting. Unless you want to leave this to the viewer, which seems to be fair as well. The whole water pot sequence doesn’t lead to anything really, since the metal box is just remotely related to the boiling in the pot. So I’m not sure if it’s helpful. And for the temperature probe in the box it’s not really clear to me where he measured that temperature. At the top of the convection ring? In its center? The ratios approach the Feigenbaum constant in the limit. So it’s not a hundred percent correct to say the the bifurcations come always in the same ratio. Those were the minor details I noticed. But all in all I find It a good introduction into chaos theory!

JDG

Derek, I think at 0:40 you should mention that the function is recursive.

JDG

Also, what program are you using to plot the function at 3:00?

David Durant

Really enjoyable but, depending on the target audience, perhaps a bit too quick in places. "Complex plane" got mentioned with no definition for example. Might be good to remind people what "r" as it feels referred to without context in the later half of the video. At the start it feels aimed at people without a specific background in math but by 2/3rds of the way through that felt much less the case. It'd be great to accompany this with something like a Nicky Case Explainable for people to play with. The rabbits section reminded me of the first computer game I ever played, back in 1982, showing the interaction of two feedback loops (foxes and rabbits) which you can now play here: https://archive.org/details/zx_Foxes_and_Rabbits_1982_Sinclair_Research_a. Always love your stuff - thanks.

Steve Dixon

This is like quantum mechanics for me. You drew me into chaos but it’s all way over my head. Now I want to see more videos on the subject and maybe cone back to this one when it makes more sense. The part that tripped me was the graph going from x,y to the mandelbrot part adding the z axis. More fractal videos from you would be awesome.

Dakramar

I think the video is great :) The last two vlog segments felt a bit slower in pace compared to the rest, but that's up to creative freedom :P

Tristan Ursell

5:17 -- "and then at r = 57 ... " 57? The critical value for the onset of chaos is r = 3.57. Great video :)

Patrick Nagelmaier

The pronounciation is weird at around 7 minutes, when you explain the equation: You pick a number "si" and start with "si" equals zero. The equation says c ("si") and z ("zed"). Also when describing the z-axis I was shortly confused at first, because I have never seen a "si"-axis on a diagram.

Tristan Ursell

Also, 7:09, back projection works much better for this kind of display, I have used high thread-count cotton sheets.

Tristan Ursell

When you say that you want students to be exposed to chaos (which I totally agree with), what exactly do you mean? For instance, many (most?) physics and math undergrads, and some CS, *are* exposed to it ... or at least, I have taught it and I know others have. Also, of interest in this topical space: http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Duffing_oscillator There's also a nice connection in there between hysteresis and chaos. Finally, I noted that you did not stress the "extreme sensitivity to initial conditions" which maybe is not relevant here. In another video, you could show how the logistic map can be used for symmetric key encryption .. i.e. as a deterministic pseudo-random number generator.

Kevin Davis

Thanks for the great 3D visualization of the Mandelbrot set! Since the values are complex, I'm assuming what's being plotted is the modulus of the equilibrium? If so, is there any pattern in the arguments of the iterated values?

Paul Looyen

Great video and fascinating, especially the universality part. You discuss the Mandelbrot set but you are assuming the viewer knows this and how this relates to the equation. I am conscious of length. Is it worth showing how the Mandelbrot set is generated? Look forward to seeing more on this aspect

Marco Trevisan

Amazing video! By the way, probably you know already, but another amazing example of system with regular and chaotic windows is the Solar System itself. It's fascinating how so many apparently unrelated systems share these patterns!

Veritasium

Really enjoyed Bradley's Feigenbaum constant video and will link to it - Wide aspect ratio is to be able to put two graphs side-by-side and look good.

Veritasium

I originally had cobweb plots in the video but they seemed to add complications without adding clarity.

Veritasium

I originally had this in earlier but moved it later because I didn't want to get bogged down just looking at the equation. Hence it's now part of the first example...

Veritasium

This was written in Python and we'll make it available on GitHub with the launch of the video.

Veritasium

thanks! I jumped right over complex plane to try to avoid it and because we don't need it to understand the bifurcation part of the set...

Veritasium

haha Americans say "zee" instead of "zed" but it is confusing when there is also a "cee" involved

Jerrad Pierce

The last bit with the many adjustments and crammed in Gleick reference might be polished, and someone who follows other educational channels, things were rather familiar and starting to drag a bit with the bifurcation and Mandelbrot setups, but the 3D reveal was really cool.

Veritasium

yeah I didn't want to go too deep on Mandelbrot from fear of it taking over the video. Hopefully most viewers will at least have some familiarity with it.

Veritasium

Python, and we'll make code available through GitHub when the video goes live

Andreas Fink

Great video, I really enjoyed it. The growing rabbit population reminded me of Leonardo da Pisa, better known as Fibonacci, who around 1200 wrote the liber abbaci, a textbook to make his fellow Italians familiar with Arabic numbers and teach them mathematics. That helped them a great deal to become successful merchants, as it is very cumbersome to do calculations with Roman numbers. To explain the Fibonacci numbers he also used a growing rabbit population. These numbers do not only define the golden cut (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fibonacci_number) but it also relate to a lot of phenomena in nature, e.g. the arrangement of seeds in a sunflower. That may well be worth a video too; or did you make one already and I missed it? These topics are definitely worth being taught in school. Make math fun!! I would also appreciate a link to the graphics program. (I just now created a spreadsheet in Excel and turned the numbers into a graph because I could not believe how bizarre this function behaves between 3 < r < 4) but the graphics program you used seemed to be more convenient.

