Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello! I wish you all a happy holidays and a safe and prosperous new year!! I have one final video for 2020 that is nearly there - it just needs your input.

Please let me know what you think: parts you like/don't like, things unclear, timestamps of illusions that don't work for you, general comments/suggestions. Title and thumbnail suggestions are welcome.

Be warned: there is no music yet, some sections will seem empty or flat - they may get cut or I may find good music for them.

Thank you!

Files

I Turned Myself Into An Illusion

No music yet, let me know what works and what doesn't.

Comments

Kurt Allen Raeuchle

I liked it, honestly kinda liked it with out the music. I’m like these it’s science but it’s different then normal stuff. Keep it up!

Joey Luther

I absolutely love illusions. They make me realize that not everything you see is exactly as you see it. This is probably why I strayed towards Chemistry in college 😂

Robert Blum

I love it! I don’t think you need to change anything (that’s a first for me 😂) - plus I’m a fan of all irony.

Marc Forand

Time index 1:39: I recommend to let people look at one complete revolution which feels especially important since you ask "...Now that you know... ...can you correctly perceive...?" (with some voice over to prevent boring those who do not want to). Well I would really have enjoyed trying to answer your question but I was not given the opportunity (as enthusiastic as I frequently am, this spoils my fun).

Veritasium

My favorite line in the video. I'm a dad after all.

Kimberly Green

1. You must have driven your wife -crazy- with all those windows. 2. For the big window, what disrupted the illusion for me ... your hands holding onto some of the lower panes. 3. Now I understand how Willy Wonka (Gene Wilder) had that magic corridor that led them into the chocolate river room.

Chris Stone

Great video. Liked it better without music. Audio is a bit off in the Iron shirt scenes, different mic maybe. Your interest in these topics is absolutely infectious. It really shows, even without the pile of window cutouts. Keep up the great work.

Coheed2313

Great work! I would double check on incriminating yourself regarding getting around sports blackouts. I would hate for something so silly to cause you trouble.

Veritasium

1. YES! 2. I was thinking the same thing as I watched it today. Originally I was thinking I’d be like Superman through the window but balancing one’s body on an inch and a half of spinning plywood is no easy feat.

Mike 1.0

This video has an appropriate quantity of puns. I think it would be fun to put some other familiar objects in the large window. A ladder would be fantastic, since it is "windowed", but will maintain perspective. Also, pool noodles, an entire Christmas tree, a folding or wooden chair, even put a dress on a hanger on one side and a suit on the other. :) Very good content, as always.

Chloe Garner

That little window really throws me for a loop, but when you were hanging in the window it didn't look too convincing, maybe the lighting was off like you said?. The Rubics cube part definitely made me anxious, I was certain that it would let me see the actual rotation, but when it didn't woah.. btw adorbs little ones :) I'm sure they've got happy lives ^.^ I've loved your content for years now, glad to be a part of this patreon now too.

Ken Schwarz

Wow, this made me laugh out loud. I think the false depth cues on the panes are a significant contributor to the overall illusion. Did you experiment with them omitted and just the trapezoid window shape? I always like your music, especially the motif that cues the “aha!” moment. That you don’t depend on it speaks to the strength of the material and how much you develop it over the 15 minutes. Thanks for creating this!

Michael Tuvim

Very nice piece! The text is a bit repetitive in the fist couple of minutes.

Rick Fleischer

I didn't miss the music. I don't mind it; I just didn't notice.

Matt Dunlap

*slow clap* easily my favorite of your videos. I'm still hung up on your single direction speed of light episode; I don't see why a large clock on the moon wouldn't solve it.... but this one is so much more visceral, and simple. Well done.

Paul Looyen

Great video Derek and very interesting and engaging. As mentioned, your family must be patient. 😂 What I like.... 1. The reference to Curiosity Show. I watched that ad nauseum in the late 70’s 2. Great connection to science at the end. Not too preachy and good to be said esp the examples you used. 3. The Ames room I’ve experienced in Wanaka NZ and is a nice reference and I like the simulations of how they are designed. 4. Oh the irony pun. Love it Suggestions 1. Is worth paying for the footage? Watermarks bit ‘cheap’. And what is the large number in some of the footage? 2. Is it worth putting the Ames window explanation before the discussion on the paintings so it ‘stays together? Maybe also the construction part. Hope that makes sense. It seems a little disjointed IMHO 3. Maybe a quick reference to how sports advertisers use distorted images on playing fields. That’s very common these days. Great work once again

Eber Anaya

Once explained, I can normally see through an illusion. Sometimes some take more focus, but this one I just cant get over! Great video! don't let the NFL know about NordVPN though.

katgod

As usual a very interesting video, I would like to 2nd Ken Schwarz comment about the depth cues, I kept thinking you were going to say something about them. Maybe they are not important but I suspect they are.

