Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey! Want to see a rough draft of a video? Mostly I think it needs some music and audio editing but I'd love to get your thoughts. I feel like you always point out things I didn't notice because I get too close to the edit and can't see errors/omissions. Thanks for your help!

Derek

Files

Why the world seems fair even though it isn't

Here's a draft

Comments

Veritasium

Also, title suggestions are welcome

SkaveRat

"You are lucky seeing this video"

Joel Menken

Besides the audio I think it’s ready. Good job! Can’t wait to share with my friends.

Kimberly Green

I anticipate that some of your YouTube comments on the finished video will discuss political concepts such as capitalism (which is kinda like the accumulation of & leveraging of luck), socialism (which is a bit like trying to spread out the effects of luck equitably), communism, etc. It may get pretty vitriolic considering the upcoming election cycle. PS: I found Veritasium through VSauce, but -not- that referred video. I found it through the luck of the YouTube algorithm. I've never regretted that, unlike some of the crap that algorithm offers me. Oh, and being subscribed to Veritasium and VSauce brought me to PBS Eons.

Daniel Posen

Great video - and extremely important too! Don’t think it really needs any changes! But since you’re asking :)... you might consider being even more explicit in the astronaut simulation about the fact that the selected candidates were near the top in skill too... just not the literal top 11. I think viewers who are inclined to discount the role of luck in their success may feel that you glossed over this and could use that feeling to downplay your main message. An alternative would be to ask the audience to think about it from the perspective of those top skilled people who weren’t picked. For them, it’s small comfort that those who were picked are nearly as good... they still missed out because of luck!

Edith Dubiner

around 3:17 and also 3:30 smeared picture. title: "I feel lucky" or "Feeling lucky?"

Earthwormia

Not so much a content thing, but I'm getting tons of weird graphical artifacts toward the bottom of the screen during the running animation. Starting at about 3:13 or so

TickyTack

I think it's great, I get into these conversations a lot with my brother, and close friends. For audio and music, I'd ask the question of how serious do you want the video perceived? Having no music, or audio effects on the cartoons, will give a real conversation feel. If you are worried about losing peoples attention, just know that this is a very common subject people contemplate about.

Daniel Turner

Possible title: - Why are my kids lucky I'm on Instagram? Fortune favours the brave or were they just lucky? Do skill and hard work owe a lot to luck? Ask yourself one question: Do I feel lucky?

Daniel Turner

A thoroughly enjoyable video BTW.

Jason Pratt

Nitpicky: At 3:59, "Hardwork" should be two words: "Hard Work". Also, as others noted, a lot of visual artifacts show up on the table and runner's legs around 3:16.

Daniel Turner

Perhaps use the API features to auto-update the title with the number of views and have: CONGRATULATIONS: You're the <#> person to view this video - aren't you lucky?

Veritasium

Nice! Yes I have similar concerns about vitriolic comments...

Graham Haynes

Ugh it's so good. Title suggestion. Why I now believe I'm more lucky than smart/gifted/talented. Ps you really are very much all of those. It's such a pleasure following you.

Veritasium

Yes! The way I would put it is that if there are a lot of people for a few positions, lots of people are at the same very high skill level.

Veritasium

yup, that's part of the temp - it'll be fixed in the final

Jason Pratt

The Dunning–Kruger effect really feels like it belongs in this discussion. I can imagine a graphic with the skill vs. luck bar showing how the more someone's success is based on luck rather than skill/experience/hard work, the more they believe it was the skill/experience/hard work that brought them success.

Jason Pratt

"You're luckier than you think. Here's what you should do about it"

Pattmyn

Yeah, I saw it too. Was about to comment in kind.

Pattmyn

Yeah, I saw it too. Was about to comment in kind.