Julika7

That's nice but I find it too mathematical to be expected from your channel. I'm expecting more physical physics. But maybe I just didn't get the math part. :^^

Melodie Bitting

Love the content, could use more bunnies and some animation when explaining population fluctuations

Veritasium

Vi Hart has a couple great videos on Fibonacci in nature. We'll publish code on GitHub when the video goes live for our visualizations.

mike beavington

IDK, that 18 minutes seemed to go by pretty quickly. Might have been better for a softer tangible opening. Maybe start with the drippy faucet or animated bunnies to capture the idea of chaos.

Brian Makepeace

Really depends which bit of audience you're pitching to? Bunnies before math maybe? I feel like the stable periodicity can be described with bunny populations and water drops before it is defined with math, while starting to refer to the branching graph. Then "But why? Well, this equation". I wonder if it's more accessible to root the idea in the easy to imagine material things first, then explain the equation up to the constant, then come back to convection, flickering light, and bunny hearts. I always remember your video "your mass is not from the higgs boson", the first 34s of that are incredibly tight, driving and well written, and the hook is more material before it gets especially abstract. 21 grams! ... But most of your mass doesn't come from higgs! etc This one sort of feels like it might be 3 videos? 1) Tale of the constant: bunnies, water drops, equation, constant, convection, defibrillation. 2) Mandelbrot + z is the constant, how cool is that? 3) Math dive on the computer where you show your working with the variables and grow the bifurcation tree one step at a time. 1) can end with does that look fractal to you? check out 2) etc... Does that make sense? It's a beautiful big topic, and I love how you've brought all of it together. I also feel like it might benefit from being parsed into chapters, keeping the first lower on math, and expanding into that with 2 and 3 maybe.... These are my thoughts Lots of love

Gary Nolan

There was a lot of stuff I didn't understand in this one, compared to most others. Definitely not familiar with the Mandelbrot set. I think it's still an interesting video, but it seemed entirely mathematical, whereas most other videos seem to explain things as seen in real life, that you then explain. Whereas this was all the explanation without showing anything real life that we observe to show how this info explains it, if that makes sense.

Daniel Wisehart

I don't find it fiddly at all. There are a few details that can be cleaned up, like when you are explaining the Mandelbrot set, we are seeing the computer generated graphic, but not you, and you say something like "the needle here", but there is nothing in the graphic that is pointed to: presumably you were pointing to the needle in the projection. The math is easy to follow and presented at a nice, slow pace. The connections back to real world phenomenom happen often enough to keep it interesting. Exen if you decide to reshoot sections of it, I think the framework you have makes for a quality presentation. I hope you will do more videos like this.

Salvatore Mendola

Derek, holy cow, amazing video. It's on a fascinating topic. The 3D take on the Mandelbrot set was the only thing that was truly new to me and by itself it warrants a like on the video. But the rest of the material though already familiar to me was presented in incredibly clear and intuitive way, that was very enjoyable to watch. I can see that it is nerdier than your average video and maybe the opposite of click bait, but I freaking loved it.

Quasitling

I agree that you should put the equation later in the video. Talk about something concrete first, like the bunnies or water drips. Likewise, de-emphasize the equation in the title. Maybe "This Hidden Pattern Pops Up Everywhere" instead?

Michael Krugman

Characteristically captivating Derek, though I think a far more interesting, important , and unmentioned aspect of all this is the overarching implication underlying this sort of phenomena, that, at its foundations, nature follows relatively simple rules or algorithms which yield patterns and, in turn, topographical and topological forms, e.g., charts, graphs, and, in nature, intricate and ultimately capable material things. Equations are, after all, just algorithms... Take a value, perform a sequence of operations on it, feed the result back into the process, repeat. Many such processes interact, yielding complexity and emergent properties, with matter, chemistry, life (and, more parochially, VR and CGI) representing particularly compelling hierarchical examples. In other words, the *fundamental* laws of nature can be represented formulaically and algorithmically, though, through their interaction in the aggregate, their underlying simplicity is ultimately subsumed and obscured by unimaginable depth and complexity. As an aside, this is one of the reasons I don’t buy the Everett Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, i.e., just accept and apply the Schrödinger equation at face value in nature, leading to Many Worlds—one of the most complicated and implausible physical postulates ever proposed—but I digress. :-)

Shad Sterling

It was great, but way too long to remember the 5 things you said you were going to connect by the end... and I don't think you actually connected it to neurons in your brain... I'd like to see a checklist pop up with a new item checked off when you reach that point. In some cases it might be better to let it be forgotten, but in this case I think it adds something to be reminded of just how unexpected the connections are.

Paul Wicker

Dude, I'm reading Chaos by Gleick right now! Get out of my brain!

Felix Noble

AAARRRGH, please get those fingerprints off the mirror

Gregor Shapiro

I think the "x=rx-(1-x)" in the rabbit equation should initially have different (and not just subscripts) variables instead of 3 x's; subsequently "normalize" them. Show some real world population data early on too.

Chris Nyman

When the mandelbrot set rotated to reveal the bifurcation diagram, it blew my mind. Amazing!

Bernard Gisin

I like this video, but can understand that most people are not familiar with complex numbers and will not understand the Mandelbrot set. Just be aware that this video is for a restricted audience.

Rob Nichols

I have no specific feedback beyond that I liked the video very much. The subject matter was interesting to me and I thought that the presentation was quite clear. Thank-you!

Steve Ford

I found it very refreshing to see a chaos video that doesn't mention butterflies and hurricanes, or chaotic double pendulums.

Binal Bruno

I guess you missed the part about the firing of the neurons?