Bryce Stoddart Esquire

Excellent video, I thought it does a good job a showing how the effect happens with the cube. Love the reference to the "Curiosity Show" , grew up watching them and trying to recreate what Rob and Deane did.

DER RÜTTLER

It was kind of being implied but I think the point that the illusion only works if you can't look at it with both eyes or through a camera should have been said more explicitly.

Alan W

I don't feel like the addition of the illustration with of the room with the light through the windows having it's geometry changed was really adding all that much ... for me. Perhaps it'll be helpful for others though.

Mat Horton

The end of the video is perfect! (13:20+) It highlights your point perfectly without sounding preachy at all. Once you get into the shots of the largest Ames window (11:35 to 12:15) the illusion completely goes away to me as well (just as others have stated) I can tell you dont have as much room as you want to get the right shots here and getting consistant lighting becomes a real challenge so good luck if you decide to change anything there! I also would totally not have noticed there was no music if you had not pointed it out.

Michael heslar

Very trippy but simple illusion! You did a good overview of the physics and discussion of the impacts on depth perception. You could add a one revolution clip with dubstep music to emphasize the trippiness of the illusion, but I get that isn't your video style. I liked it without music though.

Shawn Van Ness

My brain is still reeling from the speed-of-light-roundtrip video.. now this. And then you tie it all back at the end. Bravo! I say add a little music and shipit.

Goutham Bharadwaj

At 15:06 there's a sudden jump cut? Feels abrupt. Apart from that it was super smooth! Great illusion!

i❤computers

Showing the projections of the room at around the 8:34 mark was really helpful for me to understand how that illusion worked. The overlaying of the windows at the 12:22 mark was almost similar method of explanation, but it would be more helpful if you explicitly visualized what is happening in reality and what our brains are perceiving. Overall, I’m glad you’re diving deep into optical illusions. It was one of my favorite topics from science programs I saw as a kid.

Poker Chen

Great work! The trick to breaking the illusion is to concentrate on imperfections and the rotating base, which does not suffer from the ambiguity. Even so, it takes me a moment to re-map the apparent frame to the correct "propriocepted" frame. Suggestion: Add a reference to sports advertisers on fields. The Rugby Leauge in Australia, for example, sits the camera off to one side in the exact mid-line, so the grass is painted with extended images that make sense when you see it on TV. Simple example: https://www.sportingnews.com/au/league/news/nrl-suncorp-stadium-host-entire-round-brisbane-broncos/1ml3wn231pnqf1p47br3ken85z Suggestion 2: Paper reference? I would be interested in when babies begin to construct the 3D world based on visual inputs. I think some of this may have to do with aphantasia.

Andres Bucher

For me, the illusion didn't work as well, when something was put through the window. The window with the ruler at 3:21 seems first to oscillate back, then for a short time my brain seems to see both and then I see the window rotating instead of oscillating. And similar to Mat Horton, the illusion didn't work for me with the largest window at all, so the window with the Rubiks Cube was the craziest part for me. Although I wouldn't change anything in the video, because overall I found it still very interesting and a cool deep dive into the illusion.

Poker Chen

More specifically, people's ability to consciously impose their own constructs onto their visual field. The illusion is indeed for me a product of the subconscious processing, which I can alter.

Oliver Hendrey

The video is great, no issues for most of it. Although in the shot of you in the window I can only see it as rotating, not oscillating.

Uri Rothschild

loved the curiosity show reference. i think many will do as well. maybe tell some more. also the explanation of the room is challenging but understandable after one or 2 tries :-) . perfect use of the other illusions. and great ending.

IcyMidnight

Works pretty well. I dislike the title, though, of course :P

Candice Sheaffer

Great video. Sometimes when there was another object on the window I was able to see the rotation. But, after seeing it once, I went back to seeing the oscillation.

Patrik Andersson

Great video! The ending conclusion is extreamly powerful, love it! Perhaps the joke takes away some power from it, Think I would like it to end there on the "less certainty" and place the joke someware else? After the sponsor? or have a longer pause and fade to black between?

marenoodles

For some reason, the illusion completely failed for me during the first scene where you go through the window yourself, but the other times it succeeded.