Daniel Wisehart

The validity of our knowledge is based upon the validity of the concepts we use. If you are going to expand this out into the political realm, the meaning of the concepts you use is critical. "Capitalism is a social system based on the recognition of individual rights, including property rights, in which all property is privately owned." "There is no difference between the principles, policies and practical results of socialism—and those of any historical or prehistorical tyranny. Socialism is merely democratic absolute monarchy—that is, a system of absolutism without a fixed head, open to seizure of power by all corners, by any ruthless climber, opportunist, adventurer, demagogue or thug." "There is no difference between communism and socialism, except in the means of achieving the same ultimate end: communism proposes to enslave men by force, socialism—by vote. It is merely the difference between murder and suicide."

Clayton Greenwell

Like you said, could use some sort of audio, music, sound effects etc. Topic is great though. Yes, you are most assuredly going to ruffle some YouTube feathers, and open the door for some political hijacking, but what topic doesn't these days. You are simply creating a video about the importance of humility. Something we could all use a large dose of.

Hector Montalvo

I think that more than music it needs sound effects to accentuate the actions and movement of the animations, like motor sound of the vehicle, some paper moving and tearing, people walking or crowd noise. Something along does lines.

Pattmyn

I think I might be the rogue outlier on this one but I don't feel this is the kind of video I'd be going to Veritasium for. Not to say that the video is bad in any way (except for that artifacting which many folks have mentioned) but it just doesn't seem to fit what I'd expect from the channel. I typically support and watch the videos to do with the "hard" sciences like maths, physics, and various quantum mechanics, etc, versus the "soft" sciences of psychology and sociology. My sincerest apologies if that might sound harsh, I'm just using the "hard/soft" metaphor as the easiest way to translate what I was taught in French regarding said different scientific disciplines. It probably doesn't help that I was raised in a "middle of nowhere" community where sciences of any kind took a back seat to athletics. However, said background is what motivated me to continue to seek out knowledge in my own way and fill the gaps from my education from Gr9-12 which I much prefer compared to having learnt it all in a classroom environment. tl;dr - I don't feel like this is a video that would be coming from Veritasium. PS: Shade-ball 2880 here.

Omer Demir

I like the animations - especially the lightning... ouch! In addition, I find that the ideas of many of the other people are good, like sound effects, title suggestions, etc.

Michael Slade

You’ve done an excellent soft sell on the idea of “born on third base but thought you hit a triple”. I wonder if it is possible to increase empathy for those not born on third base. This lack of emotional understanding leads to a lot of societal conflict.

Will Latinette

It's a small thing I know but as a skater the stick man hockey player doesn't look at all like they're skating- but walking?

Will Latinette

The methodology of your 'astronaut simulation' is unclear to me. You generated a 'luck score' of 0-100 and then, in the case of that score being 100 it contributed an additional 5% to the 'skill score'? The result of your simulation seems surprising indeed. Maybe consider a link with more detail on it?

Shelby Doolittle

I like all but part of the conclusion. I think it's important to not delude yourself when deciding how to act in life. So lying to yourself about having to work hard is not a good idea. I think the take away is to work hard but to look out for opportunities for luck to arise. I think a lot of hard work goes unnoticed because it's not given the opportunity to be lucky. Additionally, take many non-terminal chances. The more rolls you have, the more likely you are to roll high.

Ukrainian IT Army

Definitely some sound effects to spice up the animations would help :)

Melodie Bitting

Loved the animations and the cutaways, they made me giggle. The content was well-organized and easy to ingest. This is a winner!

Jean-Manuel Izaret

This is a brilliant and important argument particularly now when inequality is at such a high point. Lots of content well explained. Now to the nit picky. In your stylized race you could have the aliens pick some of the pack leaders (as opposed to followers) to illustrate that even the some of the faster racers can be taken out. That would reinforce your astronaut point.

katgod

I agree with this, I took 2 passes through it and I still thought it was not clear how it was helping your case or maybe I was just expecting more.

katgod

I also liked this video even if it was more social science then hard science. There is one part where you finish a statement with and "all that" if I remember correctly, seemed a little sloppy. I can still remember saying good luck to someone to which they replied, no luck involved. This made me think they were a not totally aware of how the world works, but as you said it no doubt allowed them to think they were in total control.

Uri Rothschild

lile the video a lot. especially since it not obvious from.the beginning where it's going. making you stay and watch it all. the astronaut example seems clear to me. some added sounds etc might make sense but not too much im.krder to nkt distract the viewers as it's important they listen to what's said :-)

George41

I like the title "Do you feel lucky, punk", but thats because I love movie quotes.

Gregor Shapiro

For the "Astronaut school" simulation adding some other simulations with other values than 5% for luck would be interesting.

Liran Katzir

Great topic! I think a 'Freakonomics' citation would be great.

Nicolas Berney

No sure if music will add much to this great content. Maybe turn down a bit the background noise.

Tomáš Vician

Video has visual glitches in animations most visual is the glitch in the table of records on 3:17. I can hear a noise in most parts. Maybe some noise reduction or quiet music to cover noise would be nice to tweak the sound of this video :) I am grateful for luck that brought me to your channel and for my decision to become your Patreon to see this kind of content :)

Edith Dubiner

BTW, as far as the conclusion of the astronauts-simulation goes: if we use 95% skill and 5% "quality-x" -- which can be "money", "beauty", anything we might think has a marginal effect, not necessarily "luck" -- we would get the exact same thing.

Miklós Boros

What popped into my mind was hearing the last words "help each other" is that I would like to see the simulation about which simulated group achives more, the one where the talented and lucky inviduals use their time to help the less lucky and less talented inviduals or where they use their time to do science and work as an engineer or scientist. Maybe it is a different topic. don't know

paercebal

Love it. To be fair, as far as I am concerned, there's nothing to change. It works as it is. As for the content itself, it is awesome, both in the "random" experiments, and personal accounts (I love the "and this is how I met your mother..."). As a side note, a french youtuber did a similar, if more cynical (and yet, still exact) video (with very decent English subtitles): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ezdtQIrO8oI I point this because, indeed, realizing that being privileged is more related to luck than we are comfortable with would probably make us better humans. And having different, unrelated people communicate about that makes me hope this is something we, as a whole, are slowly realizing that.

Thomas Biersack

I've a problem with your Astronaut calculation and have redone it. I recalculated your problem, with the 95to5% luck score and got the same result with 1.6 out of 11 persons pickt Just because of their luck and a bias of 94.7% of luck. So there is not my problem. I ask my self why 5% luck and not 4% or less say 1% ( at 4% I've 1,73 persons and luck a bias of 94.3% and at 1% 3.39 Persons and a bias of 88.4%) Yes, I got the picture and it is still impressiv, but why 5% and not more or less? On what did you base these 5%? So I asked my self let's say every one of these persons has to solve a test with 100 possible correct answers and every one with more 99.5 points would get the 100 points and would be in the final. There would be approximately 91 participants with the full score and, but only 1.34 of the truly best would be in the final 11,... !?! So how did you come up with these 5%?

Uwe

it really doesn't feel like a draft. I've sent it to my friends when I didn't even finish the video but the calculation of your 100 simulations aren't 100% clear to me. maybe I have to re-watch it or jot the numbers down on a paper

Victor

The only thing I have an issue with is background noise cutting in and out. It's not even a problem with the noise itself (it's barely noticeable), but the cuts sound really jarring. Other than that, awesome video. And yeah, I also had to re-do your simulations about luck to believe them :-).

Candice Sheaffer

I would say be careful about adding music. Pick your spots. I thought the video was good even without the music, but I agree it may need a little bit. Sometimes music can be distracting to me in a video that I am watching to learn something. I don't know if that is the same for others, I can only speak for myself on this.