Tony Charlton

Brilliant, absolutely love your genuine reactions at 2:46, same as mine even though i know whats happening and before you put the cube on i could just follow the actual rotation if i tried hard enough. But with the cube it indeed looks like the cube is orbiting the oscillating window....Science and history of Ames, as always the detail you provide hits the spot for me . . but where do i get the iron man shirt? is it merch? . . As for the rest of the video there was nothing that went flat for me the illusion worked pretty much as you described and with you through the middle it worked most of the time for me event hough I am getting better at seeing what is really going on now. As for the lack of music right now, i didn't really notice and i am a musician so the content works for me and didn't need padding but im sure music will lift part you think need it. all good for me, thumbs up.

Jay Shaffer

Very engaging video! Around 9:26 you mention the concept of "privileged position" which creates the image of "normal" room. It would be interesting to learn about "privileged position(s)" especially where an illusion disappears.

Christopher Chapman

Same comment as others, the first scene I saw you and it rotating all the way around. Perhaps just start with a good example of the illusion. I think it would also be entertaining (if possible) to "break" the window illusion at the end of the video. Could you remove the coloring of the larger side after a few rotations?

Veritasium

Or maybe I could stick the joke somewhere in the middle... hmmm I'll think about this.

Veritasium

what's wrong with the title? And if you dislike it, what's a better one? As these things usually go I'd rather have one title for my core audience and a different one for the casual observer. Not having that functionality, I normally go with the one for a broader audience and hope my core audience will trust that it will be good an in depth as they've come to expect.

Veritasium

Yeah, I've been torn about that one. In fact many of the illusions don't work for me when I know which way they were spinning, but if I flip the image in post or reverse the direction of the clip then they do work...

Veritasium

yeah - with that size and uneven lighting it's hit and miss. Also kind of depends on where you're looking.

Veritasium

I wonder what makes people less/more susceptible to the illusion besides experience with rectangles etc.

Veritasium

I was thinking about showing anamorphic logos on sports fields too - and maybe text on roads...

Veritasium

1. Yes, will pay (this is a draft) 2. I kind of like spacing things out and coming back to it but maybe transitions could be smoothed or logical progressions more clearly outlined. 3. Yes, was definitely thinking about sports logos on cricket pitches etc. Very common in Australia, not sure how common elsewhere but definitely something I've been thinking about.

Veritasium

Yeah, could cut the story down you mean? Or I should use different phrases?

Veritasium

Thank you! Yes, I have some images without the shading and it definitely makes the illusion less effective (it's considered a *weak* form of the illusion)

Veritasium

Thank you! And thanks for the feedback. Yeah the large window was a bit of a disappointment for me. I even contemplated making it again but we already sunk a week and lots of money into that build. I find it better without me in it. Sometime just standing in my house looking at it (not rotating) I feel like it messes with my sense of perception. The kids are enjoying it but have also bumped their heads a few times so I've gotta take it down!

Veritasium

these are good ideas. I'll see what I can whip up today.

Olivier

Hi, the beginning phase, I would say, show more of the good footage of the rotating frame and less of the mishaps/climbing/falling and less of the 'making off' maybe move some of the making off to the end as 'out-takes'. Maybe shorten the video slightly. The illusion worked for me at all times. Can you compare this to other illusions? More of the rectangular/perspective illusions?

Steven K Knapp

Overall, excellent. The illusion worked for me almost always. In fact, even with conscious effort knowing what was happening, my mind had trouble "breaking" the illusion. Perhaps placing a piece of colored tape on one side would "break" the illusion and make the rotation more obvious. I particularly liked the connection you made at the end to interpretations of empirical evidence and how your perspective might influence your interpretation. The following meme immediate came to mind. https://imgur.com/gallery/1zZ6VSe I can't wait to show this to my daughter, who is exploring perspective in her artwork.

Veritasium

I really like that - thanks for sharing. I feel like I'll be tempted to post that everywhere now

Andres Bucher

I agree. I also get the impression that it depends on which part is focused on. The first few times my eyes mainly followed the ruler and it didn't work so well. But when I focus on the window the illusion is longer maintained (but never the full rotation). Although this seems only to have a minor effect overall.

Cassian Alexandru

I agree, I think the message about humility about knowing the world is super important, especially nowadays where everyone is turning into an armchair-everything (vaccinologist etc)

Paul Matthijsse

@10:17 more or less: Is that a hole in your pants or a spot?

Michael Tuvim

Just a bit different wording, I think, to express the bewilderment, instead of repeated “wow, what is happening”