OG

Such a great topic, Derek! I don't miss any music, however there's some noise in the whole video except for the voiceover for the astronaut part. (Did Gene mess it up when recording? :D). My suggestions: – to the astronaut luck score part: I think the message is correct ("even if only 5% is good luck, it plays a huge role. But in reality it's even more than that" – it shows how important luck is), but I had to rewatch it two more times to get it (it may be my poor English though:) – IMO, the race animation should eliminate the racers in the front and let the slower racer win to show the idea that luck is important. The current animation shows that the winners would win anyway I really like the conclusion. Work hard and hope to be lucky. There's one question unaswered though. How should we talk about the successful people? "Oh, the winner was incredibly lucky"? :-)

amir

This is such a great video. makes me think about my own path in life, and in particular about what is to be smart. I've almost finished my PhD in electro-optics and work as algorithm developer in a big company. Today, I feel much more capable than most people I meet and discuss with, but it was not always like that. I was very average when I was studying for bachelor’s degree, and even before that, at high-school, I was not among the smartest. So, by conventional definitions, I’m not smart. I’m lucky because I decided to continue studying and during that time, I understood how to study. Then I began to grasp new ideas and concepts very deeply. This can happen to anyone, at any stage of life, or, not to happen at all. It is not taught at school and I believe this is the big factor that artificially separate the kids into those “smart” groups. It can begin from a young age, when some lucky kids have knowledgeable parents and from young age are taught by example and have more informational conversations. Then, like the hokey example, during the time, this advantage aids them to faster understand the right approach to learning and increases the smart gap. I believe this is also why many of the brightest students in my bachelor’s degree have parents with academic background.I even dare to say that most of the university Professors are not much smarter than the rest, but luckier, because they figured out how to study.

ava_aster_parmessur

i think the lack of extra music/editing as well as the content material make the tone of the video different from the usual, which is a good thing in 2 ways. number 1, your current viewers will immediately catch on that this video is different from the usual topics. number 2, it can reach a demographic beyond the usual and hopefully involve more random people in science related content (also a good thing). imo i occasionally share videos you make on my insta. but this one I AM 100% sharing. generally, i think about what proportion of my followers will be interested in content i post. this is sure to capture the curiosity of most people

Jorge Sinde

I loved it, for me it's Okey as it is.

David Sherier

I can not think of anything I would change in the video. The animations work well and add needed visuals. The personal anecdotes are awesome! I had no idea you met your wife like that. Fantastic video. I definitely learned something about how luck and hard work influence our lives.

Nick Neynens

Great video, makes you think. Happiness is an important topic. I like to believe I'm lucky, I know I get good and bad luck, but you've got to be in it to win it. Intersection of preparation and opportunity.

Adam Bryer

"Why the world seems fair even though it isn't" is a great title. "You are lucky seeing this video" comes off pretentious, I would not click that.

Matthew Pitts

One thing you did in your recent Dust video that you did not do here is music over the talking. It was very distracting, but I am happy to not see that done here. It makes for a cleaner video to me and easier to pay attention to the relevant content. Music is great, on its own, but not when it overtakes your voice. Thank you for your hard work.

Dhandforth

This is so good that I'm going to make my kids watch it. Good job.

Scott Lowe

Great video! I don't think it needs music, but you could add it for some atmosphere.

Adam

I think it is great as is. If you want to add music I would keep it to an intro and/or outro

Dave Glyer

Here are a couple of corrections to the records in track and field:

Dave Glyer

100 Hurdles 12.20 Keni Harrison (US) London, England 7/22/16, and the 10.49 record is badly flawed, the wind at the time was about 5meters/second (11miles per hour) and the zero came from a non-functioning wind meter that affected the initial round of the Olympic Trials. Note, [T&FN believes the 10.49 was illegally wind-aided and should never have been accepted as the WR. Loved the video; some of my work involved selection bias, but I never tied it together remotely as well as this. We believe the real fastest is 10.61 Florence Griffith Joyner (US) Indianapolis, Indiana, 7/17/88]. Finally you missed probably the biggest example of wind-aided more. Bob Beamon's iconic world record (hence the term Beamonesque) was set with a wind reading of 2.0 meters/second, the maximum allowed for a record, beyond that it does not qualify so you have to also be lucky to have a decent tailwind but not too large. It is very likely the case that Beamon was lucky because the person manning the wind meter did not know what he was doing because he was rounding down all readings to the next lower whole number, so unless the wind reading was 2.00 instead of any other number between 2.01 and 2.99 his record was with wind over the threshold.

Veritasium

this is very helpful - thank you! do you have references for this info?

Veritasium

thanks! Music was something I was planning to add. I'll try to keep it to a minimum. I working with a new audio mixer so sometimes the balance is a bit off and sometimes it sounds better in headphones and worse on a computer or phone

Veritasium

the number is completely arbitrary. It's small but not that small. It's meant to take into account things like getting a good night sleep before the interview, or having your flight not delayed, or to use a totally unrelated example the fact that Bill Gates was one of only a few dozen high school students in the US who had access to a computer at that time etc. There is no way to logically establish how much of a role luck plays so to me it seems fair to use 5% in our toy model.

Veritasium

thanks for redoing the simulations!

Veritasium

thank you for redoing them! Always good to have an extra check

Veritasium

Thanks! I'll try to keep it minimal

Veritasium

thanks for the good notes! I felt my delivery through the astronaut part was too fast when I did it to camera (so it's not Gene's fault!) that's why I put the VO in. I'll try to smooth audio transitions.

Veritasium

Great observations. I don't think of myself as especially smart - I have been the beneficiary of fortunate circumstances for sure and if I have any special innate ability it is that I can keep going even when I don't feel like it.

Veritasium

I was planning on adding a little music. Hopefully that won't be off-putting?

C.J. Smith

I don't have any suggestions yet, but I don't like the title as is, because I don't think the world seems fair :P and I'm not sure how many people do.

C.J. Smith

Perhaps something along the lines of, "Hard work matters, but it also doesn't"

Eber Anaya

First, great video! I personally know I've been lucky in some ways and unlucky in others. I try to be mindful of this as often as possible. As for the video, the only thing I had a very minor issue was was the background noise in between some of your speaking (Ex. 5:10 - 5:11). It's so minor that I probably only heard it because I was searching for it. Overall, the video is great, it doesn't need you to add music, it'll probably just distract.

Rocco Neil April

I love this! I am with the others, no need for music, or keep it real low. It’s super clean as is. My main note is on the super quick piece about discrimination and prejudice. I would LOVE to hear a few more sentences on that, as I think this whole video is a great lead-in to the concept of white-priviledge.

Matthew Pitts

For me personally I typically watch YouTube through my Roku on a TV. Yours with the family if I can to get some education! If on computer or phone, with headphones. I did not try and listen to the dust video to see if it is different with headphones but I may try that. Thank you for responding.

Joseph E. LeBlanc

I agree with the comments above. No need for music. Good examples. Clear and direct language. The swaying figures were peculiar at the beginning, but fit well into the ideas being developed.

Joseph E. LeBlanc

I just heard a relevant podcast on "Innovation Hub" titled "Is Meritocracy Damaging our Economy?" (8/7/2020). Please check it out. It explains the reason for the inequality gap we are experiencing in the United States, in particular. Great work!

Josh Grossman

I love it just the way it is! I imagine you will add music, and I do understand, but I personally prefer it without. You should probably give a shout out to Malcolm Gladwell. Outliers is clearly inspirational to this video - right down to the hockey player birthday tale.

veritanuda

Good or bad luck is a false concept. It is all to do with perspective. Maybe you were unlucky to miss your flight but then the plane crashes. What is it? Good or bad luck? There are plenty of real world examples if you examine them in your life where what you perceive as bad luck seems good in the end or something you think is good luck turns out to be really bad in the end. It falls back to the fundamental human trait that means we all have to have faith in something or someone. Even if you think the whole universe is random you are still having faith in chaos. Believing in things is just what humans do regardless of the logic or even because of it. So yeah.. we mess without our own perceptions. It is a typically human thing to do.

John Graham

That has to be the best most appropriate video in my point in life. Thank you Derek Now I have to re watch it!

John Graham

Oh as is, you can’t guild a Lilly....

Poker Chen

I think it's fine overall. It may be worth pointing out that the synonym "chance" is a more neutral term than "luck". Often the deciding factor is the sum of multiple probabilities where the applicant shares hobby X or attitude Y that makes them a good co-worker

Ruben A

I'm not missing any music, but maybe have some sections, I know you can add them these days in the scroll bar (chapter feature) to organize the video a bit into different topics that you talk about, like 'intro', 'examples of luck' and 'my own tests on NASA astronauts', 'my own luck' etc. Looking forward to sharing this with my friends when it's out. Thanks!

igge

Brilliant video. I love the sentiment that people must realize how much external circumstances and environment plays a role in who we turn out to become. One thing - I didn't really feel like the first part tied in to the rest of the video though. I get that it's about how we put too much emphasis on our own work, but I didn't get how it tangents the luck aspect. Might just be me though, but maybe around the part where you talk about "how i met your mother", which was a really cute part, maybe you could tie that back to the house chores or similar? One small thing I noticed also was the first time you mention where we are born, around 2:30, you say something along the lines of "many of us are born into prosperous countries". I would argue only a small percentage of the world's population are lucky in this sense, rather than "many". I'm guessing that you maybe mean many of us "who have the privilege to watch this video", but that might not come across to everyone. Other than that a very nice video. Maybe add some of that trademark veritasium music over some of the animations, but it's not a necessity.

Mik Scheper

I literally cheered when you talked about survivor bias in that more personal vid you did a year or two ago, so I think it's fantastic that you're covering it in more depth. But did you intend for the stick figures to look like they came out of The Demented Cartoon Movie, especially in the race scene? 😁 I disagree with people who say it doesn't need music; I actually love the music you put to your vids. But other than that, I think this is pretty much ready for production. It seemed balanced, the examples were relatable, it was easy to understand, you didn't waffle, and it had a nice amount of humour and anecdote—I love the story of how you met your missus. ☺ I can't wait to share the uploaded version. P.S: I can't tell where you filmed this video, which is probably good, since you have a habit of posting videos from cities that I've just left, whether they're in Australia, the US, Canada or Europe, and I recently left the Bay Area, which is well and truly on fire right now. 😢 P.P.S: Yes, I discovered your channel through vSauce. But I've discovered some other channels through yours, so it comes around. And I hope that some day, you do a tour like Michael did a couple of years ago.

Mark Widmer

Really good video as usual. At 1:05, not sure I would say "you overestimate your own contributions". At least not in an absolute sense. The point seems to be that you underestimate the contributions of others. So in a *relative* sense you overestimate yourself. Don't know if there's a better way to convey this, maybe it's clear enough to people as-is.

Mark Widmer

Starting at 4:05, would it make sense to add "0" and "100" at the left and right ends of the astronaut score charts? That being said, it was obvious to me what those charts represent even without the numbers, but I"m not sure how obvious to less-math-savvy viewers it would be. You probably have a better idea than I how well different people would process the information.

Christopher Reichert

I know you intend to work on the audio and I'm not sure if it was just me, but at the end the audio was out of sync, but only just noticeably. Great job on another interesting video!

Jerrad Pierce

The end seems a bit rushed. There's more than enough build-up, but then jut a few words about adopting conflicting views. I think more is needed i.e; practical advice; although it may not fit in this video/your style. What about sending folks on to a second video from BrainCraft?

Rocco Neil April

I actually came back a few days later to watch the video for similar reasons. I was thinking that this could be two distinct videos on their respective subjects.

Rocco Neil April

Hehee, from Wikipedia: Wayne Douglas Gretzky CC (/ˈɡrɛtski/; born January 26, 1961)

JOHN S THURMAN

My take away from this video is that if I feel some measured level of success, then I should not forget that my hard work and a little bit of luck got me there. If that is the point you were driving at, I think you did good. I would've tried to tie by the point and the end a little more directly to the egocentric bias you brought in the beginning. It was there, but it could've been a bit more explicit. Beginner's opinion. On another note, I look at luck as the manifestation of preparation, Rob Dyrdek simplified that as "you make your own luck". I think that you made a very humanitarian point about maintaining those two competing thoughts in your brain to keep you more compassionate.